Referee (3 Viewers)

Sky Blue Pete · Saturday at 11:10 PM

Nick said:
I assume he was bleeding.

The issue was it was a clear foul on him to cause it.

He was bleeding but safety is key
It’s added time
It’s 11 v 10 at the corner
It’s just such a silly decision to press
Far better for binks to go down and get treated
It was a clear push on him with the ref looking straight at it
I imagine he has some great games letting the game run but he’d try it and then decide to give a free kick for something he’d previously let go
Allen yellow
Eccles yellow
Both shocking decisions
On that show Kitching lucky not to be sent off after 5 mins

Nick · Saturday at 11:15 PM

Sky Blue Pete said:
He was bleeding but safety is key
It’s added time
It’s 11 v 10 at the corner
It’s just such a silly decision to press
Far better for binks to go down and get treated
It was a clear push on him with the ref looking straight at it
I imagine he has some great games letting the game run but he’d try it and then decide to give a free kick for something he’d previously let go
Allen yellow
Eccles yellow
Both shocking decisions
On that show Kitching lucky not to be sent off after 5 mins

It wasn't a sending off for kitching.

The ref was dog shit. Again.

If safety is key, you give fouls.

Terry Gibson's perm · Saturday at 11:16 PM

Nick said:
I assume he was bleeding.

The issue was it was a clear foul on him to cause it.

I thought it was a foul at the time by windass but haven’t seen it since

Nick · Saturday at 11:17 PM

Terry Gibson's perm said:
I thought it was a foul at the time by windass but haven’t seen it since

From what I remember he pushed him in the back with 2 hands but yeah would need to see it again

Sky Blue Pete · Saturday at 11:17 PM

Nick said:
From what I remember he pushed him in the back with 2 hands but yeah would need to see it again

That’s what happened

Frostie · Saturday at 11:36 PM

Sky Blue Pete said:
Yep no foul on keeper and clear foul on binks
Why he made him go off rather than getting treated on the pitch is beyond me
What was the issue with letting him be treated

He had to go off because he was bleeding. Regardless, even if he was treated on the pitch he'd have had to go off anyway. We didn't deal with that situation well at all.

jay2015 · Saturday at 11:37 PM

Hope the referee never does own game again he was shocking overtime theor fell over he give it you just knew Sheffield was going to get a goal

skyblue_55 · Saturday at 11:42 PM

I really don’t know what these ref’s have got against us , as the Norwich one was awful & now tonight’s ref ……it might be that we are too soft & don’t moan enough , but they are getting worse , as to not see the gamesmanship from these teams

David O'Day · Saturday at 11:56 PM

Let's see adge defend that

Sent from my SM-G991B using Tapatalk

David O'Day · Saturday at 11:57 PM

pusbccfc said:
Ref tonight

Thought he was excellent

www.owlstalk.co.uk

'Thought he was excellent'.

Love it

They have season tickets near him ti be fair

Sent from my SM-G991B using Tapatalk

zuni · Sunday at 12:08 AM

Ref was a fart particle, needs looking into

David O'Day · Sunday at 12:12 AM

the ref was probably the worst i have seen in a good few years

shocked he didn't try and say Dovin was off his line

MusicDating · Sunday at 12:36 AM

Sky Blue Pete said:
That’s what happened

Windass pushes Binks and he catches Thomas's boot

Sky Blue Pete · Sunday at 7:07 AM

MusicDating said:
Windass pushes Binks and he catches Thomas's boot

Yep
Clear as day
Ref had perfect view
Decided not to give it

Adge · Sunday at 10:41 AM

Frostie said:
He had to go off because he was bleeding. Regardless, even if he was treated on the pitch he'd have had to go off anyway. We didn't deal with that situation well at all.

This. Has to go off if bleeding/cut. Head injury assessment aswell into the mix.

MalcSB · Sunday at 10:45 AM

Adge said:
This. Has to go off if bleeding/cut. Head injury assessment aswell into the mix.

The real issue is the failure to give a free kick for the foul then, not Binks being told to leave the field of play?

Alternatively perhaps should have subbed someone on for him.

Sky Blue Pete · Sunday at 11:13 AM

MalcSB said:
The real issue is the failure to give a free kick for the foul then, not Binks being told to leave the field of play?

Alternatively perhaps should have subbed someone on for him.

He went off not long into extra time

Potbellypig · Sunday at 5:11 PM

Ref dreadful last night, ref dreadful in the Tamworth/Spurs game today, ref dreadful in the Arsenal/Man Utd game. Refs just seem to be getting worse and worse. Surely they can't all be dreadful and while it'll never happen, maybe it's time to look at simplifying the rules to make it easier to ref.

Sky Blue Pete · Sunday at 5:16 PM

Potbellypig said:
Ref dreadful last night, ref dreadful in the Tamworth/Spurs game today, ref dreadful in the Arsenal/Man Utd game. Refs just seem to be getting worse and worse. Surely they can't all be dreadful and while it'll never happen, maybe it's time to look at simplifying the rules to make it easier to ref.

It would help if players didn’t cheat

Warwickhunt · Sunday at 5:34 PM

Sky Blue Pete said:
He was bleeding but safety is key
It’s added time
It’s 11 v 10 at the corner
It’s just such a silly decision to press
Far better for binks to go down and get treated
It was a clear push on him with the ref looking straight at it
I imagine he has some great games letting the game run but he’d try it and then decide to give a free kick for something he’d previously let go
Allen yellow
Eccles yellow
Both shocking decisions
On that show Kitching lucky not to be sent off after 5 mins

He was wrong to make Binks get up and go off before the trainers could make a concussion review.

Warwickhunt · Sunday at 5:35 PM

Potbellypig said:
Ref dreadful last night, ref dreadful in the Tamworth/Spurs game today, ref dreadful in the Arsenal/Man Utd game. Refs just seem to be getting worse and worse. Surely they can't all be dreadful and while it'll never happen, maybe it's time to look at simplifying the rules to make it easier to ref.

Too many Refs havecthe opinion that they make the rules as they see fit if you ask me

Nuskyblue · Sunday at 5:39 PM

Skybluekyle said:
One of those, is it really a foul? Probably not. Are they given every game, including today? Yes

For that reason, the referee should have given the foul.

Agree 100% on this.

Nuskyblue · Sunday at 5:47 PM

jim20 said:
And I think that’s what partly needs to change, they won’t improve if they can’t be challenged or questioned

They need to simplify matters, the laws are so convoluted now it's no surprise that we are seeing what we see now.

Nick · Sunday at 7:08 PM

Adge said:
This. Has to go off if bleeding/cut. Head injury assessment aswell into the mix.

The issue was the clear foul missed that caused the injury.

Nick · Sunday at 7:09 PM

Sky Blue Pete said:
It would help if players didn’t cheat

Probably do it because refs are so poor

Sky Blue Pete · Sunday at 7:15 PM

Nick said:
Probably do it because refs are so poor

The needle returns to the start of the song

Sky Blue Pete · Sunday at 7:15 PM

Warwickhunt said:
Too many Refs havecthe opinion that they make the rules as they see fit if you ask me

That’s exactly what the laws say

Skyblue Bangkok · Sunday at 7:24 PM

Nick said:
Probably do it because refs are so poor

Players cheating or mangers encouraging it has nothing to do with refs

Nick · Sunday at 7:25 PM

You only have to see the posters on here who ref or know refs to see they think it's everybody else's fault.

Adge · Sunday at 7:27 PM

Nick said:
The issue was the clear foul missed that caused the injury.

I didn’t see that but for those who are still thinking he was wrong to ask Binks to leave the field of play-

In relation to the management of injuries, the Referee should also:

- Ensure that any bleeding player, or a player with blood on their playing equipment, should leave the field of play. The player should only return after a signal from the Referee and when they have stopped bleeding and have no blood on their equipment.

Sky Blue Pete · Sunday at 7:30 PM

Adge said:
I didn’t see that but for those who are still thinking he was wrong to ask Binks to leave the field of play-

In relation to the management of injuries, the Referee should also:

- Ensure that any bleeding player, or a player with blood on their playing equipment, should leave the field of play. The player should only return after a signal from the Referee and when they have stopped bleeding and have no blood on their equipment.

It’s just the advantage that it gave them from the corner
Explained better and Lampard has the option of a change

Nick · Sunday at 7:32 PM

Adge said:
I didn’t see that but for those who are still thinking he was wrong to ask Binks to leave the field of play-

In relation to the management of injuries, the Referee should also:

- Ensure that any bleeding player, or a player with blood on their playing equipment, should leave the field of play. The player should only return after a signal from the Referee and when they have stopped bleeding and have no blood on their equipment.

Course you didn't see it, you're a ref.

The issue was, it was a clear foul. He didn't give it and made our player go off while we defended when it should have been a free kick to us.

Quote the rules all you want

blunted · Sunday at 7:35 PM

Ref got worse as the game went on. Almost as if he wanted extra time. Do they get paid more?
That said, we should have managed the game better. Spurs, Norwich and Sheff Wed, we have managed to throw away two and nearly three.

AJB1983 · Sunday at 7:40 PM

Again for me, it’s the inconsistency. Last night and Tamworth today as an example.
there doesn’t appear to be any differences between certain incidents yet one is a free kick and one isn’t?

I just don’t know what’s a foul now and what isn’t. Last night it just felt like every time a SW player went down for certain things it was a foul but if it was us it wasn’t.

Tamworth today - their player gets barged off ball outside box - no foul. Spurs go up other end - Son receives similar and it’s a free kick from which they scored.

Adge · Sunday at 7:46 PM

Jeez! Tar us all with the same brush!
I quoted the laws of the game on the basis that he was right to send Binks off the field as he had a cut/head injury and that IS correct.
Were we disadvantaged on that basis-YES!
Was that the referees doing-NO, as he correctly applied the laws of the game.
Was the cut on Binks a result of a foul before that?, you are saying yes but I can’t comment as didn’t see it.
Just for clarification, if the foul was awarded in Binks favour, he still would have had to leave the pitch.

Referee (3 Viewers)

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Euro 2016 Prediction League Champion!!

Attachments

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency