RATINGS FOLKS V Barnsley (1 Viewer)

johnniericoh · Feb 25, 2012

Murphy 7
Christie 7
Keogh 8
Cranie 7
Clarke 7
Baker 5
McSheffrey 6
Deegan 7
Norwood 7
Nimely 8
Plattini 8

MoM - has to be the big fella Plattini

PUSB

SkyBlue_Bear83 · Feb 25, 2012

Murphy-?-Spectator
Christie-6
Keogh-8
Cranie-7
Clarke-7
Baker-4
Norwood-7
Deegan-6
Sheff-6
Platt-8
Nimely-8

Otis · Feb 25, 2012

Murphy 6 (only because he had nothing to do)
Christie 7
Keogh 8
Cranie 7
Clarke 6
Baker 2 (truly dreadful)
McSheffrey 4
Deegan 7
Norwood 7
Nimely 8
Platt 8

MOTOM: Platt.

stupot07 · Feb 25, 2012

Murphy 6 (only because he had nothing to do)
Christie 6
Keogh 8
Cranie 7
Clarke 6
Baker 2 (truly dreadful)
McSheffrey 5
Deegan 7
Norwood 7
Nimely 8
Platt 8

Bell 6

MOTOM: Platt.

JazzCat · Feb 25, 2012

Murphy 6
Christie 6
Keogh 7
Cranie 6
Clarke 6
Baker 5
McSheffrey 5
Deegan 6
Norwood 7
Nimely 7
Plattini 8

Bell 7

Cooksta94 · Feb 25, 2012

Murphy 6
Christie 6
Keogh 7
Cranie 7
Clarke 6
Baker 4 (complete waste of space)
Mcsheffery 5
Deegan 6
Norwood 7
Nimely 8
Platt 8

Bell 7 (looked threatening)

M.o.M - Platt

wingy · Feb 25, 2012

I'm with JR ,add 7 for Bell ,SAme for manager ,4for durso ,convinced he has an issue reffing us

Nonleagueherewecome · Feb 25, 2012

Some generous ratings today..I'd start by giving most of the Barnsley players between 4-6, with Steele a 7, and that twat Korey Smith a 1. Attitude!
As for us:

Murphy-7
Christie-6
Keogh-7
Cranie-5
Clarke-8
Baker-4
Deegan-7
Norwood-6
McSheffrey-5
Platt-9
Nimely-8

Bell-7

Nonleagueherewecome · Feb 25, 2012

wingy said:
I'm with JR ,add 7 for Bell ,SAme for manager ,4for durso ,convinced he has an issue reffing us

He was an utter twonk!

Cooksta94 · Feb 25, 2012

Nonleagueherewecome said:
Some generous ratings today..I'd start by giving most of the Barnsley players between 4-6, with Steele a 7, and that twat Korey Smith a 1. Attitude!
As for us:

Murphy-7
Christie-6
Keogh-7
Cranie-5
Clarke-8
Baker-4
Deegan-7
Norwood-6
McSheffrey-5
Platt-9
Nimely-8

Bell-7

8 for clarke? All he did was set up the goal. He was poor apart from that

Nonleagueherewecome · Feb 25, 2012

At least 3 superb defensive interceptions in the last 10 minutes?

Otis · Feb 25, 2012

He did do some stuff well, but also made a number of mistakes. Which is why I only gave him 6. thought his performance was rather mixed.

SkyBlue · Feb 25, 2012

Joe Murphy - 6 (Had nothing to do?)
Cyrus Christie - 7
Richard Keogh - 8
Martin Cranie - 7
Jordan Clarke - 7
Carl Baker - 4
Gary Deegan - 5
Oliver Norwood - 7
Gary McSheffery - 6
Alex Nimely - 7 (Probably his worst game for us, the miss seemed to effect him a bit, still decent though)
Clive Platt - 8

David Bell -
Andy Thorn - 5

@richh87 · Feb 25, 2012

Murphy 7
Christie 6
Keogh 8
Cranie 7
Clarke 5
Baker 4
McSheffrey 6
Deegan 6
Norwood 6
Nimely 7
Plattini 8

MoM - Platt

rob9872 · Feb 25, 2012

SkyBlue said:
Alex Nimely - 7 (Probably his worst game for us, the miss seemed to effect him a bit, still decent though)

Really? I thought the lad was totally unplayable. The only blot on his performance was the casual roll past the post when one on one (really should hit the target as a minimum there). He showed pace, tricks, strength against very tight and deep markingt and yet despite only being on loan his work rate was unbelieveable. Along with Platt and Keogh who gave his usual commanding performance, he was one of our top performers imo.

SkyBlue_Bear83 · Feb 25, 2012

rob9872 said:
Really? I thought the lad was totally unplayable. The only blot on his performance was the casual roll past the post when one on one (really should hit the target as a minimum there). He showed pace, tricks, strength against very tight and deep markingt and yet despite only being on loan his work rate was unbelieveable. Along with Platt and Keogh who gave his usual commanding performance, he was one of our top performers imo.

I agree with this, the lad was buzzing today. Was feeding off scraps and Platt knock downs for the majority as we were very long ball today. There were so many balls where you are thinking he is never getting that but the desire was great and he wanted it more than any of the Barnsley defenders.
Barnsley were shitting themselves everytime he got the ball and tried to not allow him to get into his stride running with the ball.

dongonzalos · Feb 25, 2012

Murphy 7
Christie 7
Keogh 8
Cranie 7
Clarke 7
Baker 5
McSheffrey 6
Deegan 7
Norwood 7
Nimely 8
Plattini 9

MoM - has to be the big fella Plattini

PUSB

Grendel · Feb 25, 2012

Nonleagueherewecome said:
At least 3 superb defensive interceptions in the last 10 minutes?

Agreed - don't get the anti-Clarke thing at all. Beginning to annoy me actually.

Grendel · Feb 25, 2012

Murphy - 6
Christie - 6
Cranie - 7
Keogh - 7
Clarke - 7
Deegan - 6
Norwood - 6
Baker - 2
McSheffery - 5
Nimley - 8
Platt - 7

Bell - 6

rob9872 · Feb 25, 2012

Clarke was dreadful against Leeds but clealry short of match fitness for a young guy playing out of position. He was massively better today and the desire at the end to get the ball back for Platt was an outstanding contribution. Still wayward and positioning a problem, but will get better and has all th ebasic tools to have a decent career imo

Skybluesimon · Feb 25, 2012

Clarke was also one of our best players against Forest, and he's not yet fully fit!
Lay off the lad, he'll learn from his mistakes and improve with time.

@richh87 · Feb 25, 2012

rob9872 said:
Clarke was dreadful against Leeds but clealry short of match fitness for a young guy playing out of position. He was massively better today and the desire at the end to get the ball back for Platt was an outstanding contribution. Still wayward and positioning a problem, but will get better and has all th ebasic tools to have a decent career imo

Also terrible versus Forest - both goals coming down his side. It was his positioning then too for me.

The desire at the end today was fantastic though.

Otis · Feb 26, 2012

rob9872 said:
Clarke was dreadful against Leeds but clealry short of match fitness for a young guy playing out of position. He was massively better today and the desire at the end to get the ball back for Platt was an outstanding contribution. Still wayward and positioning a problem, but will get better and has all th ebasic tools to have a decent career imo

Totally agree. Claus Jorgensen said it was schoolboy stuff when Clarke came out of position to chase the ball and Barnsely simply passed the ball around him leaving the winger free in acres of space to get a cross in, in the first half.

That was embarrassing from the young player. As I said, he did a number of things well, but also made a fair few mistakes and on another day, that could have cost us.

dave1903 · Feb 26, 2012

Barnsley Ratings

Going to the game yesterday was a refreshing change to see us actually outplay and attack a team for long period. Felt very unusual.
makes you think how have Barnsley got more point than us when they looked very poor

My Ratings

Murphy - hard to rate, did he have to do anything?
Christie - 7
Keogh - 9 (so hope we can keep hold of him for next season, gives the defense so much composure)
Craine - 7
Clarke - 7 (Only becuase he assisted the goal)
Norwood -7
Baker - 4 (Dear god he was dreadful)
Deegan - 7
Sheffers - 6
Platt -9 (Man Mountain of a player, was very impressed)
Nimeley - 8

well thats my two cents anyways.

WillieStanley · Feb 26, 2012

That's fair. You forgot Bell though. I'd say, due to the impact of taking Baker of, he gets a 7. I also think 6 for Sheffers was a bit generous. He was surprisingly absent.

ccfcway · Feb 26, 2012

Clarke is a right footed right back playing at left back

Just saying its not all his fault.

Didnt see gary Neville playing at left back much did you, wonder why that is, oh, because Man Utd could afford to have a fit left back.

Clarke is doing his best in a position he doesnt play. If he was playing like this at right back then fair enough, but lets leave off him hey !

joemercersaces · Feb 26, 2012

If you want to hear an exercise in self-delusion listen to Keith Hill's comments on BBC Sport. Says Barnsley deserved more from the game and kept our goal threat to minimal levels and after he'd set his side up to get a point how close them came.

I would have liked to hear the interviewer ask him about our 19 shots to their 3 and also why they'd come to us looking only for a point?

Thought that the game yesterday very closely matched the Leeds match in that they started brightly, a side full of confidence but we got totally on top in the second half and showed real determination to get something. Rewarded twice by late winners. I've long said that these late goals aren't lucky, look at Man Utd and how often they score them.

oakey · Feb 26, 2012

Keogh and Cranie had virtually nothing to do. When they did receive the ball (usually kicked straight to them from a Barnsley error) both were able to bring the ball forward unchallenged as the opposition retreated. Their distribution was often poor or hoof.
Thus both can get 6, or 7 if you wish to be generous.

This love-in for Keogh is getting tedious now.

johnniericoh · Feb 26, 2012

oakey said:
Keogh and Cranie had virtually nothing to do. When they did receive the ball (usually kicked straight to them from a Barnsley error) both were able to bring the ball forward unchallenged as the opposition retreated. Their distribution was often poor or hoof.
Thus both can get 6, or 7 if you wish to be generous.

This love-in for Keogh is getting tedious now.

This love-in is based on us having one of the BEST centre backs in our league (arguably THE best) who gives us outstanding performances week in week out, could easily make the transition to the Prem League and is the sort of player most clubs dream about.

But we've got him - so let's enjoy whilst he's here - it might not be for very long !!!.

PUSB

dave1903 · Feb 27, 2012

WillieStanley said:
That's fair. You forgot Bell though. I'd say, due to the impact of taking Baker of, he gets a 7. I also think 6 for Sheffers was a bit generous. He was surprisingly absent.

yeh forgot to rate Bell i suppose he would have got a 6/7 did ok, but a long with most of the midfield wernt really excelling.

i see your point about clarke playing left back too , but last time i saw him play was at right back and he was just as average.

Keogh probably would have had less to do if the midfield in front of him wernt so, jittery at times, i felt he had to show a calm head and look after them often.
Saying he hoofed it a lot, his distribution to platt was reasonably good.

rob9872 · Feb 27, 2012

oakey said:
Keogh and Cranie had virtually nothing to do. When they did receive the ball (usually kicked straight to them from a Barnsley error) both were able to bring the ball forward unchallenged as the opposition retreated. Their distribution was often poor or hoof.
Thus both can get 6, or 7 if you wish to be generous.

This love-in for Keogh is getting tedious now.

Do you not think a lot of this was to do with how Barnsley marked tight and squeezed the play into a limited space though?

Often when the defenders had the ball their outlets were limited and the movenment ahead of them was not very sharp or bright, leving them to go on a marauding run (of which Keogh did considerably more than usual) or to kick longer than desired up to Platt and hope it stuck there. Barnsley may have offered nothing, but they had certainly done their homework on us.

Keogh and Cranie did what was required of them and made some decent interventions and never gave the opposition a sniff with the exception of one mistake When Cranie mis-timed going for a header on a high line and was well beaten to it by the CF, but Keogh even then went across to hold him up.

I think the "love-in" is far from tedious and is justified here. He is player of the season so far (imo) by a country mile.

Jack Griffin · Feb 27, 2012

Yeah Barnsley & Leeds really closed the space down. The midfield had a hard time finding an out ball, that is one reason why Bell coming on helped a lot, he made himself available & can hold the ball.

oakey · Feb 27, 2012

Keogh is player of the year and he has played well in most games, but he is over-praised for this, as he has been the best of a bad bunch.
I'm dreading the time he gets caught in possession and costs us a goal, which looks likely as he takes too many risks at times...many close shaves recently where he almost lost it but recovered well. He needs to keep it simple.
BTW, if it happens we will all make excuses for him

Nonleagueherewecome · Feb 27, 2012

Yeah, and I'm really angry with Murphy for that error he might make in the next few weeks, probably... and that sitter Alex is gonna miss against Palace...:thinking about:

covcity4life · Feb 28, 2012

Nonleagueherewecome said:
Yeah, and I'm really angry with Murphy for that error he might make in the next few weeks, probably... and that sitter Alex is gonna miss against Palace...:thinking about:

now you are WUMMING

you are trying to put words in peoples mouths to suit your own agenda

cut it out.

RATINGS FOLKS V Barnsley (1 Viewer)

Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Member

Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Jack Griffin

Guest

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency