Player Ratings via QPR (3 Viewers)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
skybluesam66
Well-Known Member
All 7 except
Godden Giles and o hare 8
dabo 2nd half 8
Godden Giles and o hare 8
dabo 2nd half 8
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
Marosi 7
Dabo 9
Mcfafz 8
Hyam 8
Osrigaard 8
Giles 8
Hamer 8
Shipley 7
Allen 6
O hare 9
Godden 9
Dabo 9
Mcfafz 8
Hyam 8
Osrigaard 8
Giles 8
Hamer 8
Shipley 7
Allen 6
O hare 9
Godden 9
Last edited:
Blind-Faith
Well-Known Member
Marosi 7
Dabo 8
Giles 9
Mcfafz 7
Hyam 7
Osrigaard 7
Hamer 8
Shipley 5
Allen 5
O hare 9
Godden 8
Dabo 8
Giles 9
Mcfafz 7
Hyam 7
Osrigaard 7
Hamer 8
Shipley 5
Allen 5
O hare 9
Godden 8
HuckerbyDublinWhelan
Well-Known Member
Marosi 6
Dabo 8
Ostigard 7
McFadzean 7
Hyam 7
Giles 8
Shipley 5
Hamer 6
O’Hare 8
Allen 7
Godden 7 (felt for him - had one chance all night - he took it!)
Dabo 8
Ostigard 7
McFadzean 7
Hyam 7
Giles 8
Shipley 5
Hamer 6
O’Hare 8
Allen 7
Godden 7 (felt for him - had one chance all night - he took it!)
Harry_Walker
Well-Known Member
First half all were 2’s and 3’s apart from the goal.
overall:
Marosi 6
Ostigard 6
McFadz 6
Hyam 6
Dabo 8
Hamer 7
Shipley 5
Giles 9
O’Hare 8
Allen 5
Godden 7
Probably a bit harsh on the centre halves but I don’t appreciate the mini heart attack every time we try and play out from the back. Think Shipley and Allen out of their depth at this level despite us winning today. Second half was a very good performance as even tho they controlled possession I never felt threatened (similarly to Bristol City last week). Thought the wing backs is what gave us the edge over them as both were phenomenal today
overall:
Marosi 6
Ostigard 6
McFadz 6
Hyam 6
Dabo 8
Hamer 7
Shipley 5
Giles 9
O’Hare 8
Allen 5
Godden 7
Probably a bit harsh on the centre halves but I don’t appreciate the mini heart attack every time we try and play out from the back. Think Shipley and Allen out of their depth at this level despite us winning today. Second half was a very good performance as even tho they controlled possession I never felt threatened (similarly to Bristol City last week). Thought the wing backs is what gave us the edge over them as both were phenomenal today
Marosi - 7 Distribution excellent, whether long or short
Dabo - 7 Such a fun player to watch
Hyam - 7 If you don't really notice him, he's usually doing well
McFadzean - 7 Clumsy for the penalty (though I think it was harsh), made up for it
Ostigard - 6 Looks comfortable on the ball but still learning the system
Giles - 7 All he does is cross....and it's great
Hamer - 7 Like Liam Walsh who's just hit the flashing star power-up in Mario
Shipley - 6 Could someone explain to him how to defend back post corners
Allen - 7 Tired near the end but such an under-rated part of our side
O'Hare - 8 If he keeps this up, he'll be in the Premier League soon
Godden - 7 Drifted in and out of the game as usual, but can be a real handful
Dabo - 7 Such a fun player to watch
Hyam - 7 If you don't really notice him, he's usually doing well
McFadzean - 7 Clumsy for the penalty (though I think it was harsh), made up for it
Ostigard - 6 Looks comfortable on the ball but still learning the system
Giles - 7 All he does is cross....and it's great
Hamer - 7 Like Liam Walsh who's just hit the flashing star power-up in Mario
Shipley - 6 Could someone explain to him how to defend back post corners
Allen - 7 Tired near the end but such an under-rated part of our side
O'Hare - 8 If he keeps this up, he'll be in the Premier League soon
Godden - 7 Drifted in and out of the game as usual, but can be a real handful
SkyBlueGuy
Well-Known Member
Never do these but here's my two cents:
Marosi - 6 didn't have all that much to do. Didn't mess about when under pressure. Not much he could do about either goal.
Giles - 7 would have been higher, but I feel he faded in the second half. Great crosses though!
