Strongest 11 after 6 games (1 Viewer)

ms639 · Oct 21, 2020

So McCallum got his first championship start last night and looked absolutely quality. Assured on the ball, strong when under pressure and a fantastic outlet as we played on the counter. The goal obviously came down his flank but the reality is if you play the wing backs high then it's always a risk, bit of quality from Ayew not unexpected!

For me we have to be looking at McCallum at LWB and Dabo at RWB when fit, gives us a big threat going forwards and I think McCallum gives us more defensively than Giles.

After Sheaf's performance last night I think we have 3 strong CM options in Sheaf, Hamer and Kelly and I think those 3 could work interchangeably

Unfortunately despite his goal I think Shippers has looked a bit out of his depth at this level, and would quite like to see Ryan Giles alongside O'hare behind Godden, Giles looks like a class act further up the pitch but think he's shakey defensively. My starting 11 below, thoughts?

Marko

Rose, Fadz, Hyam
Dabo McCallum
Kelly / Sheaf, Hamer,

O'hare Giles

Le God

stevefloyd · Oct 21, 2020

I think Wolves would have to agree playing their left back out of position first

curly_tom · Oct 21, 2020

Shipley was not out of his depth last night. He played well. Maybe not a starter every game but an important part of the squad...

shmmeee · Oct 21, 2020

Don’t agree on Shipley at all.

Yorkshire SB · Oct 21, 2020

stevefloyd said:
I think Wolves would have to agree playing their left back out of position first

Not exactly unheard of though is it? Turning an attacking full back to midfielder. We also have no pace up top, so I can see why the suggestion is made

shmmeee · Oct 21, 2020

Yorkshire SB said:
Not exactly unheard of though is it? Turning an attacking full back to midfielder. We also have no pace up top, so I can see why the suggestion is made

i think the point is he’s a winger in the process of being turned into a WB by Wolves.

Yorkshire SB · Oct 21, 2020

shmmeee said:
i think the point is he’s a winger in the process of being turned into a WB by Wolves.

Surely our prerogative to play him where we want to. Alternative is he doesn’t play, or shares a lot of minutes with McCallum

kg82 · Oct 21, 2020

I only saw the last 20 mins last night (I’m 7 hours ahead where I am) but in that time Allen looked fantastic. He was all over the place, picking up loose balls, taking on a man, playing decent balls into decent areas. To me, just on that 20 minutes, it looked like he’s adjusting to the pace and intensity of the league.

rob9872 · Oct 21, 2020

I think it won't be long before Walker replaces Godden. A few games without a goal now and whether you agree or not with the decision he's not spent that much on Walker not to play, so unless we change our formation I think he has to score against Blackburn.

David O'Day · Oct 21, 2020

drop Giles? nah

mr_monkey · Oct 21, 2020

David O'Day said:
drop Giles? nah

No he is playing giles at cam because he is an idiot

ms639 · Oct 21, 2020

kg82 said:
I only saw the last 20 mins last night (I’m 7 hours ahead where I am) but in that time Allen looked fantastic. He was all over the place, picking up loose balls, taking on a man, playing decent balls into decent areas. To me, just on that 20 minutes, it looked like he’s adjusting to the pace and intensity of the league.

He was very good last 15, can’t disagree but that was his good spell.

I think he causes sides problems towards the end of the game, would like to see him off the bench for impact

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

ms639 · Oct 21, 2020

mr_monkey said:
No he is playing giles at cam because he is an idiot

Yeah it’s mad to suggest an attacking wing back moving to an attacking midfield role, like that’s never happened before

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

KersleyDigs · Oct 21, 2020

Marosi
Rose McFadzean Hyam
Dabo Kelly Hamer McCallum
Shipley O'Hare
Godden

Sheaf was much improved last night so will push and I hope Tyler Walker starts to get some opportunity and push on

David O'Day · Oct 21, 2020

ms639 said:
Yeah it’s mad to suggest an attacking wing back moving to an attacking midfield role, like that’s never happened before

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

It's normally the other way round

mr_monkey · Oct 21, 2020

ms639 said:
Yeah it’s mad to suggest an attacking wing back moving to an attacking midfield role, like that’s never happened before

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yep it really is he is a winger turned into a wingback and is doing bloody well this season I don't get the hate at all, I suppose some people always need a scapegoat

ms639 · Oct 21, 2020

mr_monkey said:
Yep it really is
he is a winger turned into a wingback and is doing bloody well this season I don't get the hate at all, I suppose some people always need a scapegoat

How am I giving the bloke ‘hate’?

. I’m saying he’s been better going forward than he has defensively. Do you think Giles should play over mccallum in that LWB position?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

mr_monkey · Oct 21, 2020

ms639 said:
How am I giving the bloke ‘hate’?
. I’m saying he’s been better going forward than he has defensively. Do you think Giles should play over mccallum in that LWB position?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

It's Giles' shirt to lose and so far he has done nothing to deserve to lose it so yes I'd play Giles ahead of Mccallum at the moment

David O'Day · Oct 21, 2020

ms639 said:
How am I giving the bloke ‘hate’?
. I’m saying he’s been better going forward than he has defensively. Do you think Giles should play over mccallum in that LWB position?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

yes

torchomatic · Oct 21, 2020

kg82 said:
I only saw the last 20 mins last night (I’m 7 hours ahead where I am) but in that time Allen looked fantastic. He was all over the place, picking up loose balls, taking on a man, playing decent balls into decent areas. To me, just on that 20 minutes, it looked like he’s adjusting to the pace and intensity of the league.

He had a really good game. Has looked decidedly average until last night.

Jamesimus · Oct 21, 2020

kg82 said:
I only saw the last 20 mins last night (I’m 7 hours ahead where I am) but in that time Allen looked fantastic. He was all over the place, picking up loose balls, taking on a man, playing decent balls into decent areas. To me, just on that 20 minutes, it looked like he’s adjusting to the pace and intensity of the league.

He got moved further forward when Kelly came on in place of Shipley and he is defo better in that attacking position rather than deeper / defensive mid one.

Also, it seems to me like his fitness has improved a lot.

mr_monkey · Oct 21, 2020

Jamesimus said:
He got moved further forward when Kelly came on in place of Shipley and he is defo better in that attacking position rather than deeper / defensive mid one.

Also, it seems to me like his fitness has improved a lot.

It's almost like we hadnt played competitive football for almost 6 months and the players needed to get their match fitness up....

Jamesimus · Oct 21, 2020

mr_monkey said:
It's almost like we hadnt played competitive football for almost 6 months and the players needed to get their match fitness up....

Ha yeah there is this! Seems more naturally athletic than Godden and Shipley.

Terry_dactyl · Oct 21, 2020

torchomatic said:
He had a really good game. Has looked decidedly average until last night.

Took his ‘goal’ really well. Was it godden offside? If it was, I thought it was a bit silly that he was.

superskyblue · Oct 21, 2020

Ideally we'd probably try and fit Hamer, Sheaf and Kelly into the first choice team. Given attacking midfield is one of the weaker spots with Allen/Shipley not entirely convincing so far, I wonder if we might change shape.

If I was MR I'd be trying to find a way to get all 3 CMs on the pitch at the same time.

Yorkshire SB · Oct 21, 2020

I think before too long we’ll realise we need more going forward. Hopefully Walker is going to offer a lot, as we can’t just have O’Hare and Godden trying to hold up play and hope they can conjure something between them.
As great as the performance was last night, they barely had a sniff, and we’ve drawn at home.

speedie87 · Oct 21, 2020

Marosi
Dabo rose mcfad osti McCallum
Kelly sheaf
Hamer ohare
Godden

cc84cov · Oct 21, 2020

speedie87 said:
Marosi
Dabo rose mcfad osti McCallum
Kelly sheaf
Hamer ohare
Godden

Been thinking myself today maybe Hamer could be used further forward with O’Hare behind Godden

Gibbo · Oct 21, 2020

Yorkshire SB said:
Not exactly unheard of though is it? Turning an attacking full back to midfielder. We also have no pace up top, so I can see why the suggestion is made

I suggested this a couple of weeks ago and was absolutely dumped on by the 'never play a player out of their normal position' brigade. By taking McCallum in the first place, it must have been in Robins' mind. Why drop the man who has offered the most attacking potential so far for Shippers or Allen.

Gibbo · Oct 21, 2020

Hamer, Kelly and Sheaf (who has become undroppable in 20 minutes) in the same line up - interesting. Requires one of them - Hamer - to play out of position...

cc84cov · Oct 21, 2020

Gibbo said:
Hamer, Kelly and Sheaf (who has become undroppable in 20 minutes) in the same line up - interesting. Requires one of them - Hamer - to play out of position...

I don’t think Hamer would have any issues playing further forward

Saddlebrains · Oct 21, 2020

Play hamer further forward.

Box midfield then of

Kelly. Sheaf

O'Hare. Hamer

shmmeee · Oct 21, 2020

Got to love this site. Playing a winger at AM is the craziest idea ever encountered in football, but sticking a guy who has played DM and RB his entire career behind the striker makes perfect sense.

Gibbo · Oct 21, 2020

cc84cov said:
I don’t think Hamer would have any issues playing further forward

I agree

Gibbo · Oct 21, 2020

shmmeee said:
Got to love this site. Playing a winger at AM is the craziest idea ever encountered in football, but sticking a guy who has played DM and RB his entire career behind the striker makes perfect sense.

Aren't wingers just a form of attacking midfielder?

Strongest 11 after 6 games (1 Viewer)

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency