singers_pore
Well-Known Member
Burge - 7 - didn't have much to do but did well when called upon
Grimmer - 6 - some very good moments and some dreadful moments. You can see why he is in L2.
Willis - 6 - did ok. Could be a bit more intelligent on the ball.
McDonald - 8 - defence looks so much more assured when he is in there. Not sure he deserved the red card. My first reaction was that the red card was unwarranted but need to see the replay. Will be a big miss in our next game.
Stokes - 6 - Not sure what's gone wrong. Doesn't look the same player as before his injury.
Kelly - 6 - ok, nothing special
Doyle - 6 - doesn't impact the game enough but good to have a vocal presence in the middle.
Vincenti - 7 - his best game for us so far (as noted by Robins in his post-match comments). Would have given him a higher rating but for his suicidal back pass which almost resulted in an equalizer.
Andreu - 5 - didn't hold the ball up, didn't create much, not impressed today.
Jones - 8 - outstanding. If we could get another forward who is this good we would easily get promoted.
McNulty - 6 - did his normal stuff for the first half an hour before being subbed. Ran around, looked skillful but ultimately doesn't look to be a threat.
Nazon - 6 - offers something different. In particular he is better than Beavon and McNulty at making the ball stick up front. However, he also has some bad moments.
Davies - 5 - not on long enough to be very noticeable.
Beavon - 5 - simply not good enough. Made a couple of decent interceptions but nothing else.
Robins - 6 - yes we won but Port Vale are the worst team we have played this season. Our forward line lacks goals and we are over-reliant on Jones. Robins was a great forward himself, so it's strange he didn't talent spot someone who is better than McNulty, Biamou, etc. Maybe a finances issue?
Grimmer - 6 - some very good moments and some dreadful moments. You can see why he is in L2.
Willis - 6 - did ok. Could be a bit more intelligent on the ball.
McDonald - 8 - defence looks so much more assured when he is in there. Not sure he deserved the red card. My first reaction was that the red card was unwarranted but need to see the replay. Will be a big miss in our next game.
Stokes - 6 - Not sure what's gone wrong. Doesn't look the same player as before his injury.
Kelly - 6 - ok, nothing special
Doyle - 6 - doesn't impact the game enough but good to have a vocal presence in the middle.
Vincenti - 7 - his best game for us so far (as noted by Robins in his post-match comments). Would have given him a higher rating but for his suicidal back pass which almost resulted in an equalizer.
Andreu - 5 - didn't hold the ball up, didn't create much, not impressed today.
Jones - 8 - outstanding. If we could get another forward who is this good we would easily get promoted.
McNulty - 6 - did his normal stuff for the first half an hour before being subbed. Ran around, looked skillful but ultimately doesn't look to be a threat.
Nazon - 6 - offers something different. In particular he is better than Beavon and McNulty at making the ball stick up front. However, he also has some bad moments.
Davies - 5 - not on long enough to be very noticeable.
Beavon - 5 - simply not good enough. Made a couple of decent interceptions but nothing else.
Robins - 6 - yes we won but Port Vale are the worst team we have played this season. Our forward line lacks goals and we are over-reliant on Jones. Robins was a great forward himself, so it's strange he didn't talent spot someone who is better than McNulty, Biamou, etc. Maybe a finances issue?
Last edited: