Reinvesting money (1 Viewer)

speedie87

Well-Known Member
We aren’t very good at this are we? Can anyone think of forwards we have sold for big money and then spent the money on replacements who were better

Robbie Keane - Bellamy
Mcsheffrey - Mckenzie and kyle
Mcnulty - Baka /Chaplin
 

Otis

Well-Known Member
We aren’t very good at this are we? Can anyone think of forwards we have sold for big money and then spent the money on replacements who were better

Robbie Keane - Bellamy
Mcsheffrey - Mckenzie and kyle
Mcnulty - Baka /Chaplin
The bloke before Clarrie Bourton - Clarrie Bourton
 

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
We aren’t very good at this are we? Can anyone think of forwards we have sold for big money and then spent the money on replacements who were better

Robbie Keane - Bellamy
Mcsheffrey - Mckenzie and kyle
Mcnulty - Baka /Chaplin

Suspect it's because we don't get money to spend that often so when we do we blow it on the first player the 'recruitment team' comes back with.
 

Frank Sidebottom

Well-Known Member
We aren’t very good at this are we? Can anyone think of forwards we have sold for big money and then spent the money on replacements who were better

Robbie Keane - Bellamy
Mcsheffrey - Mckenzie and kyle
Mcnulty - Baka /Chaplin

Very difficult to buy a better player than we've sold.... if the player we bring in is better then the club buying our player would've bought that player instead..... were we really expecting Baka/Chaplin/Hiwula to be better than McNulty? If they were then why would Reading not have signed them instead? We've signed 3 younger players and if we're lucky one of them will turn out to be decent for a season and then we will sell them. Repeat until we're top of the Premier League, triple European champions with millions of fans all over the world.
 

Sky_Blue_Dreamer

Well-Known Member
Not really big money but we sold Paul Furlong and brought in Mick Quinn.

We also sold Mick Harford and John Gayle and brought in Dublin, but he was far more expensive and needed the sale of Babb. Selling Huckerby to bring in Keane/Rousell (although again aided by the Boateng sale) and Rousell for Hartson?

Since relegation though nothing, although most of the sales have been swallowed up by running costs rather than reinvesting in the team so not surprising.

I did think maybe we'd sold George Thomas and brought in McNulty, but having checked we brought in Yakubu and Beavon in that window while McNulty joined 6 months later.
 

oucho

Well-Known Member
That was the start of the rot.
Don't forget we also didn't replace Gunnarson and Turner that summer. Westwood and King also left and we didn't have budget for "like for like" replacements. Joe Murphy was a sufficient replacement for Westie although didn't catch enough balls. Cody Mac never threatened to have the impact King had for us.
 

Razzle Dazzle Dean Gordon

Well-Known Member
We aren’t very good at this are we? Can anyone think of forwards we have sold for big money and then spent the money on replacements who were better

Robbie Keane - Bellamy
Mcsheffrey - Mckenzie and kyle
Mcnulty - Baka /Chaplin

I think we took a big risk on Bellamy given his injury, he ultimately showed himself to be a good player (and total twat) but probably needed his season with us to get fit and used to PL level. Could you class Keane as being signed with the money from Dublin? If not then I think I'm struggling to come up with an example!
 

mark82

Super Moderator
Not really big money but we sold Paul Furlong and brought in Mick Quinn.

We also sold Mick Harford and John Gayle and brought in Dublin, but he was far more expensive and needed the sale of Babb. Selling Huckerby to bring in Keane/Rousell (although again aided by the Boateng sale) and Rousell for Hartson?

Since relegation though nothing, although most of the sales have been swallowed up by running costs rather than reinvesting in the team so not surprising.

I did think maybe we'd sold George Thomas and brought in McNulty, but having checked we brought in Yakubu and Beavon in that window while McNulty joined 6 months later.

Thomas left the same window we brought McNulty in.
 

Esoterica

Well-Known Member
Not really big money but we sold Paul Furlong and brought in Mick Quinn.

We also sold Mick Harford and John Gayle and brought in Dublin, but he was far more expensive and needed the sale of Babb. Selling Huckerby to bring in Keane/Rousell (although again aided by the Boateng sale) and Rousell for Hartson?

Since relegation though nothing, although most of the sales have been swallowed up by running costs rather than reinvesting in the team so not surprising.

I did think maybe we'd sold George Thomas and brought in McNulty, but having checked we brought in Yakubu and Beavon in that window while McNulty joined 6 months later.
And Beavon was part of the deal for selling our top scorer Sordell I think?
 

cc84cov

Well-Known Member
I think we took a big risk on Bellamy given his injury, he ultimately showed himself to be a good player (and total twat) but probably needed his season with us to get fit and used to PL level. Could you class Keane as being signed with the money from Dublin? If not then I think I'm struggling to come up with an example!
I’m sure Keane come as replacement from Huckerby could be wrong tho.
 

ajsccfc

Well-Known Member
Not long after we sold Wilson, Tudgay came in for a free. Not only did we save a stack of cash I'd argue we got a hell of an upgrade while at it.
 

skybluegod

Well-Known Member
Not really big money but we sold Paul Furlong and brought in Mick Quinn.

We also sold Mick Harford and John Gayle and brought in Dublin, but he was far more expensive and needed the sale of Babb. Selling Huckerby to bring in Keane/Rousell (although again aided by the Boateng sale) and Rousell for Hartson?

Since relegation though nothing, although most of the sales have been swallowed up by running costs rather than reinvesting in the team so not surprising.

I did think maybe we'd sold George Thomas and brought in McNulty, but having checked we brought in Yakubu and Beavon in that window while McNulty joined 6 months later.

I thought we had got compensation for Thomas in summer last year and that was probably used to get Mcnulty- ie. larger wages.
 

ceetee

Well-Known Member
Callum Wilson - Nobody
Nobody replaced Jutkiewic when he left, but Callum Wilson was the "nobody" who replaced him the following season.
i remember the criticism by fans complaining that the club were relying on an Academy graduate...
 

SkyBlueCRJ

Well-Known Member
Nobody replaced Jutkiewic when he left, but Callum Wilson was the "nobody" who replaced him the following season.
i remember the criticism by fans complaining that the club were relying on an Academy graduate...

Imagine the moaning when Callum Wilson and Leon Clarke were replaced with Shaun Miller, Marcus Tudgay and Simeon Jackon
 

Ashdown

Well-Known Member
Very difficult to buy a better player than we've sold.... if the player we bring in is better then the club buying our player would've bought that player instead..... were we really expecting Baka/Chaplin/Hiwula to be better than McNulty? If they were then why would Reading not have signed them instead? We've signed 3 younger players and if we're lucky one of them will turn out to be decent for a season and then we will sell them. Repeat until we're top of the Premier League, triple European champions with millions of fans all over the world.
I wouldn't bank on any of these three lame ducks.
 

Ashdown

Well-Known Member
I thought Keane was bought by a consortium of crooked board members for £6 million and sold to inter Milan for £13 million in a private arrangement ?! Or did I dream that ?
 

skyblueeyesrevisited

Well-Known Member
I thought Keane was bought by a consortium of crooked board members for £6 million and sold to inter Milan for £13 million in a private arrangement ?! Or did I dream that ?
Yes that is my understanding. Remember Strachan saying he knew nothing about it until the chairman phoned him to say he’d just bought Robbie Keane.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top