All penalty takers are going to miss at some point. It's all about odds. So with this in mind, I would keep Macca as pen taker. He isn't worried about them.
I think that Portsmouth should take the next penalty. At least 10 points again. Can't see it though as the ones running the league are allowing them to cheat
Sheff should take it. All Clingan wants is a goal onto his stats to help him get a contract elsewhere, he can fick off as far as i'm concerned. I prefer Thomas in his role, he will be a much better player in the future than "Sammy the soft shell crab"
All this reminds me of the great Ron Farmer who took our penalties for probably 6-7 years. In all that time he only missed one which hit the bar & bounced out. I know cus I was there! Anybody heard what has happened to our Ron? He was chief scout in JH's day. What a great wing half. Wish we had him now.