Bertie Hound vs Simms (4 Viewers)

Diogenes · Sep 18, 2024

Very early days I know but...

I think Bertie is going to become first choice at some point this season.

He plays with an intensity and drive that Simms doesn't have. I like Simms so this isn't a bash simms thread, but he is so passive compared to Bassette who really led the line tonight. Our solid defence started with him.

He chases everything down and harries the opposition, whereas Simms is often found jogging round the centre circle.

He makes it easy for people to find him, ping the ball up and 9/10 times he will get there.

Personally, I would start him on Saturday.

SeaSeeEffCee · Sep 18, 2024

Bassette deserves to start based on what I’ve seen from both so far this season.

Cally Fedora · Sep 18, 2024

Big difference is Simms is a proven goal scorer. Bassette is not at the moment. That’s not saying Bassette won’t get there but it does mean Simms is currently 1st choice.

Shannerz · Sep 18, 2024

He looks a better footballer, tbf.

The way he took on that ball over the top from Eccles and got a very good shot away was a level of technique Simms doesn't seem to have.

edgy · Sep 18, 2024

Gyokeres X Vardy

fernandopartridge · Sep 18, 2024

Cally Fedora said:
Big difference is Simms is a proven goal scorer. Bassette is not at the moment. That’s not saying Bassette won’t get there but it does mean Simms is currently 1st choice.

He's a proven goal scorer with 1 in his last 14 league games yeah

Sky Blue Harry H · Sep 18, 2024

Squad depth. Great he seems so up to speed so early on. Didn't expect him to be near the first team at this point.

Cally Fedora · Sep 18, 2024

Be real. Have you forgotten last season. In the Championship. When he scored goals.

ptr · Sep 18, 2024

fernandopartridge said:
He's a proven goal scorer with 1 in his last 14 league games yeah

4.

Nick · Sep 18, 2024

Cally Fedora said:
Be real. Have you forgotten last season. In the Championship. When he scored goals.

They need to be judged on form and the opposition / their strengths and weaknesses.

No point playing somebody solely because they scored last season.

I wouldn't be opposed to them both playing up top.

SeaSeeEffCee · Sep 18, 2024

Cally Fedora said:
Be real. Have you forgotten last season. In the Championship. When he scored goals.

Well, scored goals consistently for what, about an 8 game period in the league?

steve101 · Sep 18, 2024

Hard to criticise Simms and Wright considering last season's goal tallies, but they are both underwhelming much of the time. There are occasional games where either of them show some aggression but few and far between. Bassette and Thomas-Asante have so much more endeavour about them. The way the latter took his goal was class. Bassette is a real handful and already has shown better decision making than Wright. I would start both on Saturday with Sakamoto on the right.

Diogenes · Sep 18, 2024

Nick said:
I wouldn't be opposed to them both playing up top.

I think they would compliment each other - Bassette would be creating a shedload of chances for Simms.

SkyBlue_Bear83 · Sep 18, 2024

Shannerz said:
He looks a better footballer, tbf.

The way he took on that ball over the top from Eccles and got a very good shot away was a level of technique Simms doesn't seem to have.

Agree Bassette seems a better striker of the ball than Simms. The one he took from Eccles long pass and the angled drive in the second half, whilst didn't score worked the keeper on both occasions.

Feel like Simms has been in similar positions quite a few times recent and miscued his shot more than once.

Gynnsthetonic · Sep 18, 2024

Bassette starts all day long, should of played the 90 tonight, he's an eager keen young lad ffs, why take him off!

Terry Gibson's perm · Sep 18, 2024

Norman makes lots of runs in behind but we just don’t look to get it forward to him quickly enough.

Earlsdon_Skyblue1 · Sep 18, 2024

Norman is really showing something special. I don't see how you can't reward that performance with a start on Saturday.

chiefdave · Sep 18, 2024

Why do people always talk like we have to bin one player off. Can't we be happy to have squad depth, to be able to rotate & rest players, to have cover for injuries?

Saddlebrains · Sep 18, 2024

Bassette for me all day

There was a moment with about 7 or 8 minutes to go, the ball.was cleared and when you would want your striker up there trying to hold it up and cause a nuisance

Simms was ambling a good 15 yards behind where he was meant to be

Robins was apoplectic at Simms, shouting, gesturing and generally going mental at him

Rightly so tbh, Simms sometimes is nowhere near on his positioning

Alkhen · Sep 18, 2024

Way too early to say that. They are so different.

Simms is oddly underrated by some, I think it's his size and calm nature that makes people think he's lazy. He is always challenging for the ball. Proven finisher and still very young. Seems we've started hitting more aimless long balls this season which is a bit of a thankless task for a striker to deal with but he always puts a shift in if you actually watch him.

Bassette looks more dynamic. Some one compared him to a young Vardy which I can totally see.

What great options to have, lucky to have both

Perennial Lurker · Sep 18, 2024

He likes that left hand channel a lot so could maybe replace Wright who was largely underwhelming tonight .
Bassette - Simms - BTA ?

Cally Fedora · Sep 18, 2024

Nick said:
They need to be judged on form and the opposition / their strengths and weaknesses.

No point playing somebody solely because they scored last season.

I wouldn't be opposed to them both playing up top.

Nor would I. I thought tonight’s game suited the harrying style of Bassette and BTA as Spurs were always going to have a lot of the ball.

nicksar · Sep 18, 2024

Norman really is a very good signing.

Ring Of Steel · Sep 18, 2024

chiefdave said:
Why do people always talk like we have to bin one player off. Can't we be happy to have squad depth, to be able to rotate & rest players, to have cover for injuries?

this is very accurate- it’s either “he has to start” or “get rid”, with never anything in the middle. Eccles was branded dogshit in previous matches, tonight from the comments you’d think he was destined for an England call-up.

Ashdown · Sep 18, 2024

Bassette will surely get ahead of timid Ellis at some point soon. Needs a couple of goals to top off the effort put in but adds a lot , especially when working defenders and creating space for his team members to run into.

Alkhen · Sep 18, 2024

SkyBlue_Bear83 said:
Agree Bassette seems a better striker of the ball than Simms.

How can you make that call? He's had about 6 shots total for us so far.

Simms has done well, no need to sell him short

fernandopartridge · Sep 18, 2024

ptr said:
4.

Got my numbers wrong, 1 in his last 11 after he'd had a good run mid season.

He's scored in 10 of his 51 league appearances for us.

Evo1883 · Sep 18, 2024

If I was to say that bassette is more of a mark robins player would that make sense ?

They both have their attributes , but I think Simms looked good at Watford

AFCCOVENTRY · Sep 18, 2024

Terry Gibson's perm said:
Norman makes lots of runs in behind but we just don’t look to get it forward to him quickly enough.

Robins will have to make decision at some point to build the team around him. I’m that confident he is the next big thing for us. What he’s capable of at his age is just baffling how we signed him.

Cally Fedora · Sep 18, 2024

Simms scored on Saturday for crying out loud! Literally 4 days ago.

fernandopartridge · Sep 18, 2024

Saddlebrains said:
Bassette for me all day

There was a moment with about 7 or 8 minutes to go, the ball.was cleared and when you would want your striker up there trying to hold it up and cause a nuisance

Simms was ambling a good 15 yards behind where he was meant to be

Robins was apoplectic at Simms, shouting, gesturing and generally going mental at him

Rightly so tbh, Simms sometimes is nowhere near on his positioning

When he's interviewed he seems so laid back, you need aggression to make it. Look at Vik, huge part of his game.

Perennial Lurker · Sep 18, 2024

AFCCOVENTRY said:
Robins will have to make decision at some point to build the team around him. I’m that confident he is the next big thing for us. What he’s capable of at his age is just baffling how we signed him.

Is that a thumbs up for our shit recruitment team?

CovValleyBoy · Sep 18, 2024

Has Simms ever watched his lack of effort on tape. It is truly shocking.

Perennial Lurker · Sep 18, 2024

CovValleyBoy said:
Has Simms ever watched his lack of effort on tape. It is truly shocking.

What on earth are you on about ?

CCFCSteve · Sep 18, 2024

Alkhen said:
Way too early to say that. They are so different.

Simms is oddly underrated by some, I think it's his size and calm nature that makes people think he's lazy. He is always challenging for the ball. Proven finisher and still very young. Seems we've started hitting more aimless long balls this season which is a bit of a thankless task for a striker to deal with but he always puts a shift in if you actually watch him.

Bassette looks more dynamic. Some one compared him to a young Vardy which I can totally see.

What great options to have, lucky to have both

Bizarrely, although Bassette was quality tonight and a handful all game, with a bit of luck simms could’ve had a couple (or assists with EMC on far post) in the short time he was on the pitch. Fine margins

Very different players. Great to have options

Bertie Hound vs Simms (4 Viewers)

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency