I'll say it (17 Viewers)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
fellatio_Martinez
Well-Known Member
Christ almighty. Will you cut out this whole "m8" crap. It was unfunny and old ten years ago on GMK, you gargantuan repetitive bore.
Cue another hilarious m8 line.
usskyblue
Well-Known Member
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Let’s be honest if you pick players in the correct position you’re half way there in this league
Otis
Well-Known Member
Yeah, I said that too and I think Grendel called me delusional.
We just weren't putting the chances away before.
Missing chances, is still our Achilles heel, but atleast we are creating them, should have had game well wrapped up yesterday before their late goal. Had Thomas alone put half of his good chances away we’d be a good ten points better off.
D
Deleted member 5849
Guest
See, I really don't expect us to push on as I think we've overachievef, players are out of contract, or only on loan.
I still wouldn't sack the manager if we did worse, mind!
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
We’ve got 2-3 players out of contract. I think Robins will convince Willis to stay. As for Burge, I wouldn’t be upset if he chose to part ways. Bright is also out of contract, I’m hoping we can snap him up when he becomes available. Signing Willis and Bright would be a statement of intent that we’re aiming for L1 promotion.
I like Sterling and Thomas a lot, but there may be free agents coming up this summer that will soften their departures. Ideally, a winger who is more clinical than Thomas would be great.
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
Goijg agsin next season in league 1 always has to be plan b
If we got promoted this year it could be pivotal for this club
If we got promoted this year it could be pivotal for this club
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
It wasn’t just that Otis. It was stubbornly persisting with the same selections and refusing to give others a chance up front, bizarre substitutions (take Shrewsbury away as an example) and a common theme of folding after half time.
We had a patch of winning 3 in a row around Christmas when he decided to change things up. Then he reverted to type and we dropped a lot of points against the worst sides in the league. Then Burge and Craplin get injured and the forced changes get us taking chances without insanity in goal
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Wolves have another year option on Bright. I doubt they’ll be letting him go.
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
It would be a fight for survival but at least some decent football on offer
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
Yup higher quality perms and loans
More media coveragw
And as always the hope something magical happens and you reach prem which woulf end financial issues i imagine
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
Personally, I think they will let him go, Wolves ought to be competing for a Europa League spot and beyond after this season. Bright is a good player, but I can’t see him being in a position to play 1st team for Wolves again.
For me, he probably ends up at a Championship side unless Robins really sells the CCFC ‘project’.
Irish Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Still no credit for Robin’s then. You felt we were lucky to be promoted last season? In a harder league we are 25 places higher than we were last season. We are winning games with Shipley (central midfielder) playing on the wing and Hiwula (striker) also playing on the wing. However, Robins has simply become successful because he is playing players in their correct positions. He needs to be given time to succeed. The next time we lose a game it would be nice if we didn’t get the usual negative reaction. Look at the comments on Robins and certain players after the Burton game.
Irish Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
I also don’t understand the ”Craplin” tag you continue to give one of our players, this season’s “Mc Numpty”?Whatever people think of him as a player, most who are fair minded would agree that he always gives 100%. He is a 21 year old living away from home for the first time but is apparently fair game to be written off and treated with contempt. It hasn’t come off in the way everyone would have hoped, but I think he has shown glimpses of the player he could be next season. Robins stuck with Biamou and McNulty when there was a clamour from some to bin them both. It is a good job he has the patience and the courage to back his judgements.
Last edited:
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
This is a God awful league Irish, the one below was even worse and we snuck home after the shackles were let off in the final run-in. Are there many teams here with master tacticians at the helm or high quality players? No, there are teams better or worse organised and the best teams have strikers who know where the net is. Criticism came for his management across sequences of games where his stubbornness continued to cost us. It isn't simply 'we lost, Robins out'
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
What else do you call a player whose misses routinely defy belief for a professional. He's paid bloody good money to miss from 6 yards every week
ccfcway
Well-Known Member
His stubbornness has meant he persisted with hwuila on the wing, Shipley in the match day squad, not filling the team with journeymen footballers and promoting youth who will be here medium / long term or will make us a profit when out the door.
Long may this stubbornness continue as I for one am grateful to have him here
Long may this stubbornness continue as I for one am grateful to have him here
Irish Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
His management across the sequence of the season got us promoted. I would think that that is the sequence that counted. Last season, as with this season, I felt in many games we were by far the better team (Cambridge away for example) where the results simply did not match the performances. We lost Andreu and Jones through injury, arguably our two most influential players and Nazon in January. Despite all of this, he managed to get us up. His starting position was also the team that were so abject the season before. His acquisition of McNulty on a free, got us a 28 goal forward and also his fee seems to have funded this season’s incoming players who have produced another play off chasing season.
Robins became the first manager to give us a promotion in fifty years. The first one to give us a top 6 finish in 40 years. You can only compete in the league you are in, master tactician or not, in a league of poor teams or not, Robins achieved his objective. Over a 49 game season to say that this is down to luck is a little bit churlish.
Were you bouncing around with the rest of us in Nottingham and at Wembley last May? I bet you were! That we were able to forge memories that will last a lifetime is down to good management.
Last edited:
Irish Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
I’ve watched Swindon a few times this season including watching us play Luton on the Sunday having watched them play Grimsby on the Saturday. This league is miles better than the fourth division in my opinion. The players are far more comfortable on the ball with much more emphasis on keeping possession. We have made the step up and but for the profligacy up front we should be at least be comfortably in the play offs. Only Luton at home have outplayed us I think.
Last edited:
Irish Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Luke Thomas, who I have really enjoyed watching this season and who I think has the chances to be a top player, has missed far more. Do we call him names too? Granted the overall contribution of Thomas has been more than that of Chaplin but Chaplin has still contributed to the team. He has scored poacher’s goals (Peterborough and Wycombe at home), he has scored two great free kicks (Bradford and Plymouth away). His two disallowed goals just after he signed show that he can also score outside of the box. He has missed some great chances, so did McNulty so does every striker. He hasn’t hit the ground running in the way everyone hoped but does he deserve the contempt he gets from some? If he hid, shirked responsibility and strolled through games fair enough. He doesn’t do that. The negativity on here towards our own players is unbelievable sometimes. According to one poster (not you) after the Burton game the players were cowards and Robins was an incompetent.
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
It isn’t contempt, it’s legitimate criticism. The comments against him aren’t personal and when Robins screws up I don’t think it’s unfair to call it out. If I’m wrong City succeed and I ‘m quite happy having egg on my face. But he insisted on playing out of form strikers during a barren spell, made bizarre subs every week etc etc
Some praise him sticking with the same stuff week in week out, others see it as a predictable weakness. This is a poor league and there is little between most of the teams. Does it mean I want him to do badly of course not. But we should all want improvement even when results are good.
ccfcway
Well-Known Member
Not having a go, but genuine question. Do you not think he wants improvement ?.
I get it with slade etc, but surely robins deserves our support ?
Sky_Blue_Dreamer
Well-Known Member
I largely agree with you apart from the bit in bold.
I think it was more BECAUSE rather than in spite of that that we improved and pushed on. Had Jones and Andreu not got injured I'm not sure MR would've altered the system/personnel which gave Bayliss his opportunity and helped McNulty show his goalscoring form alongside Max?
Similarly this season, although we're still nowhere near clinical up front, since Chaplin got injured he's effectively been left with just Baka and Hiwula as strikers and I think we've looked a bit more dangerous up front since that. Had Chaplin been available, do you think MR would've given those two (Baka esp) a run of games to prove themselves at Chaplin's expense? I doubt it.
Having said that I do think that it's now happened when Chaplin is fit MR will recognise he has to wait for his chance to dislodge one of them.
MR does seem to be 'lucky' in that respect - major injuries that would normally totally derail a team somehow led to us finding something that worked better, and I'll take a lucky manager any day of the week!
kg82
Well-Known Member
He dropped Chaplin before he was injured though. Baka has been in the starting line up about 9-10 games in a row now. Chaplains only been injured for about 5-6 of them.
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
I think he does, but a bit like Pressley, he gets stuck in his ways. None of his critics WANTS anything other than to be proven wrong.
HuckerbyDublinWhelan
Well-Known Member
I feel like this is a write off season for Chaplin, that being said - he’s established within the squad, if he gets a good pre-season behind him I reckon MR will get the best from him
DannyThomas_1981
Well-Known Member
I agree with your post ccfcway.
But in many ways, I also see Robins as one of our most flexible managers who is not afraid to change things and admit mistakes. For example, this season I know that Robins had really big hopes for his marquee signing (Ogogo) and a high class player returning from injury (Andreu). Neither worked out and Robins moved to a different plan. He has also been flexible in moving on both Doyle and JCH for the benefit of the wider team. Other managers would have stuck to the tried and tested and playing favourites vs. making changes (Strachan playing Telfer every week as a good example).
letsallsingtogether
Well-Known Member
Some would still want him out.
They just like him.
Same with players some take a dislike to them and will never give them credit.
ccfcway
Well-Known Member
I completely get the “I think we might lose today but I hope I’m wrong” comments on a match day.
I dont get “we shouldn’t get rid of manager and player x etc, but i hope they improve and I hope I’m wrong”. That’s not support. It’s fine to have that opinion, but at least stick to it.
I dont get “we shouldn’t get rid of manager and player x etc, but i hope they improve and I hope I’m wrong”. That’s not support. It’s fine to have that opinion, but at least stick to it.
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
No it’s ‘I think he’s stubbornly sticking to something that isn’t working but hope I’m wrong’.
Look at our performances in both winless runs and it sticks out like a sore thumb
ccfcway
Well-Known Member
1 up front and jordi on the wing ?. We didn’t deserve to lose as many as we did during that patch this season
Irish Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
It’s a bit pedantic to go on about it I know, but labelling him “Craplin” does seem to be personal and to be holding him in contempt. No problem with legitimate criticism. To write him off at 21 after half a season seems harsh.
You say that Robin’s “stubbornness” is a fault. As mentioned above, this stubbornness could be interpreted as having faith in his players and giving them a chance to succeed, something that happened with both Biamou and McNulty. It can therefore be interpreted as one of his strengths. Both Hiwula and Bakayoko were in the team before Chaplin’s injury and both are also his signings. Remember the vitriol heaped on both Bakayoko and Robins when he first joined? I think the departure of JCH says more about Robin’s views on Bakayoko than leaving Chaplin out. Surely it is more JCH he is replacing than Chaplin.
Robins either has or is close to having the best win ratio of any City manager. Despite this and all of the other facts that show how well he has done you can guarantee that as soon as we hit a rocky patch, the Robins Out brigade will be back. Even if we go up this season, a poor spell in the Championship will again have people calling for his head.
It’s madness. After all of the merry go round of managers we have had, one every year or 18 months, some want to go back to the lottery of getting someone else in when we clearly have someone who knows what he is doing.