21/22 Summer transfer mega-thread (33 Viewers)

Deleted member 11652 · May 6, 2021

Robins’ signings in attacking midfield and out wide since rejoining:

Vincenti
Andreu
Westbrooke
Barrett
Maguire Drew
Hiwula
Allassani
Wakefield
Luke Thomas
Bright
Allen
O’hare
Jobello
Kastaneer
Hilssner

Not an awful lot to shout about there. He has to get it right this summer in that area

Sky Blue Pete · May 6, 2021

Boosh said:
Robins’ signings in attacking midfield and out wide since rejoining:

Vincenti
Andreu
Westbrooke
Barrett
Maguire Drew
Hiwula
Allassani
Wakefield
Luke Thomas
Bright
Allen
O’hare
Jobello
Kastaneer
Hilssner

Not an awful lot to shout about there. He has to get it right this summer in that area

Seriously???

Terry_dactyl · May 6, 2021

mark82 said:
Don't think it'd be a disaster if we had the same 4 from this year (i.e. minus Baka). In an ideal world I think we'd want to upgrade but think Walker & Godden are good enough, plus a prem loan. Would maybe bring in a free agent if there's a promising young one available.

Biggest thing would be to add a bit of creativity/goals in midfield/AM. If Walsh is available would be good (injury concerns aside). Would also look at someone like Scott Twine as a compliment to / competition for O'Hare. That's been a weak spot this year, which has lead to O'Hare being overplayed at times and having limited alternative when he's needed a rest or not playing well.

I agree, wouldn’t be a disaster. You’d think Walker and Gyo are going to improve and Godden is good enough as long as he remains injury free...Max is good enough as back up (cue new thread ‘is Max good enough as back up’).
If we can get more creativity I’m sure walker will score a hatful.
I think we need more pace and strength throughout the side. Obviously they need to be good as well!
Despite his occasional mistakes we look better with mcfadzean at the back...we need a younger version of him.

Deleted member 11652 · May 6, 2021

Sky Blue Pete said:
Seriously???

Nah I’m joking, all of those signings were brilliant and I hope he gets it wrong in the summer.

Which part was not serious?

Magwitch1 · May 6, 2021

Get Walker fully fit is vital but so is another striker and that includes if we keep Gyokeres buy one or loan one not bothered but we need four,
Taveres would be a bonus.

Ccfcisparks · May 6, 2021

Sky Blue Pete said:
Seriously???

I don't often agree wiht him but how is he wrong here? Other than O'Hare and Bright, Hiwula and Westbrooke in spells, who has impressed off that list?

Danceswithhorses · May 6, 2021

Terry_dactyl said:
I agree, wouldn’t be a disaster. You’d think Walker and Gyo are going to improve and Godden is good enough as long as he remains injury free...Max is good enough as back up (cue new thread ‘is Max good enough as back up’).

We were a half decent side this year, despite injuries decimating our squad (strikers especially), so it follows that with a relatively injury free season, we should do better, even with the same 4.
Do i also remember correctly, that we hit the post/bar, more than any other team in Championship this last season ?
Could be a useless stat, but at least it shows we were creating chances, even if we weren't quite finishing them.

NortonSkyBlue · May 6, 2021

Ccfcisparks said:
I don't often agree wiht him but how is he wrong here? Other than O'Hare and Bright, Hiwula and Westbrooke in spells, who has impressed off that list?

Luke Thomas,
Andreu was injured playing for us,
Allen was part of the squad that won League One
So now we are over a 50% per cent rate of success, I would say in football terms that is not so bad.

Ccfcisparks · May 6, 2021

riyadhskyblue said:
Luke Thomas,
Andreu was injured playing for us,
Allen was part of the squad that won League One
So now we are over a 50% per cent rate of success, I would say in football terms that is not so bad.

Allen I could maybe give you. Andreu is just ridiculous because you are basing that off If's buts and maybes, how can you call that a succesful signing when he hardly played. Thomas was overrated.

Deleted member 11652 · May 6, 2021

riyadhskyblue said:
Luke Thomas,
Andreu was injured playing for us,
Allen was part of the squad that won League One
So now we are over a 50% per cent rate of success, I would say in football terms that is not so bad.

Thomas, Bright, Allen, O’hare and Westbrooke. That’s 5/15

Mucca Mad Boys · May 6, 2021

Boosh said:
Thomas, Bright, Allen, O’hare and Westbrooke. That’s 5/15

Our recruitment really has been hit and miss over the past 5 seasons, hasn’t it?

Not like we’ve gone from a L2 team to a Championship one...

Deleted member 11652 · May 6, 2021

Mucca Mad Boys said:
Our recruitment really has been hit and miss, over the past 5 seasons, hasn’t it?

Not like we’ve gone from a L2 team to a Championship one...

No but in that area of the pitch it has been? Which is my point, we are lacking there and need to get it right this year

Marty · May 6, 2021

riyadhskyblue said:
Luke Thomas,
Andreu was injured playing for us,
Allen was part of the squad that won League One
So now we are over a 50% per cent rate of success, I would say in football terms that is not so bad.

Andreu looked a good player tbf just never fully recovered after the ACL injury.

NortonSkyBlue · May 6, 2021

Boosh said:
Thomas, Bright, Allen, O’hare and Westbrooke. That’s 5/15

You missed out Hiwula and as stated Andreu was injured in our name.
I think it is pushing it to say that Allessani and Wakefield were bought as first team players when it was stated they were development buys and whilst agreeing that the others never shone in our colors or are yet to shine, the degree of negativity on here reflects the Slade or late Mowbray era and is unjustified in my opinion based on the progress made in that time.

Deleted member 11652 · May 6, 2021

riyadhskyblue said:
You missed out Hiwula and as stated Andreu was injured in our name.
I think it is pushing it to say that Allessani and Wakefield were bought as first team players when it was stated they were development buys and whilst agreeing that the others never shone in our colors or are yet to shine, the degree of negativity on here reflects the Slade or late Mowbray era and is unjustified in my opinion based on the progress made in that time.

I liked Hiwula but no counting him as a success given he ended up in the bomb squad. If we aren’t counting development players then we can’t count Westbrooke so?

shmmeee · May 6, 2021

Boosh said:
I liked Hiwula but no counting him as a success given he ended up in the bomb squad. If we aren’t counting development players then we can’t count Westbrooke so?

He was bought as a striker and was our top scorer his first season!

Deleted member 11652 · May 6, 2021

shmmeee said:
He was bought as a striker and was our top scorer his first season!

We can take him off the list then. Either way, he didn’t end up a success out wide did he? In saying that, I liked him and didn’t want him to be bombed out

shmmeee · May 6, 2021

Boosh said:
We can take him off the list then. Either way, he didn’t end up a success out wide did he? In saying that, I liked him and didn’t want him to be bombed out

We play some weird ass formations that don’t lend themselves to wingers/AMs. In L2 we played that weird 442 with the “wingers” more central like a box, then the box last season.

I think considering that we’ve done OK with the likes of Allen, O’Hare, Shipley and Westbrooke, Bayliss before them as well.

But yeah, considering we went into this season with 8 AMs on the books and finished with just one we’d trust on the pitch it’s not great.

Terry_dactyl · May 6, 2021

Danceswithhorses said:
We were a half decent side this year, despite injuries decimating our squad (strikers especially), so it follows that with a relatively injury free season, we should do better, even with the same 4.
Do i also remember correctly, that we hit the post/bar, more than any other team in Championship this last season ?
Could be a useless stat, but at least it shows we were creating chances, even if we weren't quite finishing them.

That’s right! I think that stat was ridiculous...in terms of the number of times we hit the woodwork compared to others. It wasn’t like one or two more times...more like 10 more times or something. Although I think someone on here pointed out that we went into to score immediately after a few of those. But still...

And of course when O’hare finds his scoring boots we’ll be laughing.

Sky Blue Pete · May 6, 2021

Boosh said:
Nah I’m joking, all of those signings were brilliant and I hope he gets it wrong in the summer.

Which part was not serious?

Not an awful lot to shout about. Nope just one cup two promotions and staying in championship. I think we should take robins out the back and beat the crap out of him lol

Deleted member 11652 · May 6, 2021

Sky Blue Pete said:
Not an awful lot to shout about. Nope just one cup two promotions and staying in championship. I think we should take robins out the back and beat the crap out of him lol

Meaning not many of the players were worth shouting about. I didn’t think it was difficult to understand.

Sky Blue Pete · May 6, 2021

Boosh said:
Meaning not many of the players were worth shouting about. I didn’t think it was difficult to understand.

No your negativity is completely easy to understand don’t worry.
You have to speculate in order to come up trumps. Off that list hiwula Ohare westbrooke Allen bright and luke Thomas were all excellent. We’ve progressed so much that people recruited are left behind

SBAndy · May 6, 2021

Left-sided CB suggestion: Lewis Gibson, currently at Everton.

SBT · May 6, 2021

Boosh said:
Robins’ signings in attacking midfield and out wide since rejoining:

~~Vincenti~~
Andreu
Westbrooke
Barrett
Maguire Drew
Hiwula
Allassani
Wakefield
Luke Thomas
Bright
Allen
O’hare
Jobello
~~Kastaneer~~
Hilssner

Not an awful lot to shout about there. He has to get it right this summer in that area

Six who were objectively good (underlined)
Two who were objectively shit (struck out)
Four who got derailed by serious injury (in red)
The rest were just stopgaps or lottery tickets

Not like anyone's going to die on a hill for most of those players, but silly to suggest MR has some kind of weird mental block for signing attackers either.

