Weird how one player can divide opinion like this. Some people saying he's awful, others saying potential to be best in the division. Really is mental how people's views of the same games differ. Anyway for what it's worth I'd bring him back of his wages were low. Worth a punt on his potential and he's a decent squad player for now.
Gael (5 Viewers)
- Thread starter KersleyDigs
- Start date
Otis
Well-Known Member
So he's therefore somewhere on the scale between Pele and Pat Butcher.
idm1975
Well-Known Member
So 13 games does not count as premier league experience because you dont like him?
Cavan O'Doherty
Well-Known Member
Nouble had premier league experience and was awful. Same with Simeon Jackson
Nick
Administrator
No, 13 games doesn't make somebody an experienced Premier League footballer whether I like them or not.
R
RB1992
Guest
I'm not on the wind-up, I genuinely believe Gael has the potential to be a very good player at this level. I only seem him in a handful of games last season and bar his debut 10/15 minute appearance (which granted was very poor), I thought he looked a class above most other players on the field. Exactly the same as what I thought during his original spell with us.
If we do sign him this season, I very much look forward to the "I told you so" thread that will pop up around May 2017.
If we do sign him this season, I very much look forward to the "I told you so" thread that will pop up around May 2017.
Cavan O'Doherty
Well-Known Member
Why have we got a habit of hanging on to bang average(at best)players?
Grendel
Well-Known Member
So every league one club will. E clamouring for his signature then?
Si80
Well-Known Member
Swindon signed C Thomas for 3 fucking years so I guess theirs hope for any footballer who fancied a dabble at League 1 level
The Reverend Skyblue
Well-Known Member
I bloody hate people who sit on the fence
D
Deleted member 2477
Guest
Is the op taking the piss
stevefloyd
Well-Known Member
Wasn't it Bobby Robson that signed Bigi? can't remember now
Cavan O'Doherty
Well-Known Member
Good. I didn't see much in him the first time round. Just a fairytale
Esoterica
Well-Known Member
Pardew. Newcastle's 13th manager (including temps!) since Sir Bobby!
Grendel
Well-Known Member
That was my first thought.
Yorkshire SB
Well-Known Member
Christ he's not that bad. Played well on a few occasions last season, notably Bradford away.
Needs a full season playing week in week out to see where's he's at. Not sure we have the budget to make that gamble though
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Needs a full season playing week in week out to see where's he's at. Not sure we have the budget to make that gamble though
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Pipehitterz
Well-Known Member
He ran that midfield in the absence of fleck
oscillatewildly
Well-Known Member
"I'm leaning on my midfield partner in the centre of the pitch and hoping that my last pass doesn't go too wide, oh me! Oh my! I've yet again passed to the opposition oh I could die"!
idm1975
Well-Known Member
Who said he was an experienced premier league footballer?
Nick
Administrator
The post I was replying to?
idm1975
Well-Known Member
I suggest you read it again before you jump on it
Grendel
Well-Known Member
He has actually started only 3 premier league games - most of his other substitute appearances were late appearances so in terms of game time it's a lot less.
It's also irrelevant as to his ability now.
idm1975
Well-Known Member
So he has had premier league experience then?
Grendel
Well-Known Member
He's played games in the premier league which has zero relevance to how good he is.
Nick
Administrator
Hardly enough to want to sign him based on it as implied is it?
Earlsdon_Skyblue1
Well-Known Member
I'm really surprised to see so many people keen to have him back.
He did a couple of alright things last season, but was one of the worst players on the pitch the majority of the time he played. Does everyone forget the eery shudder in the stadium when he was about to be bought on as a substitute?
I maybe, just maybe can tolerate him as a squad player on a low wage. However, we already needed another CM and now we have lost Vincelot too. If the budget is tight we need to look at bringing better quality in.
To have Bigi in as a replacement for Vincelot is in no way acceptable on any level.
He did a couple of alright things last season, but was one of the worst players on the pitch the majority of the time he played. Does everyone forget the eery shudder in the stadium when he was about to be bought on as a substitute?
I maybe, just maybe can tolerate him as a squad player on a low wage. However, we already needed another CM and now we have lost Vincelot too. If the budget is tight we need to look at bringing better quality in.
To have Bigi in as a replacement for Vincelot is in no way acceptable on any level.
Grendel
Well-Known Member
It wouldn't matter how many games he played - he is now in the championship and they still don't want him - also it seems no bids have come in which is odd of he is such a special talent who just needs a few games under his belt.
Hobo
Well-Known Member
I think there is still the potential of a good player in there. One of the very few ex players I would have back. He started well at Newcastle then seems to have had some bad luck.
If Mowbray has other ideas I wouldn't be disappointed either. This one may have to wait until January when McCann exits.
If Mowbray has other ideas I wouldn't be disappointed either. This one may have to wait until January when McCann exits.
jimmyhillsfanclub
Well-Known Member
He was good for a while many years ago......recently he appears to be a 3rd division plodder.....
so a pretty good synergy with our club then....
so a pretty good synergy with our club then....
ClarkeZ
Well-Known Member
I'd be more than a little concerned if he came back. If he comes back it needs to be newcastle paying his wages or a seriously low cost to us, it would be a waste of the tiny resources we have if we spend any money on Bigi. Better quality if needed as our current defense and midfield are barely a skeleton of a team we need to be competitive.
When he played last season he was lightweight, looked to have little to no forward vision whatsoever, passed the ball as often forwards as Fleck did in the back half of the season. Then hes played as a defensive mid and can barely make a tackle, muscled off to easily and too often out of position. Albeit that was a team-wide issue much of the time.
Personally, I'd rather not take him at all and wait in hope we get someone else with the money. Thats making a bold assumption we aren't already at our wage budget...
When he played last season he was lightweight, looked to have little to no forward vision whatsoever, passed the ball as often forwards as Fleck did in the back half of the season. Then hes played as a defensive mid and can barely make a tackle, muscled off to easily and too often out of position. Albeit that was a team-wide issue much of the time.
Personally, I'd rather not take him at all and wait in hope we get someone else with the money. Thats making a bold assumption we aren't already at our wage budget...
R
RB1992
Guest
I know when he joined Newcastle he was on ~£7k per week if he didn't play (1st team), ~£15k per week if he did. I'm assuming he's still on that sort of money, so unfortunately I don't think we really have much of a chance.
idm1975
Well-Known Member
Looks like Mourinho doesnt want Juan Mata again, is he shit too?