Player Ratings v Luton (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
SeaSeeEffCee
Well-Known Member
Wilson 2
Dabo 4
Ostigard 7
McFadzean 4
Hyam 5
McCallum 4
Hamer 2
Kelly 4
James 4
O’Hare 6
Biamou 3
Dabo 4
Ostigard 7
McFadzean 4
Hyam 5
McCallum 4
Hamer 2
Kelly 4
James 4
O’Hare 6
Biamou 3
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Don't think many come away with anything there...
Biamou is not a good footballer, I think I'm done talking about him now because to defend him week after week is frankly absurd.
Wilson was poor , Marosi must come back in the side
Hamer, well I dont know what's happened to him since january tbh
Kelly, 2 poor games in recent weeks ... Needs to sharpen up
Dabo... Very inconsistent this season, just needs to believe in himself again, poor defensively tonight.
Sam mac.... Can't defend
Fadz.. Harsh red, was beaten easily early on... Sold down the river by Wilson
James - has to use the ability he has more often, felt like he couldnt be arsed at times..
Just a shite night
Biamou is not a good footballer, I think I'm done talking about him now because to defend him week after week is frankly absurd.
Wilson was poor , Marosi must come back in the side
Hamer, well I dont know what's happened to him since january tbh
Kelly, 2 poor games in recent weeks ... Needs to sharpen up
Dabo... Very inconsistent this season, just needs to believe in himself again, poor defensively tonight.
Sam mac.... Can't defend
Fadz.. Harsh red, was beaten easily early on... Sold down the river by Wilson
James - has to use the ability he has more often, felt like he couldnt be arsed at times..
Just a shite night
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
Wilson 4 - gets points back for some good saves second half
Dabo 4
Ostigard 6 motm
McFadzean 5 sending off looked harsh though
Hyam 5 - too slow, needs replacing next season if we stay up
Mccallum 5
Kelly 5 - not at the races but not really sure how him, James and Hamer all fit into a team that sits deep enough as it is
James 4 as above, he was half hearted and looks to me like he's carrying a bit of timber
Hamer 5 was better second half but got hooked despite how atrocious James was
O'Hare 7 - we're completely lost without him
Biamou 4 - the first miss I could forgive if he scored the second
Sheaf 4 - off the pace unsurprisingly, still giving the ball away sloppily in his own half
Godden 5 - won a few balls in the air but we had no plan for how to play with two strikers, any time we got a decent crossing position we didn't beat the first man
Walker 5 as Godden
Robins 4 - he's persisted with Wilson despite it being obvious for months that he isn't up to it, his defenders have no confidence in him. Similarly, he's signed Walker to use him sporadically in favour of a French non league player
Dabo 4
Ostigard 6 motm
McFadzean 5 sending off looked harsh though
Hyam 5 - too slow, needs replacing next season if we stay up
Mccallum 5
Kelly 5 - not at the races but not really sure how him, James and Hamer all fit into a team that sits deep enough as it is
James 4 as above, he was half hearted and looks to me like he's carrying a bit of timber
Hamer 5 was better second half but got hooked despite how atrocious James was
O'Hare 7 - we're completely lost without him
Biamou 4 - the first miss I could forgive if he scored the second
Sheaf 4 - off the pace unsurprisingly, still giving the ball away sloppily in his own half
Godden 5 - won a few balls in the air but we had no plan for how to play with two strikers, any time we got a decent crossing position we didn't beat the first man
Walker 5 as Godden
Robins 4 - he's persisted with Wilson despite it being obvious for months that he isn't up to it, his defenders have no confidence in him. Similarly, he's signed Walker to use him sporadically in favour of a French non league player
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
Forgot
Dacosta 5 he's all over the place and not in a good way
Dacosta 5 he's all over the place and not in a good way
no_loyalty
Well-Known Member
Osti man of the match, at least he was battling.
SeaSeeEffCee
Well-Known Member
Hamer is playing like a player who knows he won’t be here much longer, he’s been so poor for months now. I’d honestly consider dropping him for Allen next game.
Liquid Gold
Well-Known Member
Was Hamer’s head turned by the Rangers rumours in Jan?
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Agreed on both counts. And yet equally he’s our only goal threat from midfield.
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
Who's going to sign him?
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Nobody on recent showings
matesx
Well-Known Member
Fuck it take the £15m and move on.
hill83
Well-Known Member
One of the top four in the prem wasn't it?
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Biamou and Wilson deserve nowt
The Philosopher
Well-Known Member
That was painful.
My Mrs is football mad.
Really clued up.
She’s a Luton fan.
The entire team gets 1. I won’t. Not in the mood now.
My Mrs is football mad.
Really clued up.
She’s a Luton fan.
The entire team gets 1. I won’t. Not in the mood now.
Liquid Gold
Well-Known Member
Sky Blue Pete
Well-Known Member
I wonder if marosi is still not mentally right
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
I. Will take an open University course, complete it and get tested in 2 days and give him therapy on Friday to make sure he's OK
Sky Blue Pete
Well-Known Member
He seemed to perk up for the start of the second half. We need to see some fire in our players bellies to get the points we need to stay up
Pretty much agree with all that although Ostigard wasn't motm. You rightly mark O'Hare higher. O'Hare was a class above the rest of the team tonight.
What has happened to Hamer? He's lost that intensity of early in the season. And I am really not a fan of three holding midfielders. We can't expect O'Hare to create everything. Even when he does we have no one to finish it off.
Dreadful miss by Biamou. Agree with your comment.
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
Yeah I spotted my contradictory ratings but cba to change it!
skybluepm2
Well-Known Member
Wilson 1 should never play at this level again
Max 2 huge chance blew our chance to take a big step towards safety. Almost the perfect finish, but fine lines
McFadz 2 although the red was debatable, was still unavoidable in my opinion and our comeback hopes were extinguished. such a Jekyll and Hyde player this season
McCallum 3 not very good. Won’t be missed
O’Hare 6 only player to give his all.
Let down by those around him
Osti 6 our best defender. Great double goal-line clearance
Everyone else 4
shite.
Max 2 huge chance blew our chance to take a big step towards safety. Almost the perfect finish, but fine lines
McFadz 2 although the red was debatable, was still unavoidable in my opinion and our comeback hopes were extinguished. such a Jekyll and Hyde player this season
McCallum 3 not very good. Won’t be missed
O’Hare 6 only player to give his all.
Let down by those around him
Osti 6 our best defender. Great double goal-line clearance
Everyone else 4
shite.
GaryMabbuttsLeftKnee
Well-Known Member
I swear I remember being one of the few people who said Wilson looked like he’d cost us a few goals a game but the mistakes weren’t being punished. Now feels like everyone has thought he’s terrible for ages. A quick turnaround
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Grendel
Well-Known Member
Where is he going? No one would have signed him at his peak as he wasn’t much good by higher standards even then
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
I must have missed the series of match winning performances every one seems to remember. At times he's showed flashes but on the whole he's had more poor games than good.
cc84cov
Well-Known Member
If that’s the case why does robins pick him ? Surely he’s making the correct noises but his performances have dropped massively
SeaSeeEffCee
Well-Known Member
No-one on current showing but he’s playing as if he’s expecting someone to.
Grendel
Well-Known Member
He’s overhyped on here by the same idiots who think Dabo is with £10 million Hamer is a bang average low end championship player
cc84cov
Well-Known Member
I admit i had Hamer at £15m....but I’m willing to drop this to 12 
First half was like keystone cops - absolute shambles. They restored some respect 2nd half.
Wilson 5 (handling and kicking was dreadful 1st half. Should have done better with first goal and his inability to punch led to the pen. 2 very good saves later on but damage had been done)
Dabo 6 (not sure he is fit. Lacked his usual energy)
McCallum 6 (delivery into the box was poor from crosses and throw ins)
Ostigard 9 (motm. He was superb 2nd half. His double clearance off the line summed him up)
McFadzean 6 (not his assured self. Maybe unlucky with the red card. Almost scored a calamitous own goal before that)
Hyam 6 (he needs to be able to head the ball further than the edge of the box and not centrally)
Kelly 6 (he has lost his form recently. Did okay defensively but passing was poor)
James 6 (drifted out of the game after the sending off and looked like his head had dropped)
Hamer 6 (another to have lost his form, though thought he was coming into the game the 10 minutes before being dubbed)
O'Hare 6 (ran around)
Biamou 5 (should have scored 2 and was unlucky with the shot that was blocked. His movement leading to the chances was much better but couldn't make it count)
Sheaf 4 (I would have hoped by now his customary pass to an opponent in a dangerous area would have been coached out of him but clearly not)
Dacosta 5 (looks reckless at times and the drag back in the penalty area could have been costly)
Walker 6 (looked sharper than recent)
Godden 5 (minutes in the tank)
Wilson 5 (handling and kicking was dreadful 1st half. Should have done better with first goal and his inability to punch led to the pen. 2 very good saves later on but damage had been done)
Dabo 6 (not sure he is fit. Lacked his usual energy)
McCallum 6 (delivery into the box was poor from crosses and throw ins)
Ostigard 9 (motm. He was superb 2nd half. His double clearance off the line summed him up)
McFadzean 6 (not his assured self. Maybe unlucky with the red card. Almost scored a calamitous own goal before that)
Hyam 6 (he needs to be able to head the ball further than the edge of the box and not centrally)
Kelly 6 (he has lost his form recently. Did okay defensively but passing was poor)
James 6 (drifted out of the game after the sending off and looked like his head had dropped)
Hamer 6 (another to have lost his form, though thought he was coming into the game the 10 minutes before being dubbed)
O'Hare 6 (ran around)
Biamou 5 (should have scored 2 and was unlucky with the shot that was blocked. His movement leading to the chances was much better but couldn't make it count)
Sheaf 4 (I would have hoped by now his customary pass to an opponent in a dangerous area would have been coached out of him but clearly not)
Dacosta 5 (looks reckless at times and the drag back in the penalty area could have been costly)
Walker 6 (looked sharper than recent)
Godden 5 (minutes in the tank)
Otis
Well-Known Member
Thought Biamou was a little unlucky with that first shot that hit the post, but was then very poor after that.
Yorkshire SB
Well-Known Member
I know Hamer’s been off from, but Allen? Jesus we’re in trouble then
