Player Ratings (3 Viewers)

Nick · Feb 10, 2018

Anybody brave enough?

Obrien - 5 - Didnt have much to do, a few shit kicks. Not much hope with either goal.
DKE - 4- Bonus point for the tackle, targetted all game
Willis - 3 - Lost most headers, him and mcdonald messed up for goal, Awful
McDonald - 4 - Got bossed all game
Stokes 5 - Got up and down the touchline but thats about it, took some throw ins
Shipley - 4 - Awful on the left, awful in the middle
JMD - 3 - Seriously?
Kelly - 4 - I can stand in the centre circle and call for the ball then hammer it forward as hard as I can without looking if thats what footballers should be doing
Bayliss - 3 - Was he playing?
Biamou - 6 - Ran and took the ball off defenders a few times, battled well - MOM
McNulty - 4 - Pointless him even playing, not really his fault as nobody gave him anything

Vincenti - 5 - Better than JMD and at least tried to make things happen
Reid - 5 - Can see him coming back in for loads more games, also tried to get forward
JCH - 4 - Like McNulty, pointless him coming on really to watch the ball get hoofed to their keeper

Robins - 3 - Have a word, outthought, no gameplan or anything. Can't use illness as an excuse, absolutely nothing going forward in the last 2 games. Needs to start taking risks.

stevefloyd · Feb 10, 2018

As I just put in the match thread, Biamou 6 the rest all 5 and under...they didn't play for me so I can't be arsed to write about them

Brighton Sky Blue · Feb 10, 2018

Loaning in children from the reserves of Champs/PL sides is pointless, we may as well blood our own if that's the best we can bring in.

stevefloyd · Feb 10, 2018

Nick said:
Anybody brave enough?

Obrien - 5 - Didnt have much to do, a few shit kicks. Not much hope with either goal.
DKE - 4- Bonus point for the tackle, targetted all game
Willis - 3 - Lost most headers, him and mcdonald messed up for goal, Awful
McDonald - 4 - Got bossed all game
Stokes 5 - Got up and down the touchline but thats about it, took some throw ins
Shipley - 4 - Awful on the left, awful in the middle
JMD - 3 - Seriously?
Kelly - 4 - I can stand in the centre circle and call for the ball then hammer it forward as hard as I can without looking if thats what footballers should be doing
Bayliss - 3 - Was he playing?
Biamou - 6 - Ran and took the ball off defenders a few times, battled well - MOM
McNulty - 4 - Pointless him even playing, not really his fault as nobody gave him anything

Vincenti - 5 - Better than JMD and at least tried to make things happen
Reid - 5 - Can see him coming back in for loads more games, also tried to get forward
JCH - 4 - Like McNulty, pointless him coming on really to watch the ball get hoofed to their keeper

Robins - 3 - Have a word, outthought, no gameplan or anything. Can't use illness as an excuse, absolutely nothing going forward in the last 2 games. Needs to start taking risks.

I think you gave JMD 3 points too many

stevefloyd · Feb 10, 2018

Brighton Sky Blue said:
Loaning in children from the reserves of Champs/PL sides is pointless, we may as well blood our own if that's the best we can bring in.

We needed more experience rather than more kids but if it was to be kids then surely we could have done better than JMD and Barret

covcity4life · Feb 10, 2018

O brien 4 rooted to his line all the time. Nothing lik3 keeper i saw start of season

Dke 3 like his bro when he has ball its either safe nothing pass or lost possession. Didnt defend all that well either

Macdonald 4 becoming a donkey
Willis 4 not much better
Stokes 5 should be a leader. But no urgency at all

Shipley 3 needs to be taken out of team for a bit. Shit passing and decision making

Baylis 2 i could hsve done better.

Kelly 2 should be subbed off whenever we go behind. Offer snothing in attacking sense

Maguire drew 1 terrible

Mcnukty 5 no service

Biamou 8 showed heart and won most duels

Reid 5 2 great crosses. Robins left it too late

Clarke harris 4

Vincente 4

Robins 0

Modcons86 · Feb 10, 2018

Did obrien attempt to come and collect any corner?

