I’ve been thinking this since I was 24!
I’m not one generally for “isn’t the world going to hell”, but I do think there’s been clear changes in approaches to children that harm a lot of working class communities. A move to a parenting style that they are not familiar with and have no support in maintaining.
Also even before I taught I felt that one disruptive kids “right to education” shouldn’t trump the rights of the other 30 in the room.
I especially agree with the last sentence. Decent kids suffer an don't achieve as much as they could because the time is spent disproportionately dealing with those that are disruptive.
It's always been a problem, esp with Tories, that their experience of education is often very different to the norm so their ability to understand and provide education for those from other backgrounds is hampered. You can esp see this in those that were privately educated in boarding school as they've changed the testing to end-of-year exams rather than continual assessment and there are a number who think Latin should be back on the curriculum because that classical education is what made them the success they are. It's not - it's the contacts made that makes the biggest difference.
Trouble is now an increasing number of those on the left are also going through private education making the problem even worse.
As I've said before an increasing effort needs to be made to try and offer as broad a range of subjects as possible so kids can find something of interest to them and those non-academically minded aren't alienated by education and are less likely to be troublesome as they find something they can engage in. If that's vocational or physical so be it - not everyone is a STEM genius. See the two as equal paths to success in the future, not two tiered of clever/not clever.
Of course there will still be a handful that will just be a pain in the arse and someone above mentioned some sort of military based boot camp school. I'm not a fan of national service at all but a no-nonsense environment similar to the military could well help as a last resort, three strikes and you're out, sort of deal for the most unruly. Run by ex-servicemen/women it wouldn't be part of the armed forces so not like they're being 'foisted upon them'.