Deleted member 11652 · May 6, 2021

Sky Blue Pete said:
No your negativity is completely easy to understand don’t worry.
You have to speculate in order to come up trumps. Off that list hiwula Ohare westbrooke Allen bright and luke Thomas were all excellent. We’ve progressed so much that people recruited are left behind

O’hare and Bright were excellent. Westbrooke, Allen and Thomas were good. The rest failures.

SBT said:
Six who were objectively good (underlined)
Two who were objectively shit (struck out)
Four who got derailed by serious injury (in red)
The rest were just stopgaps or lottery tickets

Not like anyone's going to die on a hill for most of those players, but silly to suggest MR has some kind of weird mental block for signing attackers either.

NortonSkyBlue · May 6, 2021

Boosh said:
O’hare and Bright were excellent. Westbrooke, Allen and Thomas were good. The rest failures.

When Kelly got injured against Stoke recently trying to prevent a goal against, when Marosi took a boot in the face they did it wearing our badge and to call anybody injured in the line of duty a failure actually shows where you are from. Hiwula top scorer? a failure? Development players who don't reach the level you expect yet 90% of all development players fall by the wayside. I think you have very high standards that Mark Robins can't possibly match. I think you should be on the other Sky Blues forum to faun over Pep, if he's good enough of course.

Deleted member 11652 · May 6, 2021

riyadhskyblue said:
When Kelly got injured against Stoke recently trying to prevent a goal against, when Marosi took a boot in the face they did it wearing our badge and to call anybody injured in the line of duty a failure actually shows where you are from. Hiwula top scorer? a failure? Development players who don't reach the level you expect yet 90% of all development players fall by the wayside. I think you have very high standards that Mark Robins can't possibly match. I think you should be on the other Sky Blues forum to faun over Pep, if he's good enough of course.

Nah you’re right. Everyone Robins has signed is a success. Long live the King

NortonSkyBlue · May 6, 2021

Boosh said:
Nah you’re right. Everyone Robins has signed is a success. Long live the King

No you are right.
Actually Boosh having lived with a generation of abject shit I would have hoped that Robins would have been given some latitude within our fanbase but perhaps that was asking too much.

rexo87 · May 6, 2021

Sources: Rangers, Norwich City & Brighton interested in Coventry City star

A handful of teams are looking at Coventry City's Gustavo Hamer ahead of this summer's transfer window, a source has revealed exclusively to Football League World.

footballleagueworld.co.uk

No idea how reliable this source is but Hamer linked with a few clubs... it begins

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Ccfcisparks · May 6, 2021

rexo87 said:
Sources: Rangers, Norwich City & Brighton interested in Coventry City star

A handful of teams are looking at Coventry City's Gustavo Hamer ahead of this summer's transfer window, a source has revealed exclusively to Football League World.

footballleagueworld.co.uk

No idea how reliable this source is but Hamer linked with a few clubs... it begins

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Surprising, because I've been told on here we would struggle to get our money back for him.

HuckerbyDublinWhelan · May 6, 2021

Ccfcisparks said:
Surprising, because I've been told on here we would struggle to get our money back for him.

I mean I wouldn’t let him go, but how about a swap deal involving Gyorkeres and Ostigard for Hamer. We then use our money to sign Walsh and James

SBAndy · May 6, 2021

rexo87 said:
Sources: Rangers, Norwich City & Brighton interested in Coventry City star

A handful of teams are looking at Coventry City's Gustavo Hamer ahead of this summer's transfer window, a source has revealed exclusively to Football League World.

footballleagueworld.co.uk

No idea how reliable this source is but Hamer linked with a few clubs... it begins

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

We’ll keep him until January and then he will leave.

Saddlebrains · May 6, 2021

Club-by-club guide of every Championship free agent this summer

Reported Middlesbrough targets and former Boro players feature in the list of freebies

www.gazettelive.co.uk

Have a look at this.

The amount of decent players out of contract is ludicrous.

We could really improve even on our budget if we shop wisely and not waste time on the jobellos and hillsners of this world

junglej13 · May 6, 2021

SBAndy said:
We’ll keep him until January and then he will leave.

Think he is the sort of player who will thrive off the crowd. His value could double next season.

Deleted member 9744 · May 6, 2021

SBT said:
Six who were objectively good (underlined)
Two who were objectively shit (struck out)
Four who got derailed by serious injury (in red)
The rest were just stopgaps or lottery tickets

Not like anyone's going to die on a hill for most of those players, but silly to suggest MR has some kind of weird mental block for signing attackers either.

Agree with all that, although I would say Barratt was terrible

21/22 Summer transfer mega-thread (33 Viewers)

Deleted member 11652

Guest

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Deleted member 11652

Guest

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Deleted member 11652

Guest

Well-Known Member

Deleted member 11652

Guest

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Deleted member 11652

Guest

Well-Known Member

Deleted member 11652

Guest

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Deleted member 11652

Guest

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Deleted member 11652

Guest

Well-Known Member

Deleted member 11652

Guest

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Deleted member 9744

Guest

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency