Player ratings v weds (3 Viewers)

Nick · Oct 5, 2024

Thomas made a few tackles.
Rudoni scored

Robins stood there hands in pockets all game again when it was clear we needed changes.

He was hoping for the point. They wanted the win.

Skyblueweeman · Oct 5, 2024

I thought Rudoni was the only one who played alright. Bidwell as well until he went off was ok.

The rest? Meh.

steve101 · Oct 5, 2024

Wilson 5
Van Erwijk 6
Thomas 7.5
Kitching 5
Bidwell 6.5
Eccles 7.5
Sheaf 8 motm
Rudoni 7
Mason-Clark 4
Thomas-Asante 6
Wright 5

DaSilva 6.5
Simms 6

Assistant referee disgraceful, ignoring clear offsides.

Sheffield Wednesday were not a good team and made us look poor.

Can't fathom the lack of substitutions.

procdoc · Oct 5, 2024

steve101 said:
Wilson 5
Van Erwijk 6
Thomas 7.5
Kitching 5
Bidwell 6.5
Eccles 7.5
Sheaf 8 motm
Rudoni 7
Mason-Clark 4
Thomas-Asante 6
Wright 5

DaSilva 6.5
Simms 6

Assistant referee disgraceful, ignoring clear offsides.

Sheffield Wednesday were not a good team and made us look poor.

Can't fathom the lack of substitutions.

Sheaf 8

The Philosopher · Oct 5, 2024

Wilson 6

Not sure he did get a big push for their disallowed goal and that could have easily been classed as a clanger. One or two great reaction saves but at the end of the day no clean sheet. Distribution mixed at best.

MVE 8 MOM

Our centre backs would concede plenty if MVE didn’t stop so many opposing wingers get past him. Got down the line well and linked up with BTA towards the end. Can’t think he did anything wrong.

Bidwell 7

Did his job well and also covered the jobs of our often-out-of-position centre backs.

Thomas 5

Ok, got a few decent blocks and last minute tackles in but wouldn’t have had so much to do if he had a clue where he was meant to be. He and Kitching allowed their attackers to run rings around them.

Kitching 5

All over the place at times. What is clear is that there is no one marshalling that defence.

Sheaf 7

Performance a 6 but gets an extra point for playing 90 minutes.

Rudoni 8

Great goal and was the one who orchestrated the play.

Eccles 5

Plenty of effort but dispossessed easily. Passes back and sideways reasonably and can find an open pass to the wing. However, many forward passes to feet are telegraphed and result in turnover of possession.

EMC 5

Still not sure if he’s a champ player.

BTA 7

Great pressing and some great runs.

Wright 6

Looked disinterested.

Subs

All blah.

Deity · Oct 5, 2024

Skyblueweeman said:
I thought Rudoni was the only one who played alright. Bidwell as well until he went off was ok.

The rest? Meh.

Rudoni great goal but totally anonymous in second half ….

procdoc · Oct 5, 2024

Wilson 5 - just not good enough
MVE 5 - Touch is awful at times
Bidwell 6 - one of the better players
Thomas 6 - didn’t do much wrong
Kitching 3 - waste of space
Sheaf 5 - ineffective
Eccles 5 - ineffective
Rudoni 6.5 - our best player
Wright 4 - dreadful
EMC 3 - dreadful
BTA 6 - skinned his man a few times and tried

SeaSeeEffCee · Oct 5, 2024

0 for every single one of the useless pricks.

Actually, 0 is probably a little too generous for the clowns that are Simms. Kitching and Mason-Clarke. £12m worth of alleged talent

Otis · Oct 5, 2024

Deity said:
Rudoni great goal but totally anonymous in second half ….

He seems to do that a lot. It's worrying.

steve101 · Oct 5, 2024

procdoc said:
Sheaf 8

Thought he played well. His passing was excellent and a couple of deft ones created chances. The problem for me we had noone able to hold the ball up further forward.

lewys33 · Oct 5, 2024

Some good performances but mostly poor.

MVE, Eccles, Thomas, Rudi had good performances. Shout out to BTA who put the effort in as well although wasn’t his best

Wilson, EMC, Kitching were poor.

Wright is currently stealing a living.

Robins was utterly clueless. But hey ho. Loyalty.

lewys33 · Oct 5, 2024

Imagine Rohl with a decent team. Their setup was levels above us today.

Cally Fedora · Oct 5, 2024

I thought 6-7 all round. Eccles and Asante 7-8

Winny the Bish · Oct 5, 2024

Wilson - 4 - Had no idea where his near post was for the first goal. He thought he was letting it go wide.
MVE - 7 - Did a good job against a very tricky winger and got forward well.
Thomas - 7 - His blocks stopped it being 3 or 4.
Kitching - 4 - Also made an error for the first. Not convicing at all when he has to run towards his own goal. Skinned when pulled out wide.
Bidwell - 5 - Poor. Robins has tried to move him on multiple times and you could see why today.
Sheaf - 6.5 - Some good passes, but slow to get back on counters.
Eccles - 6 - Not sure he stood out at all.
Rudoni - 6.5 - Good goal, good energy, but needs to be more creative in the final third.
EMC - 5 - Ghosted through the first half.
Wright - 5 - Sometimes he's good, sometimes he's crap. This was Crap Haji.
BTA - 6 - Looked better on the RW and managed to skin his full back a few times.

Simms - 6 - Well he ran today and won some headers so that's better than what we normally see from him.
Dasilva - NA.

Robins - 1 - Not convinced he knows how to change it. Becoming more apparent that Viveash was the tactical brains of the operation.

Nick · Oct 5, 2024

lewys33 said:
Imagine Rohl with a decent team. Their setup was levels above us today.

What's that thing he did where he brought players off and put others on? One of the ones he brought on got an assist by running at us.

We should try it.

MacReady · Oct 5, 2024

Robins - 1.5 for looking like a gorm for 90 minutes.

lewys33 · Oct 5, 2024

Nick said:
What's that thing he did where he brought players off and put others on? One of the ones he brought on got an assist by running at us.

We should try it.

2 subs, 1 of which was in the 80th minute for an injury. Laughable isn’t it.

stupot07 · Oct 5, 2024

Wilson 5
MVE 6
Thomas 7 MOTM
Kitching 6
Bidwell 6
Eccles 6
Sheaf 6
EMC 4
Rudoni 6
Wright 5
BTA 5

Subs
Simms 5
Dasilva n/a

Robins 2

Our xG. 0.65
Sheff Wed. XG 1.53

Nick · Oct 5, 2024

lewys33 said:
2 subs, 1 of which was in the 80th minute for an injury. Laughable isn’t it.

I reckon we should try making changes to where the players are on the pitch as well. We could alter things during a game.

lewys33 · Oct 5, 2024

Nick said:
I reckon we should try making changes to where the players are on the pitch as well. We could alter things during a game.

Do you have a UEFA A or UEFA B license?

Nuskyblue · Oct 5, 2024

Sheaf and Eccles 7.

BTA 6.

5s and 4s for the rest.

I think Kitching and Thomas were OK but the second goal was poor. One of them had to engage but then again they were left exposed....

Ref = Cuck

Blind-Faith · Oct 5, 2024

Wilson 6
Van Erwijk 6
Thomas 7 MOTM
Kitching 5
Bidwell 6
Eccles 7
Sheaf 7
Rudoni 7
Mason-Clark 3
Thomas-Asante 6
Wright 3

DaSilva na
Simms 5

Badly let down today by our wide players not wanting it enough and a CB who the jury is still out on

rob9872 · Oct 5, 2024

Thomas (7.5) motm covering for the clown he was playing next to (3). The only others to come put with credit really were Bidwell (7) and Rudoni (7). BTA worked hard but never posed a threat (6), MVE tried but struggled (6) Sheaf and Eccles first half decent but picked up cheap bookings meaning we couldn't pit a foot in thereafter (6's), not their fault Robins (2) should've changed it. Everyone else (5)

Wednesday fans were utterly classless outside the stadium and I've no idea why I'd always preferred them to Sheff Utd. After their recent publicised incidents (again) and the cunts ive met tonight, they can all get in the bin.

Lee77 · Oct 5, 2024

I don't like to single out players but I'm losing patience with Haji Wright. Lethargic and uninterested. His body language screams he doesn't want to be here.

torchomatic · Oct 5, 2024

The Philosopher said:
Sheaf 7

Performance a 6 but gets an extra point for playing 90 minutes

Haha, this genuinely made me LOL.
Sheaf gets a higher mark because he did a thing he's paid to do. Highlights what a fuck up our midfield is and how we rely on someone who's injured or coming back from injury foe large parts of out season.

I gave him a 9 as he put his boots on the right feet and his shirt on the right way around. Fuck me.

torchomatic · Oct 5, 2024

Lee77 said:
I don't like to single out players but I'm losing patience with Haji Wright. Lethargic and uninterested. His body language screams he doesn't want to be here.

Same here. Really frustrating today. I actually shouted out, "stay on your fucking feet!" at one point.

WestEndAgro · Oct 5, 2024

Can't be arsed to rate em, but fuckin hell, those 94 minute's pissed by, and can't remember a single chance created other than the goal.

steve101 · Oct 5, 2024

Chops and changes but keeps with players who are woefully under performing - Kitching and Wright. One player who has looked a threat is Bassette, who hasn't had a look in. Dovin, in my opinion, did very little wrong. Wilson is a great character and did well v Blackburn and Spurs, but today shows why he is not up to the standard required for a number 1.
With Bidwell out now for a while, we will now have no decent cover for either full back position.

Fergusons_Beard · Oct 5, 2024

Has Bassette shagged Robins wife….

And has Wright shagged Robins?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

stevefloyd · Oct 5, 2024

And don't forget the fucking atrocious blind bastard cheating linesman

ptr · Oct 5, 2024

Thomas defended very well. Needs to be more confident on the ball though and step in to give us a different option. Takes the easy option far too much.

Earlsdon_Skyblue1 · Oct 5, 2024

stevefloyd said:
And don't forget the fucking atrocious blind bastard cheating linesman

Sorry to be that guy, but if he's blind, how can he cheat?

Chris1987 · Oct 5, 2024

The only conclusion that I can reach is that MVE is way too good for this team.

Chris1987 · Oct 5, 2024

steve101 said:
Wilson 5
Van Erwijk 6
Thomas 7.5
Kitching 5
Bidwell 6.5
Eccles 7.5
Sheaf 8 motm
Rudoni 7
Mason-Clark 4
Thomas-Asante 6
Wright 5

DaSilva 6.5
Simms 6

Assistant referee disgraceful, ignoring clear offsides.

Sheffield Wednesday were not a good team and made us look poor.

Can't fathom the lack of substitutions.

Sheaf was shit

Brighton Sky Blue · Oct 5, 2024

Wilson 5
MVE 6
Thomas 6
Kitching 4
Bidwell 6
Sheaf 5
Eccles 6
Rudoni 6
Wright 5
EMC 4
BTA 5

Subs
Simms 5
Dasilva N/A

Player ratings v weds (3 Viewers)

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency