Alan Dugdales Moustache
Well-Known Member
Who on earth would want one season of relegation against a glorious piece of forever history ? People on here would .
Win the FA Cup or promotion for one year . (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Alan Dugdales Moustache
- Start date
StrettoBoy
Well-Known Member
My heart says the cup for the reason you have given.
My head says win promotion for the money and financial stability it would give the club.
My head says win promotion for the money and financial stability it would give the club.
CJ_covblaze
Well-Known Member
Win the cup. If you ask fans from Swansea, Blues and Wigan I bet most will say they wouldn’t swap their cup wins for being in the Prem now despite how things have gone since.
Boicey
Well-Known Member
Is winning the FA cup that much ‘history’ anymore? Can you remember who won the last few or anything about the games? Did you even watch them?
In the end the whole driving purpose of the team and management is to strive for promotion. To become the top Premiership standard.
In the end the whole driving purpose of the team and management is to strive for promotion. To become the top Premiership standard.
jimmyhillsfanclub
Well-Known Member
No it's not.....
It's about winning honours.
Flying Fokker
Well-Known Member
We get 38 finals with the other option. No silverware.
Mr Panda
Well-Known Member
We'd be the first to win it outside the premier league since football was invented in 1992 - that's memorable!
Terry Gibson's perm
Well-Known Member
Although I would love a European adventure after a cup win I would have to choose promotion especially if it was instead of the six fingered gang at the other end of the m69.
The premier league would probably say non prem teams can’t enter Europe and try to force it through with the fa so that Fulham can moan about the extra games and play their reserves.
The premier league would probably say non prem teams can’t enter Europe and try to force it through with the fa so that Fulham can moan about the extra games and play their reserves.
stupot07
Well-Known Member
We're never going to win the FA Cup, but we do have a chance at being promoted. Whilst it wouldn't be nice to see us do a Sheffield in the premier league, the £200m for being promoted would be a complete game changer for the club.
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
Last edited:
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
Depends if it's guaranteed only for one year or not
Otherwise promotion every time
Otherwise promotion every time
Alan Dugdales Moustache
Well-Known Member
I bet Burnley fans will talk about this season for many many years . As they did last time . Achieved absolutely bugger all. They'd take a trophy instead I'm sure.
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
FA Cup would be legendary - I’ve changed my mind since the last thread on the topic.
It’s felt quite nice being snide about being in the quarter finals!
It’s felt quite nice being snide about being in the quarter finals!
Alkhen
Well-Known Member
Didn't we do this thread before the last round ?
Cup and it's not even remotely close. Odds on on a team of our status winning the cup are tiny. It would be huge for us and raise our profile massively. People saying that the FA cup isn't glamorous anymore are missing the point that a championship team winning it would help bring the magic back to the competition.
Would also mean a European adventure next year. Something we were cruelly denied in 87.
Plenty of opportunities to build a better squad and have a run at the league in the next few seasons. Obviously I'd take promotion any way we can get it but the squad is work in progress and we'd get battered like Sheffield United are if we went up now.
Cup and it's not even remotely close. Odds on on a team of our status winning the cup are tiny. It would be huge for us and raise our profile massively. People saying that the FA cup isn't glamorous anymore are missing the point that a championship team winning it would help bring the magic back to the competition.
Would also mean a European adventure next year. Something we were cruelly denied in 87.
Plenty of opportunities to build a better squad and have a run at the league in the next few seasons. Obviously I'd take promotion any way we can get it but the squad is work in progress and we'd get battered like Sheffield United are if we went up now.
Boicey
Well-Known Member
I think the players would take making it to the Premiership. Playing at the top table, pinnacle of their career.
Rather than winning a cup many don’t take seriously anymore. it’s not much of an ‘honour’ anymore is it??
Alkhen
Well-Known Member
You sound dangerously like a Man city fan jaded by success
It's only belittled because it's won by the same 4 or 5 teams. Ask any Leicester, Portsmouth or Wigan fan and they would tell you how much it means
Otis
Well-Known Member
Exactly my thoughts.Didn't we do this thread before the last round ?
Cup and it's not even remotely close. Odds on on a team of our status winning the cup are tiny. It would be huge for us and raise our profile massively. People saying that the FA cup isn't glamorous anymore are missing the point that a championship team winning it would help bring the magic back to the competition.
