I hope the UK bin our Supreme Court or adopt the US system of electing judges. It’s anti democratic and a fiasco - I’m sure Corbyn would have done the same if he was elected
But what about Johnson? If it takes as long for Labour to get back into an electable state as some are suggesting Conservatives would also have an opportunity to control SC appointments for a significant time and long term far more likely to control appointments given time in power by each major party. Wouldn't want either party having excess control over the highest court appointments. We're trying far too hard to ape a US system and way of life that has passed its zenith.
Reason I don't like US system is you've got legislative, judicial and executive which are supposed to be independent of each other and provide checks and balances of the others. How can they be independent if one of those three gets to choose one of the others?
Don't like the idea of lifetime appointments and one being replaced every electoral cycle is an option, but that still leaves the chance of multiple appointments by a single PM due to deaths etc.
Not sure of the answer (as you say scrapping it is potentially an answer) but for me the choice should come from within the judiciary itself, which I guess makes a papal style election the most analogous.