Ratings (3 Viewers)
- Thread starter cc84cov
- Start date
The Philosopher
Well-Known Member
13Wilson - 6 - wonder if he’ll get some kind of record of penalty conceded goals ratio. Did ok.
2Østigard -7 - good assist, most things well
5McFadzean - 7 - solid
15Hyam - 7 - did ok
23Dabo - 8 - attacking menace - quality player
6Kelly - 9 - awesome but should have had a hat trick (satire)
14Sheaf - 5 - several sloppy passes. Gave away a pen. I’m unconvinced that we play better with him in the team.
21McCallum - 7 - good
11O'Hare - 7 - good running, needs a goal to really get his confidence up.
26Shipley - 5 - not today shippers.
19Walker - 6 - ok.
Sub Baka - 5 - I don’t understand how he thinks. Let a decent ball run for a goal kick. Didn’t press and harangue enough.
Biamou - 8 - Brilliant cameo
Hamer - 8 - class
2Østigard -7 - good assist, most things well
5McFadzean - 7 - solid
15Hyam - 7 - did ok
23Dabo - 8 - attacking menace - quality player
6Kelly - 9 - awesome but should have had a hat trick (satire)
14Sheaf - 5 - several sloppy passes. Gave away a pen. I’m unconvinced that we play better with him in the team.
21McCallum - 7 - good
11O'Hare - 7 - good running, needs a goal to really get his confidence up.
26Shipley - 5 - not today shippers.
19Walker - 6 - ok.
Sub Baka - 5 - I don’t understand how he thinks. Let a decent ball run for a goal kick. Didn’t press and harangue enough.
Biamou - 8 - Brilliant cameo
Hamer - 8 - class
Earlsdon_Skyblue1
Well-Known Member
Leo, Hamer, Kelly, Biamou, Dabo were instrumental for me. Even Max did more in 5 minutes than some players.
Shipley, Bakayoko, Walker, McCallum - all were absolutely dreadful.
The rest that played were decent.
There is a big gulf in our team and it isn't just about ability. It's effort as well. I'm overjoyed with the win but fuck me it was stressful to watch.
Shipley, Bakayoko, Walker, McCallum - all were absolutely dreadful.
The rest that played were decent.
There is a big gulf in our team and it isn't just about ability. It's effort as well. I'm overjoyed with the win but fuck me it was stressful to watch.
cc84cov
Well-Known Member
Started slow then got upto speed seems to have gone slightly backwards
SeaSeeEffCee
Well-Known Member
Wilson 6
Dabo 7
Ostigard 7
McFadzean 7
Hyam 6
McCallum 6
Kelly 8
Sheaf 5
Shipley 5
O'Hare 6
Walker 5
Hamer 7.5
Bakayoko 5
Biamou 7
Dabo 7
Ostigard 7
McFadzean 7
Hyam 6
McCallum 6
Kelly 8
Sheaf 5
Shipley 5
O'Hare 6
Walker 5
Hamer 7.5
Bakayoko 5
Biamou 7
Esoterica
Well-Known Member
I am, but today he looked like a player who has been sat on his arse for 3 games without a competitive minute.
Blind-Faith
Well-Known Member
Wilson 7
Dabo 7
Ostigard 8
McFadzean 7
Hyam 7
McCallum 6
Kelly 8
Sheaf 4
Shipley 4
O'Hare 6
Walker 6
Hamer 7
Bakayoko 6
Biamou 6.5
Dabo 7
Ostigard 8
McFadzean 7
Hyam 7
McCallum 6
Kelly 8
Sheaf 4
Shipley 4
O'Hare 6
Walker 6
Hamer 7
Bakayoko 6
Biamou 6.5
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
Wilson 6
Dabo 7
Ostigard 8
McFadz 7
Hyam 7
Sam....6
Kelly 8
Sheaf 6.....Tough baptism for him on his comeback.
O’Hare 7
Shipley 4
Walker 6...thankless task again.
Baka 5...
Hamer 8...motm, changed the game.
Max...7....helped close it out.
Robins 6...Don’t want to say more but baffling couple of decisions. When everyone can see.
Dabo 7
Ostigard 8
McFadz 7
Hyam 7
Sam....6
Kelly 8
Sheaf 6.....Tough baptism for him on his comeback.
O’Hare 7
Shipley 4
Walker 6...thankless task again.
Baka 5...
Hamer 8...motm, changed the game.
Max...7....helped close it out.
Robins 6...Don’t want to say more but baffling couple of decisions. When everyone can see.
My heart was pumping near the end. Relieved to get through with a win.
Wilson 6 (didn't have to do much. Good distribution but got lucky with last gasp spill)
Dabo 7 (got better second half with some good forward runs cutting inside)
McCallum 7 (beaten too easily on occasions but won a number of free-kicks to take pressure off. Some good crosses again)
Ostigard 9 (great solid performance again. Some good clearances and great defensive diving header, albeit given as a free-kick)
McFadzean 8 (didn't do much wrong. Not as dominant as Ostigard)
Hyam 6 (not his norm. Indecisive positionally on occasion and beaten easily another time)
Kelly 9 (motm. Great strike for first goal and reacted well for second. It looked like he made the decision to stay on. Otherwise likely to have been just 1-0 at half-time)
Sheaf 5 (two wayward passes straight into touch, a silly booking and giving away a penalty albeit soft. He did make a last gasp challenge soon after they scored which was crucial)
Shipley 4 (maybe he was ill but relieved to see him being replaced early)
O'Hare 8 (great work rate as usual. Better second half with some nice interchanges)
Walker 7 (disappointed on occasions with his use of the ball but was involved in both goals, scrapping before the first and won free-kick which led to the second)
Hamer 8 (great energy and breaking up play. Sees things early including his audacious shot from halfway which clipped the post)
Bakayoka 7 (did what was needed in terms of energy and linked up well a few times with O'Hare. Had more time on occasions to turn and be more positive)
Biamou 7 (nice cameo. Exactly what was needed. Shame about needless booking)
Wilson 6 (didn't have to do much. Good distribution but got lucky with last gasp spill)
Dabo 7 (got better second half with some good forward runs cutting inside)
McCallum 7 (beaten too easily on occasions but won a number of free-kicks to take pressure off. Some good crosses again)
Ostigard 9 (great solid performance again. Some good clearances and great defensive diving header, albeit given as a free-kick)
McFadzean 8 (didn't do much wrong. Not as dominant as Ostigard)
Hyam 6 (not his norm. Indecisive positionally on occasion and beaten easily another time)
Kelly 9 (motm. Great strike for first goal and reacted well for second. It looked like he made the decision to stay on. Otherwise likely to have been just 1-0 at half-time)
Sheaf 5 (two wayward passes straight into touch, a silly booking and giving away a penalty albeit soft. He did make a last gasp challenge soon after they scored which was crucial)
Shipley 4 (maybe he was ill but relieved to see him being replaced early)
O'Hare 8 (great work rate as usual. Better second half with some nice interchanges)
Walker 7 (disappointed on occasions with his use of the ball but was involved in both goals, scrapping before the first and won free-kick which led to the second)
Hamer 8 (great energy and breaking up play. Sees things early including his audacious shot from halfway which clipped the post)
Bakayoka 7 (did what was needed in terms of energy and linked up well a few times with O'Hare. Had more time on occasions to turn and be more positive)
Biamou 7 (nice cameo. Exactly what was needed. Shame about needless booking)
speedie87
Well-Known Member
Wilson 6 better to be lucky than good hay, the spill at the end could have cost us but think god didn’t
Dabo 7 some good stuff and some bizarre moments from him today
Ostigard 8 what a leap he has on him
Mcfadzean 8
Hyam 7
McCallum 7
Kelly 9
Sheaf 5 pretty dodgy today
Shipley 5 him getting a knock and hamer coming on changed first half
Ohare 7 lots of hard work and not a lot end product
Walker 7 some good moment but never got a chance
Hamer 8
Baka 5 poor from him today
Dabo 7 some good stuff and some bizarre moments from him today
Ostigard 8 what a leap he has on him
Mcfadzean 8
Hyam 7
McCallum 7
Kelly 9
Sheaf 5 pretty dodgy today
Shipley 5 him getting a knock and hamer coming on changed first half
Ohare 7 lots of hard work and not a lot end product
Walker 7 some good moment but never got a chance
Hamer 8
Baka 5 poor from him today
mrtrench
Well-Known Member
I'd rather be good hay, but then I keep animals. Differences of opinion is what makes a good forum I guess.
