USSR invades Ukraine. (5 Viewers)

PVA

Well-Known Member
Seeing all these videos of Russian conscripts being rounded up, chucked into vans, fighting amongst themselves, drunks stumbling around with bottles of booze, being given WW2 equipment, 2 weeks training.

It's unbelievable.
 

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
Seeing all these videos of Russian conscripts being rounded up, chucked into vans, fighting amongst themselves, drunks stumbling around with bottles of booze, being given WW2 equipment, 2 weeks training.

It's unbelievable.

It’s the only strategy the country has ever known. Just send wave after wave of fodder at the enemy
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
Genuinely seems like a way to get a load of people out of prisons, off their dole and the pension list, or out of the way if they moan about the government or are a bit too Asian more than a serious attempt at a military operation.
 

PVA

Well-Known Member
I would suggest the WW2 casualty rate says otherwise

Germany lost more soldiers as a % of total population than The Soviet Union in WW2.

Their tactics were not to throw wave after wave of fodder at the enemy. But, similar to today, they lacked the organisation, leadership and training to successfully implement their tactics so it often appeared like they were just throwing men at it.

Films like Enemy at the Gates have a lot to answer for!
 

Flying Fokker

Well-Known Member
Germany lost more soldiers as a % of total population than The Soviet Union in WW2.

Their tactics were not to throw wave after wave of fodder at the enemy. But, similar to today, they lacked the organisation, leadership and training to successfully implement their tactics so it often appeared like they were just throwing men at it.

Films like Enemy at the Gates have a lot to answer for!

just wonder if this is where you got your stats from?
 

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
Germany lost more soldiers as a % of total population than The Soviet Union in WW2.

Their tactics were not to throw wave after wave of fodder at the enemy. But, similar to today, they lacked the organisation, leadership and training to successfully implement their tactics so it often appeared like they were just throwing men at it.

Films like Enemy at the Gates have a lot to answer for!

I have a pretty strong interest in WW2 beyond Jude Law films. Stalin saw people as expendable, no question. The proportion lost for the losing side would of course be higher but the absolute totals for the USSR are horrendous.
 

PVA

Well-Known Member
I have a pretty strong interest in WW2 beyond Jude Law films. Stalin saw people as expendable, no question. The proportion lost for the losing side would of course be higher but the absolute totals for the USSR are horrendous.

The Enemy at the Gates comment wasn't aimed at you, it was just a general comment 👍🏻

People were expendable for all leaders and all countries, that's just the nature of war in those times.

Of course the totals for the Soviets are awful, but that still doesn't mean that sending wave after wave of people was their strategy. It happened sometimes, but was not their strategy. Same as now really.
 

tisza

Well-Known Member
Poor fuckers. it’s going to be a bloodbath.


they are quite literally cannon fodder. Mass groupings going to use up Ukrainian larger missiles which are difficult to replace. Literally sending people to their death to deplete Ukrainian arms reserves.
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
they are quite literally cannon fodder. Mass groupings going to use up Ukrainian larger missiles which are difficult to replace. Literally sending people to their death to deplete Ukrainian arms reserves.

Still think the primary aim is ethnic cleansing.
 

PVA

Well-Known Member
Still think the primary aim is ethnic cleansing.

It does make you wonder if that's what's going on.

Though poor minorities in the middle of nowhere are less likely to cause unrest and protests than plucking people from the major cities so I think they will be conscripted in much larger numbers.
 

duffer

Well-Known Member
Imagine my shock when I woke up on Sunday morning to find that I was still alive. Talk about an anticlimax.

Yeah, with hindsight maxing out my credit card on bottles of Cristal down the casino on Saturday night probably wasn't a good move... Saying that, with this government we'll probably all be bust by the end of the month anyway.

Smoke 'em if you got 'em, seems to be the official cabinet line. 😁
 

Otis

Well-Known Member
Yeah, with hindsight maxing out my credit card on bottles of Cristal down the casino on Saturday night probably wasn't a good move... Saying that, with this government we'll probably all be bust by the end of the month anyway.

Smoke 'em if you got 'em, seems to be the official cabinet line. 😁



If ya ain't got em, then ya hit rock bottom.

😎
 

PVA

Well-Known Member
Lyman looks like it will be encircled soon. I wonder if this will result in a collapse of the Donbas front similar to that of Karkhiv (fingers crossed).


 

jimmyhillsfanclub

Well-Known Member
Hmm, not sure. You get information and disinformation on all sides, so hard to tell. It is a Russian type of thing to do though.

Are they saying it is definitely sabotage and not a fault?

Seismologists confirmed it was explosions.....whether they were caused deliberately or not is still a guess I suppose.

Just seems to me that if the Russians wanted to disrupt the gas flow, they could do it a lot more simply & a lot closer to home without risking a covert underwater mission in Danish/German waters....
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
Hmm, not sure. You get information and disinformation on all sides, so hard to tell. It is a Russian type of thing to do though.

Are they saying it is definitely sabotage and not a fault?

Unless the fault was someone left 100kg of C4 down there by accident…

Very weird all round, not sure why the Russians would do it, unless it’s the ensure no way back from war.
 

SBAndy

Well-Known Member
Unless the fault was someone left 100kg of C4 down there by accident…

Very weird all round, not sure why the Russians would do it, unless it’s the ensure no way back from war.

My hunch is that they’ve done it to show they have the capability to take out that new Norwegian pipeline at any time. Bit of a strange way of doing it, mind.
 

LastGarrison

Well-Known Member
My hunch is that they’ve done it to show they have the capability to take out that new Norwegian pipeline at any time. Bit of a strange way of doing it, mind.
Surely this just pushes the EU into finding alternatives and cutting off their reliance altogether?

Unless of course it is done to drive gas prices up further to add additional pressure to EU countries over the cost of living crisis coming into the winter months.
 

Frank Sidebottom

Well-Known Member

This is absolutely nuts, Drafting Ukrainians into the Russian Army to fight against Ukraine.... I'm sure that'll work well.
Fucking horrendous situation for those poor folks to be forced into.... but surely arming Ukrainians to attack their own countrymen is a very, very stupid idea.
 

eastwoodsdustman

Well-Known Member
So do we all believe its the Russians that have sabotaged the nord-stream pipelines?
I'm sure I read somewhere that the only vessel in the area at the time was a US navy one.
Disclaimer: I did have cheese that evening so could have been a vivid dream.

Maybe It wasn't a dream:

 
Last edited:

eastwoodsdustman

Well-Known Member

This is absolutely nuts, Drafting Ukrainians into the Russian Army to fight against Ukraine.... I'm sure that'll work well.
Fucking horrendous situation for those poor folks to be forced into.... but surely arming Ukrainians to attack their own countrymen is a very, very stupid idea.
This is mental if they do it. They're basically asking Ukrainians to fight eachother.
The more I see of Russia's actions there, the more it parallels 1930's and 1940's Germany in Europe.
 

Kieranp96

Well-Known Member
So do we all believe its the Russians that have sabotaged the nord-stream pipelines?
Somebody is at fault but who knows who, I don’t think it benefits anyone, apart from maybe the us who can now sell gas to us via ships. One thing is for sure Europe will be struggling for a few winters to come, hopefully the governments come together and find a solution.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top