Skyblueweeman
Well-Known Member
It took us half a season to get off 'McWanktys' back and then he started scoring for fun...
Amadou Bakayoko - Confirmed 2 Year Deal (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter junglej13
- Start date
It took us half a season to get off 'McWanktys' back and then he started scoring for fun...
D
Deleted member 5849
Guest
Let's hope so!
tbh I find utterly bizarre the 'let's give him X numnber of games and then judge'. It's such an arbitrary thing to do, suggests players can't go through dips and peaks of form... where would Rosario and Adebola be if we decided 10 games was the time to judge their entire city career?
Just what is wrong in pointing out his record at Walsall is pretty dire, his start with us has not been stunning, and asking why has he signed? That's totally different from not encouraging him on the day of a match, and totally different from hoping that somewhere there's a player bursting to get out.
D
Deleted member 5849
Guest
Alternatively, he started scoring, and those on his back then got off it.
It's apples and pears anyway. McNulty at least came with some kind of profile that encouraged, and was in position to miss chances. it was often said of Andy Cole he missed about seven chances to every one scored, but the point was he had a striker's instinct and intelligence to make the runs to be in position to miss said chances. Any striker that does that will eventually start scoring. If they don't have the instinct of a forward to get into those positions then it doesn't really matter how we play, the striker won't score as he won't open up the space to be found. It's not just the midfielders' responsibility to pass him the ball, it's the striker's responsibility to get into appropriate positions.
Do that, and there's always hope!
Nick
Administrator
He has got into positions when he has the ball at his feet. Plymouth and Wimbledon he got into decent positions and linked up well with Andreu.
Irish Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Bakayoko is no Cyrille Regis, but a comparison can be made in the fact that you won’t see the best of them if they are played in the wrong way. Sillett based his team plan on playing to Cyrille’s strengths and not playing him as a target man, a role that didn’t suit him, as had been done by the previous Coventry manager. Bakayoko obviously isn’t a target mam. He actually looked quite neat and tidy in his 5 minutes at Gillingham when the ball was played to his feet. He may turn out to be another Kevin Kyle but to write him off after a handful of games, particularly when he is a Robin’s signing is totally unfair.
Greggs
Well-Known Member
So? If 100 people had been to a restaurant that you've not been to and told you it's terrible, would you still go?
Greggs
Well-Known Member
Football is football, no matter the colour of the kit.....
fatso
Well-Known Member
Tbf City fans would go to that restaurant, agree that it was shit, but then go again once a fortnight anyway, believing that it must improve eventually!
Nick
Administrator
So every player is either rubbish or good for every team and can't do better for a different team?
Like I said, much easier to judge him once we play to his strengths for a few games
fatso
Well-Known Member
What are his strengths, I hear he does a good Elvis impression.
Greggs
Well-Known Member
No, talent is talent. I would say, as a neutral, it's fair to judge a player that has featured 100+ times at this precise level
Greggs
Well-Known Member
All whilst criticising others for their level of realism...
Nick
Administrator
It was pretty obvious from watching him so far, some were probably busy booing or shouting abuse though.
Otis
Well-Known Member
Greggs, post:
The restaurant comparison is a daft analogy.
Footballers regularly have good games and bad games and quiet games and two football matches are never the same.
You go to a restaurant you should be consistently getting the same level of service night after night. They may have the odd off day, but the two things are not at all comparable.
The restaurant comparison is a daft analogy.
Footballers regularly have good games and bad games and quiet games and two football matches are never the same.
You go to a restaurant you should be consistently getting the same level of service night after night. They may have the odd off day, but the two things are not at all comparable.
Otis
Well-Known Member
Yep, totally. That's why Louis Carey was player of the season and loved to bits at Bristol City but didn't pull up any trees at all here.
Greggs
Well-Known Member
Could still see his quailty though. He was homesick too. Plenty of variables, but talent usually shines through.
Greggs
Well-Known Member
But would you keep going to that poor restaurant on the premise that one day you might get a good meal??
Nick
Administrator
In which case McNulty would never have played again last season after his shockers.
Oh yeah "talent shines through" to try to make it different.
If we are going off walsall fans, they also seemed to think he wasn't a target man or a lone striker. Yet we chucked him there to do that.
We went round in circles the same last year about strikers.
Greggs
Well-Known Member
Ok, this one is a perhaps more relevant. Would you hire a prozzie, with terrible reviews from previous punters, on the premise that one day she might get her act together?
Otis
Well-Known Member
Yeah, agree on that and Bakayoko might well prove to be crap and I did question the decision when we got him, but let's at least try and play to his strengths before we totally dismiss him as a player for this club.
Greggs
Well-Known Member
For the record, i've dismissed nobody, i've learnt my lesson. I just like to balance opinions. 3 types of people on here, realists, optimists and pessimists. Just constant bickering between the 3
Nick
Administrator
Robins doesn't seem to know his style of play.
Why would we sign wing backs and play wing backs in pre season and then suddenly change?
Captain Dart
Well-Known Member
Bakayoko will be okay believe me as long as we play to his strengths, that’s his feet not his neck. He has pace galore, our forwards now have pace and perhaps more to come from Chaplin if signed, let’s give the bloke a break and reserve judgement for a couple of months
Otis
Well-Known Member
Stop talking bleedin sense for gawd's sake.
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
We didn’t sign wing backs to play 5-3-2 though. Brown has mostly played as a LB, and whilst Sterling plays wingback for Chelsea, doesn’t mean he isn’t also a RB (he’s said he’s slightly more comfortable at WB, but that’s it). To me, Robins was looking, and experimenting with a 5-3-2 formation. We know MR is a 4-2-3-1 or 4-4-2 manager. Personally, I didn’t think we was going to start the season off with a 5-3-2 shape, that was pretty obvious.
Otis
Well-Known Member
I totally agree on the number of games and I only use that thinking because when I say things like give him time, the reply from some is 'how much time? How much time should we give him'?
If I then come back with 'enough time' they then ask 'how much time is enough time'?
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
Oh dear oh dear
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
such a muppet
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
Lol Robins doesn't know his style of play.
Don't think any of his previous managers have.
I think I should put on my boots on and see how many games it takes to discover my strengths.
Nick
Administrator
You keep going on but you don't seem to be able to actually discuss things?
I was saying Robins doesn't know his own style of play, hence I then mentioned wingbacks.
It would pain some if he did well, it's embarrassing. Probably the type of pricks to boo their own players, cheer when they come off and then stand and applaud McSheffrey when he scores against us.
Grendel
Well-Known Member
Some would go 30 times and only on the 30th time find something worth eating. Same people soul write 30 positive reviews.
Same people at a different place give it bad reviews before they even get there
Otis
Well-Known Member
Don't be so harsh on yourself.