rob9872
Well-Known Member
I hope you're right, but I keep reading despite zero goals that he's already playing well, I can't see it.
Bristol city player ratings (5 Viewers)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
And today was not one of his better games either. He's been a v good signing
peteCCFC
Well-Known Member
Lampard 10.
Spent previous weeks watching Da Silva being bullied by a long ball for 90 minutes with no help, first 10 minutes I was worried as he was being targeted again. Watched Frank talking to Binks and Kitching telling the to get tighter to the left hand side to help the situation and it worked.
Spent previous weeks watching Da Silva being bullied by a long ball for 90 minutes with no help, first 10 minutes I was worried as he was being targeted again. Watched Frank talking to Binks and Kitching telling the to get tighter to the left hand side to help the situation and it worked.
Hobo
Well-Known Member
Agree with this except Torp 6.5. He did some good stuff but also some terrible passes. Also he doesn't always give the player on the ball and option to pass, i.e run and make an angle.
Simms more 7 than 8.
GaryMabbuttsLeftKnee
Well-Known Member
Dovin really does look the part at this stage. Dasilva was very good. Felt like far more came down the right than the left. Don’t think Simms was bad but the ‘outstanding’ and ‘bully’ comments feel way OTT for me. He worked hard, put himself about but there were some really low quality moments in there too. He’s still my pick for CF. God knows what you’re gonna get with BTA, 2 superb touches in the first half to hold up play, plenty of “what is he doing?!” then a superb finish to round it off
Earlsdon_Skyblue1
Well-Known Member
Yes, I agree. I wasn't particularly enthused watching him earlier in the season but he's looked solid since Lampard has come in. Long may it continue.
Sky Blue Pete
Well-Known Member
Kitching definitely binks not good at covering as lcb
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
Same i genuinely love Simms. Should have had at least 2 assists today.
Its a travesty he hasnt had a proper run (starts) in games. Hes getting close to the form where he scored 15 in about half a season.
Think he linked very well with Asante who i thought was on it from minute today and git worse after he scored. Very frustraing.
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
Dovin 8. Unbelievable he was out of the team. Absolute class.
MVE ..6.5
Lati....7
Binks..6
Kitching...7.5..one his best games.
Da Silva...6
Allen...8
Torp...5.5..Dont see what others did today
Rudoni..7
Simms 8
BTA 7...extra point for the goal improved xg with that one!
MVE ..6.5
Lati....7
Binks..6
Kitching...7.5..one his best games.
Da Silva...6
Allen...8
Torp...5.5..Dont see what others did today
Rudoni..7
Simms 8
BTA 7...extra point for the goal improved xg with that one!
Ccfcisparks
Well-Known Member
Da silva and Torp 6 and 5.5 but Rudoni a 7 wow
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
Torp passes well , always shows for the ball and now he tackles, becoming a good all round midfielder for me.
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
Correct ..Torp i thought was awfull not his fault though playing out of position on the right.offered no outlet for MVE at all.
He did a job hence just a 6.
Rudoni through ball was a thing of beauty get an extra point for being one of my favs.
Cally Fedora
Well-Known Member
Dovin. Excellent
Kitching. Excellent
Allen. Excellent
Don’t rate Torp but he had one of his better games today
Kitching. Excellent
Allen. Excellent
Don’t rate Torp but he had one of his better games today
Torp was not playing on the right.
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
Yes when you play wing backs then they are the only wide players and provide all the width.
Torp was playing central midfield, as was Eccles (not left midfield as you put in another thread.)
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
I'd love to know what formation you think we were playing if you thought Torp played right midfield and Eccles left midfield.
Ccfcisparks
Well-Known Member
Robins played Dovin a lot so I don’t get your pointPeople still wondering why Robins had to go should look at the inclusion of Dovin and Kitch and recent upturn in form and results. It ain’t difficult.
CCFCAnalysis
Well-Known Member
You either spent the whole game in the bar, or didn’t actually go at all.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
harvey098
Well-Known Member
Brilliant thisPeople still wondering why Robins had to go should look at the inclusion of Dovin and Kitch and recent upturn in form and results. It ain’t difficult.
a few weeks ago people were saying “Robins had to go because he’s wasted good money on players like Dovin and Kitching”.And for what it’s worth…. Dovin started 11/14 under Robins. It was clear he was his preferred choice.
Last edited:
I think the point is that this season Robins chopped and changed from
Match to match which doesn’t help build players confidence or understanding on the pitch.
I think Dovin has been excellent since he was reintroduced into the team, I do think Frank prefers a more experienced and vocal keeper and his comments after each match make me think Dovin wouldn’t need to do too much wrong for Wilson to get another chance. I hope I’m wrong as I think Dovin is showing real potential and for that to blossom he needs to feel confident.
What?!
They are two entirely different positions, it's not pedantry. I cannot even believe this needs explaining.
Gibbo
Well-Known Member
Torp was one of my top players for the game only bettered buy Dovin and Kitching.
He has a really neat trick of dispossessing an opponent legally almost from behind. It is is a shame that by and large thereafter he plays the ball back to reset the attack, rather than forward because at the point he robbed the opponent the opposition are in attack mindset and could be caught unawares. He must learn to seize the moment
Torp rather than Eccles has gained most from having Lampard as a coach
Gibbo
Well-Known Member
Best: Dovin and Kitching. Begs the obvious 'if only' question? Kitchings long passes down the left were particularly effective
Astonished by the negativity of the match thread during the 1st half. I really enjoyed it. It was either a bit frantic or more direct, take your pick But great fun. I was just so glad that either through choice or because it was forced on us by the Bristol high press, we were far more direct.
Nobody had a stinker. Simms caused them all sorts of problems and should have scored. You could say the same for Rudoni. Lati at least doesn't give the ball away like Thomas.
Negatives: Still not sure why we bought Binks. And sorry JDS, but even in a 3-5-2 formation and with all your lovely footwork, you are still pants at defending. That Lampard had to tell Binks and Kitching to cover says it all. And the neat footwork did not lead to anything. Bring back Bidwell for Blackburn Frank, please...I beg of you.
Astonished by the negativity of the match thread during the 1st half. I really enjoyed it. It was either a bit frantic or more direct, take your pick But great fun. I was just so glad that either through choice or because it was forced on us by the Bristol high press, we were far more direct.
Nobody had a stinker. Simms caused them all sorts of problems and should have scored. You could say the same for Rudoni. Lati at least doesn't give the ball away like Thomas.
Negatives: Still not sure why we bought Binks. And sorry JDS, but even in a 3-5-2 formation and with all your lovely footwork, you are still pants at defending. That Lampard had to tell Binks and Kitching to cover says it all. And the neat footwork did not lead to anything. Bring back Bidwell for Blackburn Frank, please...I beg of you.
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
I think of RCM as central position
Rm as wing position
I dunno what u two r arguing about though btw
Sick Boy
Super Moderator
Not only is Dovin the better 'keeper, despite being 10 years younger, Dovin is not far off the same number of first team appearances as Wilson.
Exactly. Someone said Torp played right midfield and Eccles left midfield. That is plainly false, they both played centrally.