Events Executive Job Going (25 Viewers)

SkyBlueCRJ

Well-Known Member
"Please note replies will not be given to applicants who do not meet the essential requirements of the job."

Really ?

That is pretty common. It's like 14 year olds applying to be the next manager of their preferred football club. Why would an employer bother reading the application if it bares no relevance....
 

italiahorse

Well-Known Member
That’s common practice what’s the problem??
That is pretty common. It's like 14 year olds applying to be the next manager of their preferred football club. Why would an employer bother reading the application if it bares no relevance....

Little bit out of it since retirement.
But these days it costs nothing to just email the applicant with a standard dear John.
I can understand the silly applications but a lot of people will believe they match the criteria and not get a reply.
They may even phone up then, I would.
 

SkyBlueCRJ

Well-Known Member
Little bit out of it since retirement.
But these days it costs nothing to just email the applicant with a standard dear John.
I can understand the silly applications but a lot of people will believe they match the criteria and not get a reply.
They may even phone up then, I would.

Unfortunately these days common curtesy is a thing of the past my good sir. In all fairness many companies still reply to their applicants but put it this way, it's not a shock if some don't as they simply don't have the time.
 

italiahorse

Well-Known Member
Unfortunately these days common curtesy is a thing of the past my good sir. In all fairness many companies still reply to their applicants but put it this way, it's not a shock if some don't as they simply don't have the time.

I take it that my application for Disabled rep is binned then as I have heard nothing ?
 

skyblueinBaku

Well-Known Member
Unfortunately these days common curtesy is a thing of the past my good sir. In all fairness many companies still reply to their applicants but put it this way, it's not a shock if some don't as they simply don't have the time.
It's not just 'these days', James. I was out of work in the early '90s and was shocked at the number of job applications I made that didn't get a reply - not even an acknowledgement of receipt.
 

italiahorse

Well-Known Member
Depending on how long ago you applied, highly likely.
See I'm old school on this.
I've waited 4 weeks with no acknowledgement and I've already decided that because of this that even if they reply I can't work with them.
Don't forget that one is voluntary.
This is the second time this has happened as I offered my services to Jonathan strange and the old group twice a few years back.
Still no rep at the club, still have the disabled struggling on anything match specific, particularly away games.
 

italiahorse

Well-Known Member
Good to see Italia get in early to twist what seems to be a positive improvement to try and build a few more revenues.

Can't blindly follow poor practice 'for the sake' of the club.
It's a normal business practice to have these positions.
A bit like hygiene, it happens but there is no need to talk about it like it's special.
 

SkyBlueCRJ

Well-Known Member
It's not just 'these days', James. I was out of work in the early '90s and was shocked at the number of job applications I made that didn't get a reply - not even an acknowledgement of receipt.

That's a shame. Maybe it's more exposed now due to the amount of applications that are flying about these days. Employment has obviously always been competitive but these days it's a different kettle of fish. For an average executive position you can easily get north of 25+ people applying. Either way it's not excusable whether companies are failing to provide feedback/a standard response in the 90s or now.
 

SkyBlueCRJ

Well-Known Member
On a positive note it's great to see the commercial team is being expanded as operating on a team of 4/5 is simply incomprehensible given the size of the club.
 

Nick

Administrator
Can't blindly follow poor practice 'for the sake' of the club.
It's a normal business practice to have these positions.
A bit like hygiene, it happens but there is no need to talk about it like it's special.

So what point are you trying to make?

It's a positive thing surely, yet you are scraping the barrel that people who don't match the criteria don't get a reply to go off on one.
 

italiahorse

Well-Known Member
So what point are you trying to make?

It's a positive thing surely, yet you are scraping the barrel that people who don't match the criteria don't get a reply to go off on one.

Can't make excuses these days for not replying.
Just add their email onto one standard email and send it out at the end of the day.

Not criticising the job just the process that will put some people off applying.
 

Nick

Administrator
So people who don't meet the essential requirements will be put off from applying in case they don't get a reply?
 

italiahorse

Well-Known Member
That's a shame. Maybe it's more exposed now due to the amount of applications that are flying about these days. Employment has obviously always been competitive but these days it's a different kettle of fish. For an average executive position you can easily get north of 25+ people applying. Either way it's not excusable whether companies are failing to provide feedback/a standard response in the 90s or now.

Exactly.
Employers can help some applicants by just giving them some feedback.
Obviously just a standard dear John joint email to the obvious no chancers.

As I said I'm a little bit out of it but if thats the practice these days then it's a shame.
 

italiahorse

Well-Known Member
So people who don't meet the essential requirements will be put off from applying in case they don't get a reply?

No, the process is poor compared to what I see as the norm and it will put people off working for such employers.
I would say the perception of working for CCFC is poor and that needs to be improved to get the best candidates.

I do however like the case study process they are using.
 

Nick

Administrator
No, the process is poor compared to what I see as the norm and it will put people off working for such employers.
I would say the perception of working for CCFC is poor and that needs to be improved to get the best candidates.

I do however like the case study process they are using.

No it wouldn't, it says essential requirements.

If I applied for something I don't meet the requirements it is wasting people's time.

I couldn't give 2 shits when applying for a job whether they reply if people don't meet the criteria, where I work now we have about 50 people from India apply for every job. Safe to say they don't get a reply.

The process for realistic candidates is fine, it's just saying in advance people may not get a reply if they don't meet the basics.
 

italiahorse

Well-Known Member
No it wouldn't, it says essential requirements.

If I applied for something I don't meet the requirements it is wasting people's time.

I couldn't give 2 shits when applying for a job whether they reply if people don't meet the criteria, where I work now we have about 50 people from India apply for the job. Safe to say they don't get a reply.

The process for realistic candidates is fine, it's just saying in advance people may not get a reply if they don't meet the basics.

I consider myself an ideal candidate for the disabled rep but have never received a reply on 3 occasions.
Do I want to work for these people ....... No
I've already withdrawn my application.
 

Nick

Administrator
I consider myself an ideal candidate for the disabled rep but have never received a reply on 3 occasions.
Do I want to work for these people ....... No
I've already withdrawn my application.

This thread is about an events executive isn't it?
 

italiahorse

Well-Known Member
This thread is about an events executive isn't it?

Exactly.
But theres nothing wrong in discussing the detail in the vacancy write up, surely?

The positives on this is that the club now realise they can get incomes other than match day revenues.
Previously it was stated that the club was solely relying on match day incomes and other incomes were not available.
As I've previously said, you can generate many incomes using CCFC brand be it away from the Ricoh or as appears to be happening by hiring facilities at the Ricoh.
 

SkyBlueCRJ

Well-Known Member
Exactly.
Employers can help some applicants by just giving them some feedback.
Obviously just a standard dear John joint email to the obvious no chancers.

As I said I'm a little bit out of it but if thats the practice these days then it's a shame.

If they are realistic candidates I'd definitely agree with you but like Nick mentioned if the applicants are by no means qualified then the lack of a reply is hardly unprecedented - otherwise it's a waste of time for the individual who is in charge of applications as they're the ones sending out the replies. But for instance if you've gone for an interview and not received a response which has happened to a number of friends and colleagues of mine, then this is fairly bad taste.
 

Nick

Administrator
Exactly.
But theres nothing wrong in discussing the detail in the vacancy write up, surely?

The positives on this is that the club now realise they can get incomes other than match day revenues.
Previously it was stated that the club was solely relying on match day incomes and other incomes were not available.
As I've previously said, you can generate many incomes using CCFC brand be it away from the Ricoh or as appears to be happening by hiring facilities at the Ricoh.

The detail that people might not get a reply if they don't meet the basic requirements for the job? Basics to try and cut out timewasters.
 

italiahorse

Well-Known Member
The detail that people might not get a reply if they don't meet the basic requirements for the job? Basics to try and cut out timewasters.

Still wrong to me for the sake of copying an email address into an address line.
Some you can obviously just bin.
The essential criteria is subjective so a lot of potential good candidates will be waiting or checking their junk daily.
 

Nick

Administrator
Still wrong to me for the sake of copying an email address into an address line.
Some you can obviously just bin.
The essential criteria is subjective so a lot of potential good candidates will be waiting or checking their junk daily.

You have just contradicted yourself in the first 2 lines. Shock.
 

Covstu

Well-Known Member
If I applied for a role where I thought I didn't meet the basic requirements then I wouldn't expect a response however I would never apply in the first place. The volume of applications companies get these days is very high and normally you would either get the similar response (as above) or a blanket 'no thanks' generated from the job system.
Take a job like this, probably a great example of people who think they have the required skills and experience i.e. I have organised my works night out so I am qualified to people who potentially could do this role in corporate events (but probably not in a sporting arena) so they are bound to have a lot of applications.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top