Player ratings (2 Viewers)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
superskyblue
Well-Known Member
Mainly 6s. 7 for Shipley. 8 for Willis and Hyam.
skyblueelephant76
Well-Known Member
Are you saying you'd give Kelly 6?
hinckley cov
Well-Known Member
Burge 6
Sterling 5
Mason 6
Willis 7
Hyam 5
Kelly 7
Baylis 4
Thomas 5
Bright 3
Jordy 6
Backa 5
Shipley 7
Sterling 5
Mason 6
Willis 7
Hyam 5
Kelly 7
Baylis 4
Thomas 5
Bright 3
Jordy 6
Backa 5
Shipley 7
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
Burge 6
Sterling 7
Willis 7
Hyam 7
Mason 6 (better second half)
Kelly 8
Bayliss 6
Bright 5
Thomas 6
Hiwula 6
Bakayoko 5
Subs
Shipley 7
Meyler 6
Wakefield 6
Sterling 7
Willis 7
Hyam 7
Mason 6 (better second half)
Kelly 8
Bayliss 6
Bright 5
Thomas 6
Hiwula 6
Bakayoko 5
Subs
Shipley 7
Meyler 6
Wakefield 6
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
What did Sterling or Hyam do wrong?
Winny the Bish
Well-Known Member
Burge 5
Sterling 5
Willis 7
Hyam 5
Mason 5
Kelly 7
Baylis 5
Thomas 4
Bright 5
Hiwula 6
Shipley 6
Sterling 5
Willis 7
Hyam 5
Mason 5
Kelly 7
Baylis 5
Thomas 4
Bright 5
Hiwula 6
Shipley 6
superskyblue
Well-Known Member
Thought he did well second half to make up for first half.
hinckley cov
Well-Known Member
Hyam lost his man for the goal and sterling was very quiet by his standards, and Baylis was poor also , he gave the ball away cheeply too many times
superskyblue
Well-Known Member
Was Kelly's man I thought.
cooperskyblue
Well-Known Member
Burge 7
Sterling 7
Willis 8
Hyam 7
Mason 6
Kelly 7
Bayliss 6
Hiwula 6
Thomas 5
Bright 4
Bakayoko 5
Shipley 7
Sterling 7
Willis 8
Hyam 7
Mason 6
Kelly 7
Bayliss 6
Hiwula 6
Thomas 5
Bright 4
Bakayoko 5
Shipley 7
hinckley cov
Well-Known Member
Well if it was it’s stupid midfield player marking centre half
GaryMabbuttsLeftKnee
Well-Known Member
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
Burge 5. Got a pt at end for saves but terrible overall
Mason 5 doesnt attack. Poor tehcnically. Lost man alot
Hyam and willis 9
Sterking 5 poor game surprisingly
Kelly 8 battled v well
Bayliss 6
Thomas 5 didnt happen 4 him. Poor control today
Hiwulla 6 good assist. No servkce to him 2nd half
Shipley 6 good finish. No attacking 2nd half which was predictable. Placebo effect to pretend we were more solid 2nd half. We Got dominated
Mason 5 doesnt attack. Poor tehcnically. Lost man alot
Hyam and willis 9
Sterking 5 poor game surprisingly
Kelly 8 battled v well
Bayliss 6
Thomas 5 didnt happen 4 him. Poor control today
Hiwulla 6 good assist. No servkce to him 2nd half
Shipley 6 good finish. No attacking 2nd half which was predictable. Placebo effect to pretend we were more solid 2nd half. We Got dominated
Pete in Portugal
Well-Known Member
Watched on Sky TV - a good hard won fight and generally another good team performance. Well done to our fans too.
Burge 5 - would've been 4 but for 2 good saves near the end
Sterling 6 - some wayward passing
Willis 8 - got through a lot of work and looked solid
Hyam 6 - with Burge, he was possibly culpable for their goal?
Mason 5 - was poor in first half and better in second half
Kelly 8 - another good performance
Bayliss 7 - was a handful at times and unlucky to be booked
Bright 5 - just looked a bit slow and off the pace today
Thomas 6 - struggled against tough defenders
Hiwula 6 - a bit anonymous, but a great pass to set up our goal
Bakayoko 6 - it was definitely a penalty
Subs
Shipley 7 - worked hard - good to see him score even if it was an easy goal
Meyler 6 - helped to mange the game towards the end
Wakefield 6 - showed a couple of glimpses of his pace
Burge 5 - would've been 4 but for 2 good saves near the end
Sterling 6 - some wayward passing
Willis 8 - got through a lot of work and looked solid
Hyam 6 - with Burge, he was possibly culpable for their goal?
Mason 5 - was poor in first half and better in second half
Kelly 8 - another good performance
Bayliss 7 - was a handful at times and unlucky to be booked
Bright 5 - just looked a bit slow and off the pace today
Thomas 6 - struggled against tough defenders
Hiwula 6 - a bit anonymous, but a great pass to set up our goal
Bakayoko 6 - it was definitely a penalty
Subs
Shipley 7 - worked hard - good to see him score even if it was an easy goal
Meyler 6 - helped to mange the game towards the end
Wakefield 6 - showed a couple of glimpses of his pace
pastythegreat
Well-Known Member
Burge 5. Pan hands, can't except that "he made a good save at the end". Was straight at him. Just luckily in the right place.
Sterling. 5. Not a very good game today. Piled through Hylton in the area late on and on another day could of conceded a penalty.
Willis. 8. Dealt with the best strikers in the league with ease today. Great 200th appearance.
Hyam. 6. Down from 7 for losing his man for their 1st. That said, a ball floating on the 6 yard box SHOULD be gobbled up by the keeper (as seen the last 2 week's).
Mason. 6. Done well defensively, still looks dreadful going forward though. So indecisive.
Thomas. 5. Don't think any forwards got into the game today. Mainly because when we got there the passing was so innacurate and weak.
Kelly. 5.5. Poor 1st half. Improved in the 2nd so up half a point.
Bayliss. 5. Same as above. Floated in and out of the game.
Hiwula. 5.5. Extra half a mark for the assist.
Bright. 5. Hardly even noticed he was on the pitch.
Shipley. 6. Marked up 1 for the goal but then disappeared like the rest of the forward line.
Baka. N/A. Should of won a penalty but did nothing else before he came off.
Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
Sterling. 5. Not a very good game today. Piled through Hylton in the area late on and on another day could of conceded a penalty.
Willis. 8. Dealt with the best strikers in the league with ease today. Great 200th appearance.
Hyam. 6. Down from 7 for losing his man for their 1st. That said, a ball floating on the 6 yard box SHOULD be gobbled up by the keeper (as seen the last 2 week's).
Mason. 6. Done well defensively, still looks dreadful going forward though. So indecisive.
Thomas. 5. Don't think any forwards got into the game today. Mainly because when we got there the passing was so innacurate and weak.
Kelly. 5.5. Poor 1st half. Improved in the 2nd so up half a point.
Bayliss. 5. Same as above. Floated in and out of the game.
Hiwula. 5.5. Extra half a mark for the assist.
Bright. 5. Hardly even noticed he was on the pitch.
Shipley. 6. Marked up 1 for the goal but then disappeared like the rest of the forward line.
Baka. N/A. Should of won a penalty but did nothing else before he came off.
Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
Liquid Gold
Well-Known Member
I think the points for the full backs are too low. I know neither of them were very adventurous today but they were part of a unit that kept Luton to few chances.
With Shipley lost 9 of 23, without lost 4 of 11. So the ratio of losses is worse with him in the team this season. While not an indication of much it does prove your point isn't entirely correct
hinckley cov
Well-Known Member
Just read the marks on telegraph website they gave bright and Thomas 8 !!! do they watch games or what
rob9872
Well-Known Member
Is that based on the games he played or when actually on the pitch? Also what's the points ratio. Thx in advance.
speedie87
Well-Known Member
Burge 4 goal his fault
Sterling 6 not his best game
Mason 5
Willis 7 would have been 8 but for than last min foul
Hyman 8
Kelly 8
Baylis 6 would be an 8 but just often loses the ball just poking it past players to no one
Bright 7 ran the game first half went awol second
Thomas 6 stop giving free kicks away man
Hiwula 6
Baka na
Shipley 7
Sterling 6 not his best game
Mason 5
Willis 7 would have been 8 but for than last min foul
Hyman 8
Kelly 8
Baylis 6 would be an 8 but just often loses the ball just poking it past players to no one
Bright 7 ran the game first half went awol second
Thomas 6 stop giving free kicks away man
Hiwula 6
Baka na
Shipley 7
eastwoodsdustman
Well-Known Member
We have a winner!
On the pitch as per your original statement. Points gained with him is slightly higher percentage but then he has only started 15 of those 23 games. For example at Charlton he played 1 minute when we won so could be argued that was a game played without him
Just done starts only. 15 starts 5 wins 3 draws 7 defeats. Sub appearances played only 152 minutes across 8 games. Therefore the stats based on starts only show 40% points won with him and 39% without. Depending how you count sub appearances it would be higher without him as 5 wins this season he has been on the pitch for a total of 68 minutes of these wins.
Last edited:
Nick
Administrator
Have to worry about anybody who has that all worked out ready for when somebody mentions Shipley.
What shoe size is he? Where does he live?
Took me 20 minutes after rob mentioned it. Shoe size between 4 and 12 lives in a house.
stevefloyd
Well-Known Member
They listen to Clive
Cov kid 55
Well-Known Member
Luton had won the last 19 games where they had taken the lead. They are unbeaten in 22(?) games. They are 5 points clear at the top of the league. They are vastly experienced compared to our team (on Sky, the commentator noted that we were like an under 23 team). I’m not surprised that we were dominated in an away game against a team that’s flying, but we stood up and didn’t lose. To me, that’s a positive.
Adge
Well-Known Member
Sorry mate you only get a 4 this week for reading the Telegraph site.