McFadzean (3 Viewers)

robbiekeane

Well-Known Member
Just saw the FGR highlights and saw he missed his pen. I mean...noone really gives a shit about that competition but he's had an absolute stinker of a couple of weeks and that will probably not have made it better for him.

Interested to see how he bounces back, a real test of character. Hope he smashes it!
 

Sky Blue Harry H

Well-Known Member
Played ok last night (a miss in a penalty shoot out shouldn't really be held against him - especially in this competition; Champions League final - different!)
 
Last edited:

AFCCOVENTRY

Well-Known Member
Think some time out to reflect will be good. Unless Hyam and Rose have a mare in the next few games he won’t walk back into the team and will need to prove himself.
 

stevefloyd

Well-Known Member
He had a decent enough game last night lets not forget Hyam had s stinker when we lost 6-1 a couple of seasons back and he is rated now so lets not give up on him just yet
 

1ccfc

Well-Known Member
I might be wrong, but I'm pretty sure he wasn't signed for his penalty taking! He took the 9th penalty so I don't think we can hold it against him too much. After the first few games you'd think we signed John Terry, now after a bad game or two he should be dropped? I think he does add experience and that physical presence needed in league one. And that's it, we are in league one where players are not always consistent. As you go up the leagues it's not just ability but consistency. We have all seen players in league one dominate a game but go missing for the next 5.
 

SkyBlueDom26

Well-Known Member
I might be wrong, but I'm pretty sure he wasn't signed for his penalty taking! He took the 9th penalty so I don't think we can hold it against him too much. After the first few games you'd think we signed John Terry, now after a bad game or two he should be dropped? I think he does add experience and that physical presence needed in league one. And that's it, we are in league one where players are not always consistent. As you go up the leagues it's not just ability but consistency. We have all seen players in league one dominate a game but go missing for the next 5.
Literally, his experience is vital to the team!!! He's deffo been our best defender so far this season, just wish he'd cleared it instead of pissing around twice Saturday
 

Sky Blue Harry H

Well-Known Member
He had a decent enough game last night lets not forget Hyam had s stinker when we lost 6-1 a couple of seasons back and he is rated now so lets not give up on him just yet

They only thrashed us 6-2, not 6-1 (if you mean Yeovil!)
 

rob9872

Well-Known Member
I was more surprised that he took one so late rather than actually missing. He was the pantomime villain to the FGR fans after a couple of minor skirmishes, so it was all set up for him to miss really, but as an experienced senior player, in a fairly meaningless competition, I'd like to have seen him take responsibility a little sooner. Perhaps not in the 5 if he's not so proficient (although any player should really fancy his chances in a shoot out) but perhaps in at eg 6th.

He took some unnecessary flak before that, I guess due to the last couple of mediocre performances, but although FGR didn't offer much by way of an attacking threat, he was far from the worst player on our team last night. The front three were woeful. I wont hang some of the kids out as they're still learning at this level, but Baka really should have taken this chance to stake a claim and he was again dreadful. I also expected Kelly to boss the middle and dictate the play in there, but he looked a bit short at times. Wakefield before his injury (made of glass!) offered very little and I fail to see what he adds, I can't see him being here past this season unless he really steps up. Zain was probably the pick of the bunch in the middle and Wilson did nothing wrong in goal, but I'd like to have seen a few banging on the door to try and be included Sunday.
 

SkyBlueDom26

Well-Known Member
I was more surprised that he took one so late rather than actually missing. He was the pantomime villain to the FGR fans after a couple of minor skirmishes, so it was all set up for him to miss really, but as an experienced senior player, in a fairly meaningless competition, I'd like to have seen him take responsibility a little sooner. Perhaps not in the 5 if he's not so proficient (although any player should really fancy his chances in a shoot out) but perhaps in at eg 6th.

He took some unnecessary flak before that, I guess due to the last couple of mediocre performances, but although FGR didn't offer much by way of an attacking threat, he was far from the worst player on our team last night. The front three were woeful. I wont hang some of the kids out as they're still learning at this level, but Baka really should have taken this chance to stake a claim and he was again dreadful. I also expected Kelly to boss the middle and dictate the play in there, but he looked a bit short at times. Wakefield before his injury (made of glass!) offered very little and I fail to see what he adds, I can't see him being here past this season unless he really steps up. Zain was probably the pick of the bunch in the middle and Wilson did nothing wrong in goal, but I'd like to have seen a few banging on the door to try and be included Sunday.
How can he be the worst player? I'd say the attacking players played worse considering we scored no goals but kept a clean sheet
 

rob9872

Well-Known Member
How can he be the worst player? I'd say the attacking players played worse considering we scored no goals but kept a clean sheet
"he was far from the worst player on our team last night"

It helps to read it properly :)
 

Dickie

Well-Known Member
We just need to play to his strengths. He’s not John Stones and if he doesn’t like the ball played to him under pressure then we shouldn’t.
 

skyblueelephant76

Well-Known Member
I was more surprised that he took one so late rather than actually missing. He was the pantomime villain to the FGR fans after a couple of minor skirmishes, so it was all set up for him to miss really, but as an experienced senior player, in a fairly meaningless competition, I'd like to have seen him take responsibility a little sooner. Perhaps not in the 5 if he's not so proficient (although any player should really fancy his chances in a shoot out) but perhaps in at eg 6th.

He took some unnecessary flak before that, I guess due to the last couple of mediocre performances, but although FGR didn't offer much by way of an attacking threat, he was far from the worst player on our team last night. The front three were woeful. I wont hang some of the kids out as they're still learning at this level, but Baka really should have taken this chance to stake a claim and he was again dreadful. I also expected Kelly to boss the middle and dictate the play in there, but he looked a bit short at times. Wakefield before his injury (made of glass!) offered very little and I fail to see what he adds, I can't see him being here past this season unless he really steps up. Zain was probably the pick of the bunch in the middle and Wilson did nothing wrong in goal, but I'd like to have seen a few banging on the door to try and be included Sunday.
He was in the 5 against Walsall and took a terrible penalty so no surprise he was low down the list.

It was more of a surprise that Kastaneer didn't take one.
 

LilleSkyBlue

Well-Known Member
We just need to play to his strengths. He’s not John Stones and if he doesn’t like the ball played to him under pressure then we shouldn’t.

I saw John Stones playing for England against the Netherlands in June - didn't he give away two goals by doing what McFadzean does?

Otherwise I agree with you. I wish McFadzean would just launch it.
 

ccfc1234

Well-Known Member
Literally, his experience is vital to the team!!! He's deffo been our best defender so far this season, just wish he'd cleared it instead of pissing around twice Saturday
I am not sure our most error prone defender who has given away a few penalties and also got away with some dodgy play at the back can be put ahead of Mason who has been excellent this season and has significantly improved his game.
 

Greggs

Well-Known Member
It's a bit easier to forgive mistakes from youngsters, knowing they'll most likely improve. But mistakes from an aging centre back are slightly different!
 

cc84cov

Well-Known Member
It's a bit easier to forgive mistakes from youngsters, knowing they'll most likely improve. But mistakes from an aging centre back are slightly different!
Worrying a few games he’s looked solid but always looks to have a mistake in him
 

Greggs

Well-Known Member
Like an age old pet going senile?
giphy.gif
 

TTG

Well-Known Member

cc84cov

Well-Known Member
Yeah I agree, but John Stones is a decent player, likes playing out from the back
The reason he’s not playing for England is he’s made too many mistakes doing what McFadz does...both are not good at it
 

Magwitch

Well-Known Member
McFadz had a poor game v Rotherham, it happens, wasn’t on his own. Lets all move on, as for missing a pen in a shoot out so what, so do called world superstars do that.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top