Ratings (12 Viewers)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
Johhny Blue
Well-Known Member
Maatsen was decent
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Based on the first half alone you can't give 7s out IMO ..
Kane stepped forward like a toddler to open us up for the first so loses a point on whatever his rating is ..
Sheaf lazy pass in midfield fucked us for their third , so loses a point , maybe 2 actually for his contribution to being dinked in midfield for their second by a fucking keeper .
Fadz loses 1 or 2 points for his role in the third and role in the second
Rose some blame for the first ..
Nobody today over a 6
Kane stepped forward like a toddler to open us up for the first so loses a point on whatever his rating is ..
Sheaf lazy pass in midfield fucked us for their third , so loses a point , maybe 2 actually for his contribution to being dinked in midfield for their second by a fucking keeper .
Fadz loses 1 or 2 points for his role in the third and role in the second
Rose some blame for the first ..
Nobody today over a 6
Fergusons_Beard
Well-Known Member
Cannot carry on playing a left back in midfield.
What a complete an utter waste of a playing position.
Just unbalances our team and no matter how well he plays it cannot continue.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
What a complete an utter waste of a playing position.
Just unbalances our team and no matter how well he plays it cannot continue.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
stevefloyd
Well-Known Member
Try as I might I cannot see what Bidwell brings to us...not the best at passing crossing is utterly useless he just looks lost ...too slow totally baffling...get rid of Kasta and Dacosta then brings in another lemon
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Yea I'd agree somewhat but ultimately its down the middle, Sheaf and fadz really allowed a ball to be dinked between the lines from there is tragic
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
Yeah the second goal was just pathetic, but part of that is having a back line that sits so deep
Winny the Bish
Well-Known Member
Moore - 5
Kane - 5.5
Rose - 5
McFadz - 4
JCS - 6
Bidwell - 4
Sheaf - 4.5
Hamer - 5
Allen - 3
Maatsen - 6
Gyokeres - 5
Kane - 5.5
Rose - 5
McFadz - 4
JCS - 6
Bidwell - 4
Sheaf - 4.5
Hamer - 5
Allen - 3
Maatsen - 6
Gyokeres - 5
junglej13
Well-Known Member
Honestly don't see anything in Maatsen. Beyond wasteful at wing back. Looks a fish out of water in the attacking midfielder roles, particularly when he has his back to goal (which is understandable).
Jamesimus
Well-Known Member
Moore 5 - maybe could have done better for second goal.
Bidwell 4 - seems to not yet possess a first touch. Only a second
JCS 6 - best of our defenders today
Rose 5 - think he had taken a half a valium in the interval
McFadz 4 - didn't realize you could get slower than "stationary"
Hamer 5 - extra point for scoring a goal and not celebrating because he knew we were shit today
Sheaf 4 - had the other half of Roses valium. Would be nice if he met Hamer one day in training and they learnt how to exchange passes with each other
Allen 5 - think he played. Sometimes gets lost in the long grass
Kane 5 - attempted some crosses
Gyokeres 4 - sometimes a bit selfish, had a couple of good opportunities gifted to him today that other players would have done better with
Waghorn 5 - set up the goal I think? Still don't like him.
Maatsen 5 - better at left wing back. Needs to get in the weights room or get bullied mercilessly by the other players until he becomes horrible.
Godden 5 - good effort on goal after coming on. Largely anonymous after that.
Swansea 8 - good team. Not sure why they're not up there. Grimes and Obafemi very good. "Can we play you every week" - no of course not, it's against the rules and besides, I would not enjoy it.
Bidwell 4 - seems to not yet possess a first touch. Only a second
JCS 6 - best of our defenders today
Rose 5 - think he had taken a half a valium in the interval
McFadz 4 - didn't realize you could get slower than "stationary"
Hamer 5 - extra point for scoring a goal and not celebrating because he knew we were shit today
Sheaf 4 - had the other half of Roses valium. Would be nice if he met Hamer one day in training and they learnt how to exchange passes with each other
Allen 5 - think he played. Sometimes gets lost in the long grass
Kane 5 - attempted some crosses
Gyokeres 4 - sometimes a bit selfish, had a couple of good opportunities gifted to him today that other players would have done better with
Waghorn 5 - set up the goal I think? Still don't like him.
Maatsen 5 - better at left wing back. Needs to get in the weights room or get bullied mercilessly by the other players until he becomes horrible.
Godden 5 - good effort on goal after coming on. Largely anonymous after that.
Swansea 8 - good team. Not sure why they're not up there. Grimes and Obafemi very good. "Can we play you every week" - no of course not, it's against the rules and besides, I would not enjoy it.
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
Grimes is one of the best midfielders in the league, surprised they held on to him
The Philosopher
Well-Known Member
Moore 5
Beaten 3 times, and again when there was a late offside call and again when an offside striker hit the post and Moore punched it in his own net. Bad day at the office.
Kane 8
Did well and was our best attacking threat. On another day 2/3 assists. Looked sharper than of late.
Rose 6
Part of a defence that conceded 3. Couple of sloppy balls.
McFadzean 5
Outpaced too often and just not the rock he was. Earlier in season I’d have said extend his contract. Now? £1000 a week, help the squad, take or leave.
Clarke-Salter 6
So so. Not his best game.
Bidwell 4
“Needs time”. GTF. Just really really poor today.
Sheaf 5
Is anyone allowed to say he was poor today without the usual Emperors New Clothes apologists telling us that we are thick for not seeing how great he is? He was crap today. That dithering, losing the ball and looking to the sky rather than chasing back shitplay crept back in today. He’s been better of late - but he was shite today.
Hamer 7
Bang average but + 1 for goal. He has quality.
Allen 5
Pushed around a bit today. Not brilliant.
Maatsen 7
He is quality but was unlucky today. I like him.
Gyokeres 6 (just)
Isolated. Maybe playing against defenders who know his runs. Fluffed 2 great chances.
Another day, different story.
Godden 6
So so.
Waghorn 4
So shite.
Beaten 3 times, and again when there was a late offside call and again when an offside striker hit the post and Moore punched it in his own net. Bad day at the office.
Kane 8
Did well and was our best attacking threat. On another day 2/3 assists. Looked sharper than of late.
Rose 6
Part of a defence that conceded 3. Couple of sloppy balls.
McFadzean 5
Outpaced too often and just not the rock he was. Earlier in season I’d have said extend his contract. Now? £1000 a week, help the squad, take or leave.
Clarke-Salter 6
So so. Not his best game.
Bidwell 4
“Needs time”. GTF. Just really really poor today.
Sheaf 5
Is anyone allowed to say he was poor today without the usual Emperors New Clothes apologists telling us that we are thick for not seeing how great he is? He was crap today. That dithering, losing the ball and looking to the sky rather than chasing back shitplay crept back in today. He’s been better of late - but he was shite today.
Hamer 7
Bang average but + 1 for goal. He has quality.
Allen 5
Pushed around a bit today. Not brilliant.
Maatsen 7
He is quality but was unlucky today. I like him.
Gyokeres 6 (just)
Isolated. Maybe playing against defenders who know his runs. Fluffed 2 great chances.
Another day, different story.
Godden 6
So so.
Waghorn 4
So shite.
Liquid Gold
Well-Known Member
Kane had a decent second half. Was shit all round though.
Earlsdon_Skyblue1
Well-Known Member
Struggling to see how anyone can be much above a 5. I feel really sorry for anyone that travelled today. Hopefully they took enough cocaine in the toilets to numb the pain.
The Philosopher
Well-Known Member
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Unfortunately I can't even do that these days .. so I just have to cry for 3 hours until I'm home
Sick Boy
Super Moderator
I'm taking their overall contribution during the time they were on the pitch.
Apart from his goal Hamer was poor.
Waghorn wasn't that bad when he came on and nicely picked out Hamer for the goal.
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
Hamer was atrocious in the period where the game was lost
Calista
Well-Known Member
In the last couple of seasons, I've lost count of the number of times McFadzean has given opponents a couple of yards by wasting his time putting his hand in the air and looking at the officials. It's a baffling schoolboy error, considering his experience and how mature he is in every other aspect of his game.
GaryMabbuttsLeftKnee
Well-Known Member
Didn’t go today and sounds like it wasn’t good by anyone’s reckoning, that said, very odd comment as their link up has probably been the highlight of our entire season
Jamesimus
Well-Known Member
You're of course right and my comment was largely in jest. But if you watched today you may have thought similar! @GaryMabbuttsLeftKnee
rob9872
Well-Known Member
For anyone that moans about OHare see today. No threat without him.
Blame the manager for today too, set us up wrong called the changes needed at HT and he didn't make them. Even at 3down he didn't try anything different even in shape to try 4 at the back. Went 2 up top by removing a midfielder where we were already over run.
Fadz waving his arm around for the first instead of playing to the whistle didn't help and can't believe kane given motm 7 ratings here, personally thought he was abysmal today. For me only JCS came out with any credit. Nice finish by Hamer but most of his silly flicks gave away possession. Not going down, so need to sort something ahead of Tuesday and have a good go at Luton or season could quickly tail off with a whimper.
Blame the manager for today too, set us up wrong called the changes needed at HT and he didn't make them. Even at 3down he didn't try anything different even in shape to try 4 at the back. Went 2 up top by removing a midfielder where we were already over run.
Fadz waving his arm around for the first instead of playing to the whistle didn't help and can't believe kane given motm 7 ratings here, personally thought he was abysmal today. For me only JCS came out with any credit. Nice finish by Hamer but most of his silly flicks gave away possession. Not going down, so need to sort something ahead of Tuesday and have a good go at Luton or season could quickly tail off with a whimper.
SkyblueDad
Well-Known Member
I would agree with that but I make JCS just about our best player today covers our vulnerable left side well.
Sky_Blue_Dreamer
Well-Known Member
I agree with a lot of that, but we did create some decent opportunities. Had we been as clinical as them we would have (undeservedly) got something from the game.
I think today proved we don't have the same energy without O'hare and adds a great deal to our play, but we were still getting chances in front of goal.
Now you could argue the bulk of those came when we were already 3 down and so maybe Swansea had taken the foot of the gas a bit. But we've said in previous games playing this box formation that Gyokeres looks isolated and we aren't creating much.
Nick
Administrator
We created chances and missed sitters.
