According to CCFCTV the three names on the short-list are: (1 Viewer)

singers_pore · Sep 17, 2012

Paul Ince, Mark Robbins & Richard Money

It's just been posted on Twitter.

cloughie · Sep 17, 2012

According to the telegraph its Shaw Ince and Robins

Brighton Sky Blue · Sep 17, 2012

singers_pore said:
Paul Ince, Mark Robbins & Richard Money

It's just been posted on Twitter.

Goes on to say this is verified by local media and not the club...

Baginton · Sep 17, 2012

Richard Money :facepalm: ask Wallsall and Luton fans what they think of him.

Otis · Sep 17, 2012

1. Robins 2. Money 3. Ince.

That would be my choice in order of preference.

Or

1. Money 2. Robins 3. Ince.

That would be okay too in the grand scheme of things (i.e only 3 to choose from).

Just hope the order doesn't begin with.

1. Ince.

Brighton Sky Blue · Sep 17, 2012

Money hasn't managed in the FL for donkey's years, Robins had an unspectacular spell at Barnsley coupled with promotion failures at Rotherham, whilst Ince succeeded at MK Dons and Macclesfield, but failed at Blackburn, Notts Co, and and in his second spell at MK Dons. Quite frankly, Ince doesn't seem like that bad an option compared to these two Otis.

valiant15 · Sep 17, 2012

This club just goes from bad to worse.

mr_monkey101 · Sep 17, 2012

Brighton Sky Blue said:
Money hasn't managed in the FL for donkey's years, Robins had an unspectacular spell at Barnsley coupled with promotion failures at Rotherham, whilst Ince succeeded at MK Dons and Macclesfield, but failed at Blackburn, Notts Co, and and in his second spell at MK Dons. Quite frankly, Ince doesn't seem like that bad an option compared to these two Otis.

robins only failed to get promotion at rotherham due to the 17 point deduction they had... for my money it has to be robins, and someone said on another thread, it wouldnt hurt to have a former striker as a manager

PVA · Sep 17, 2012

Robins.

Please.

speedie87 · Sep 17, 2012

Money for me

You watch mcsheffrey go upfront under money

Brighton Sky Blue · Sep 17, 2012

mr_monkey101 said:
robins only failed to get promotion at rotherham due to the 17 point deduction they had... for my money it has to be robins, and someone said on another thread, it wouldnt hurt to have a former striker as a manager

He also had the best striker in the league at his disposal. His record at Barnsley hardly leaps off the page either.

skyblue1523 · Sep 17, 2012

mark robins did a good job at both rotherham and barnsley i live in south yorkshire now have done for 18 years i always be a skyblue thoe as for mark robins both these clubs did not want robins to leave and the fans up here all agree that he was a very good manger and would have liked to hold on to him.IF he gets the job (which is what i hope) we will have a good man in charge

Nonleagueherewecome · Sep 17, 2012

Brighton Sky Blue said:
He also had the best striker in the league at his disposal. His record at Barnsley hardly leaps off the page either.

Managing City is a bit like having a 17 point deduction, so it has to be Robins out of those three for me.

Otis · Sep 17, 2012

The plus for Robins it appears is that the fans of his former clubs seem to like him, while we have had very negative comments about Phil Brown, Ince, Money etc. and Wilder too from a number of opposing fans.

Usually if fans like the manager it is a sign of something going right.

Ince has had some success but hasn't stayed with any club for any length of time has been sacked/left 3 times and there are quite a few negative comments out there about him.

Robins for me stand out amongst the other candidates.

ccfcway · Sep 17, 2012

speedie87 said:
Money for me

You watch mcsheffrey go upfront under money

I'd happily watch McSheffrey go !

kingharvest · Sep 17, 2012

speedie87 said:
Money for me

You watch mcsheffrey go upfront under money

I've watched McSheffreys legs go for the last 2 years so i don't hold much hope. Maybe 10 years ago ay.

ricohroar · Sep 17, 2012

Macca up front OMG no please not Money if thats what he has in mind

covcity4life · Sep 17, 2012

every single on of them shuld be better than thorn so lets look on bright side of it all.

