Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Relegate me now
Flatter to Deceive (3 Viewers)
- Thread starter Grendel
- Start date
Relegate me now
Malaka
Well-Known Member
Decent player, we are lucky to have him. I think that his movement and vision is excellent, it's just that some of the team are not yet on his wavelength. It reminds me of when we had McAllister here, he was too good us and looked distinctly average most of the time as a lot of our players were not in the space he passed the ball into. He had the quality around him when he moved to Liverpool, he was class and won five trophies.
Malaka
Well-Known Member
That's a shocker!
superskyblue
Well-Known Member
Yep it's a classic way to treat a new striker isn't it. Play them out wide. We've done it so many times over the years and not many recover. Only McNulty comes to mind as someone who's come out the other side.
When Walker is back I'd like to see a return to the 5212 formation with Gyok and Walker together and O'Hare in behind. Think they have the makings of a decent front 3.
Barnsley
Well-Known Member
According to Woodrows dad Fulham gave him to us for free. During the Rotherham game at Christmas the Rotherham commentator said they gave us him and they get 50% sell on the commentator used to play with Woodrows dad at Rotherham. As for wages we don’t pay big wages Wigan and Stoke paid wages bigger than us that’s why our players go there.
MusicDating
Euro 2016 Prediction League Champion!!
Personally I think James has had the benefit of calming down both Gus and O'Hare. Everything seemed pretty rushed with them before and Gus in particular was too keen to play the Hollywood ball.
With more intelligent runners back up front, I'm sure the creativity of the midfield will show through too.
With more intelligent runners back up front, I'm sure the creativity of the midfield will show through too.
Hobo
Well-Known Member
Yet people say the results arent good enough and we are in a relegation battle? Your logic is strange at times.
Grendel
Well-Known Member
Well I think whoever replaced Tim Sherwood cost a lot less so not really and relating to this thread is James massively better than Kelly?
Grendel
Well-Known Member
Leon Clarke if I’m being pedantic
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
What’s signing Sherwood 17 years ago got to do with anything?
Not after the few games no I haven’t seen much difference. Though the time for criticising signings surely isn’t now but once our fate is settled?
Frostie
Well-Known Member
Leon Clarke has only managed 6 starts & 1 goal since September & Shrewsbury have already brought in other strikers to replace him. Hardly what we need is it?
Also he wasn't available in January anyway, he moved to Shrewsbury in September & we weren't without both Walker & Godden then.
Grendel
Well-Known Member
Leon Clarke has only managed 6 starts & 1 goal since September & Shrewsbury have already brought in other strikers to replace him. Hardly what we need is it?
Also he wasn't available in January anyway, he moved to Shrewsbury in September & we weren't without both Walker & Godden then.
I was talking about when we signed him!
Frostie
Well-Known Member
I see, but not sure what looking at the past does.
Who was available in the window just gone that we could have signed that's better than what we did?
COVKIDSNEVERQUIT
Well-Known Member
Hobo
Well-Known Member
His post was ambiguous to say the least. He hopes the past gives him a rock solid argument, but of course it doesn't.
Grendel
Well-Known Member
Not really - my point is we have a lot of midfielders but very little elsewhere and he is an expensive luxury - if we decided we could not afford a centre forward as they are some kind of luxury commodity I’d then rather see a centre half instead of Hyam used to a back 3 to stop leakage of stupid goals
mark82
Super Moderator
He said affordable.
Hobo
Well-Known Member
Perhaps a slightly longer and more detailed post could have painted a clearer picture of your views.
Another angle Grendel and I accept this is just speculation like most things on here. Kelly's contract is up in the summer and we don't know what his intention is? Or what offers might come his way?
Also from the clubs point of view, when a contract expires there is a choice, stick with what you have got or try and bring someone better in.
The opportunity to bring James in gives the club time to assess him. Would he be an improvement on Kelly or possibly even just a like for like swap if Kelly moves on?
I think one of the key considerations was our side is very young and lacks experience. I think the experience factor is as important as the position. I know you argued for the experienced striker - but very few strikers are made captains and that is normally down to their position on the field rather than lacking leadership qualities.
Skybluedownunder
Well-Known Member
He had an injury early start to the season and then didn’t get much game time at Milwall and was only coming off the bench
Gyokeres was 0 in 10 for Swansea so what’s your point?
People said there was no1 better out there, my opinion was Parrott is better and much more highly rated, supposed to be the next Harry Kane according to Spurs fans and scored loads in youth leagues and U23’s etc
In comparison, Parrott is also a fully fledged international for Ireland
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
clint van damme
Well-Known Member
I mentioned Parrott based purely on his cameo against us but as with any realistic option we had it would be a gamble.
We don't have the budget for a proven Championship striker
Grendel
Well-Known Member
We don’t have a budget for a proven championship player in any position but our forwards as it stands aren’t good enough - Godden maybe it may not - so it’s a big area of concern
D
Deleted member 11652
Guest
Well we spent £1million on one so he needs to be good enough. Us staying up could depend on whether he is good enough or not.
Last edited by a moderator:
clint van damme
Well-Known Member
who was that? Because Walker was not a proven Championship player.
D
Deleted member 11652
Guest
Yeah it was more in response to the none of our forwards are good enough part.
Frostie
Well-Known Member
So why did Parrott have to drop to League One to try & get minutes? Millwall are one of the lowest scorers in the league yet he still couldn't get a game.
Gyökeres was at Swansea, flying high, one of the highest scoring teams in the league & behind an excellent partnership in Ayew & Lowe.
To correct your stats:
Parrott 0 in 14
Gyökeres 1 in 11
Gyökeres has of course scored goals in Germany & 1 for Brighton now 1 for us too whilst Parrott has never scored a single goal at senior level.
You're aware that he is a full Sweden international & has actually scored for them too?
Parrott probably will go on to have a decent career but, at this stage, Gyökeres is a better fit & was far more likely to make an immediate impact.
Skybluedownunder
Well-Known Member
I know Gyokeres is a Sweden international but if you read the comments someone commented I’d rather have Gyokeres because he is an international too so I corrected it by saying yes but so is Parrott
I’m sure Parrott probably had championship offers but like us, sometimes we loan a player to a league lower to guarentee they will get mins, like many of our players we loan out like Drysdale for example
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
And didn’t cost £1m
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Right and the only name you’ve tossed out is Leon Clarke. We did not have the funds to improve our quality up front, only the numbers.
D
Deleted member 11652
Guest
How much then? And if he really isn’t good enough, why did we bother?
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Why isn’t he good enough?
D
Deleted member 11652
Guest
That was Grendel’s point. He said none of our forwards are good enough for the championship. I stated for the money we spent on Walker (I thought it was £1million) he needs to be good enough and it could be the difference in relegation or survival. Then you and Clint jumped in missing the point
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Oh sorry. Then yeah I agree, I’ve got a vague memory of both 600 and 900k but can’t find any evidence of that other than that screenshot.
I think he’s a good striker with potential, his goals per minute ratio is good and we’ve yet to see him fit so a bit hair triggered about people writing him off
D
Deleted member 5849
Guest
Annoyingly I can't find it, but I could've sworn Grendel said the strikers as it stands aren't good enough.
That's true, the two who are / may be are out injured.
(Gyorkeres may or may not be tbf)
That's true, the two who are / may be are out injured.
(Gyorkeres may or may not be tbf)