Ricketts or Slade ?. (1 Viewer)

[rupert_bear]

Thought I would post this before the Wimbledon match. Defeat I believe would put relegation almost certain that's if it isn't already. Russell Slade has made no difference since he joined not won a league match and produced some atrocious football, add to that his signings apart from Beavon none have proved better than what we had. As I see it there's little or no future here for Russell Slade. So where do we go ? Limp along until May or act now remove Slade and bring in another, that brings me to Sam Ricketts, yes I know all about he has no managerial experience but he is young, played at all levels of pro football and he's here now, knows the players most of whom will need replacing. Let's give him from now until May see what he can offer, has to be a better option than what we are getting currently incidently from a manager with so called management experience !

I know we see ourselves as a "big" club but we are what we are now, a soon to be FOURTH division outfit we fans must grasp that reality.

 

---

[vow]

I have certainly never thought of us a "big" club in all my years supporting us, my feet are firmly on the ground regarding where you're at is where you belong.
I also think Slade will turn it around with players coming back for injury, suspensions etc.

perhaps it will be too late, but I think our form will pick up from now to the end of season.

 

[stevefloyd]

Whats this hobsons choice

 

[Warwickhunt]

Whats this hobsons choice

Used to play for Nottingham Forest :joyful:

 

[higgs]

Thought I would post this before the Wimbledon match. Defeat I believe would put relegation almost certain that's if it isn't already. Russell Slade has made no difference since he joined not won a league match and produced some atrocious football, add to that his signings apart from Beavon none have proved better than what we had. As I see it there's little or no future here for Russell Slade. So where do we go ? Limp along until May or act now remove Slade and bring in another, that brings me to Sam Ricketts, yes I know all about he has no managerial experience but he is young, played at all levels of pro football and he's here now, knows the players most of whom will need replacing. Let's give him from now until May see what he can offer, has to be a better option than what we are getting currently incidently from a manager with so called management experience !

I know we see ourselves as a "big" club but we are what we are now, a soon to be FOURTH division outfit we fans must grasp that reality.

Ricketts wasn't a leader as captain for us I certainly wouldn't see him as an inspiring manager. If slade does go we need an experienced manager for our league two promotion campaign

Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk

 

[Otis]

Slade was an experienced manager though for our League One campaign.

With managers it is not always about being leaders as players.

What about Terry Butcher? Gary McAllister, Bryan Robson, Bobby Moore, Bobby Charlton etc.

Means nowt in the grand scheme of things unfortunately.

 

[Deleted member 5849]

Once again we write a manager off after, what, a month and a half?

We write a manager off who has a track record of getting failing clubs, such as Grimsby, Orient, Yeovil... going in the right direction.

What does this say about *our* club?

Why do we always, *always* fall into the trap of deciding changing the manager will solve everything? All that does is let off those who create the conditions for a manager to fail.

 

[Esoterica]

Whats this hobsons choice

I wish it was Hobknobs choice, then we'd at least end up with a biscuit.

 

[steve82]

I didn't rate Ricketts as a player in his time here and theres nothing to suggest he could motivate this current playing squad.
If Sam Ricketts is already the man pencilled in as our manager already then I'm sure RS would walk away in a month or so if he got wind this was the case and all parties likely agree its best for the club. Ricketts gets games to slip up in and try and get momentum himself and RS does not quite get a first relegation tarnishing his cv.
I do however think that RS if given the summer to build a team with the amount of contract players we have he could assemble a team of players who would be competitive for the level of football we'd be at. A team far from what we have currently who's not fit for the league and has too many weak links in most areas and mental strength.
The brand of football ain't pretty but it will be be needed next season.
Ultimate question is could Ricketts stop the individual errors? The man made them weekly himself last season.

 

[shmmeee]

Let Slade have the rest of the season unless we find the guy who is going to be given time and resources to rebuild the club in his image.

Really don't understand why Ricketts is suddenly the great hope of CCFC. He's done literally nothing as a manager.

 

[rupert_bear]

Our fans will not accept his style of football

 

[steve82]

Our fans will not accept his style of football

In the current state your right, but I'm sure a few would be excepting of it if was winning games. (...I'm talking next season now )
It will be very tough to play proper neat tidy football on the deck come December January February next season at some grounds.

 

[oucho]

Why Ricketts? Is there anything to suggest he is even still with us in some sort of coaching role?

 

[Grendel]

Once again we write a manager off after, what, a month and a half?

We write a manager off who has a track record of getting failing clubs, such as Grimsby, Orient, Yeovil... going in the right direction.

What does this say about *our* club?

Why do we always, *always* fall into the trap of deciding changing the manager will solve everything? All that does is let off those who create the conditions for a manager to fail.

It says we act like other clubs.

I personally think if we kept Andy Thorn we'd have gone downhill quicker then we have now. Adams and Boothroyd both had the "Captain Mainwarring (ha ha)" syndrome - little men who tried to impose their will and had to go, Dowie had won 2 in 16 - what do you do when you know from history once he fails he fails.

Managers when they hit a slump rarely turn things round or show signs they will. Most have no flexibility and are very stubborn in their outlook. Obviously I do not believe that you sack Slade after a few weeks - he is caught in the crossfire of discontent - but perhaps by the nature of the job football management is a short term job. People will always quote the exceptions - and its the same names - as they are exceptions. Or the club in question is happy with the status quo. Paul Tisdale has been in charge for over 500 games with a record thats hardly any different to most of the managers you have listed - and hasn't won anything for 7 years

 

[Grendel]

Let Slade have the rest of the season unless we find the guy who is going to be given time and resources to rebuild the club in his image.

Really don't understand why Ricketts is suddenly the great hope of CCFC. He's done literally nothing as a manager.

Nor has Slade to be fair

 

[steve82]

Why Ricketts? Is there anything to suggest he is even still with us in some sort of coaching role?

It's a good question, whys he still here? He would of had a playing contract and as soon as he said I'm retired that would be void.
So he's not a over paid ball boy that helps in the warm ups before games, surely he's not even on the payroll now.
Ask yourself why he's here......

 

[Deleted member 5849]

It says we act like other clubs.

Most clubs fail, however.

I'd still argue Exeter are a damned site better off under Tisdale then if they'd rushed to sack him. At a higher level, there's a very real risk for Arsenal that they don't appreciate how good they have it now.

If we *must* sack managers, we need to have the confidence in the overall strategy to employ similar. We jump from type to type, with no thought to the long term. Pressley was building a youth system, but then his replacement went for loans ahead of all else. Now we have a bloke who's desperately short term, and completeky opposed to Mowbray in philosophy.

So how does a club build and grow, when it doesn't know what it's supposed to be doing?

 

[Grendel]

Most clubs fail, however.

I'd still argue Exeter are a damned site better off under Tisdale then if they'd rushed to sack him. At a higher level, there's a very real risk for Arsenal that they don't appreciate how good they have it now.

If we *must* sack managers, we need to have the confidence in the overall strategy to employ similar. We jump from type to type, with no thought to the long term. Pressley was building a youth system, but then his replacement went for loans ahead of all else. Now we have a bloke who's desperately short term, and completeky opposed to Mowbray in philosophy.

So how does a club build and grow, when it doesn't know what it's supposed to be doing?

Supporters expect success - if you own a business and the guy mainly in charge of revenue is failing and revenue is collapsing he goes.

Football is short term. Works the other way as well. If Mowbray was successful he'd have had an offer like robins and gone.

No structure will be the same unless you bring an apprentice in to replace the manager, we've tried that and it didn't work.

 

[oucho]

It's a good question, whys he still here? He would of had a playing contract and as soon as he said I'm retired that would be void.
So he's not a over paid ball boy that helps in the warm ups before games, surely he's not even on the payroll now.
Ask yourself why he's here......

My question, though, is....IS he still here?????

 

[steve82]

My question, though, is....IS he still here?????

Yes.
He helps warms up players on a match day. Collects the balls and cones in prior to kick off

 

[oucho]

Yes.
He helps warms up players on a match day. Collects the balls and cones in prior to kick off

OK didn't realise that (generally don't get into the ground until 2.59 on a Sat!).

Sounds like he is eminently qualified to be manager!

 

[CovBurty]

Slade is only here til end of season, let him do his worst. Rickets would be a gamble next season in div2. Easy option for Sisu is get him signed up cheap and then bring in a decent manager when he eventually starts to fail. Sisu classic history. Yes this my first post and I'm very angry atm. So angry I'm refusing a Wembley trip whilst we are facing the drop. My choice.

 

[Captain Dart]

Neither, I'd much rather Andy Morrell or John Eustace . Basically a manager with a few successful seasons at a lower level & maybe with a link to the club.

 

[steve82]

Neither, I'd much rather Andy Morrell or John Eustace . Basically a manager with a few successful seasons at a lower level & maybe with a link to the club.

John Eustace is a non starter for me along with Ricketts. Eustace has only been manager of Kidderminster barely a year.
Andy Morrell on the other has done a respectable job at Tamworth the last few years. It's a big step up tho currently from national league north.

 

[scottccfc]

I'd rather give it mo Konjic than ricketts

 

[skybluetony176]

Neither, I'd much rather Andy Morrell or John Eustace . Basically a manager with a few successful seasons at a lower level & maybe with a link to the club.

Eustace wouldn't be the worst idea. 66% win record at Kidderminster and his contract is up at the end of the season.