Appealing the red (12 Viewers)

[SkyBlueDom26]

Any ideas if we can appeal it?? Defiantly wasn't a foul let alone a red card!!! Fucking shite refereeing as usual

 

---

[ccfc92]

Any ideas if we can appeal it?? Defiantly wasn't a foul let alone a red card!!! Shocking officials as usual

I thought they changed the rules a couple of seasons ago, where if they gave a penalty, you no longer automatically receive a red card for a last man challenge?

 

[SkyBlueDom26]

I thought they changed the rules a couple of seasons ago, where if they gave a penalty, you no longer automatically receive a red card for a last man challenge?

Exactly, mate it was never a foul in a million years, its clearly shoulder to shoulder and the Rotherham player throws himself on the floor... should have been booked for diving

 

[Frostie]

Should only be a red now if deemed that it was a deliberate foul & not an honest attempt to play the ball. Red was harsh imo.

 

[ccfc92]

Exactly, mate it was never a foul in a million years, its clearly shoulder to shoulder and the Rotherham player throws himself on the floor... should have been booked for diving

Tbh, it was just a stinker of a performance all round. I wasn't surprised that two penalties and a red card given against us.

 

[SkyBlueDom26]

Tbh, it was just a stinker of a performance all round. I wasn't surprised that two penalties and a red card given against us.

4th goal completely summed the game up!

 

[ajsccfc]

I wouldn't appeal as it'd be forcing someone to watch our defending which seems cruel, ideally all footage of Saturday would be incinerated.

 

[SkyBlueDom26]

I wouldn't appeal as it'd be forcing someone to watch our defending which seems cruel, ideally all footage of Saturday would be incinerated.

We need him back alongside rose for Sunday though... thats the partnership that was working best

 

[Magwitch]

Trouble is if we appeal and it’s rejected don’t they increase the ban by a game.

 

[cc84cov]

Hopefully he don’t win the appeal we don’t need anymore of that crap next game

 

[cc84cov]

We need him back alongside rose for Sunday though... thats the partnership that was working best

Hyam is the best centre back at the club mate he is ahead of McFadz for me

 

[SkyBlueDom26]

Hyam is the best centre back at the club mate he is ahead of McFadz for me

Hyam is excellent but the partnership of Rose and Mcfadz was working the best

 

[SkyBlueDom26]

Hopefully he don’t win the appeal we don’t need anymore of that crap next game

Harsh, he's been our best defender up until Saturday.... Hyam had a shocker too giving them the 4th goal

 

[fernandopartridge]

It was a foul, it was a deliberate attempt to stop the player. Pointless appealing.

 

[SkyBlueDom26]

It was a foul, it was a deliberate attempt to stop the player. Pointless appealing.

It was literally shoulder to shoulder which i thought was allowed in football! He didn't push into him or trip him up!! One of the worst decisions I've seen

 

[larry_david]

My rotherham season ticket friend in front of their goal said they were howling with laughter that the pen got given and he got sent off. Said it was neither. They also howled at how dogshit mcfadz was but that's a fair assessment

 

[no_loyalty]

If it's a one game ban then probably not worth appealing it.

 

[skybluegod]

Robins said on the radio after that we can't appeal

 

[ccfc92]

Robins said on the radio after that we can't appeal

Why?

 

[pastythegreat]

Why?

Because if we win, we'll have to play him on the tele where the whole country will see!

Sent from my SM-N960F using Tapatalk

 

[better days]

If it's a one game ban then probably not worth appealing it.

If the ref said it was a professional foul to stop a goal-scoring opportunity then it's just a one game ban

 

[speedie87]

Only seen once on tv and looked like he deliberately tripped him so that would make it a red as not trying to play ball.

 

[better days]

Only seen once on tv and looked like he deliberately tripped him so that would make it a red as not trying to play ball.

Could still be a one game ban
Violent or dangerous play is a 3 game ban, dissent is 2 games

 

[cc84cov]

Harsh, he's been our best defender up until Saturday.... Hyam had a shocker too giving them the 4th goal

Agree he looked better with Rose but he’s been making mistakes most games his passing is woeful at times he give them 2 goals Saturday 1 against Pompey it’s not good enough mate Hyam & Rose I hope will become our pairing.

 

[skybluesam66]

Robins said on the radio after that we can't appeal

he only said that because he thought it was 2 yellows . he didnt realise it was a straight red

 

[AStonesThrow]

Swear most referees/linesman forget it's a contact sport. Next thing you know we'll have tag football

 

[KeresleyArmpit]

He needs a stadium ban for a few games regardless of whether he’s suspended or not.

 

[Wyken Sky Blue]

It was a foul and he was last man. It wad a red card.

Move on.

Sent from my G8441 using Tapatalk

 

[Skybluefaz]

It was a foul and he was last man. It wad a red card.

Move on.

Sent from my G8441 using Tapatalk

You might want to read the rules

 

[SBAndy]

You might want to read the rules

He’s right though. As McFadz didn’t attempt to play the ball it had to be a red. The ‘double jeopardy’ ruling only applies if it is felt the foul is a result of a genuine attempt to play the ball.

 

[fatso]

On that performance I’d appeal for a longer ban!

 

[OffenhamSkyBlue]

The art of the "shoulder to shoulder" challenge has been lost in recent years (or certainly the ability to referee it has). Most of the time, it is one player barging the other off the ball with the shoulder, which is a foul. There is no benefit for the attacking player to try and win the ball by going for a shoulder to shoulder, as if they fall over in response to a shoulder barge, they'll get a free kick or penalty.

 

[Mild-Mannered Janitor]

Trouble is if we appeal and it’s rejected don’t they increase the ban by a game.

That could be a positive......

 

[Skybluefaz]

He’s right though. As McFadz didn’t attempt to play the ball it had to be a red. The ‘double jeopardy’ ruling only applies if it is felt the foul is a result of a genuine attempt to play the ball.

Yeah but that's not what was said was it. It isn't simply last man + foul = red anymore.

 

[skyblueelephant76]

It was literally shoulder to shoulder which i thought was allowed in football! He didn't push into him or trip him up!! One of the worst decisions I've seen

He pushed him clearly with his left arm, it was no where near shoulder to shoulder. It was a clear pen and sending off.