CCFC_Charlie · Feb 10, 2018

O'Brien - 5 - Don't remember him doing anything
Kelly-Evans - 1 - Woeful, badly at fault for first goal and beaten by his man every single time. Will be playing at Nuneaton within a year and a half.
Willis - 3 - Can't pass, didn't defend well. Bad.
McDonald - 3 - See above
Stokes - 5 - Alright
Shipley - 5 - Not that involved really, ok in the centre
Bayliss - 3 - Worst game in a City shirt, at least tries to go forward
Kelly - 2 - Bin him off, can't pass forward and when he tries he just kicks it to the opposition. Offers nothing in attack.
Maguire-Drew - 1 - Send him back to Brighton.
McNulty - 4 - Too interested in trying to win set pieces, got no service
Biamou - 7 - Gave his all, only one that played with any heart. Fair play.

Vincenti - 3 - Nice guy but can't pass, can't dribble, can't cross and can't shoot so what is the point?
Clarke-Harris - 3 - He played????
Reid - 3 - Some ok crosses, mainly bad though.

Robins - 0 - Awful, awful, awful management. Wrong team, wrong subs, wrong tactics, wrong everything.

Fans - -2 - Don't bother coming if all you're going to do is boo the players and slag them off no matter how badly we're playing. Outsung by 500 Accrington fans today. Embarrassing.

clint van damme · Feb 10, 2018

Brighton Sky Blue said:
Loaning in children from the reserves of Champs/PL sides is pointless, we may as well blood our own if that's the best we can bring in.

this is a mans league, we can't afford to carry a team of youngsters, especially when they're either not fit or not ours.
To expect half a dozen youngsters to maintain the level of consistency needed for 15 or 16 games is the sort of madness that costs you your job.

Covstu · Feb 10, 2018

O'Brien - 4 - people say he is better that Burge? Really?
Kelly-Evans - 2 - clueless got ripped a new arsehole today
Willis - 3 - Both centre halves looked in trouble from the start and couldn’t handle them
McDonald - 3 - See above
Stokes - 5 - Meh
Shipley - 4 - lightweight, but got bypassed in the second half due to long balls
Bayliss - 3 - Headless chicken
Kelly - 3 - is Doyle covering his shortcomings?.
Maguire-Drew - 3 - please don’t play him next week
McNulty - 4 - picking up scraps all day but shite
Biamou - 6 - best player for us by far, tried his upmost but a clueless team around him

Vincenti - 3 - didn’t realise he was on the pitch
Clarke-Harris - 3 - Couldn’t really influence the game, game was lost at that point
Reid - 4 - looked a little lively but again the game was lost

Robins - 1 - not sure what his tactics were today, outplayed, outbattled today. Clueless performance but fair play to Stanley they were better in every area again

stevefloyd · Feb 10, 2018

Stanley obviously deserved to win but to be fair I think rather than them winning it today we actually gifted it to them we struggled to string a few passes together dreadful

stevefloyd · Feb 10, 2018

If Robins ever asks why we don't get more people up the Ricoh just show him a video of today's game

speedie87 · Feb 10, 2018

O’Brien 5 doesn’t give me any signs of confidence
Kelly-Evans 3 fans round me love him but every time he plays we let in goals that are his fault, and other teams target him as a weak link
Willis 4 need to re watch second goal to see whose fault it was
McDonald 4 as above
Stokes 6
Kelly5
Bayliss 4 worst I’ve ever seen the lad play including yth, u23
Mcquire drew. 3 dire
Shipley 5
Biamou 7 but still don’t look like scoring
McNulty 5 not his day was brought down when clean through second half

