The Council (3 Viewers)

rob9872 · May 16, 2019

Why would they not support any action against Wasps that would result in Wasps having to pay another £27m to CCC?

I get that Wasps were originally courted by the council before they came, but this regime is not completely the one that brought them and their first priority should be towards the people they represent who voted them in (citizens of Coventry, not CCFC). Is it therefore not in their interest and more importantly their duty, to actually back a claim that would result in more money for more services for the people of Coventry?

I'm sure I'm probably missing something fundamental as to why this isn't the case, so hoping someone here can enlighten me.

*and please not "they're only Wasps supporting scum". I might agree, but surely financial pressure from inside the council offices would supersede any personal loyalties.

fernandopartridge · May 16, 2019

Because it'll put Wasps out of business, not sure where it'd leave the council.

rob9872 · May 16, 2019

fernandopartridge said:
Because it'll put Wasps out of business, not sure where it'd leave the council.

Hopefully with a football club in the stadium that it was built for.

LB87ccfc · May 16, 2019

rob9872 said:
Why would they not support any action against Wasps that would result in Wasps having to pay another £27m to CCC?

I get that Wasps were originally courted by the council before they came, but this regime is not completely the one that brought them and their first priority should be towards the people they represent who voted them in (citizens of Coventry, not CCFC). Is it therefore not in their interest and more importantly their duty, to actually back a claim that would result in more money for more services for the people of Coventry?

I'm sure I'm probably missing something fundamental as to why this isn't the case, so hoping someone here can enlighten me.

*and please not "they're only Wasps supporting scum". I might agree, but surely financial pressure from inside the council offices would supersede any personal loyalties.

Probably because the council have something to hide, hence the hysteria panicking regarding the case and using Wasps as their puppet to cover up the illegal use of taxpayers money at the time of bringing Wasps to Coventry.

KarmicChris · May 16, 2019

It would show that CCC used taxpayers money to help in a private venture, which is a no no and you’d like to think there would be some serious consequences for them.

I think? That’s my understanding of the whole state aid scenario. Happy to be proved otherwise however!

jim20 · May 16, 2019

I hope the EU commission does find some illegal going’s on, not because I want SISU to win but I think it could ultimately get rid of Wasps or at least get us back to the Ricoh long term

Sky Blue Pete · May 16, 2019

They won’t find anything different to the rest of the law. Come on it’s madness to keep doing the same thing and expecting a different outcome

chiefdave · May 16, 2019

Sky Blue Pete said:
They won’t find anything different to the rest of the law. Come on it’s madness to keep doing the same thing and expecting a different outcome

I think there's a slight but significant difference. The judicial reviews are on the finer points of the law, the impression I get is that the EC investigation has wider scope.

OffenhamSkyBlue · May 16, 2019

I agree with Chief, from what i understand of it having done a bit of reading around.
The JRs claimed that the actions of CCC had been unfair to CCFC/Otium/SBS&L/SISU. The EC will look at whether CCC sold their share of ACL at a lower price to Wasps than was available to SISU, or than general market value, in all its manifestations. I think the rulings from the JRs addressed certain points of law.

Sky Blue Harry H · May 16, 2019

chiefdave said:
I think there's a slight but significant difference. The judicial reviews are on the finer points of the law, the impression I get is that the EC investigation has wider scope.

I tend to agree, but also think this would be...….like Endgame, The Avengers - natty title for this saga (i.e. no more to come after that!)

On a film/saga topic, if we could get hold of Arya Stark's e-mail address (assuming she survives the last episode) could we all chip in to hire her and add a few 'nominations' to her 'list'

Sky Blue Pete · May 16, 2019

chiefdave said:
I think there's a slight but significant difference. The judicial reviews are on the finer points of the law, the impression I get is that the EC investigation has wider scope.

Okay I hear you. Very unlikely though

Nick · May 16, 2019

Sky Blue Pete said:
Okay I hear you. Very unlikely though

In which case there's no action at all.

David O'Day · May 16, 2019

Sky Blue Pete said:
Okay I hear you. Very unlikely though

Unlikely because you say so?

Sent from my SM-G975F using Tapatalk

WillenhallSkyBlues · May 16, 2019

Surely if after all of this sisu won a court case would that not mean they’d be able to sue to the council for loss of earnings etc. Therefore putting the council massively out of pocket. That’s maybe been why they’ve been so defensive because by using possibly 15-30m of public funding they could be hit with a 100m+ compo claim

OffenhamSkyBlue · May 16, 2019

Sky Blue Pete said:
Okay I hear you. Very unlikely though

On what basis do you make that statement??? Inside info???

HuckerbyDublinWhelan · May 16, 2019

WillenhallSkyBlues said:
Surely if after all of this sisu won a court case would that not mean they’d be able to sue to the council for loss of earnings etc. Therefore putting the council massively out of pocket. That’s maybe been why they’ve been so defensive because by using possibly 15-30m of public funding they could be hit with a 100m+ compo claim

Well if that’s the case, we should be asking why our council has made a catastrophic error?

Kind of like when they’ve got to come up with a plan to reduce pollution and they can’t even do that

djr8369 · May 16, 2019

You need to look at it in the wider context of events.

Why do the council and wasps coordinate?
Why was a PR company involved in turning people abasing SISU (who were unpopular anyway)
Why were the council talking to the previous wasps owners?
Why are the council trying to push SISU out?
Why does the consortium appear at just the right time?
Why must any legal action be dropped if there is no wrong doing? Wasps are a business and the best business decision is to keep city at the Ricoh.
Why haven’t the council been proactive in pushing a new stadium build? It’s in their interests to have the club in the city.
Why did the council conspire behind SISUs back and lead them on in a false negotiation while they did another deal?

