January transfer window (26 Viewers)

Mucca Mad Boys · Dec 27, 2020

AFCCOVENTRY said:
It would be a blunder not to ship out some of the ineffective players in our squad and replace them with better quality. It might be we ship 2 useless players out to bring in 1 decent one. Or Sisu sanction some loan signings.

That is very much a Michael Owen comment to make. Obviously MR wants to bring in better quality players.

The reality is that we have to find destinations for said players, and we have to find the right players with the right quality, for the right price.

MR isn’t usually active in January, and rightly so. It’s a market for teams who are usually pretty desperate because they either; haven’t got their summer right, have a new manager, or have loads of injuries to deal with.

Off the top of my head, the last decent permanent signing we made in the January transfer market was Leon Clarke, and before that, probably Fox and Dann.

Magwitch · Dec 27, 2020

Puts sisu on the spot, as I see it we are on a see-saw at the moment stay as we are squad wise be lucky injury wise I reckon we will be about in the position we are now come the end of the season and that would be okay but should we get just two or three more longish injuries we could slip dangerously towards the drop zone trouble is this season injured players are missing a lot of games with us playing Saturday/Wednesday/ Saturday on the other hand get a couple of players in loan or permenant who come off we could gain points to put us top half.

cc84cov · Dec 27, 2020

Robins has done his part got us in contention to stay up I would be shocked if he’s not backed if he asks for it at least a loan

Sick Boy · Dec 27, 2020

Problem is that we could end up being saddled with players on wages we couldn’t afford if we ended up being relegated to League 1. We’ll hold off until the summer and then see where are then.

cc84cov · Dec 27, 2020

Sick Boy said:
Problem is that we could end up being saddled with players on wages we couldn’t afford if we ended up being relegated to League 1. We’ll hold off until the summer and then see where are then.

Or try get the right player in who will make the difference,we look ok now but I think teams around us will be looking to strengthen

Sick Boy · Dec 27, 2020

cc84cov said:
Or try get the right player in who will make the difference,we look ok now but I think teams around us will be looking to strengthen

Not convinced with the pandemic situation, chances as we will make do with what we have and look where we are in the summer.

Magwitch · Dec 27, 2020

Loans won’t cost us anything next season relegation will, even if it were a player or even two on £10k a week for five months it’s a case of is that investment worth it to try and ensure we stay in the championship.

Deity · Dec 27, 2020

Magwitch said:
Loans won’t cost us anything next season relegation will, even if it were a player or even two on £10k a week for five months it’s a case of is that investment worth it to try and ensure we stay in the championship.

I completely agree. Let’s not forget Sisu are a hedge fund. At some point they need an exit. We are more attractive as a championship side than league one. That’s why a long term Ricoh deal is so critical, both parties know that.

Robins will bring in 2 players I think. Whether that will be enough time will tell.

We really don’t offer much attacking threat and the clean sheets won’t go on fit ever. Very fine lines at the minute.

Magwitch · Dec 27, 2020

I agree this league is so tight in most games there’s only a goal in it lots of late winners and equalisers, there’s also biggish clubs below us Forest, Derby, Wednesday and QPR any or all could put runs together. We defiantly need a forward or even two, I’m classing Da Costa and Hilsner as newbies too neither have really kicked a ball in anger yet but will hopefully give MR more options.

Londonccfcfan · Dec 27, 2020

Magwitch said:
Loans won’t cost us anything next season relegation will, even if it were a player or even two on £10k a week for five months it’s a case of is that investment worth it to try and ensure we stay in the championship.

Robins and our management will and should look for good young players from league 1. Who won't cost a fortune.

Players like Dack/lowe/Stockley/Bradshaw etc.

We won't buy proven championship players at or near their peak. Not our model.

cc84cov · Dec 27, 2020

Londonccfcfan said:
Robins and our management will and should look for good young players from league 1. Who won't cost a fortune.

Players like Dack/lowe/Stockley/Bradshaw etc.

We won't buy proven championship players at or near their peak. Not our model.

Lad called JCH doing well league 1

Magwitch · Dec 27, 2020

Londonccfcfan said:
Robins and our management will and should look for good young players from league 1. Who won't cost a fortune.

Players like Dack/lowe/Stockley/Bradshaw etc.

We won't buy proven championship players at or near their peak. Not our model.

There will be players lower down even in non league who will come into higher leagues and be top players the next Jamie Varney is there somewhere. In times gone by we did well from lower leagues.

Deity · Dec 27, 2020

Magwitch said:
There will be players lower down even in non league who will come into higher leagues and be top players the next Jamie Varney is there somewhere. In times gone by we did well from lower leagues.

I think we have seen a more pragmatic Robins this season. Let’s be honest our football is rubbish to watch now but it’s getting more points.

we really lack championship experience. I could see Robins looking to bring in 2 older heads to help the younger players.

it’s not how we normally operate but it might what Robins feels we need

shepardo01 · Dec 27, 2020

Magwitch said:
There will be players lower down even in non league who will come into higher leagues and be top players the next Jamie Varney is there somewhere. In times gone by we did well from lower leagues.

Jamie Vardy or Luke Varney?

Johhny Blue · Dec 27, 2020

Magwitch said:
There will be players lower down even in non league who will come into higher leagues and be top players the next Jamie Varney is there somewhere. In times gone by we did well from lower leagues.

Did you mean the first Jamie Varney?

Gibbo · Dec 27, 2020

Mucca Mad Boys said:
That is very much a Michael Owen comment to make. Obviously MR wants to bring in better quality players.

The reality is that we have to find destinations for said players, and we have to find the right players with the right quality, for the right price.

MR isn’t usually active in January, and rightly so. It’s a market for teams who are usually pretty desperate because they either; haven’t got their summer right, have a new manager, or have loads of injuries to deal with.

Off the top of my head, the last decent permanent signing we made in the January transfer market was Leon Clarke, and before that, probably Fox and Dann.

Bright?

Magwitch · Dec 27, 2020

Su

Johhny Blue said:
Did you mean the first Jamie Varney?

Suppose to be Vardy, I was watching On the Buses at the time of posting

Mucca Mad Boys · Dec 27, 2020

Gibbo said:
Bright?

Sorry, I was strictly talking about permanent signings which wasn't very clear - so that's on me.

HuckerbyDublinWhelan · Dec 27, 2020

Here’s a curve ball. Jacob Murphy back? Scored 9 in 39 for Sheffield Wednesday last season. Presumably from the wing/attacking mid. Surely potential loan there

KenilworthSkyBlue · Dec 28, 2020

HuckerbyDublinWhelan said:
Here’s a curve ball. Jacob Murphy back? Scored 9 in 39 for Sheffield Wednesday last season. Presumably from the wing/attacking mid. Surely potential loan there

He's on a reported £25k pw. Even with a favourable wage split Murphy would be way out of our reach.

stupot07 · Dec 28, 2020

HuckerbyDublinWhelan said:
Here’s a curve ball. Jacob Murphy back? Scored 9 in 39 for Sheffield Wednesday last season. Presumably from the wing/attacking mid. Surely potential loan there

KenilworthSkyBlue said:
He's on a reported £25k pw. Even with a favourable wage split Murphy would be way out of our reach.

Plus he is starting for Newcastle in the PL.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

Deity · Dec 28, 2020

HuckerbyDublinWhelan said:
Here’s a curve ball. Jacob Murphy back? Scored 9 in 39 for Sheffield Wednesday last season. Presumably from the wing/attacking mid. Surely potential loan there

Currently starting for Newcastle most weeks ........

Tommo1993 · Dec 28, 2020

Jacob Murphy, the regular starter for Newcastle in the Premier League? I feel stupid for not thinking of that.

shmmeee · Dec 28, 2020

That Salah lad from Liverpool might do the job while Walkers out. Scored a few last season.

Terry_dactyl · Dec 28, 2020

Deity said:
I think we have seen a more pragmatic Robins this season. Let’s be honest our football is rubbish to watch now but it’s getting more points.

we really lack championship experience. I could see Robins looking to bring in 2 older heads to help the younger players.

it’s not how we normally operate but it might what Robins feels we need

I never really understand this idea that ‘older heads’ ie older players will help out. What will they do?
Surely what we need are better players/players that contribute more positively to the system we play Regardless of age.

fernandopartridge · Dec 28, 2020

Terry_dactyl said:
I never really understand this idea that ‘older heads’ ie older players will help out. What will they do?
Surely what we need are better players/players that contribute more positively to the system we play Regardless of age.

It's just another cliché isn't it? The idea that we need old heads when years of signing them have invariably been disastrous. Our team might be generally young but they're not so naive

Terry_dactyl · Dec 28, 2020

fernandopartridge said:
It's just another cliché isn't it? The idea that we need old heads when years of signing them have invariably been disastrous. Our team might be generally young but they're not so naive

Yeah it is cliche...and as you point out it doesn’t have much substance.?

procdoc · Dec 28, 2020

Terry_dactyl said:
I never really understand this idea that ‘older heads’ ie older players will help out. What will they do?
Surely what we need are better players/players that contribute more positively to the system we play Regardless of age.

I remember when we signed Stephen Hunt to add experience. He made us worse

Paxman II · Dec 28, 2020

What we need is a replacement for kelly. A like for like one. When he came back into the side we consolidated and got results. It seems too simple but it's a fact. Is there a player at the club who can fulfill that role? If not who can we go after bearing in mind budget constraints?

Liquid Gold · Dec 28, 2020

It’s also a myth that we only buy young players. Our overall transfer policy is to buy young, develop and sell at a profit but Robins wasn’t afraid to bring in 38 year old Doyle and there are plenty around the 27-31 age he’s bought since returning.

Frostie · Dec 28, 2020

Terry_dactyl said:
I never really understand this idea that ‘older heads’ ie older players will help out. What will they do?
Surely what we need are better players/players that contribute more positively to the system we play Regardless of age.

ironically it's probably the same people that were calling for us to drop McFadz.

shmmeee · Dec 28, 2020

Say experience doesn’t matter if you like but it’s not a coincidence that Godden Kelly and McFadz have been so critical to our success.

lord_garrincha · Dec 28, 2020

shmmeee said:
Say experience doesn’t matter if you like but it’s not a coincidence that Godden Kelly and McFadz have been so critical to our success.

But there is a difference between at their peak (28 to 33) than over the hill... Like the rubbish we brought in during the noughties... Bar Wise.

Terry_dactyl · Dec 28, 2020

shmmeee said:
Say experience doesn’t matter if you like but it’s not a coincidence that Godden Kelly and McFadz have been so critical to our success.

They have been but you could argue they’ve not been our very best performers - Dabo? Hamer? Walsh?

Colin Steins Smile · Dec 28, 2020

The obvious issue is unless we can offload squad players, who are not featuring in a meaningful way there's no budget to bring someone else in ....and given the fact a lot of other clubs in L1 & 2 are having a very difficult time financially....I can't see us offloading anyone.

January transfer window (26 Viewers)

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Super Moderator

Well-Known Member

Super Moderator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency