Cyrille or Dion? (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter rob9872
- Start date
rob9872
Well-Known Member
I disagree Deity but apologies if you took it that way. There is a thread already that most have contributed on for RIP and condolences, but I was looking back through my posts regarding Cyrille and had totally forgotten about this. I actually think it''s perfect timing to compare the attributes of my 2 all time favourite players one who has passed today.
NortonSkyBlue
Well-Known Member
I take your point as it is a bumped thread. I just believe that today is about paying our respects to one of our family who has passed, not to be comparing the merits of his comparative ability against Dion.
Cov kid 55
Well-Known Member
Just watched a clip of the game at Sheff Wed, 6th round of the FA Cup. Cyrille scoring the first goal, pace, power, composure, total joy from him when he scored, and the 15,000 City fans in the Leppings Lane end, a great day and memory. I’ve been extremely fortunate to see 2 iconic centre forwards in Cyrille and Dion in my time supporting City.
Otis
Well-Known Member
Do find it rather odd timing.
christonabike
Well-Known Member
Can’t we put this on hold for a few weeks?
I too find it a tad distasteful. Please let the family and friends deal with the tragic loss.
Surely think of his closest and dearest at their darkest moment.
We will be short of topics soon enough so maybe some decorum at the min.
I too find it a tad distasteful. Please let the family and friends deal with the tragic loss.
Surely think of his closest and dearest at their darkest moment.
We will be short of topics soon enough so maybe some decorum at the min.
Stan 43
Member
first seen cyrille in 85 against chester. he scored 5 in a 7-2 win. my fav cov player of all time, dion is my 2nd. cyrille first for me
rob9872
Well-Known Member
Stop being so precious. It's not a competition to see who is the most upset and faux outrage at a thread based on appreciation of an icon. In a few weeks it will not be as relevant, nothing disrespectful simply discussing the attributes of two former greats. We're all adults, bypass the thread and don't contribute - it will soon fall off the bottom, but let's not pretend you're so emotionally scarred that this is upsetting.
Hobo
Well-Known Member
After that I have deleted my tribute to both great players
Today is to mark one great player Cyril Regis
christonabike
Well-Known Member
That’s your opinion and entitled to it.
I’m not emotionally scarred as you say but I do believe there is a time and place for everything. Just seems a wee bit soon.
But that’s just me.
Otis
Well-Known Member
It's because you are doing it on the day of his death.
Personally I think Dublin was the better player, but it seems so wrong to say that today.
Just think there's a time and a place and on the day of someone's death you celebrate their life, not say another player was better than them. Just seems weird to compare players and anyone who thinks Dublin is better is surely not going to come out and say that today, on the day Regis died.
christonabike
Well-Known Member
Rob no harm harm intended were all
a mix and that’s what’s great about our support. A great man with a lot of people who knew him closer than we would ever imagine and must be in shock never mind grieving for the big fella who was suddenly taken away.
I hope and will pray for his family.
PUSB
a mix and that’s what’s great about our support. A great man with a lot of people who knew him closer than we would ever imagine and must be in shock never mind grieving for the big fella who was suddenly taken away.
I hope and will pray for his family.
PUSB
stevefloyd
Well-Known Member
Both were City legends and now one is a deceased legend sadly.....leave it at that
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
This is a moot debate, because we all know Biamou rules all CCFC strikers to have graced the shirt. All hail the king...
Otis
Well-Known Member
Beavon v Biamou, now that's a debate!!!
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
Kevin Kyle v Clive Platt for worst CCFC striker.
christonabike
Well-Known Member
Hang on Biamou hasn’t scored yet! Marcus hall tops him! Everton at HR I recall :woot:. Oh and Oggy has scored more than him and that was in the Prem or top league.
Brings it home doesn’t it!
Brings it home doesn’t it!
Brylowes
Well-Known Member
Just to reassure the public:
there were no Banjos broken nor cows arses hurt during the Course of this debate :emoji_scream:
rupert_bear
Well-Known Member
Always hard to compare players, I saw them both and without doubt at their best Cyrille Regis was the better player strength, pace, power, skill on the ball but Cyrilles best was at West Brom at City Dublin edges it overall. The early years of Cyrille at Cov we’re very ordinary to say the least but once John Sillett took over and changed tact the next 3 seasons 87 to 90 Regis was vintage but did lack goals on a consistent basis, Dublin on the other hand scored goals, made goals and defended brilliantly too. If I had to pick one it would be Cyrille Regis 1987 to 1990 all round class act.
Terry Gibson's perm
Well-Known Member
Born 75 and it would be Dublin for me
Skyblueweeman
Well-Known Member
I was reading through this and thought 'oh, Dongo's back'. Then saw a post from MMM and thought that it must be an oldie.
Agree with what Astute put though. I was lucky enough to see both players. Regis was probably one of my earliest heros. But as Astute pointed out, Dublin was not only a great front man, but he was a decent centre back as well, so that just shades it for me.
Agree with what Astute put though. I was lucky enough to see both players. Regis was probably one of my earliest heros. But as Astute pointed out, Dublin was not only a great front man, but he was a decent centre back as well, so that just shades it for me.
torchomatic
Well-Known Member
Always Cyrille for me. Always. Dublin doesn't come anywhere near him.
Bumberclart
Well-Known Member
Dublins record was better, but he played as part of a far stronger side than Cyrille did.
Look at the rest of the squad that Regis played in, would Dion have scored that many goals in that team?
Both greats for the club, for differing reasons, and deserve full respect.
Look at the rest of the squad that Regis played in, would Dion have scored that many goals in that team?
Both greats for the club, for differing reasons, and deserve full respect.
Gosford Green
Well-Known Member
I saw both, Dion scored more goals per, rallied the troops on the pitch and was a good man to have in the dressing room. He probably kept us up for 2 seasons.
Cyrille however gave us the magic, he scored goals that last in the memory and on his day he could be unplayable and a joy to watch. I agree he took his time when arriving and would not turn up some games but the stand out reason for the 87 FA cup win was John Sillett getting the ball played in to Cyrille`s feet.
I would pick both and play Dublin at centre half.
Cyrille however gave us the magic, he scored goals that last in the memory and on his day he could be unplayable and a joy to watch. I agree he took his time when arriving and would not turn up some games but the stand out reason for the 87 FA cup win was John Sillett getting the ball played in to Cyrille`s feet.
I would pick both and play Dublin at centre half.
It's not really disrespectful to talk about two City greats, I saw both players in a City shirt. Love Regis for his part in our greatest cup run and moment in history and appreciated his contribution in bringing other players into the game but I actually think overall Dublin was a slightly better player for City at least and his goals and contribution kept us in the top league year after year.
West Bromwich fans will be able to reminisce more about Regis in his prime and I also saw him score against us !!
West Bromwich fans will be able to reminisce more about Regis in his prime and I also saw him score against us !!
Richard Shaw tops Biamou !!
Gosford Green
Well-Known Member
Could you afford the respect of getting the great mans name right before you indulge us with your righteousness?
NortonSkyBlue
Well-Known Member
Now about righteousness......Cyrille Regis died on Sunday night, it was announced yesterday that he had passed. I believe that rather than discuss the relative merits of Cyrille and Dion at this time we should have had at least a day to express our condolences and celebrate his great service to our club. I would suggest that is decency.
Now calling out a guy about incorrect spelling is pompous and condescending IMO.....
Otis
Well-Known Member
As I say, I believe Dublin was definitely the better player, but yesterday, after it being announced the Regis had died, for me it seemed really inappropriate to then big up Dion over Cyrille.
Regis only scored at a rate of over 1 goal every 5 games, so if I were to discuss Dublin's goalscoring record it comes across that I am then criticising Regis.
Yesterday should have only been about the contribution that Cyrille Regis made to this club and not been a day to compare him to someone who many see as a better player and make criticism of Cyrille's lack of goals.