Evans020 · Sep 17, 2012

Mcsheffrey would be better up top than what we currently have imho

Mucca Mad Boys · Sep 17, 2012

mr_monkey101 said:
robins only failed to get promotion at rotherham due to the 17 point deduction they had... for my money it has to be robins, and someone said on another thread, it wouldnt hurt to have a former striker as a manager

1 of those failed promotion years was when Robins nearly got Rotherham promoted... When the started with -17 points! Add them to their tally, good chance they would've got promoted. Haven't seen the table for that year tbh.

Oh, and at this level (as people keep banaging on, wrongly, about formations) it is unlikely you're going to hire a manager who hasn't failed elsewhere, in fact, unless you're the elite, it is unlikely, every manager has failed, or will do.

CUS Wyken · Sep 17, 2012

Who or what are CCFCTV???

Nonleagueherewecome · Sep 17, 2012

Plus Robins hasn't failed, y'know? He was poached by a bigger club, and he left them on a matter or principle.

CovLis86 · Sep 17, 2012

Its got to be Robins.

skyblueinBaku · Sep 17, 2012

Robins, I suppose. But I find it hard to believe that these three are the best of the original applicants.

Baginton · Sep 17, 2012

Will Robins be bringing his own backroom staff

Jack Griffin · Sep 17, 2012

Otis said:
1. Robins 2. Money 3. Ince.

That would be my choice in order of preference.

Or

1. Money 2. Robins 3. Ince.

That would be okay too in the grand scheme of things (i.e only 3 to choose from).

Just hope the order doesn't begin with.

1. Ince.

My sentiments exactly.

sw88 · Sep 17, 2012

covcity4life said:
every single on of them shuld be better than thorn so lets look on bright side of it all.

Most said that about Shaw

sw88 · Sep 17, 2012

He did do well after a 17 point deduction, and at this rate, he'll need to make up 17 points to get us finishing in a decent position so Robins is the man (out of this list that is)

Hateley's Heed · Sep 17, 2012

Otis said:
1. Robins 2. Money 3. Ince.

That would be my choice in order of preference.

Or

1. Money 2. Robins 3. Ince.

That would be okay too in the grand scheme of things (i.e only 3 to choose from).

Just hope the order doesn't begin with.

1. Ince.

'Money' in whatever order would be nice seeing as we don't have any!

cloughie · Sep 17, 2012

People are saying on many different threads these are a poor 3/4 shortlist if so many applied

and why isn't wise on the short list

I am sure regarding the restrictions given to the incoming manager many better candidates would have said thanks but no thanks

Nonleagueherewecome · Sep 17, 2012

Maybe Wise was the one who wanted the weekend to think about it, and after Saturday, rang them back to say "Naaah, you're OK, ta."

@richh87 · Sep 17, 2012

covcity4life said:
every single on of them shuld be better than thorn so lets look on bright side of it all.

Yeah, like Shaw is...

Up North Sky Blue · Sep 17, 2012

Brighton Sky Blue said:
He also had the best striker in the league at his disposal. His record at Barnsley hardly leaps off the page either.

Adam Le Fondre, yeh he signed him.

Black6Osprey · Sep 17, 2012

Its a rubbish short list but all that aside whoever gets the job will still have to work with the same team.

So which one will get the best loan deals?

As non of them will be successful IMO without some good loan additions.

OyJimmy · Sep 18, 2012

Based on what Wasall fans have said to me I'd go for Money. He did really well at Walsall with an inherited squad and no money. And if he's going to play Mcsheffrey upfront then fan bloody tastic. The managers we've had have shown how gormless they really are by not playing the best finisher in the team in his natural position.

According to CCFCTV the three names on the short-list are: (1 Viewer)

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Jack Griffin

Guest

Chief Commentator!

Chief Commentator!

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Member

New Member

New Member

Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency