Referee Analysis Barnsley (2 Viewers)

Johhny Blue · Apr 18, 2021

Good job we won but this ref was terrible.
Free kick against McFadz when he was fouled twice in a matter of seconds.
Bought lots of dives throughout the game
Throw ins (worth a thread) It’s getting farcical. He moved back one for each side but almost every throw gained 10-15 yds. It’s time to give refs the discretion to award the throw to the other team for blatent encroachment
Often out of position including one time off the field.
Good job he didn’t have to make any big decisions
Overall rating 4

robbiethemole · Apr 18, 2021

Lee Mason being Lee Mason

Frostie · Apr 18, 2021

Feared the worst when I saw in the week it was Lee Mason but wasn't as bad as feared, still not great though. His interpretation of advantages was utterly baffling.

stevefloyd · Apr 18, 2021

Its about time cheating players are punished...be it our players or opposition because its fucking rife now...thats not sport its see how much you can cheat and con the blind refs

skyblueeyesrevisited · Apr 18, 2021

Johhny Blue said:
Good job we won but this ref was terrible.
Free kick against McFadz when he was fouled twice in a matter of seconds.
Bought lots of dives throughout the game
Throw ins (worth a thread) It’s getting farcical. He moved back one for each side but almost every throw gained 10-15 yds. It’s time to give refs the discretion to award the throw to the other team for blatent encroachment
Often out of position including one time off the field.
Good job he didn’t have to make any big decisions
Overall rating 4

The irony is we scored the second goal after they stole 20 yards from the throw in.

shmmeee · Apr 18, 2021

stevefloyd said:
Its about time cheating players are punished...be it our players or opposition because its fucking rife now...thats not sport its see how much you can cheat and con the blind refs

Its sad that over the season I’ve started willing us to do it simply because it works against us so much. Teams have no choice but to do it or be at a disadvantage, refs need to be the ones stamping it out across the board.

Legia Sky Blue · Apr 18, 2021

Would have to re-visit our goal to see if we did steal the 20

Ignore this - misread the post by skyblueeyes revisited

Sick Boy · Apr 18, 2021

Their throws were getting more and more blatant as the game went on.

Johhny Blue · Apr 18, 2021

Sick Boy said:
Their throws were getting more and more blatant as the game went on.

“He’s not going to do anything let’s just keep pushing it”

kg82 · Apr 18, 2021

I actually thought Mason wasn’t too bad yesterday. Couple of things, but pretty minor.

Frostie · Apr 18, 2021

kg82 said:
I actually thought Mason wasn’t too bad yesterday.

Perhaps he wasn't but how about today?

wingy · Apr 18, 2021

Frostie said:
Perhaps he wasn't but how about today?

Not in HK.

kg82 · Apr 19, 2021

Frostie said:
Perhaps he wasn't but how about today?

I’m in Hong Kong mate! It was yesterday for me when I posted that!

Amcoventry · Apr 19, 2021

Shocking referee missed our 2nd goal being offside by 10 yards.

kg82 · Apr 19, 2021

Amcoventry said:
Shocking referee missed our 2nd goal being offside by 10 yards.

To be fair, that’s the lino’s job!

Magwitch1 · Apr 19, 2021

Is there ever a game where a finger can’t be pointed at the officials, I thought Lee Mason showed the difference between our normal refs and a top rated one, I thought he was anonymous but then again always up with play, managed the game well kept it flowing and not finneky of course as said we won’t agree with every decision for a start we see incidents usually from a different angle to him and we tend to come to an opinion with our Sky Blue specs on. Our second goal ? not seen a replay yet but off-side is usually a linesman decision.

Johhny Blue · Apr 19, 2021

Magwitch1 said:
Is there ever a game where a finger can’t be pointed at the officials, I thought Lee Mason showed the difference between our normal refs and a top rated one, I thought he was anonymous but then again always up with play, managed the game well kept it flowing and not finneky of course as said we won’t agree with every decision for a start we see incidents usually from a different angle to him and we tend to come to an opinion with our Sky Blue specs on. Our second goal ? not seen a replay yet but off-side is usually a linesman decision.

What did you think of the throw ins?

rhino1002 · Apr 19, 2021

there was a time when the law was changed to make taking a throw in from the wrong place a foul throw
but they all seemed to get bored with implementing that so it faded into obscurity
Equally referees and linesman (sorry assistant referees ) don't seem to enforce the foul throw law any more
i can watch any number of games when players lift one foot of the ground especially when throwing the a ball longer than normal
it never gets pulled up any more unless they have changed the law without me knowing

Nick · Apr 19, 2021

In terms of foul throws, can they throw it downwards now?

So many throws seem to be aimed downwards and I always thought it was a foul throw.

rhino1002 · Apr 19, 2021

Nick said:
In terms of foul throws, can they throw it downwards now?

So many throws seem to be aimed downwards and I always thought it was a foul throw.

No its yet another way they disregard the law
the player should be behind the line have both feet on the ground at the point of delivery and deliver the ball from above or behind the head line (not in front of the the head)

kg82 · Apr 19, 2021

rhino1002 said:
No its yet another way they disregard the law
the player should be behind the line (not on it) have both feet on the ground at the point of delivery and deliver the ball from above or behind the head line (not in front of the the head)

Didn’t they change that behind the line one? I’m sure I remember us scoring from a throw-in a couple seasons ago and the opposition fans going crazy because his foot was on the line. Someone then showed the rules and it turned out it was legal.

rhino1002 · Apr 19, 2021

kg82 said:
Didn’t they change that behind the line one? I’m sure I remember us scoring from a throw-in a couple seasons ago and the opposition fans going crazy because his foot was on the line. Someone then showed the rules and it turned out it was legal.

yes you are correct
the foot can be on the line but not over it

rhino1002 · Apr 19, 2021

its the foot of the ground that gets constantly missed though
it happens a few times in each game i watch

Magwitch1 · Apr 19, 2021

Johhny Blue said:
What did you think of the throw ins?

I was watching the game not throw ins, pinching yards at throw ins has gone on for years.

Deleted member 4439 · Apr 19, 2021

Frostie said:
Feared the worst when I saw in the week it was Lee Mason but wasn't as bad as feared, still not great though. His interpretation of advantages was utterly baffling.

Tbf, that one where one of our lot was fouled (can't remember who) and the advantage was to find ourselves with the ball on the touchline surrounded by 3 opposition players was a well-played advantage, for Barnsley.

Deleted member 4439 · Apr 19, 2021

Magwitch1 said:
I was watching the game not throw ins, pinching yards at throw ins has gone on for years.

It has, and we're no angels. But one or two of Barnsley's were taking the piss a bit.

Magwitch1 · Apr 19, 2021

One of their worst ones led to our second goal, football is a funny old game.

Frostie · Apr 19, 2021

dubed said:
Tbf, that one where one of our lot was fouled (can't remember who) and the advantage was to find ourselves with the ball on the touchline surrounded by 3 opposition players was a well-played advantage, for Barnsley.

Yep. O'Hare robbed their wing-back dallying on the ball & he cynically hauled him down, should have been a free kick & yellow card. Instead Biamou literally on the right touch line had to perform a fancy flick just to keep the ball in, retain possession & roll it back to O'Hare who was by then surrounded. Terrible decision.

Otis · Apr 20, 2021

Magwitch1 said:
I was watching the game not throw ins, pinching yards at throw ins has gone on for years.

It's gotten so much worse though. To ridiculous lengths. Never ever been as bad as it is now.

LilleSkyBlue · Apr 20, 2021

Amcoventry said:
Shocking referee missed our 2nd goal being offside by 10 yards.

Not sure it was ten yards but on watching it back Godden's surely, even on the most generous reading, level with their last man (but leaning offside) - though probably a clear couple of yards offside at the exact moment O'Hare lumps the ball forwards.

None of their players called for it either though.

Mcbean · Apr 20, 2021

Thought Fadz was pretty cool when he was thrown to the floor and had a foul awarded against him

thing is with the throw ins - who is going to take over when McCallum goes elsewhere - Barnsley couldn’t handle them

scottccfc · Apr 20, 2021

can see McCallum coming back on loan again next year now norwich have been promoted.

Sick Boy · Apr 20, 2021

Magwitch1 said:
I was watching the game not throw ins, pinching yards at throw ins has gone on for years.

They were more than pinching them...

Sick Boy · Apr 20, 2021

scottccfc said:
can see McCallum coming back on loan again next year now norwich have been promoted.

More likely he returns on a permanent as I doubt they’ve paid the full transfer fee yet.

Johhny Blue · Apr 20, 2021

scottccfc said:
can see McCallum coming back on loan again next year now norwich have been promoted.

Maybe he’ll stick around long enough for a testimonial

Referee Analysis Barnsley (2 Viewers)

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Super Moderator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Deleted member 4439

Guest

Deleted member 4439

Guest

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Super Moderator

Super Moderator

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency