Otis
Well-Known Member
Yep. Kelly was very good today.
Player ratings (3 Viewers)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
Chaplin has been awful for since we bought him. But today agreed the other two strikers were awfull too.
Really cannot understand or comprehend Chaplins lack of. He offered zilch. Can’t hold the ball up. Offers zero goal threat. Can’t blame Robins for continuing to back him to the hilt. As obviously he’s one of his favourites not just because of the price tag.
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
A few overreactions on here, we played really well and should have won the game, it was certainly frustrating to watch. Previous Cov teams would have lost today and credit to how we responded and didn’t panic and eventually got the equaliser and continued to go for the win. The decision to start McCallum seems strange but he had played well off the bench and despite his dodgy clearance, we should’ve dealt with the corner.
Burge, 6 - made a decent save, and did all the routine stuff well. He wasn’t at fault for their goal.
Sterling, 6 - good performance but his crossing was bad today, second game running now.
Willis, 6 - should’ve done better at the corner, but aside from that defended well.
Hyam, 7 - same as Willis but he made up for it by dealing with their long balls with ease and totally nullifying his man.
McCallum, 5 - didn’t back up his promising substitute appearances. His dodgy clearance gave away the corner for their goal, but that should’ve been dealt with. Looked nervous throughout making pretty basic errors at times. His defending was good though so there are positives to take from today.
Thomas, 8 - 1st half he was a bit hesitant and tried to pass too much. Second half, he back himself and got the goal. More of that please!
Bayliss, 7 - absolute class to put Hiwula in at the end, and is so important for us in the final third.
Kelly, 7 - probably our most important player. Sounds like a strange claim, but he got several interceptions and tackles and minus the one blip (which nearly cost a goal), his distribution was v good.
Bright, 6 - made a lovely dribble in the box and laid it off to Hiwula instead of being selfish, the right decision, but Hiwula had a bad day today.
Chaplin, 6 - Thomas got the credit for the goal, but from my angle, it looked like Chaplin helped it in. Unlucky not to be credited in my view! Either way, had some good bits of link up play but other than that, not a lot went on for him.
Hiwula, 5 - should’ve done better with the half chance in the 1st half. I could forgive that, it was a right angle. The second chance Bayliss gave to him on a plate? Unforgivable and he knows it. He had so much time and just bottled it frankly. He’ll probably get dropped for that.
JCH, 6 - didn’t really get up to much today and wasn’t helped by our pretty bad crossing!
Burge, 6 - made a decent save, and did all the routine stuff well. He wasn’t at fault for their goal.
Sterling, 6 - good performance but his crossing was bad today, second game running now.
Willis, 6 - should’ve done better at the corner, but aside from that defended well.
Hyam, 7 - same as Willis but he made up for it by dealing with their long balls with ease and totally nullifying his man.
McCallum, 5 - didn’t back up his promising substitute appearances. His dodgy clearance gave away the corner for their goal, but that should’ve been dealt with. Looked nervous throughout making pretty basic errors at times. His defending was good though so there are positives to take from today.
Thomas, 8 - 1st half he was a bit hesitant and tried to pass too much. Second half, he back himself and got the goal. More of that please!
Bayliss, 7 - absolute class to put Hiwula in at the end, and is so important for us in the final third.
Kelly, 7 - probably our most important player. Sounds like a strange claim, but he got several interceptions and tackles and minus the one blip (which nearly cost a goal), his distribution was v good.
Bright, 6 - made a lovely dribble in the box and laid it off to Hiwula instead of being selfish, the right decision, but Hiwula had a bad day today.
Chaplin, 6 - Thomas got the credit for the goal, but from my angle, it looked like Chaplin helped it in. Unlucky not to be credited in my view! Either way, had some good bits of link up play but other than that, not a lot went on for him.
Hiwula, 5 - should’ve done better with the half chance in the 1st half. I could forgive that, it was a right angle. The second chance Bayliss gave to him on a plate? Unforgivable and he knows it. He had so much time and just bottled it frankly. He’ll probably get dropped for that.
JCH, 6 - didn’t really get up to much today and wasn’t helped by our pretty bad crossing!
Last edited:
lord_garrincha
Well-Known Member
In a similar vein... I did go... do I have to do ratings, because I don't want to!
Sky Blue Pete
Well-Known Member
Wtf !!! 2 just mad
Sky Blue Pete
Well-Known Member
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
Especially when you consider Hiwula missed 1 guilt edge chance and another good opportunity in the first...
To be rated lower than a 4, you need to have had an absolute stinker and be directly at fault for more than 1 goal as a defender/keeper. Karius in the the Champions League final springs to mind!
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
Really glad Chaplin being rat
Agreed and you get a like for rating Chaplin and MacCallum 4s.
Agreed and you get a like for rating Chaplin and MacCallum 4s.
Pete in Portugal
Well-Known Member
Well just to be clear, my ratings are nearly always based on watching on iFollow.
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
Burge 5
Sterling 7
Hyam 7
Willis 7
MacCallum 4....a bit too soon for young lad..Mason must injured.
Bright 7
Bayliss 7
Kelly 7
Thomas 7
Hiwula 5
Chaplin4
JCH 4
Dominated the game, but clearly lacking the final cutting edge and a natural goal scorer.
Lacking pace and a physical threat up front.
Demoralising to even think Chaplin will be upfront for us next season. We are just one good striker away from top 6.
Sterling 7
Hyam 7
Willis 7
MacCallum 4....a bit too soon for young lad..Mason must injured.
Bright 7
Bayliss 7
Kelly 7
Thomas 7
Hiwula 5
Chaplin4
JCH 4
Dominated the game, but clearly lacking the final cutting edge and a natural goal scorer.
Lacking pace and a physical threat up front.
Demoralising to even think Chaplin will be upfront for us next season. We are just one good striker away from top 6.
Johnnythespider
Well-Known Member
Chaplin gets 90 mins because if Robins drops him he also has to admit he's chucked 500,000 down the pan.
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
Has anybody else noticed...Robins was in post interview after Chaplins first month backed him post interview that he’s a natural goalscorer and will bang then in. Funny how he’s stopped verbally backing or bigging him up after dud performances.
Robins isn’t stupid he knows this lad isn’t 20 goal season in league 1 or any league.
rob9872
Well-Known Member
An early goal 8 men behind the ball and some big units. We tried but they let us have the ball and we were largely ineffectual. The forwards were poor, but apart from that golden opportunity at the end for Hiwula we didn't provide them with much. Willis Hyam Sterling Thomas the pick of them, as was Bayliss in parts. That said Wimbledon were dreadful and despite coming from behind it feels like a defeat.
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
Think it's Important to remember that if hiwula scores and we win the talk will be about how 1 of our strikers will alwaus pop up and get the goals we need between them on rotational basis
Fuck it now move on to next game and see what we can do.
Fuck it now move on to next game and see what we can do.
clint van damme
Well-Known Member
If anyone is unsure about how bonkers our support is just read the comments on Kelly in this thread!
Adge
Well-Known Member
Burge 6 Only gets 6 because he wasn’t tested by them to much so was anonymous but has got the jitters again when balls come into the box.
Sterling 7 Decent enough.
Willis 6 Apart from the goal was solid but hoofing to nowhere a lot of the time.
Hyam 6 Composed alongside Willis but neither really tested by the Wimbledon front men.
McCallum 4 Very nervous display and I think when he miscontrolled the first ball it played on his mind and another 3 or 4 followed.
Kelly 7 Man of the match. Had a another good game and I feel is very underrated.
Bayliss 7 Was at the forefront of most of our good play.
Bright 5 Mostly dark!
Thomas 7 Along with Bayliss was pivotal if we were going to get anything out of the game and got the goal which happens if you shoot!
Hiwula 4 An absolute stinker! Just has to put that chance away at the end-no excuses.
Chaplin 5 A bit better second half but that really is the only positive.
Subs-
JCH 5 Didn’t really get into the game as of late when he has came off the bench.
Grimmer N/a
Sterling 7 Decent enough.
Willis 6 Apart from the goal was solid but hoofing to nowhere a lot of the time.
Hyam 6 Composed alongside Willis but neither really tested by the Wimbledon front men.
McCallum 4 Very nervous display and I think when he miscontrolled the first ball it played on his mind and another 3 or 4 followed.
Kelly 7 Man of the match. Had a another good game and I feel is very underrated.
Bayliss 7 Was at the forefront of most of our good play.
Bright 5 Mostly dark!
Thomas 7 Along with Bayliss was pivotal if we were going to get anything out of the game and got the goal which happens if you shoot!
Hiwula 4 An absolute stinker! Just has to put that chance away at the end-no excuses.
Chaplin 5 A bit better second half but that really is the only positive.
Subs-
JCH 5 Didn’t really get into the game as of late when he has came off the bench.
Grimmer N/a
SkyBlueGreeny
Member
Agree with Willis Thomas bayliss and am a huge fan of sterling now he's found his feet but didn't think much of Kelly today give it away cheaply doesn't seem to want to turn on the ball or ever look to get us going forward I know that's more bayliss job but we were chasing the game from minute 2 and players like Kelly get found out in them situations
Nick
Administrator
Kelly hit the bar and forced a save from the keeper?
Legia Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Don't really get the Kelly love in from some He has played well in recent weeks but I thought he made quite a few basic errors today, while Bayliss was the star turn in midfield today making some quality passes in the danger area that our forwards should have taken better advantage of.
Burge - 6
Sterling - 6
Willis - 7
Hyam - 7
McCallum - 5
Thomas - 7
Kelly - 6
Bayliss - 8
Bright - 6
Hiwula - 4
Chaplin - 5
JCH - 5
Burge - 6
Sterling - 6
Willis - 7
Hyam - 7
McCallum - 5
Thomas - 7
Kelly - 6
Bayliss - 8
Bright - 6
Hiwula - 4
Chaplin - 5
JCH - 5
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
Kelly was only caught in possession once, iirc.
The difference in our play is night and day when he’s on the pitch. He’s hugely influential and I’d stick my neck out and say he’s our most important player*. He wins the ball a lot in midfield and that perhaps goes unnoticed by a lot of fans. In fact, after someone pointed out his stats on interceptions, I was far more aware of it today myself. If Hiwula sticks in that gilt edge chance and we win the game, everyone goes home happy and we all congratulate the team’s performance.
*this is not saying he’s our ‘best’ player, as that title belongs to Bayliss at the minute because since Boxing Day, he’s stepped up his game massively!
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
I’m surprised that Kelly is receiving a bit of stick, actually. I thought he played well and he keeps the team ticking. Meanwhile, Sterling recieved a few 7s because his crossing was off today. Thankfully, he’s a very reliable defender, but the last two games his delivery has been below his usual solid standards.
HerneBayGaz
Well-Known Member
Good assessment. I also thought Willis had a very good game and was my man of the match.
Pitch played a major part for the poor control of the ball. Didn't bother Wimbledon, They just lumped the ball forward at every opportunity.
Your right about young Sam thought he grew into the game after a nervous start. Defo got a big future in the game, hopefully with us.
The new loan signing 'Bright' showed some nice touches but definitely not match fit. But will be an asset.
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
He was poor today
Otis
Well-Known Member
Bit surprised at the 6 for Hiwula.
He missed three gilt-edged edge chances. And besides that he was quite anonymous I felt, but for those chances alone I think he has to be marked down substantially past an average score.
Chance 1: First half when he should have scored, but hit the ball quite weakly at the keeper, from only a few yards out.
Chance 2: Was put clean through on goal by Chaplin in the second half of and took a poor touch
Chance 3: An absolute sitter at the death.
stevefloyd
Well-Known Member
Yep he is
Kelly being rated a 4 ... wtf, did these people go to the game !!
up their for man of the match with Thomas, and by some margin, closing down balls, playing positive foward balls one minute then chasing back with defense the next to put pressure on their forward play
Yes we had a lot of the play for most the match , but so we should have, they were shocking! Should be beating teams like that by 3/4... and we would of if we dared to shoot!
That hiwula & bayliss fiasco at the end just about summed up our ability to shoot on goal. Great build up play and then totally flap it!
hiwula was woeful today
up their for man of the match with Thomas, and by some margin, closing down balls, playing positive foward balls one minute then chasing back with defense the next to put pressure on their forward play
Yes we had a lot of the play for most the match , but so we should have, they were shocking! Should be beating teams like that by 3/4... and we would of if we dared to shoot!
That hiwula & bayliss fiasco at the end just about summed up our ability to shoot on goal. Great build up play and then totally flap it!
hiwula was woeful today
Last edited:
Otis
Well-Known Member
Hiwula and Bayliss I think you mean don't you?
oops yes sorry, had Thomas on my mind for man of the match.
Best bit if business we have done this year is getting him in and keeping him for season. Threat every game.
GaryMabbuttsLeftKnee
Well-Known Member
He is so much better than Doyle in that role it’s crazy
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
Agreed.
I still like Doyle and think they could make an effective pair again if we get any injuries, but Doyle can’t be the main distributor in the the side anymore. He’s been caught out for at least 3 goals that I’ve seen. All games that were draws, or with Scunthorpe, we lost by the single goal. Mind you, Kelly has been caught out in a similar fashion twice (Luton and Wimbledon) and both went unpunished, thankfully.
Esoterica
Well-Known Member
Think Kelly suffered today in that before we scored it was 9 players on 5 whenever he looked up with the ball. There was also not much of an outlet on the left side. Bright was all over the place and Mccallum very shaky controlling the 30 yard switches Kelly is so good at. Was forced to go sideways today as the forward options were more limited so had to get the full backs involved more.
speedie87
Well-Known Member
Yep all fair points but at least he was getting chances I can’t stand forwards who never get themselves in the right place to score
clint van damme
Well-Known Member
And also man of the match in some of the ratings.