Would also mean a European adventure next year. Something we were cruelly denied in 87.
Plenty of opportunities to build a better squad and have a run at the league in the next few seasons. Obviously I'd take promotion any way we can get it but the squad is work in progress and we'd get battered like Sheffield United are if we went up now.
They qualified for Europe about 4 years ago. Pretty decent.
Boicey
Well-Known Member
You reckon the players would regard winning the FA cup as a greater ‘honour’ than making it to the premiership?You sound dangerously like a Man city fan jaded by success
Ask any Leicester, Portsmouth or Wigan fan and they would tell you how much it means
You’d swap winning the cup as it is now with getting back to the top tier for the first time in over 20 years and playing all the top teams home and away?
Last edited:
itsabuzzard
Well-Known Member
Cup all day long and in to the night 
Alkhen
Well-Known Member
The question wasn't what the players would like was it.
Anyhow I reckon most would rather a medal and a shot at the Europa League next season.
After all you can't show the grandkids your 20th place Premier League participation medal can you.
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
To win it would most likely mean having beaten two of Man Utd/Man City/Chelsea/Liverpool in the process at Wembley, European football, millions in prize money and a load of profile boost.
Pretty good compensation for not going up in my view, but ultimately irrelevant as it'll come undone at Molineux anyway.
Pretty good compensation for not going up in my view, but ultimately irrelevant as it'll come undone at Molineux anyway.
Otis
Well-Known Member
We can win for sure, but it's going to need Wolves to be off form and us to have quite a bit of luck.
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
The Wolves manager seems to think it’s in the bag based on his comments. Probably not wrong
pusbccfc
Well-Known Member
Spot on
Otis
Well-Known Member
Well, it's a game of football at the end of the day. Own goals are scored, contentious decisions are made, players do get sent off and often, there is a slice of luck with a deflection and out of the blue wonder goals are scored etc.
I predict a loss of course, but who knows, if the Gods are with us on the day, we have a chance.
SkyBlueMatt
Well-Known Member
FA cup. I'd only want to get promoted to the PL for the money, we're never going to realistically ever compete.
Sure it's been devalued by the top clubs but for lower end Prem and Championship clubs, it still means a lot.
Promotion would revolutionise the club but in 10 years time. No one is going to care about a season spent getting beat most weeks.
I can only live off the Checkatrade Trophy for so long!
Sent from my M2101K6G using Tapatalk
Sure it's been devalued by the top clubs but for lower end Prem and Championship clubs, it still means a lot.
Promotion would revolutionise the club but in 10 years time. No one is going to care about a season spent getting beat most weeks.
I can only live off the Checkatrade Trophy for so long!
Sent from my M2101K6G using Tapatalk
Otis
Well-Known Member
I would love us to be able to go up to the Premier and make a fist of it, but I really think we would end up like Derby and be utterly embarrassed every week.FA cup. I'd only want to get promoted to the PL for the money, we're never going to realistically ever compete.
Sure it's been devalued by the top clubs but for lower end Prem and Championship clubs, it still means a lot.
Promotion would revolutionise the club but in 10 years time. No one is going to care about a season spent getting beat most weeks.
I can only live off the Checkatrade Trophy for so long!
Sent from my M2101K6G using Tapatalk
Would love to be proved wrong of course.
Briles
Well-Known Member
the last team I remember winning the FA cup was Wigan
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
I doubt that. Luton have put up by far the best go of it out of the 3 this season.
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
Mild-Mannered Janitor
Kindest Bloke on CCFC / Maker of CCFC Dreams
Players would want Prem all day long as its life changing for their agents and them with their new contracts.
FA Cup all day long, only really 4 trophies to win all year, who knows the positions in the prem from 8-17 year on year. If you can stay in there, great financially and always a better chance of then doing better in the cups because of that.
FA Cup all day long, only really 4 trophies to win all year, who knows the positions in the prem from 8-17 year on year. If you can stay in there, great financially and always a better chance of then doing better in the cups because of that.
Otis
Well-Known Member
They have, but name players we have who could do a job in the Premier.
I think we would pretty much need a new team.
I am definitely leaning towards a more Derby situation than a Luton one unfortunately.