Reid 7 should start next league match
Clark Harris 5 looks strong and pacy need to play him in behind not with his back to play
Vincentti 4

torchomatic · Feb 10, 2018

O'Brien - didn't do a lot wrong - 5
DKE - Not very good - 4
Stokes - Slow, incapable of passing - 3
Willis - Not one of his good days - 4
McDOnald - Same as Willis - 4
Kelly - terrible - 3
Bayliss - terrible - 3
JMD - terrible - 3
Shipley - best of a bad midfield bunch - 4
McNulty - No service, no goals - 5
MAX BIAMOU - MOTM - By far the only one giving his all - 7
Vincenti - Won headers...but usually into space or to their players - 4
Reid - At least he attacked and did a few good crosses - 5
JCH - No service so had no impact - 5

SAJ · Feb 10, 2018

O'B Poor seen a bar football goalie come further off his line. 3
DKE At fault for the first goal ruled to shreds all match did one good tackle 3

JW Awful passing no leadership no communications. Under 8's mistake with McDonald for second goal. Lost most headers.3

McDonald similar to Willis shade of what he was doing early in the season. 3
Stokes. Better than recent performances could have been the rest of the back for were that bad he had a better game. 5
JMD Did he control the ball once. What does he offer? 2
Kelly Eddy Waring would have been proud of the amount of up and under today. 2
Bsyliss Look dead on his feet worst performance so far could do with a rest.3
Shipley Played marginally better once moved into centre midfield. 4
McNulty. Even I'll was better than most of the others Tried but looked dad on his feet. 5
Max Put a lot of effort in once quite a few balls off their defence but had no one to assist him. 6 MON.
Vinceti Got into some good positions had a reasonable chance that he should have done something better than thump it at the corner flag. 4
Reid. 2 good crosses but not much else 4
JCH No real impact 3
Robins Did he have any tactics today. From the moment they scored we were inept, didn' t try anything different. 2

shy_tall_knight · Feb 10, 2018

DKE is too small to play at full-back he was targeted with those cross field diagonal balls and was tot ally at fault for the first goal, his lack of height just encurages the opposition to aim the ball in that area as they expect him to struggle.

clint van damme · Feb 10, 2018

shy_tall_knight said:
DKE is too small to play at full-back he was targeted with those cross field diagonal balls and was tot ally at fault for the first goal, his lack of height just encurages the opposition to aim the ball in that area as they expect him to struggle.

and they created chances using the same tactic throughout the game yet we didn't do anything to counteract it.

steve82 · Feb 10, 2018

O'Brien 5 - not a lot he could do with the goals. Boxed in at corners but safe overall with nothing to save.

DiKE 2- that was woeful!! Kids a liability, reckless in the challenge even if a meal was made of it. Positional play poor, sold more times than a old Rover! At fault for the 1st goal.

Willis 3- very poor, Billy Kee bullied him all afternoon, distribution poor, communication limited. Captains arm band cut the blood circulation off to his head today.

Mcdonald 3.5 - poor by his standards. The .5 will be left or taken away on the post-mortem to the Willis-Mcdonald fiasco.

Stokes 4- nothing special, but the pick of a poor defence.

JMD 2- non existent, I expect him to have flu tomorrow after that 45 minutes. Very poor showing.

Baylis 3- the run had to end, out of his depth today. Poor touch, heavy passes and shocking decision making. Lost without Doyle.

Kelly 4- not the worst in the side by a long shot but but that's not a great marker. Off the pace still.

Shipley 4- as Kelly but didn't really get into the game. Tried.

McNulty 5- limited with what opportunities he was given but should of had a penalty before Accrington scored. Shot in anger the best chance of the game at half time.

Biamou 6- MOTM. the pick of a bad bunch. Worked his socks off without a sniff of goal. Cannot question his application and desire to impact the game today.

Vincenti 4- another not the worst but little impact.

Reid 4- flashed a few crosses in, still poor and lacks confidence.

JCH 3- didn't get into the game with only 20 mins left. The looped long ball isn't for him to feed off.

steve82 · Feb 10, 2018

shy_tall_knight said:
DKE is too small to play at full-back he was targeted with those cross field diagonal balls and was tot ally at fault for the first goal, his lack of height just encurages the opposition to aim the ball in that area as they expect him to struggle.

Kid was a liability today. Not a surprise to see him targeted by Accrington. As I said in my ratings. Sold more times than a old rover.

He and his brother are unfortunately out of there depth in the professional game. Height is a issue unfortunately and yes he might bleed sky blue blood but overall not good enough.

Liquid Gold · Feb 10, 2018

DKE played like we'd drafted in a 12 year old today, awful. Everything Accrington created came down his side.

stevefloyd · Feb 10, 2018

Didn't see the point in booing Reid when he came on .... mindless once again booing one of our own players

stevefloyd · Feb 10, 2018

What we done today

lifeskyblue · Feb 10, 2018

Apart from biamou not one player deserves their wages after that. Accrington didn’t have to raise a sweat and won comfortably.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

steve82 · Feb 10, 2018

Andy Turner throws his usual shit ratings out on a Saturday evening

O'Brien- 5
DiKE - 5
Willis- 5
Mcdonald- 5
Stokes- 5
JMD- 4
Bayliss- 5
Kelly- 5
Shipley- 5
McNulty- 6
Biamou- 6

Vincenti- 5.5
Reid- 6
JCH- 4

Sometimes wonder how he arrives at his decisions.

ceetee · Feb 10, 2018

I know Stokes has not been anywhere as good as before his serious injury, and the last few games have been especially poor, but I thought he started off very soundly todsy

SlowerThanPlatt · Feb 10, 2018

O Brien - 5
Kelly Evans - 4
Willis - 4
McDonald - 4
Stokes - 4
Maguire Drew - 3
Bayliss - 4
Kelly - 4
Shipley - 5
Biamou - 6
McNulty - 4

Gazolba · Feb 10, 2018

stevefloyd said:
We needed more experience rather than more kids but if it was to be kids then surely we could have done better than JMD and Barret

Hasn't Barret played just one game, where he was barely fit? A bit too soon to judge if you ask me.

singers_pore · Feb 10, 2018

O Brien - 5
Kelly Evans - 3 - very poor
Willis - 5
McDonald - 4
Stokes - 4
Maguire Drew - 2 - terrible
Bayliss - 2 - made a couple of misplaced passes early in the game and some of the free ticket wankers who haven't seen any previous games started booing him. Never really recovered from that and rightly subbed.
Kelly - 4
Shipley - 4
Biamou - 5
McNulty - 7 - couldn't see why he was taken off, maybe one of those suffering from the virus?

Limey · Feb 10, 2018

As a right side combination Kelly Evans and JMD were disastrous. Way too lightweight and small in height for this league.

Individually they might be better than today's showing. Should have started Vincenti in Grimmers absence in front of DKE.

Biamou 7
McNulty 6

The rest 4 or below.

play_in_skyblue_stripes · Feb 10, 2018

My first home game since Oct 2014. Very poor performance.
O'Brian 2 - looked very poor keeper. Rooted to line on many occasions
DKE - 1 - Sorry looked totally out of place in level 4 of league football
Stokes - 3 Very disappointed in him. Won't last past this season. Maybe injury has had a big impact.
Willis 6 - For me one of the only two players today who can justify themselves as playing OK.
McDonald 3 - Looked slow. I saw him at Swindon and seemed better that night.
Shipley 4 - Tried but rather gangly style.
Kelly 3 - ineffective , no ambition or telling impact on creativity
Bayliss 5 - Looked good to me but went off for some reason. Definitely has potential and will rise to higher grade for sure.
Vincent 2 - First time seen him play. Sorry but of no use to team today.
McNulty 2 - I know he has been doing well and goal tally shows that, but I can only mark what I saw today.
Biamou 7 - easily best Coventry player. Credit to his effort and skill
JCH - 2 or 3 No impact. Physically looks strong and mean but didn't show it in his play. First game for him though , so give him a chance to settle down.
Reid 4 - apart from Max B, only one that created any sense of danger to opposition. Unfortunately not enough of it.
Other sub cannot remember
Oh yes MD Brighton player totally forgot about him 2 - very poor and verging on terrible, hence early substitution.

play_in_skyblue_stripes · Feb 10, 2018

steve82 said:
Kid was a liability today. Not a surprise to see him targeted by Accrington. As I said in my ratings. Sold more times than a old rover.
Sadly this is true. Cannot see him playing
He and his brother are unfortunately out of there depth in the professional game. Height is a issue unfortunately and yes he might bleed sky blue blood but overall not good enough.

Sadly this is true. I did see one of the KE brothers last year at Bury and effort shown was admirable and was about the best player on the night albeit team overall was plain rubbish.
Today was a performance indicating he won't cut it at league level. Hope it was just a bad day for him and he can improve.

Otis · Feb 10, 2018

O'Brien 5.5 - The game pretty much passed him by.

DKE 2 - I have finally given up on the DKE twins and Robins should do the same. When you have the opposition deliberately targeting a player and it clearly coming off you know you are in trouble. Think he should be dropped with immediate effect. A bit of a liability I'm afraid.

Willis 5 - Struggled today

McDonald 5 - Ditto

Stokes 5.5 - At least he did make some vital interceptions

JMD 1 - Not seen that much of him, but is looking an absolutely abysmal signing. Offered precisely nothing. Really dreadful

Kelly 5 - Not in the game enough, not organising and cajoling the players around him and not driving us forwards

Bayliss 3 - Will accept Robins' assertion that the lad was still ill. Disastrous effort.

Shipley 5 - Disappeared for long periods. Very little impact

McNulty 5 - Another who Robins said was ill and again I will take his word

Biamou 6 - Best player on the park for us.

Vincenti 6 - Thought he did okay when he came on.

Reid 5.5 - Got the ball over, but it was pretty much straight into the goalkeeper 's arms for the most part.

JCH 5 - I do believe he was the sub, but even though he purportedly came on I would dispute that. Offered nowt.

stupot07 · Feb 10, 2018

O'Brien 5 - Meh
DKE 2 - robins said he is injured and was rushed back. You could tell he was way off the pace so will give him the benefit of the doubt today.
Willis and McDonald 3 - got bullied and schooled by Stanley's front 2
Stokes 5 steady
JMD 1 - truly awful
Kelly 5 tried, but too defensive
Bayliss 2 - not a good day at the office
Shipley 4 - disappointing
McNulty 5 - worked hard no service
Biamou 6.5 - MOTM the only one that looked like he was up for the scrap. No service.

Sub's
Vincenti 5 - still not playing to his strengths
Reid 6 - actually crossed the ball into the box
JCH 4 - no real service

Robins 1.

On a side note, no centre mid on the bench. Should never have sold Stevenson, I said we left ourselves short.

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

wingy · Feb 10, 2018

Has Don lost that bet ?
Now .

SkyBlueRuffian · Feb 10, 2018

Nick said:
Anybody brave enough?

Obrien - 5 - Didnt have much to do, a few shit kicks. Not much hope with either goal.
DKE - 4- Bonus point for the tackle, targetted all game
Willis - 3 - Lost most headers, him and mcdonald messed up for goal, Awful
McDonald - 4 - Got bossed all game
Stokes 5 - Got up and down the touchline but thats about it, took some throw ins
Shipley - 4 - Awful on the left, awful in the middle
JMD - 3 - Seriously?
Kelly - 4 - I can stand in the centre circle and call for the ball then hammer it forward as hard as I can without looking if thats what footballers should be doing
Bayliss - 3 - Was he playing?
Biamou - 6 - Ran and took the ball off defenders a few times, battled well - MOM
McNulty - 4 - Pointless him even playing, not really his fault as nobody gave him anything

Vincenti - 5 - Better than JMD and at least tried to make things happen
Reid - 5 - Can see him coming back in for loads more games, also tried to get forward
JCH - 4 - Like McNulty, pointless him coming on really to watch the ball get hoofed to their keeper

Robins - 3 - Have a word, outthought, no gameplan or anything. Can't use illness as an excuse, absolutely nothing going forward in the last 2 games. Needs to start taking risks.

1/10 for the lot of them.

Player Ratings (3 Viewers)

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency