Match Thread Confirmed Ins and Outs 2023/2024 Summer (1 Viewer)

[Gibbo]

New
New, McNally, New, loan, da Silva
Hamer Sheaf
O'Hare, Eccles
New

Subs: From Wilson, Bidwell, McFadz, Allen, Kelly, Godden

EDITED

 

---

[shmmeee]

New
New, McNally, New, loan, da Silva
Hamer Sheaf
O'Hare
New

Subs: From Wilson, Bidwell, McFadz, Eccles, Allen, Kelly, Godden

Why are we only playing with ten men?

 

[Gibbo]

Why are we only playing with ten men?

edited

 

[We'll_live_and_die]

New
New, McNally, New, loan, da Silva
Hamer Sheaf
O'Hare, Eccles
New

Subs: From Wilson, Bidwell, McFadz, Allen, Kelly, Godden

EDITED

That New fella gets around the pitch well.

 

[shmmeee]

edited

Eccles at AM? Interesting.

 

[robbiethemole]

New, new, Barney Magrew, Cuthbert, Dibble and Grubb??

 

[Bernie Rhodes Nose]

Why are we only playing with ten men?

What happen to Palmer?

 

[stevefloyd]

What happen to Palmer?

Injured

 

[Gibbo]

What happen to Palmer?

O'Hare and Palmer will not play together. See Gerrard and Lampard

 

[NorthernWisdom]

I'd have Allen in there, he stretches the game and makes its more fluid.

 

[shmmeee]

Wonder if Howley will keep progressing. He’s an AM isn’t he?

 

[Offhegoes]

Wonder if Howley will keep progressing. He’s an AM isn’t he?

Wasn't that impressed to be honest + I thought he was more of a holding midfielder? Thought he looked a little lost in the games he played. Was more impressed with Burroughs at LWB, but then he kind of disappeared.

 

[NorthernWisdom]

Wasn't that impressed to be honest + I thought he was more of a holding midfielder? Thought he looked a little lost in the games he played. Was more impressed with Burroughs at LWB, but then he kind of disappeared.

Howley's only 19 though, Eccles is 23 for context.

 

[shmmeee]

Wasn't that impressed to be honest + I thought he was more of a holding midfielder? Thought he looked a little lost in the games he played. Was more impressed with Burroughs at LWB, but then he kind of disappeared.

From: Coventry City hot prospect Ryan Howley on plans for next season

 

[shmmeee]

As someone else said Howley is 19, Burroughs 22 and Eccles 23.

 

[Hertsccfc]

As someone else said Howley is 19, Burroughs 22 and Eccles 23.

I thought Howley looked really promising considering his age. In fact I could see all three of these being important players for us.

 

[NorthernWisdom]

It's Howley's decision making that seemed very slow, which I assume is not being up to pace with / having experience of competitive football.

 

[JimmyHillsbeard]

Seeing Dublin at Wembley reminded me that losing him to Villa ultimately cost us a PL place

3 seasons later?
I suppose ultimately we’ve been on a downward trend since the moon landing in the league.

 

[skyblu3sk]

O'Hare and Palmer will not play together. See Gerrard and Lampard

Not convinced by this view. Think if you went one up front there is potential.

 

[covcity4life]

edited

Why is Eccles playing attacking mid?

 

[Gibbo]

Why is Eccles playing attacking mid?

Because Hamer and Sheaf are the defensive ones, but I am not that fussed, swap him with hamer

 

[San Francisco]

New
New, McNally, New, loan, da Silva
Hamer Sheaf
O'Hare, Eccles
New

Subs: From Wilson, Bidwell, McFadz, Allen, Kelly, Godden

EDITED

Even after winning the golden glove people still don't rate Wilson...

 

[slowpoke]

Most improved player this season the only thing we do need another keeper so does Robins go for one better or a younger prospect. Simon Moore is certainly not good enough.

 

[DannyThomas_1981]

New
New, McNally, New, loan, da Silva
Hamer Sheaf
O'Hare, Eccles
New

Subs: From Wilson, Bidwell, McFadz, Allen, Kelly, Godden

EDITED

If we keep Hamer and Palmer is fully fit, I'd go for a box of:

Hamer Sheaf

O'Hare Palmer

Some might say that's reckless - but technically that combination is very good and would increase our possession. I'm a huge fan of Palmer and hope to see the best of him next season.

If we want to go more defensive in certain games/situations, I'd happily go with:

Sheaf Kelly Hamer

O'Hare

Kelly was brilliant in the final 4-5 games. If Josh continues his development he could also play the Kelly role - I love the lad's confidence and his penalty at Wembley hasn't been mentioned enough - it was huge that he volunteered to step up to take that pen at this point of his career.

 

[Nuskyblue]

I'll try to keep this updated as players come and go over the coming weeks.

Feel free to tag me below if there are comings and goings that I may have missed.

IN			FIFA 23 Rating
Jay Dasilva	LB	4 years	69
			69
OUT
Tom Billson	GK	Released	59
Josh Wilson-Esbrand	LWB	Loan End	63
Fankaty Dabo	RB	Released	69
Julien Dacosta	RWB	Released	65
Todd Kane	RWB	Released	67
Blaine Rowe	RWB	Released	55
Brooke Norton-Cuffey	RWB	Loan End	66
Michael Rose	CB	Released	70
Callum Doyle	CB	Loan End	68
Luke Mcnally	CB	Loan End	71
Jay Mcgrath	CB	Released	55
George Burroughs	CB	Released	55
Jonathan Panzo	CB	Loan End	69
Will Bapaga	LW	Released	62
Ricardo Dinanga	RW	Released	53
Aiden Finnegan	CM	Released	52
Sean Maguire	ST	Released	67
Martyn Waghorn	ST	Released	67
Tyler Walker	ST	Released	67
Harrison Nee	ST	Released	54
			1254
	FIFA 23 Out		1254
	FIFA 23 IN		69
	Difference		-1185

Do you think you could add a line at the bottom to show the average rating of players in/out?

 

[We'll_live_and_die]

Do you think you could add a line at the bottom to show the average rating of players in/out?

I probably could to be fair. It’s just an excel sheet. I’ll look tomorrow

 

[Nuskyblue]

I probably could to be fair. It’s just an excel sheet. I’ll look tomorrow

Noice, it's super easy to do in Excel.

 

[We'll_live_and_die]

Updated to include averages in and out.

 

[Gibbo]

Even after winning the golden glove people still don't rate Wilson...

You hold your breath every time the opposition win a corner. The clean sheets down to addition of McNally to Doyle & McFadz to make a very strong back 3.

 

[We'll_live_and_die]

You hold your breath every time the opposition win a corner. The clean sheets down to addition of McNally to Doyle & McFadz to make a very strong back 3.

I don't think you can argue that a good goalkeeper and back line will lead to clean sheets. He made some absolutely fantastic saves last season and I think you'd be hard pushed to find better at this level.

 

[San Francisco]

You hold your breath every time the opposition win a corner. The clean sheets down to addition of McNally to Doyle & McFadz to make a very strong back 3.

How many goalkeepers at this level are affordable and consistent at dealing with corners?

 

[rob9872]

Ffs we conceded 2 goals all season in the league from set pieces!!!

You hold your breath every time the opposition win a corner. The clean sheets down to addition of McNally to Doyle & McFadz to make a very strong back 3.

 

[San Francisco]

Ffs we conceded 2 goals all season in the league from set pieces!!!

Yeah but Wilson makes you hold your breath during corners so we need to replace him ASAP.

 

[Offhegoes]

Wilson deserves to start as No 1 next season without a doubt. You can see his and the defence's confidence in him improve dramatically as the season progressed. He's also cut out the hesitating when the ball has been played back to him, and the mad rushes off his line.
Despite that, I am still not 100% convinced. Hope Moore moves on, and we bring in a young(ish) keeper with first team experience from perhaps League 1-2 as a No 2 to keep him on his toes.

 

[slowpoke]

Most improved player in the club, maybe the division, but we do need to sign another keeper, up to the manager if he brings in better, you always need better.