torchomatic
Well-Known Member
Wilson - 6
Dabo - 7 - love him
McCallum - 7 - better in the second half. Too many passes go astray though
McFaz - 7 - Solid
Hyam - 7 - Reliable as always
Ostigard - 8 - Gets better and better
Kelly - 9 - Immense. Unsung hero. We shall miss him
Shipley - 5 - poor. Usual misplaced passes and making wrong decisions
Sheaf - 4 - Still poor part despite the penalty. Can't pass or find a man. Gives away the ball too cheaply.
O'Hare -7 - busy as usual.
Walker -6 - Never got the run of the ball today.
Hamer - 8 - Outrageous skill. Can't wait to see him live.
Baka - 6 - Can't seem to pass the ball in a forward direction. Disappointing.
Max - 7 - Good touches and great pass that led to Hamer's chance
Pleasing win.
Dabo - 7 - love him
McCallum - 7 - better in the second half. Too many passes go astray though
McFaz - 7 - Solid
Hyam - 7 - Reliable as always
Ostigard - 8 - Gets better and better
Kelly - 9 - Immense. Unsung hero. We shall miss him
Shipley - 5 - poor. Usual misplaced passes and making wrong decisions
Sheaf - 4 - Still poor part despite the penalty. Can't pass or find a man. Gives away the ball too cheaply.
O'Hare -7 - busy as usual.
Walker -6 - Never got the run of the ball today.
Hamer - 8 - Outrageous skill. Can't wait to see him live.
Baka - 6 - Can't seem to pass the ball in a forward direction. Disappointing.
Max - 7 - Good touches and great pass that led to Hamer's chance
Pleasing win.
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
Only saw bits so can't give much, thought the back 3 did well against the bombardment.
O'Hare was involved in most of our good attacking play as usual.
O'Hare was involved in most of our good attacking play as usual.
Jamesimus
Well-Known Member
Wilson - 7 - mainly okay, questionable on a couple of Wycombe deliveries. Goes long more often than Marosi.
McCallum - 6 - some good crosses. Bit wasteful in possession. Looked exhausted in the second half, too many games too soon?
McFadz - 7 - had a tough time second half. Won some important fouls.
Hyam - 7 - makes me feel calm when I'm not calm.
Ostigard - 8 - OSTIHARD. Should have let him into the stands to confront the Wycombe fans. His best game for us so far I think.
Dabo - 7 - bit of a mixed bag today, but love his merauding runs when he goes in-field
Kelly - 8 - he will be missed. I've been screaming for a Kelly hatrick for ages now and today was going to be that day if he didn't have to go off injured.
Sheaf - 5 - looked understandably rusty. Think he needs regular games to be at his best.
Hamer - 8 - made a massive difference when he came on. His vision, work rate and he loves getting stuck in.
Shipley - 5 - was clearly struggling in some way, not sure what's up. Glad he went off.
O Hare - 7 - he may be due a goal, but he's still playing well and he's also very important to the team defensively.
Walker - 6 - looked a bit tired. Good shithousery against the shithouse champs, going down and making a meal of it for that free kick.
Baka - 5 - looked okay for ten mins, then disinterested. Some baffling decisions to let the ball run out of play.
Biamou - 7 - had an instant impact and didn't try to impress for his . Tried to do things to see the game out, for the team.
Wycombe - 5 - improved version of their old selves. Constant fouls and then complaining wondering why they were being penalised. But you can see how they can get results playing in their own stadium in front of a scared ref, and that brings me onto...
Ref - 6 - Decent start, I imagine Wycombe fans would feel hard done by, because that's how their used to seeing their team play. By the end ref was making some bizzare decisions, penalising Baka for basically doing nothing. I thought the penalty was a pen.
McCallum - 6 - some good crosses. Bit wasteful in possession. Looked exhausted in the second half, too many games too soon?
McFadz - 7 - had a tough time second half. Won some important fouls.
Hyam - 7 - makes me feel calm when I'm not calm.
Ostigard - 8 - OSTIHARD. Should have let him into the stands to confront the Wycombe fans. His best game for us so far I think.
Dabo - 7 - bit of a mixed bag today, but love his merauding runs when he goes in-field
Kelly - 8 - he will be missed. I've been screaming for a Kelly hatrick for ages now and today was going to be that day if he didn't have to go off injured.
Sheaf - 5 - looked understandably rusty. Think he needs regular games to be at his best.
Hamer - 8 - made a massive difference when he came on. His vision, work rate and he loves getting stuck in.
Shipley - 5 - was clearly struggling in some way, not sure what's up. Glad he went off.
O Hare - 7 - he may be due a goal, but he's still playing well and he's also very important to the team defensively.
Walker - 6 - looked a bit tired. Good shithousery against the shithouse champs, going down and making a meal of it for that free kick.
Baka - 5 - looked okay for ten mins, then disinterested. Some baffling decisions to let the ball run out of play.
Biamou - 7 - had an instant impact and didn't try to impress for his . Tried to do things to see the game out, for the team.
Wycombe - 5 - improved version of their old selves. Constant fouls and then complaining wondering why they were being penalised. But you can see how they can get results playing in their own stadium in front of a scared ref, and that brings me onto...
Ref - 6 - Decent start, I imagine Wycombe fans would feel hard done by, because that's how their used to seeing their team play. By the end ref was making some bizzare decisions, penalising Baka for basically doing nothing. I thought the penalty was a pen.
Earlsdon_Skyblue1
Well-Known Member
I'm not having a go at anyone in particular, but sometimes it does feel like Walker gets a few sympathy marks because he's up front on his own. I actually think he has been pretty poor for a while.
Adge
Well-Known Member
Wilson 5 Done a Burge flap from a cross that came in and spill for the offside goal.Has done really well in the last few games but bit more of a wobble today.
Dabs 7 Ordinary first half but came into it more 2nd half getting forward more.
McFadz 7 Again no nonsense from him.
Hyam 6 Thought he got done a couple of times and turned too easy but not too bad on the whole.
McCallum 6 One or 2 loose ones but defensive side was ok.
Ostigard 8 MoM Great solid game and getting better still. Isn’t frightened to mix it up and certainly puts his head in where it hurts.
Kelly 8 So so important for us and will be a massive loss during his absence. Great strike for the first and in the right place for the second. Should really have had a hatrick with one before that went past the post. The oil in the machine.
Sheaf 5 Needs to step up-gave the referee a decision to make-even Robins said it was a crap one!
O’Hare 7 Hasn’t really been his season so far but work rate is outstanding-probably just missing a goal.
Shipley 4 May have been injured-replaced early doors but wasn’t really involved up till then.
Walker 6 Again a bit isolated on his own-done reasonably with what little service he had.
Subs-
Hamer 8 Changed the game and in particular the whole midfield when he came on-great vision and a tremendous shot on the halfway line that hit the post and left Allsop praying it was going wide.
Should really have scored with an easier chance .
Baka 5 He’s just not at the races and I’m not sure he ever will be. How many chances does he need-must be great in training in the week.
Biamou 7 Done more in 10 minutes than Baka in 45. Baka should take a leaf out of his book.
Robins 6 Strange team selection probably based on another game in mid-week but got the 3 points in the bag.
Dabs 7 Ordinary first half but came into it more 2nd half getting forward more.
McFadz 7 Again no nonsense from him.
Hyam 6 Thought he got done a couple of times and turned too easy but not too bad on the whole.
McCallum 6 One or 2 loose ones but defensive side was ok.
Ostigard 8 MoM Great solid game and getting better still. Isn’t frightened to mix it up and certainly puts his head in where it hurts.
Kelly 8 So so important for us and will be a massive loss during his absence. Great strike for the first and in the right place for the second. Should really have had a hatrick with one before that went past the post. The oil in the machine.
Sheaf 5 Needs to step up-gave the referee a decision to make-even Robins said it was a crap one!
O’Hare 7 Hasn’t really been his season so far but work rate is outstanding-probably just missing a goal.
Shipley 4 May have been injured-replaced early doors but wasn’t really involved up till then.
Walker 6 Again a bit isolated on his own-done reasonably with what little service he had.
Subs-
Hamer 8 Changed the game and in particular the whole midfield when he came on-great vision and a tremendous shot on the halfway line that hit the post and left Allsop praying it was going wide.
Should really have scored with an easier chance .
Baka 5 He’s just not at the races and I’m not sure he ever will be. How many chances does he need-must be great in training in the week.
Biamou 7 Done more in 10 minutes than Baka in 45. Baka should take a leaf out of his book.
Robins 6 Strange team selection probably based on another game in mid-week but got the 3 points in the bag.
Yorkshire SB
Well-Known Member
Thought we were really poor today, but still managed to get the win.
Defence did well
Kelly - wowza
Hamer - incredible player and the effort where he tackled and then didn’t break stride, top level ability
O’Hare - work rate and ability brilliant
McCallum - had a bit of an off game, on the ball anyway. Did well defensively.
Sheaf - struggled to get into it, but I think that’s more to do with the break out the team he’s had. Earlier in the season he was our best player 2-3 games consecutively, IMO.
Walker - didn’t really give us much to work with either, not sure he’s the sort of striker that can bring the rest of the team into play
Defence did well
Kelly - wowza
Hamer - incredible player and the effort where he tackled and then didn’t break stride, top level ability
O’Hare - work rate and ability brilliant
McCallum - had a bit of an off game, on the ball anyway. Did well defensively.
Sheaf - struggled to get into it, but I think that’s more to do with the break out the team he’s had. Earlier in the season he was our best player 2-3 games consecutively, IMO.
Walker - didn’t really give us much to work with either, not sure he’s the sort of striker that can bring the rest of the team into play
Blind-Faith
Well-Known Member
The guy has nothing to go off though , absolutely starved on his own, so will never be getting 7/8 on the ratings. Personally think he will always looks better with someone upfront with him, looking forward to seeing him and Godden together
Jamesimus
Well-Known Member
Ludicrous really. O Hare is as important to the team defensively as he is offensively. Yes he gives the ball away, but he's always looking forward on the attack and today he must have been fouled at least five times during the game. Had a decent game today.
Hamer was fantastic though. Loved his little interplay with Dabo in the second half when they appeared to be crowded out by Wycombe players and managed to pass their way out of it.
D
Deleted member 9744
Guest
Agree on Hamer and staggered by some of the scores given to him above. 7 really??? When he was on he was by far the best player on the pitch. He looked a Premier League player today.
I totally disagree on O'Hare. I think he is playing well and so many of our best moves go through him. Also don't underestimate his defensive work too. His work rate is amazing.
Earlsdon_Skyblue1
Well-Known Member
I think Oggy summed it up really well the other day when he said all he was missing was a goal.
Everything else is spot on and his effort always impresses me. Just needs a bit more final product, which I think will come.
larry_david
Well-Known Member
O hare did well. But needs to improve in the final third
LilleSkyBlue
Well-Known Member
Well yes, but at this rate of games three matches is scarcely over a week. He's just not quite at it yet for me. You can see there's a cultured player there though and I'm not a-slatin' him here.
I also think he looks better sat behind a front two than one of two supporting one upfront.
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
Agree on that one. The box just hasn’t worked out this season.
Personally, I think next time we thinking about playing that system, we try a more out an out 3-4-3 with either Giles or Jobello to give us more of a threat.