Johnnythespider
Well-Known Member
Why is everyone rating the City players, the thread title clearly states "Exeter Player Ratings"
Exeter player ratings (3 Viewers)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
Grendel
Well-Known Member
You said stokes is shit didn't you?
vow
Well-Known Member
If you're referring to Concrete Rod, please never use the name Rodders ever again, thank you, sir.
singers_pore
Well-Known Member
I missed the live game because I was on a plane but I saw the game today. My ratings:
Burge 7
Grimmer 7
Mcdonald 8
Willis 7
Stokes 7
Doyle 7
Kelly 8
DKE 7
Vincenti n/a
Jones 8
Nazons 8
Biamou 6
Burge 7
Grimmer 7
Mcdonald 8
Willis 7
Stokes 7
Doyle 7
Kelly 8
DKE 7
Vincenti n/a
Jones 8
Nazons 8
Biamou 6
Otis
Well-Known Member
Only ones I would pick you up there in are Grimmer and Nazon, especially Nazon. 8 seems rather high for a player who disappeared for long periods of the game and also missed a very good chance, when it would have been easier to hit the target.
I think we get 8's from him for 5 mins and then he's a 4 as he vanishes for 25 mins and then you get another good 5 mins from him. Of course if he is scoring it's not a problem. He can play like that all game long. If he's not scoring though, or creating for others, then it becomes a problem.
I was disappointed with him Saturday, as he clearly has something about him and can be a threat, but hardly showed it.
skyblueinBaku
Well-Known Member
Burge 7
Grimmer 7
McDonald 8.5
Willis 7
Stokes 7
Doyle 7
Kelly 7,5
DKE 7.5
Vincenti n/a
Jones 8
Nazon 7
Biamou 6.5
Grimmer 7
McDonald 8.5
Willis 7
Stokes 7
Doyle 7
Kelly 7,5
DKE 7.5
Vincenti n/a
Jones 8
Nazon 7
Biamou 6.5
Nick
Administrator
Burge 6 - Save towards the end and a couple of catches but he really had nothing at all to do.
Grimmer 5 - Got run ragged towards the end
McDonald 8 - Had reid in his pocket eve
Willis 6 - Shocking to see him get outpaced by Reid, is he carrying an injury? He suddenly looks a lot hencher since his haircut.
Stokes 6 - Did well with the swinging shot that hit the bar on his right foot.
Doyle 7 - Wasn't sure he was man of the match, would have been McDonald for me. Awful attempt at diving too.
Kelly 7 - Broke the game down nicely and knew when to slow it down.
Jones 7 - Same as Duke, needs to know when to pass it and when to shoot. Could potentially have had a goal if he laid it square rather than take it on.
Kelly Evans 7 - Improved loads when he went out to the left, didn't look out of place at all against top of the league. Fully deserved his goal!
Vincenti NA
Nazon 6 - Him and Jones need to work on when to lay it off and when to take it on., should have also got his shot in the first half on target (and the one in the second)
Biamou 6 Won pretty much every header and most of them went to a teammate, was hoping he would score and should have done better with his chance.
Grimmer 5 - Got run ragged towards the end
McDonald 8 - Had reid in his pocket eve
Willis 6 - Shocking to see him get outpaced by Reid, is he carrying an injury? He suddenly looks a lot hencher since his haircut.
Stokes 6 - Did well with the swinging shot that hit the bar on his right foot.
Doyle 7 - Wasn't sure he was man of the match, would have been McDonald for me. Awful attempt at diving too.
Kelly 7 - Broke the game down nicely and knew when to slow it down.
Jones 7 - Same as Duke, needs to know when to pass it and when to shoot. Could potentially have had a goal if he laid it square rather than take it on.
Kelly Evans 7 - Improved loads when he went out to the left, didn't look out of place at all against top of the league. Fully deserved his goal!
Vincenti NA
Nazon 6 - Him and Jones need to work on when to lay it off and when to take it on., should have also got his shot in the first half on target (and the one in the second)
Biamou 6 Won pretty much every header and most of them went to a teammate, was hoping he would score and should have done better with his chance.
Otis
Well-Known Member
Well yeah, I would have made McDonald MOTM but I didn't feel that the Exeter strikers put him under any threat at all and he had a relatively easy afternoon.