Ostigard - 6 mostly assured but still bedding into the system
Hyam - 6 some great play at times, but also had a couple of mad moments
McFadzean - 6/7 was a bit of a soft penalty, but not sure he needed to commit to it there. Scored the winner to make up for it. Calm under pressure.
Dabo - 6/7 quiet in the first half and playing quite deep. Brilliant in the second half. Much more like himself and beating 3 men to set up O'Hare was great.
Hamer - 6 a quieter performance but some flashes of real quality
Shipley - 5/6 seemed out of the game at times and nearly gave the ball away a bit too often. Kept going in typical Shipley fashion.
Allen - 6 some good passes and kept running. Tried a few things which just didn't quite come off. Again, kept running for the whole game.
O'Hare - 8 great performance. So many great touches and close control. Well taken goal and kept winning the ball back high up the pitch. Motm for me.
Godden - 6/7 steady performance. Very good positioning for the goal. Offside a little to often, but he plays his role really well and creates space for the two behind him.
Marosi - 6 didn't have all that much to do. Didn't mess about when under pressure. Not much he could do about either goal.
Giles - 7 would have been higher, but I feel he faded in the second half. Great crosses though!
Ostigard - 6 mostly assured but still bedding into the system
Hyam - 6 some great play at times, but also had a couple of mad moments
McFadzean - 6/7 was a bit of a soft penalty, but not sure he needed to commit to it there. Scored the winner to make up for it. Calm under pressure.
Dabo - 6/7 quiet in the first half and playing quite deep. Brilliant in the second half. Much more like himself and beating 3 men to set up O'Hare was great.
Hamer - 6 a quieter performance but some flashes of real quality
Shipley - 5/6 seemed out of the game at times and nearly gave the ball away a bit too often. Kept going in typical Shipley fashion.
Allen - 6 some good passes and kept running. Tried a few things which just didn't quite come off. Again, kept running for the whole game.
O'Hare - 8 great performance. So many great touches and close control. Well taken goal and kept winning the ball back high up the pitch. Motm for me.
Godden - 6/7 steady performance. Very good positioning for the goal. Offside a little to often, but he plays his role really well and creates space for the two behind him.
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Pretty much this. Allen bothers me. I said today I can’t remember watching a game and coming away saying “Allen played really well today”, and he’s the only player I can say that for. This isn’t slating him, he’s a decent player, but doesn’t seem to excel in anything.
Sky Blue Pete
Well-Known Member
Absolutely agree! Out of position he was excellent second half.
stupot07
Well-Known Member
Martin180
Well-Known Member
Marosi - 7 didn’t have a lot to do , no chance with either goal . Made a couple of good saves and distribution was as usual excellent
Giles - 7 first half brought us back into the game , second half faded slightly , makes the odd wrong choice but will improve the more he plays
Hyam / Ostigard/ McFadzean - 7.5 Compliment each other very well and each has their strengths , clumsy challenge for the penalty and miscommunication for the second goal . Can see this being the starting 3 when fit
Dabo - 8 very quiet first half but immense second half , very close to MOtM
Hamer -8 he is going to be very good , reads the game well , holds his position well and sees a pass early and keeps the tempo high
Shipley - 8 absolutely ran his socks off , made some crucial challenges and dovetailed with Hamer brilliantly . He does still make mistakes but he’s 22 and still improving
Allen - 6.5 his movement and workrate was brilliant but his touch tonight let him down at times and his decision making was poor too
O ‘ Hare -9 what a player we have , love his application , work rate , skill and great touch for his goal
Godden - 8 He isn’t going to struggle in this division , his game suits our style of play . Great movement for the goal and great movement throughout bringing others into the game
Giles - 7 first half brought us back into the game , second half faded slightly , makes the odd wrong choice but will improve the more he plays
Hyam / Ostigard/ McFadzean - 7.5 Compliment each other very well and each has their strengths , clumsy challenge for the penalty and miscommunication for the second goal . Can see this being the starting 3 when fit
Dabo - 8 very quiet first half but immense second half , very close to MOtM
Hamer -8 he is going to be very good , reads the game well , holds his position well and sees a pass early and keeps the tempo high
Shipley - 8 absolutely ran his socks off , made some crucial challenges and dovetailed with Hamer brilliantly . He does still make mistakes but he’s 22 and still improving
Allen - 6.5 his movement and workrate was brilliant but his touch tonight let him down at times and his decision making was poor too
O ‘ Hare -9 what a player we have , love his application , work rate , skill and great touch for his goal
Godden - 8 He isn’t going to struggle in this division , his game suits our style of play . Great movement for the goal and great movement throughout bringing others into the game
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Im hoping Bapaga can make a quick recovery. He’s raw but very O’Hare like and will break those lines. Still really to see what Hilßner does. I suspect he’s been brought in to be a better Shipley in that AM role. I think that’s the idea for the non O’Hare role is a player picking passes and taking shots from the edge of the box.
I want whatever hip operation Dabo had. What an engine considering having no pre-season!
Marosi 7 ( Happy that he didn't take risks)
Dabo 9 (love watching him play)
Giles 8 (best player first half. Top cross for goal)
Ostigard 8 (fitting in well. Strong in the air)
McFadzean 8 (great character and good goal)
Hyam 8 (solid as usual)
Hamer 9 (hard working, better discipline and what a great corner taker)
Shipley 7 ( not natural position and did much better than last week. Thought he might have been subbed earlier but to be fair he did well for the last period of the game)
O'Hare 9 (motm. What a great combination to have a young player with a balance of grit and quality)
Allen 7 (Did some good stuff but was chasing shadows first half but then was involved in 1st goal)
Godden 8 (held the ball up well, worked hard but sensibly and movement for goal was great)
Sooo happy! What a great result.
Marosi 7 ( Happy that he didn't take risks)
Dabo 9 (love watching him play)
Giles 8 (best player first half. Top cross for goal)
Ostigard 8 (fitting in well. Strong in the air)
McFadzean 8 (great character and good goal)
Hyam 8 (solid as usual)
Hamer 9 (hard working, better discipline and what a great corner taker)
Shipley 7 ( not natural position and did much better than last week. Thought he might have been subbed earlier but to be fair he did well for the last period of the game)
O'Hare 9 (motm. What a great combination to have a young player with a balance of grit and quality)
Allen 7 (Did some good stuff but was chasing shadows first half but then was involved in 1st goal)
Godden 8 (held the ball up well, worked hard but sensibly and movement for goal was great)
Sooo happy! What a great result.
Some really good performances. I know a few still don’t rate him but thought Shipley did well tonight. Come on leaps and bounds. Lot of nice touches on the ball and his defensive positioning was a lot better. Dabo brilliant second half but Giles and O’hare the difference. Those two will be key this year.
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
He seems to be caught in void of league 1 and championship. Still very early in season though. He did some alright stuff
Last edited:
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Spot on for me
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
He was very good at Bristol last season...to be honest he's actually played very little for us
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Yeah he always does alright stuff, I dunno just feel he never impacts games like you want your AM to do.
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
This is a fair point.
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
Legend says covcity4life is always right!
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
Godden has been one of the biggest pluses , his hold up play and link up play and energy simply brilliant doing it a higher level.. He looks like a seasoned championship striker. Getting better and better.
Absolutely. I must admit I doubted he’d be a threat this year. What he lacks in pace he makes up for in movement. Very clever player and will score goals with O’hare behind him.
johnwillomagic
Well-Known Member
How someone can say second goal was Shipley's fault is beyond me ,,,,sorry to spoil the Dabo love in but that goal was his fault got sucked in under the ball lost his man and headed it badly and off of Ostigaard's head when he would clearly have headed it comfortably clear but hey why let the facts get in the way of targetting a boo boy eh SBT?
mark82
Super Moderator
You lucky boy! Great second half.
johnwillomagic
Well-Known Member
That being said still buzzing and that three points should give us some confidence which was much needed judging by our sub par first half.
Great to see Dabo back he was to blame fro second goal and had a below par first half but has been out a long time second half was more like the Dabo we know and love.
Great to see Dabo back he was to blame fro second goal and had a below par first half but has been out a long time second half was more like the Dabo we know and love.
johnwillomagic
Well-Known Member
Marosi 7
Dabo 7.5
Giles 7.5
Fadz 7
Hyam 6.5
Osgaard 6
Shipley 6
Hamer 7
Allen 6
O'Hare 8 MOTM
Godden 7
Result: 8.5
Great three points boost confidence surely but still lots to work on!
Dabo 7.5
Giles 7.5
Fadz 7
Hyam 6.5
Osgaard 6
Shipley 6
Hamer 7
Allen 6
O'Hare 8 MOTM
Godden 7
Result: 8.5
Great three points boost confidence surely but still lots to work on!
mark82
Super Moderator
The sudden turning on Shipley is bizarre. I don't understand it one bit. Have to remember he's still young and developing too. He's only 22, seems like he's been around forever.