Now its potentially a reality , Will mark Robins be Coventrys greatest manager if we get promoted (1 Viewer)

Is mark robins Our greatest ever manager if we get promoted

  • Yes

    Votes: 140 95.2%
  • No

    Votes: 7 4.8%

  • Total voters
    147

Skyblueweeman

Well-Known Member
Dec 7, 2011
10,562
10,118
313
Portsmouth
Why can't we see who voted for what? Normally we can.

The 7 nos are I guess, G, Boosh and who else?
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
Sep 19, 2011
82,403
36,747
813
Why can't we see who voted for what? Normally we can.

The 7 nos are I guess, G, Boosh and who else?

Well NW I’d guess also others on the thread have said they don’t think he is.

Jimmy hill to me always will be anyway as he really created the club we have today.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Skyblueweeman

Irish Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
Jan 25, 2014
3,897
5,625
313
North Warwickshire
People equate Robins with the Checkatrade win but that wasn't his squad or his efforts to get us there. We'd already qualified for the final when Robins was re-appointed and he didn't go into that with any momentum as his first 3 games (2 at home) were all defeats. So in that context, beating Oxford in the final could be considered as much Russell Slade's success as Robins'.

Everything since though, Robins, Viveash, Adi's predecessor Steve Taylor and the rest of the backroom staff have to take the full weight of praise for what has effectively been a phoenix-like transformation of the club.
It took him those three games to get to grips with the team. After these games the form of that team was transformed. A team that was constantly losing hit a level that wasn’t far off play off form if continued across a season. Oxford were red hot favourites for that game. I’m pretty sure if Slade had been in charge instead of Robins then the bookies would have been right. By the time of the Checkatrade final Robins has already started to turn things around.
 

croatskyblue

Well-Known Member
May 18, 2023
393
356
63
It took him those three games to get to grips with the team. After these games the form of that team was transformed. A team that was constantly losing hit a level that wasn’t far off play off form if continued across a season. Oxford were red hot favourites for that game. I’m pretty sure if Slade had been in charge instead of Robins then the bookies would have been right. By the time of the Checkatrade final Robins has already started to turn things around.

Oh with Slade in charge I’d say that day would have gone very differently.

It’s a landslide at the moment, good to see that people at last see what an incredible job Robins has done
 

Happy_Martian

Well-Known Member
Jan 1, 2013
3,654
2,521
213
Why can't we see who voted for what? Normally we can.

The 7 nos are I guess, G, Boosh and who else?

Me. I gave my reasons all the way back in post 7 of the thread.

I genuinely feel at this moment Robins and Hill have both been the catalysts for incredible changes for this club and and the city as a whole. To a point that I think it's currently unfair to claim one is "greater" than the other. Even hypothetically or for fun. So I've said I think of them as joint GOATs with Sillett in 3rd.

Now, if Robins gets us a PL title or one of the European cups (if Leicester can, there's no reason we couldn't in the future), I could be tempted to rethink :)
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
Jul 11, 2011
56,213
56,104
813
Coventry, United Kingdom, United Kingdom
Me. I gave my reasons all the way back in post 7 of the thread.

I genuinely feel at this moment Robins and Hill have both been the catalysts for incredible changes for this club and and the city as a whole. To a point that I think it's currently unfair to claim one is "greater" than the other. Even hypothetically or for fun. So I've said I think of them as joint GOATs with Sillett in 3rd.

Now, if Robins gets us a PL title or one of the European cups (if Leicester can, there's no reason we couldn't in the future), I could be tempted to rethink :)

Think this is a really fair point. Not much good to come from debating whether Hill or Robins or even Sillett is better. They’re all at the same legend status.
 

baldy

Well-Known Member
Aug 12, 2008
2,519
2,076
163
Your mate Grendel tried to drum up support for getting rid of Robins for a couple of years. He still won't admit he was wrong. Why don't you ever ask him?

Boosh doesn't even support City - in fact,I don't know why he/it/she's on this forum....or on this planet
 

Ccfcisparks

Well-Known Member
May 13, 2011
11,744
10,393
313
Boosh doesn't even support City - in fact,I don't know why he/it/she's on this forum....or on this planet
He goes to most games to be fair. You can question his motives on this forum half the time, but you cannot question hes a fan.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Boosh

COVKIDSNEVERQUIT

Well-Known Member
May 27, 2016
5,430
3,083
213
The Cayman Islands.
Well NW I’d guess also others on the thread have said they don’t think he is.

Jimmy hill to me always will be anyway as he really created the club we have today.


So you've changed your mind then because you posted earlier that Noel Cantwell was the best manager, because he got us into Europe.
 

SkyBlueDaz

New Member
Sep 2, 2012
34
0
56
You can only manage what you have in front of you, and Mark Robins was inheriting a club destined for league 2. If you are tasked 6 years to get to a championship play off final would any other of our previous managers done better? Jimmy Hill worked wonders on and off the pitch in a differnt era, get us promoted and Robins more than deserves to sat along side him.
 

croatskyblue

Well-Known Member
May 18, 2023
393
356
63
You can only manage what you have in front of you, and Mark Robins was inheriting a club destined for league 2. If you are tasked 6 years to get to a championship play off final would any other of our previous managers done better? Jimmy Hill worked wonders on and off the pitch in a differnt era, get us promoted and Robins more than deserves to sat along side him.
Jimmy Hill had a very big budget, I’d say Sillett would have been better equipped as he could take a team and get them performing way better than they did previously
 

bigfatronssba

Well-Known Member
Apr 20, 2013
6,753
2,619
213
Such a shame Jimmy Hill wasn't around long enough to have a picture with Robins & Sillett.

I think this picture of Robins and Sillett is great, would be the basis of some great artwork if Jimmy Hill was there with them.

Our three greatest managers

robins-and-js.jpg
 

PVA

Well-Known Member
Apr 22, 2011
14,492
14,097
263
The lineup for Robins' first game:

Lee Burge
Kevin Foley
Nathan Clarke
Jordan Turnbull
Chris Stokes
George Thomas
Ben Stevenson
Callum Reilly
Kwame Thomas
Stuart Beavon
Charles Vernam


And now he has us one game from the Premier League.

It's a remarkable turnaround and achievement.
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
Sep 19, 2011
82,403
36,747
813
Oh dear
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
Sep 19, 2011
82,403
36,747
813
We will have Dongle back soon
 

Users who are viewing this thread