There aren’t many scenarios that address all these points. What might further legal investigation uncover?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Nick · May 16, 2019

djr8369 said:
You need to look at it in the wider context of events.

Why do the council and wasps coordinate?
Why was a PR company involved in turning people abasing SISU (who were unpopular anyway)
Why were the council talking to the previous wasps owners?
Why are the council trying to push SISU out?
Why does the consortium appear at just the right time?
Why must any legal action be dropped if there is no wrong doing? Wasps are a business and the best business decision is to keep city at the Ricoh.
Why haven’t the council been proactive in pushing a new stadium build? It’s in their interests to have the club in the city.
Why did the council conspire behind SISUs back and lead them on in a false negotiation while they did another deal?

There aren’t many scenarios that address all these points. What might further legal investigation uncover?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

It's because they don't get questioned. Why is the sky blue trust also coordinated with them?

djr8369 · May 16, 2019

Nick said:
It's because they don't get questioned. Why is the sky blue trust also coordinated with them?

Another to add to the list. I’m sure there’s more. Not being questioned is one of them.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Sky Blue Harry H · May 16, 2019

Rob. Decent points, but you got a like for the use of the verb abase (I read a lot and had to check its meaning!). Edit: mainly The Beano, The Dandy and SBT!

Ashdown · May 16, 2019

I wish that they had gone down this bloody route before and bypassed all the other crap which has took so long !

djr8369 · May 16, 2019

Ashdown said:
I wish that they had gone down this bloody route before and bypassed all the other crap which has took so long !

I think somebody said one condition of going to EC is that all other routes have already been exhausted.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

David O'Day · May 16, 2019

djr8369 said:
I think somebody said one condition of going to EC is that all other routes have already been exhausted.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

No that would be going to the echr

Sent from my SM-G975F using Tapatalk

Cov kid 55 · May 16, 2019

jim20 said:
I hope the EU commission does find some illegal going’s on, not because I want SISU to win but I think it could ultimately get rid of Wasps or at least get us back to the Ricoh long term

And if it is found that something was wrong with the sale, what’s wrong with SISU winning?

lifelongcityfan · May 16, 2019

do you believe the club will benefit if sisu win?? they will simply use the cash to recover their losses and the high interest they have charged the club and cut and run. By the time the case has settled the club will be dead

Nick · May 16, 2019

lifelongcityfan said:
do you believe the club will benefit if sisu win?? they will simply use the cash to recover their losses and the high interest they have charged the club and cut and run. By the time the case has settled the club will be dead

The tax payers and council will, won't they?

lifelongcityfan · May 16, 2019

if anyone believes that sisu are dong this for the club or the fans, i believe the fullness of time will prove otherwise. They are a hedge fund with no emotional attachment to the club..just trying to maximise the value they can extract fromit..that is what hedge funds do.
I wouldnt subscribe at all to a sisu love in...all sides are at fault imo..

Cov kid 55 · May 16, 2019

lifelongcityfan said:
do you believe the club will benefit if sisu win?? they will simply use the cash to recover their losses and the high interest they have charged the club and cut and run. By the time the case has settled the club will be dead

Surely if SISU’s complaint is upheld, they won’t receive cash, it will just mean that the selling price of the Ricoh was too low, which may have ramifications for Wasps/CCC, and may be beneficial in the long run for CCFC?

Johnnythespider · May 16, 2019

I'd like to know how far reaching their powers are, are they like the police in that they can seize documents, computers and the like, can they find out what was said at closed council meetings with rugby club owners for instance.

Nick · May 16, 2019

lifelongcityfan said:
if anyone believes that sisu are dong this for the club or the fans, i believe the fullness of time will prove otherwise. They are a hedge fund with no emotional attachment to the club..just trying to maximise the value they can extract fromit..that is what hedge funds do.
I wouldnt subscribe at all to a sisu love in...all sides are at fault imo..

It's as if you ignored the reply to what you said to go off on one about something else.

BobbyDazzler · May 16, 2019

Cov kid 55 said:
Surely if SISU’s complaint is upheld, they won’t receive cash, it will just mean that the selling price of the Ricoh was too low, which may have ramifications for Wasps/CCC, and may be beneficial in the long run for CCFC?

It’s a distressing tactic, surely? Prove state aid, Wasps have to pay more and then go out of business, SISU pick up the stadium at a knock down price.

lifelongcityfan · May 16, 2019

Nick said:
It's as if you ignored the reply to what you said to go off on one about something else.

Nick

i rarely bother posting on here...every time i come on, i see you are hounding down people who do not agree with you..you may not have noticed that many are like myself and do not post. why do you believe you are right all the time?
To say i have gone offon something else impliesihave posted many replies...pleas ***off and get a life .

perhaps set up a site for menopasual women

Nick · May 16, 2019

lifelongcityfan said:
Nick

i rarely bother posting on here...every time i come on, i see you are hounding down people who do not agree with you..you may not have noticed that many are like myself and do not post. why do you believe you are right all the time?

Shocker.

Was I hounding when I replied to your point you seemed to have missed?

If you don't want to listen to things and just aimlessly drone on, that's your choice.

lifelongcityfan · May 16, 2019

look at all your threads..75% are obsessed with proving you aree right..when actually you do not know any more than the rest

Nick · May 16, 2019

lifelongcityfan said:
look at all your threads..75% are obsessed with proving you aree right..when actually you do not know any more than the rest

I will break it down to make it simple.

You said:

do you believe the club will benefit if sisu win?? they will simply use the cash to recover their losses and the high interest they have charged the club and cut and run. By the time the case has settled the club will be dead

I said:

The tax payers and council will, won't they?

Try to keep up. I guess the thread title was too appealing

The Council (3 Viewers)

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency