Hamer vs Walsh (7 Viewers)

[cc84cov]

Fuck it I’m calling it right now Hamer is ahead of Walsh for me...probably too early to compare agreed but what a player Hamer is the club have done remarkably well to get this lad in.

 

---

[SlowerThanPlatt]

Oh dear. Why is there a need to compare players all the time?

 

[Evo1883]

Defensively hamer
Attacking Walsh

Passing hamer
Discipline Walsh

Tough one.

they are different players entirely by the looks of it

I abstain

 

[clint van damme]

just grateful that after losing one we were able to bring the other one in.

 

[Sky_Blue_Ste]

Way too early to judge

Took Walsh a good while to settle early doors

 

[Grendel]

Isaias was a genius for 3 games and rapidly turned into Ashley Grimes

 

[Mucca Mad Boys]

Too early to judge, but I’ve gone with Hamer. If it was possible, I’d love to see Walsh play alongside him as that would offer perfect balance. Praying he doesn’t sign a contract for us to poach him in Jan or in the summer.

Until we see Walsh in the Championship, it’s comparing apples and pears. Personally, I thought Hamer was the best midfielder on the pitch when we played Bristol - so it’d be interesting to see how much game time Walsh gets.

 

[stupot07]

They are very different players. I dont think you can compare.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

 

[Londonccfcfan]

Fuck it I’m calling it right now Hamer is ahead of Walsh for me...probably too early to compare agreed but what a player Hamer is the club have done remarkably well to get this lad in.

Hardly a big call.

 

[Mucca Mad Boys]

They are very different players. I dont think you can compare.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

It also reflects the fact that we’re probably going to have to play slightly differently than we did last season.

 

[Hobo]

It is simple
Hamer plays for Coventry
Walsh plays for Bristol.

I would always back the player in our squad to win the shirt over a player with a different team.

 

[lord_garrincha]

Isaias was a genius for 3 games and rapidly turned into Ashley Grimes

With Telfer 'Messi-like'... The Scum then say Blackburn are bidding £3.5m... then he became 'Telfer-like' until he retired!

 

[lord_garrincha]

When a woman goes to a date's home after a lovely meal... To find that the weirdo freak still has multiple pics of his ex.

'We' are that weirdo freak!!!

 

[KersleyDigs]

Will reserve judgement until i have seen Walsh for a few games at this level

 

[Sick Boy]

They’re different players and we’re yet to see Walsh play at this level.

 

[cc84cov]

They’re different players and we’re yet to see Walsh play at this level.

Could you imagine what Hamer would of done to teams in league one

 

[Blind-Faith]

If he keeps getting stupid bookings like he did today, then Walsh for me.

Hamer looks great , but if he’s going to be missing 4/5 games a season through idiotic suspensions then we are going to miss out.

 

[Sky_Blue_Dreamer]

Apart from being irrelevant as it's not a choice we have to make they could actual compliment each other as even though they play in the same sort of position and have some similarities they also have a lot of complimentary aspects and in an ideal world, other than the lack of height, it'd be great to see the two alongside each other at the base of the box.

Frankly we may as well have a poll saying Marosi or Godden - who's better?

 

[sw88]

Too early to judge, but I’ve gone with Hamer. If it was possible, I’d love to see Walsh play alongside him as that would offer perfect balance. Praying he doesn’t sign a contract for us to poach him in Jan or in the summer.

Until we see Walsh in the Championship, it’s comparing apples and pears. Personally, I thought Hamer was the best midfielder on the pitch when we played Bristol - so it’d be interesting to see how much game time Walsh gets.

Agreed

 

[lordy_87]

Hamer is bossing games in the Championship despite only just joining from another country. Walsh was class at league one level but hasn't done anything in the championship (granted he hasn't been given many opportunities). So for me it's Hamer, can you imagine how good he's going to be after a few months, for me he could easily slot in to a decent premiership team, his set peices, passing and vision are superb.

 

[BornSlippySkyBlue]

Could you imagine what Hamer would of done to teams in league one

Might find out next season!

 

[HuckerbyDublinWhelan]

One thing I will say, if our defenders could direct headers correctly Hamer would be a god right now with about 7 assists.

we had 3 free headers against QPR and a couple against Beistol

 

[NortonSkyBlue]

Hardly a big call.

Your judgement is questionable. I appreciate for some Hamer has become the sacred cow but a season of Walsh can’t be airbrushed away so flippantly. Walsh proved himself as the standout midfielder in league one and it is much too early to say the Hamer is going to be the player of the same or bigger influence than Walsh.

 

[Mucca Mad Boys]

Your judgement is questionable. I appreciate for some Hamer has become the sacred cow but a season of Walsh can’t be airbrushed away so flippantly. Walsh proved himself as the standout midfielder in league one and it is much too early to say the Hamer is going to be the player of the same or bigger influence than Walsh.

Hamer’s impact in all of our competitive games is there to be seen already.

Almost singlehandedly, he’s turn us into a threat from set-pieces - this is huge. He’s combative and makes a lot of important tackles/interceptions - yes, he gets a lot of yellows, but that’s his game and it’s not an obvious problem, yet. He’s shown a nice range of creative passing too.

You have to take into consideration that Hamer is the cheaper option than Walsh too. Bristol wouldn’t let us sign Walsh for £1m and there’s no way he’d be on less wages, too. We’ve got a good player for good price in Hamer - at first impression.

Walsh has got what it takes to do really well in the Championship and maybe even higher, at the right club. If the opportunity arose, we would almost definitely try to resign Walsh - even on a loan spell. In my view, Walsh and Hamer would compliment one another really well.

 

[Legia Sky Blue]

Hamer looks good, but this is typically knee jerk of the OP. If we were to sign Walsh, guaranteed that he would immediately be calling him the greatest again. If Hamer has an off day, or more likely gets himself sent off and costs us a game, first one to come on here calling him out will be the OP.

 

[steve cooper]

Might find out next season!

I can't see us selling him to a league 1 team

 

[Johnnythespider]

When a woman goes to a date's home after a lovely meal... To find that the weirdo freak still has multiple pics of his ex.

'We' are that weirdo freak!!!

What if when she gets to his home she finds his ex in bed waiting for them both

 

[Hadji's_Goatee]

 

[Hadji's_Goatee]

Great stats, maybe skewed by his Macca-esque corner taking abilities though

 

[matesx]

They’re different players and we’re yet to see Walsh play at this level.

spot on

 

[SlowerThanPlatt]

Great stats, maybe skewed by his Macca-esque corner taking abilities though

Yes definitely. He’s like our Grealish. It would be more impressive if he was playing for better team with the burden of creativity shared

 

[covcity4life]

I get that most of this thread is influenced by bias but I would add that Walsh is a championship quality player just like we didn't need to see Dabo play vs QPR to know he was too.

 

[Londonccfcfan]

Great stats, maybe skewed by his Macca-esque corner taking abilities though

Agree slightly skewed by his putting it on a plate at corners.

We are going to have to improve on the conversion of the key chances created.

 

[Briles]

Walsh was a tad quicker and more skilful however hamer has better passing and set pieces. Depends what you want.

 

[Magwitch]

I think both could play together in the team either side of Sheaf or Kelly could be good but won’t be happening.