Is anyone going to do the player ratings .... (1 Viewer)

[Otis]

And give any player more than a 5?

Can't think of many that warrant it. Proschwitz perhaps? Reda?

5's and below for Philips, Fleck, Barton, Nouble, Stokes, Burge, Ward (worst game I have seen from him in a City shirt).

 

---

[Sutty]

*sigh* go on then...

Burge - 4

Phillips - 4 (Odelusi - 4)
Pennington - 4 (Martin - 4)
Johnson - 4
Stokes - 4

O'Brien - 5
Fleck - 4
Ward - 3
Barton - 4 (Maddison - 5)

Nouble - 3
Proschwitz - 6

Dire. 20 reasonable minutes without really creating anything, then a really tame surrender after going 1 down.

 

[stupot07]

*sigh* go on then...

Burge - 4

Phillips - 4 (Odelusi - 4)
Pennington - 4 (Martin - 4)
Johnson - 4
Stokes - 4

O'Brien - 5
Fleck - 4
Ward - 3
Barton - 4 (Maddison - 5)

Nouble - 3
Proschwitz - 6

Dire. 20 reasonable minutes without really creating anything, then a really tame surrender after going 1 down.

Agree with your scores sutty.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - so please excuse any spelling or grammar errors

 

[Skybluepiglet]

Reda was ok from where I was sitting...Grant Ward was horrific today ...Fleck poor....Burge has had better games.

I went after the third Crewe goal...I simply couldn't stand it.

 

[shy_tall_knight]

When does Fleck have a good game. The Aarons Philips & Martin were both dreadful, Nouble very poor, and as for Odelusi the impact sub he had no impact. Ward chose today to have his worst game JOB was his usual highly busy but totally ineffectual,

 

[shy_tall_knight]

When does Fleck have a good game. The Aarons Philips & Martin were both dreadful, Nouble very poor, and as for Odelusi the impact sub he had no impact. Ward chose today to have his worst game JOB was his usual highly busy but totally ineffectual, barton clueless slows down all the attacks

 

[stupot07]

Reda was ok from where I was sitting...Grant Ward was horrific today ...Fleck poor....Burge has had better games.

I went after the third Crewe goal...I simply couldn't stand it.

Personally I thought it was one of Reda's worst games for us, usually he bullies centre forwards but Haber gave him a right going over.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - so please excuse any spelling or grammar errors

 

[Nick]

Johnson was lucky not to give a pen away too

 

[Skybluepiglet]

Personally I thought it was one of Reda's worst games for us,

Well that just shows you how bad we were collectively today...as he was one of our best

 

[chinamans view]

I did not rate any of our players today, nor most of the season, thats why we are near the foot of this league.

 

[Great_Expectations]

Proschwitz can take some credit, but only in the context of how poor the others were.

Him and Nouble up front do not work. Proschwitz will offer himself short or try to get into the box for crosses, but won't run behind; it's not his game. I still have no real idea what Nouble is, he's built like a target man yet (tries to) plays like a small nippy striker. He drifts out to the wing to try and receive the ball, meaning the team looks lopsided and he's rarely near enough to his striker partner. Or, he hides.

Proschwitz still doesn't win enough headers for me either.