Starting side (1 Viewer)

covboy9

Well-Known Member
what team would we go with if all the loans went back to their clubs????
 

Otis

Well-Known Member
Worries me too. You have 4 flair players in there, 3 of which who are quite notorious for their lack of good engines and fight and battle.

Think that side would get walked all over every day of the week.

Too many flair players. More steel needed.
 

stupot07

Well-Known Member
Worries me too. You have 4 flair players in there, 3 of which who are quite notorious for their lack of good engines and fight and battle.

Think that side would get walked all over every day of the week.

Too many flair players. More steel needed.

Yeah and that McDonald doesn't really hold the ball up to bring other players in to play.

But what do I know I'm a sad sad man and a gimmick poster...
 

skybluegod

Well-Known Member
easy
----------murphy----------
christie---wood--edge---hussey
------jennings----barton
baker-------moussa---sheffers
----------cody---------------

maybe fleck in for sheffers
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
Very good team

What planet are you on? That is effectivelt the team that didn't win in the first 7 games. It is awful and has bottom 6 written all over it.
 

dongonzalos

Well-Known Member
What planet are you on? That is effectivelt the team that didn't win in the first 7 games. It is awful and has bottom 6 written all over it.

One bad result in the first three.

As you are fully aware, I don't believe in the coincidence that you do regarding the following 5 defeats.

It is not a coincidence that those defeats followed the interim period of the sacking of the manager and putting in place a new one.
 
Last edited:

SkyBlue_Bear83

Well-Known Member
-------------Murphy
Christie--Edge--Wood--Hussey
Baker-----Thomas--Jennings--Mcsheff
-----------------Moussa
-----------------Elliott
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
Murphy
Christie Wood Edj Hussey
Jennings Barton
Baker Fleck Moussa
Cody

I think Bailey will sign on a perm. I hope McG does, that would be awesome!

That is a good team IMHO, Thomas in for Barton at DM, with AB and JF fighting it out for AMC.

Moussa's best position for us is LM easy.
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
One bad result in the first three.

As you are fully aware, I don't believe in the coincidence that you do regarding the following 5 defeats.

It is not coincidence that those defeats followed the interim period of the sacking of the manager and putting in place a new one.

No wins in 8 OK there is this team;

Murphy

Christie Wood Cameron Hussey

Jennings Barton

Baker Fleck Mcsheff

McDonald

And there is the team that played last night which includes Bailey, Adams, McGoldrick and Moussa.

If these two teams played each other who would win?
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
Murphy
Christie Wood Edj Hussey
Jennings Barton
Baker Fleck Moussa
Cody

I think Bailey will sign on a perm. I hope McG does, that would be awesome!

That is a good team IMHO, Thomas in for Barton at DM, with AB and JF fighting it out for AMC.

Moussa's best position for us is LM easy.

Bottom 6 at best as the team would score very few goals. Also with lightweights like Fleck and Barton it would be hopelessly outfought in midfield.

Anyone who seriously thinks McDonald can play upfront on his own is seriously deluded I am afraid.

McDonald is garbage.
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
Bottom 6 at best as the team would score very few goals. Also with lightweights like Fleck and Barton it would be hopelessly outfought in midfield.

Anyone who seriously thinks McDonald can play upfront on his own is seriously deluded I am afraid.

McDonald is garbage.

Bar McG... Our best option upfront!
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
Bar McG... Our best option upfront!

And that says why we are poor without him.

Robins I suspect actually now considers O Donovan as a better choice. I would be surprised if McDonald is here after January providing we find someone to take him.

If he does play there is no way he can be on his own. He has no strength, is very poor at bringing players into the game and lacks pace. He has been a huge disappointment and why some fans still back him defies any evidence or logic.
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
And that says why we are poor without him.

Robins I suspect actually now considers O Donovan as a better choice. I would be surprised if McDonald is here after January providing we find someone to take him.

If he does play there is no way he can be on his own. He has no strength, is very poor at bringing players into the game and lacks pace. He has been a huge disappointment and why some fans still back him defies any evidence or logic.

IMO, he could do a job, but I'm not sure if he can do it on his own, I rate him, better than Ball, Elliott, ROD etc. but he needs to be given chances, which cannot be guaranteed whereas McG can create a chance on his own - and score. Cody IMO, is a L1 standard Javier Hernandez.
 

dongonzalos

Well-Known Member
No wins in 8 OK there is this team;

Murphy

Christie Wood Cameron Hussey

Jennings Barton

Baker Fleck Mcsheff

McDonald

And there is the team that played last night which includes Bailey, Adams, McGoldrick and Moussa.

If these two teams played each other who would win?

Probably the second team.

That does not mean the first team are not a very good team, it just means the second team are better. Mainly in my opinion because of DMC.

However I don't think the first team would have lost those games with the off field crap going on.
 

dongonzalos

Well-Known Member
IMO, he could do a job, but I'm not sure if he can do it on his own, I rate him, better than Ball, Elliott, ROD etc. but he needs to be given chances, which cannot be guaranteed whereas McG can create a chance on his own - and score. Cody IMO, is a L1 standard Javier Hernandez.

He has to play alongside DMC in the build up to January in case DMC goes.
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
Probably the second team.

That does not mean the first team are not a very good team, it just means the second team are better. Mainly in my opinion because of DMC.

However I don't think the first team would have lost those games with the off field crap going on.

That team would lose more than it wins. Barton as a holding midfielder is not an attractive prospect and we would struggle to average one goal a game.
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
He has to play alongside DMC in the build up to January in case DMC goes.

I agree, we need to bring in one of our strikers into the team via sub bench or start so they can build confidence/have an idea post McG, if he doesn't sign.
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
I agree, we need to bring in one of our strikers into the team via sub bench or start so they can build confidence/have an idea post McG, if he doesn't sign.

McDonald is likely to go in January.
 

Astute

Well-Known Member
I can't see that happening, I imagine he'll stick with the 4251 formation that just won 2 away games in a row.

Will we have that many players if all the loans go back?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top