Ratings (9 Viewers)

Forums New posts
Nick

Nick

Administrator
Defence and Marosi not really tested but we won every header at the back pretty much.

Shipley was lively first half, didnt really work for Westbrooke.

O hare made the difference by running at them, Biamou worked really hard which got him a goal. Covered defensively too.

Godden wasn't really in it much.
 
cc84cov

cc84cov

Well-Known Member
We need to start 2 up front & O’Hare,Shipley & Westbrooke for me are behind Allen & O’Hare the changes 2 up front & O’Hare turned the game.Mcfadzean was brilliant as was Walsh & Hyam,off to Essex on the lash for the night great times to be a city fan PUSB !!!
 
B

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
Marosi 7
Dabo 6 Generally fine but was a walking red in the second half
Hyam 7
McF 7.5 Marshalled the defence well
Rose 7
McCallum 7
Shipley 7
Walsh 7
Kelly 7
Westbrooke 7
Godden 6.5

Subs
O'Hare 8 Injected the missing quality we needed and took a fine goal
Biamou 7.5
Pask 6
 
SkyBlueGreeny

SkyBlueGreeny

Member
Marosi and the wall 8 had cigars on all game as per

Dabo 6 lost his head
Mccallum 6 poor on ball
Kelly 7 much improved
Walsh 7 easy game for him
Westbrooke 7 thought he was unlucky to be took off
Shipley 6 looked better today
Godden 7 works hard every game very rare he doesnt offer us anything

O'Hare 9 changed the game when we needed it
Biamou 7 very good again few mistimed touches but still a presence
 
S

SBT

Well-Known Member
Marosi - 7 Another clinic on distribution from the back, just look at their keeper as an example of how not to kick in that wind

Dabo - 6 A little scatterbrain at times as usual but got under their skin and made a nuisance
Rose - 7
McFadzean - 8 Excellent all round today
Hyam - 7
McCallum - 6 Wasted a few crosses in the second half that really should have been put away

Walsh - 8 MOTM Clearly a class above anyone else on the pitch, so important to everything we do
Kelly - 7
Westbrooke - 6
Shipley - 6 Should really have scored with the shot that hit the post

Godden - 6 Once again looked a lot more dangerous with a strike partner

Subs
O'Hare - 8 Changed the game, Southend completely failed to close him down
Biamou - 7 Worked his socks off
Pask - 6

Robins - 9 Took the opportunity to rest some of our livewires and looked to control the game with Shipley and Westbrooke instead. Probably wouldn't have even needed to bring on O'Hare if one of the woodwork efforts had gone in in the first half.

Feel like the scores would be even higher if we were playing a vaguely competent team, but you can only beat what's in front of you as the cliche goes
 
bawtryneal

bawtryneal

Well-Known Member
cc84cov said:
We need to start 2 up front & O’Hare,Shipley & Westbrooke for me are behind Allen & O’Hare the changes 2 up front & O’Hare turned the game.Mcfadzean was brilliant as was Walsh & Hyam,off to Essex on the lash for the night great times to be a city fan PUSB !!!
Click to expand...

Disagree.
The reason we are keeping clean sheets is partially due to one up front for first 60 plus minutes
Has worked for last 10 games or so, so why change ??
 
Liquid Gold

Liquid Gold

Well-Known Member
jordan210 said:
10 for Marosi just for the punch were he flew like superman
Click to expand...
Loved that. Just thought ‘what would Burge have done’ at the time. Couldn’t help but think faced with that he would have stuttered and Esther left it for a free header or dropped it at the strikers feet. Marosi calm as you like sorted it out.
 
Sick Boy

Sick Boy

Super Moderator
Marosi 7
Dabo 6
Hyam 7
McF 8
Rose 7
McCallum 6.5
Shipley 6
Walsh 7
Kelly 7
Westbrooke 6
Godden 6

Subs
O'Hare 8.5
Biamou 7
Pask 6
 
DannyThomas_1981

DannyThomas_1981

Well-Known Member
bawtryneal said:
Disagree.
The reason we are keeping clean sheets is partially due to one up front for first 60 plus minutes
Has worked for last 10 games or so, so why change ??
Click to expand...

Absolutely see both sides of this argument.

In either formation, I personally would like to see O'Hare on the pitch as long as possible. He's a true 10.

I can't ever remember a City team having so many options in formation or a stronger bench.

We also have the added 'problem' of bringing a near fully fit JJ into the mix.....who offers a different dimension as well. I'm a big fan of Allen as well and what he brings.

Shipley plays a key role in this formation as he plays a truly advanced role in supporting the lone striker - and must lead the midfield stats for goals/shots on target. So he's not playing a true number 10 role but in some situations he's even more advanced than Godden.

Our midfield must be a nightmare to play against given what each player brings and how they play different roles.
 
cc84cov

cc84cov

Well-Known Member
DannyThomas_1981 said:
Absolutely see both sides of this argument.

In either formation, I personally would like to see O'Hare on the pitch as long as possible. He's a true 10.

I can't ever remember a City team having so many options in formation or a stronger bench.

We also have the added 'problem' of bringing a near fully fit JJ into the mix.....who offers a different dimension as well. I'm a big fan of Allen as well and what he brings.

Shipley plays a key role in this formation as he plays a truly advanced role in supporting the lone striker - and must lead the midfield stats for goals/shots on target. So he's not playing a true number 10 role but in some situations he's even more advanced than Godden.

Our midfield must be a nightmare to play against given what each player brings and how they play different roles.
Click to expand...
Max & Baka play the lone role better than Godden or have done of late anyway for me if we’re gonna go 1 up I would prefer one of them over Godden
 
DannyThomas_1981

DannyThomas_1981

Well-Known Member
cc84cov said:
Max & Baka play the lone role better than Godden or have done of late anyway for me
Click to expand...

Agree with that cc84 for the most part. I do think Godden does a lot of work that is unnoticed. Whoever is playing that role - it's the hardest role on the pitch - always outnumbered but always needing to find some space to receive the ball from the midfield three. Or to drag the defenders out of position to give the midfield runners space.
 
cc84cov

cc84cov

Well-Known Member
DannyThomas_1981 said:
Agree with that cc84 for the most part. I do think Godden does a lot of work that is unnoticed. Whoever is playing that role - it's the hardest role on the pitch - always outnumbered but always needing to find some space to receive the ball from the midfield three. Or to drag the defenders out of position to give the midfield runners space.
Click to expand...
Fair point my issue is he just gets dominated by big defenders seeing it most weeks
 
Grendel

Grendel

Well-Known Member
bawtryneal said:
Disagree.
The reason we are keeping clean sheets is partially due to one up front for first 60 plus minutes
Has worked for last 10 games or so, so why change ??
Click to expand...

No he won’t change it at all especially as subs come on and score
 
Grendel

Grendel

Well-Known Member
cc84cov said:
Max & Baka play the lone role better than Godden or have done of late anyway for me if we’re gonna go 1 up I would prefer one of them over Godden
Click to expand...

Godden will always start when fit
 
JWC

JWC

Well-Known Member
Weird game, we didn’t really need to come out of second gear at all. O’Hare changed it, gave us a bit more life, but Southend were poor and I was confident we’d go on and win even before the subs.

All 7s apart from McFadz, Walsh and O’Hare with 8s. Dabo gets a 6 for being stupid with those fouls. Should have been sent off I think.

Must be a nice feeling for Robins to bring on both goal scorers. I really think he’s the man to take us up.
 
cc84cov

cc84cov

Well-Known Member
Have to say if robins takes us up this season from league 2 to having no ground gaining promotion the man will deserve a statue for sure ;)
 
COVKIDSNEVERQUIT

COVKIDSNEVERQUIT

Well-Known Member
cc84cov said:
Have to say if robins takes us up this season from league 2 to having no ground gaining promotion the man will deserve a statue for sure ;)
Click to expand...

And an open top bus parade through the City.
 
stupot07

stupot07

Well-Known Member
Marosi 7
Dabo 6
Rose 7
McFadzean 8 - MOTM
Hyam 7
McCallum 6
Kelly 7
Walsh 7
Shipley 6
Westbrook 6
Godden 5

Subs
O'Hare 7.5
Biamou 7
Pask 6

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
 
Londonccfcfan

Londonccfcfan

Well-Known Member
Marosi...7
Dabo...7
Hyam 8...brilliant again..flawless. his passing is improving.
Mcfadz..8
Rose.....6...still not at his best only one of back 3 again who gives ball away needlessly. Pask would be a better option judging on last 3 games. Imo.
Macallum...6..better
Kelly ..8..back to his gritty best
Walsh..7
Westbrook...7
Shipley.....7
Godden...7...Not sure why so my many criticism of him and low rating...worked so hard for the team. I thought he was good.

Ohare...7
Biamou.. 7
 
Londonccfcfan

Londonccfcfan

Well-Known Member
covcity4life said:
Marosi 8
Hyam 9
Mcfadz 9
Rose 8
Mcallum 6
Dabo 6
Kelly 6
Walsh 7
Shipley 7
Westbrooke 6
Godden 5

Biamou 7
O hare 8
Pask 6
Click to expand...


Godden 5?...his work rate was immense.
Can see he's back to his best. Didn't really get a sniff today. But he contributed to teams cause.
 
Sky Blue Pete

Sky Blue Pete

Well-Known Member
Londonccfcfan said:
Marosi...7
Dabo...7
Hyam 8...brilliant again..flawless. his passing is improving.
Mcfadz..8
Rose.....6...still not at his best only one of back 3 again who gives ball away needlessly. Pask would be a better option judging on last 3 games. Imo.
Macallum...6..better
Kelly ..8..back to his gritty best
Walsh..7
Westbrook...7
Shipley.....7
Godden...7...Not sure why so my many criticism of him and low rating...worked so hard for the team. I thought he was good.

Ohare...7
Biamou.. 7
Click to expand...
Rose was excellent against Pompey
 
Liquid Gold

Liquid Gold

Well-Known Member
Londonccfcfan said:
Godden 5?...his work rate was immense.
Can see he's back to his best. Didn't really get a sniff today. But he contributed to teams cause.
Click to expand...
He needs to be more of a goal threat when playing up top on his own. He does some great work for the team no denying and if he’d had Shipley’s shots today I’d have said he had a good game but he spends too little time in the penalty area.
 
Evo1883

Evo1883

Well-Known Member
Londonccfcfan said:
Marosi...7
Dabo...7
Hyam 8...brilliant again..flawless. his passing is improving.
Mcfadz..8
Rose.....6...still not at his best only one of back 3 again who gives ball away needlessly. Pask would be a better option judging on last 3 games. Imo.
Macallum...6..better
Kelly ..8..back to his gritty best
Walsh..7
Westbrook...7
Shipley.....7
Godden...7...Not sure why so my many criticism of him and low rating...worked so hard for the team. I thought he was good.

Ohare...7
Biamou.. 7
Click to expand...

He was good, its the usual suspects is all... Same every week
 
Evo1883

Evo1883

Well-Known Member
How anybody can rate McCallum above godden today is mind blowing.

The lad was abysmal again for long periods
Did OK last 15

Kelly iffy again at times, Walsh grew into it.

Fadz MOTM for me
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 10 (members: 0, guests: 10)
Top