Transfer Rumour Tom Davies - Pompey (1 Viewer)

Cavan O'Doherty said:

It's not hard to understand, when I've watched him he's been crap. Can't be relying on him to come good half way through the season.

Click to expand...

It is hard to understand because you're making a statement with no explanation. 'He's been crap. He's useless'. What was? The free headers he missed? The one on ones he failed to convert? The times he failed to slip his team mates clean through?

ccfcway said:

that's one hell of a statement. Plenty of contenders

Click to expand...

I know what you mean

But the opening period last night was desperately bad, and for the first time in all my years not even up to Football League standard IMO. We were getting played off the park by Shrewsbury. I looked around at that empty stadium and the clueless rubbish being served up on the pitch, and honestly felt like crying.

Second half was OK though.

Cavan O'Doherty said:

You can't tell me that he's the answer. From what I've watched he's been useless.

Click to expand...

Yes and you have seen the Grand total of 120 minutes from him? He might well turn out to be shit, but he needs to be given a chance. So many times in football. players a written off as shit before being given a chance

I'd be the first to admin Biamou doesn't look up to scratch yet but he's in his first few minutes of league football. Give him a few months of sub appearances and training time and he may well become a decent asset.

skybluegod said:

Yes and you have seen the Grand total of 120 minutes from him? He might well turn out to be shit, but he needs to be given a chance. So many times in football. players a written off as shit before being given a chance

Click to expand...

Of course It IS too early to wright him off, he may well settle and become a valued member of the squad.
But having said that, he hasn't exactly helped his cause by not breaking sweat when given the brief chance he's had. And if we were scoring for fun, he wouldn't be mentioned at all.
He will get another chance, but he has to put a shift in as people's patience will not last forever, especially when he's taking a place on the bench ahead of Ponticelli.

From MR's post match interview last night he seemed to pretty much rule out getting another striker basically saying that the issue was service to the strikers we already have.

skybluetony176 said:

From MR's post match interview last night he seemed to pretty much rule out getting another striker basically saying that the issue was service to the strikers we already have.

Click to expand...

At present, I agree with MR. The strikers should score some goals at this level, given previous record of some. But, if we aren't playing to their strengths, we are going to struggle.
I think most can see the gap between the forward line and midfield, hoofing to a lone striker isn't working with our current strikers and we can play well with ball at feet, but not yet cutting through teams consistently.

ccfcway said:

so,in summary, after 26 posts, we need

a CB for cover
a striker as Biamou is no good
a winger as we only have one

people do know we are down to our last 4 goalkeepers. what if 3 of them get injured.

Click to expand...

a striker as Biamou is no good - Nor are Mcnulty or Beavon
a winger as we only have one - Who is shit

skybluetony176 said:

From MR's post match interview last night he seemed to pretty much rule out getting another striker basically saying that the issue was service to the strikers we already have.

Click to expand...

Pretty much what Benno was saying too, pre and post match

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

The little I’ve seen of us we’ve had trouble linking play and stretching the game. I’d rather see Andreu pulled back to midfield and some pace on the wing I think, but not seen enough of Nazon to know if he could do a job there. Even if he can, if Jodi or him are off form we don’t look like unlocking defences.

I’d still like to see Thomas given a run as well before we give up on him

Pompey progress in potential Davies and Smith sales

Apparently we'll be paying a fee. I know it'll only be a minimal one but think if we do have a little bit of money surely a wide player is more of a priority?

Davies and Baker might join

play up Pompy, sorry, Sky Blues

I wonder if willis is off?

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

Willis out with Davies and Baker coming in would be a good trade off I reckon.

Reading this thread does highlight some imbalances in the squad.

4 goalkeepers - (all a bit suspect)
6 strikers - (all a bit suspect)
1 main winger - (who we know is a bit suspect)

Losing Willis, RCC + a striker on loan would be fine if we bought in Davies, Baker and another goal threat.

CM does worry me a bit too...

stupot07 said:

I wonder if willis is off?

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

Click to expand...

Has to be the case, cannot imagine why there would be such a shift in our transfer activities at this stage and even with reports are we're paying a fee otherwise it don't add up.

With Willis likely off things add up and make sense why we'd be paying a fee.

That would give us 5 possible central defenders.
Mcdonald, Hyam, Pearson and Davis. With Stokes available to cover.

Nick said:

Could be, for him to suddenly be going after a CB.

Either that or McDonald is badly injured.

Click to expand...

keep a watch on Birmingham Nick something is going on there with the CB position! only supposition though! they might be in for Willis. Nothing would surprise me

skybluetony176 said:

From MR's post match interview last night he seemed to pretty much rule out getting another striker basically saying that the issue was service to the strikers we already have.

Click to expand...

Yeah, but we are fans and know much better.

If fit I'd start Thomas upfront with McNulty on Saturday. Ponticelli or Nazon on the bench.

As said we don't have the luxury of just being able to endlessly sign players until it clicks.

stupot07 said:

Pretty much what Benno was saying too, pre and post match

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

Click to expand...

Benno was class on CWR last night. Not sure what his live match commentary was like but he made the drive to and from the game entertaining.

shmmeee said:

The little I’ve seen of us we’ve had trouble linking play and stretching the game. I’d rather see Andreu pulled back to midfield and some pace on the wing I think, but not seen enough of Nazon to know if he could do a job there. Even if he can, if Jodi or him are off form we don’t look like unlocking defences.

I’d still like to see Thomas given a run as well before we give up on him

Click to expand...

It made a difference last night when Andreu played more midfield second half and started linking play up. Might be his best position for us based on last night.

Nick said:

Wouldn't mind that too much, still not sure if we will bother with Baker.

Click to expand...

More worried about Davies for Willis. Davies has played less than 60 games in 5 years - is he really going to be better than Willis - no. OK, if we need funds, Willis is one of the few who can bring some in...but is his replacement up to much?
I don't know much about Davies whereas Willis is a good player at this level (and league one).

Somerset Sky Blue said:

More worried about Davies for Willis. Davies has played less than 60 games in 5 years - is he really going to be better than Willis - no. OK, if we need funds, Willis is one of the few who can bring some in...but is his replacement up to much?
I don't know much about Davies whereas Willis is a good player at this level (and league one).

Click to expand...

Willis has been rather injury prone.

Not only injury prone, his record when in the team must be pretty shocking. Our best periods over the last few years were when Robins was here first and he rarely played and the first half of Mowbray's first full year when he was injured.

pastythegreat said:

Even with McDonald out we still have Willis, Pearson and Hyam and Stokes can fill in there worst case. It's not like we're massively light in that position. NEED a striker. Not a CH

Sent from my SM-G928F using Tapatalk

Click to expand...

I think it's a bit premature to be saying we 'need' a striker... We have 4 senior strikers plus Ponticelli. I think (and hope) things will improve: McNulty has 2 goals now in 5 games, that's a good ratio (fair enough 1 is a penalty). You've got Kwame Thomas and Ponticelli in fine form for the U23s and if that continues, they'll get a shot.

I'm not going to press the panic button yet as a lot of us have.

Mucca Mad Boys said:

I think it's a bit premature to be saying we 'need' a striker... We have 4 senior strikers plus Ponticelli. I think (and hope) things will improve: McNulty has 2 goals now in 5 games, that's a good ratio (fair enough 1 is a penalty). You've got Kwame Thomas and Ponticelli in fine form for the U23s and if that continues, they'll get a shot.

I'm not going to press the panic button yet as a lot of us have.

Click to expand...

I don't quite get how people are saying bring a new striker in and yet at the same time asking why Ponticelli isn't getting any game time.

Otis said:

I don't quite get how people are saying bring a new striker in and yet at the same time asking why Ponticelli isn't getting any game time.

Click to expand...

It works though. Both statements suggest the strikers playing now aren't good enough. Not that I agree.

Pearson's gone. Something must be happening.

hill83 said:

Pearson's gone. Something must be happening.

Click to expand...

Strange that he started last night, if he had been planning on going today? Ah well let's see what it brings

Gilbert will be locking his felt tips in his desk draw now so if anything's going to happen today then it'll be soon.

Liquid Gold said:

Gilbert will be locking his felt tips in his desk draw now.

Click to expand...

He does that every day though in order to stop self harming or have someone's eye out.

I'd be a bit pissed off if they used the fee to pay off Baker and he ended up going to BR!! :-(

skybluegod said:

Strange that he started last night, if he had been planning on going today? Ah well let's see what it brings

Click to expand...

No last look at him. Not crossed the line.