Referee Analysis Brentford (2 Viewers)

[Johhny Blue]

I missed most of the first half. Didn’t realize it was a 12:30 K.O. Thanks Mark for the reminder.

Thought I’d start a thread anyway and waiting to see if I missed anything.
Similar to last game I like the way he let the small niggly fouls go and kept the game flowing. It was the same for both teams and the players seemed to know how far they could push it.
O’Hare & Hyam yellows. Both good calls. It’s good to see our players taking good yellows instead of the silly ones.
Played a few advantages that were only borderline advantage to the fouled player. I’m ok with that.
Seemed to lean on Lino’s a lot. Again no problem with that.

No real hard decisions needed.
Overall rating 7.5 (0.5 deducted for waiting until half time to change his shirt)

 

---

[Skyblue_LDN]

Thought he had a good game all in all, nothing fancy, and was quite nice to see him clamp down on players gaining ground on throw ins and free kicks

 

[stevefloyd]

No real complaints today half decent not noticed too much which is how it should be

 

[shmmeee]

Can’t remember a single complaint today TBH.

 

[procdoc]

He had big biceps

 

[Somerset Sky Blue]

Thought he was very good - and the linesman for the penalty...not sure all would have flagged so vigorously and might have left it so see if ref had spotted it (and make the decision)!

 

[Johhny Blue]

Thought he had a good game all in all, nothing fancy, and was quite nice to see him clamp down on players gaining ground on throw ins and free kicks

Didn’t notice that to be honest. Another pet peeve of mine. I’ll give him back his half point for that.
Revised overall rating 8

 

[Johhny Blue]

Thought he was very good - and the linesman for the penalty...not sure all would have flagged so vigorously and might have left it so see if ref had spotted it (and make the decision)!

Haven’t seen that yet.
Lino rating 10

 

[Travs]

I personally thought the penalty was rather soft.... Biamou was going away from goal, the defender was unlucky to get there a split-second late.

That said, it would have been a free-kick anywhere else on the pitch, so i suppose it was the correct decision.

But no doubt we benefited greatly from it.

As many have said above, i thought the referee was very fair.

 

[Mcbean]

That penalty was the same as Wilsons one - he caught the player after the ball had gone - good decision

 

[Frostie]

What I think was particularly pleasing was you had Assistants that were actually prepared to give a decision & they actually worked together as a team.
Doesn't happen often enough.

 

[no_loyalty]

The best referee we have had this season got all of the decisions right, a special mention goes to the linesman for flagging for the penalty.

 

[Jamesimus]

Ref was a unit. Wouldn't argue with him either way. Actually got the penalty decision right so whatever else he did I can pass on.

 

[Cov kid 55]

Yep, I thought ref was good, can’t think of any instances where I was abusing him from my settee for a decision I didn’t agree with.

 

[ccfc92]

He had big biceps

Looked a proper roid head didn't he?

 

[ccfc92]

Thought he was very good - and the linesman for the penalty...not sure all would have flagged so vigorously and might have left it so see if ref had spotted it (and make the decision)!

This.

The Lino was adamant it was a foul, nice to see them making the call for once rather than waiting for the ref's.

 

[Grendel]

This.

The Lino was adamant it was a foul, nice to see them making the call for once rather than waiting for the ref's.

Yes from his angle the referee could easily have not given it

 

[pastythegreat]

I missed most of the first half. Didn’t realize it was a 12:30 K.O. Thanks Mark for the reminder.

Thought I’d start a thread anyway and waiting to see if I missed anything.
Similar to last game I like the way he let the small niggly fouls go and kept the game flowing. It was the same for both teams and the players seemed to know how far they could push it.
O’Hare & Hyam yellows. Both good calls. It’s good to see our players taking good yellows instead of the silly ones.
Played a few advantages that were only borderline advantage to the fouled player. I’m ok with that.
Seemed to lean on Lino’s a lot. Again no problem with that.

No real hard decisions needed.
Overall rating 7.5 (0.5 deducted for waiting until half time to change his shirt)

The lino flagged for a free kick, luckily the ref was paying attention and noticed it was in the area and awarded the penalty.

Sent from my SM-N960F using Tapatalk

 

[Sky_Blue_Dreamer]

Well he did come out for the first half practically in our kit, so the opposition may have though he was our henchman. When he reality he's just a hench man.

 

[Amcoventry]

If that penalty had been against us how many moaners would there have been on here. Lucky to get it and we still deserved the win.PUSB!!

 

[Earlsdon_Skyblue1]

Reminded me of that darts player, Gerwyn Price. 'Iceman', who is the exact opposite of such thing!

 

[mrtrench]

Thought he was very good - and the linesman for the penalty...not sure all would have flagged so vigorously and might have left it so see if ref had spotted it (and make the decision)!

Don't think a red would have been fair. I agree it was a penalty but I don't think it was deliberate or reckless.

 

[skybluesam66]

If that penalty had been against us how many moaners would there have been on here. Lucky to get it and we still deserved the win.PUSB!!

Sorry he was kicked inside the box. Biamou was first to the ball. The defender was late
That’s a nailed on penalty
Direction of travel etc is irrelevant

 

[pastythegreat]

If that penalty had been against us how many moaners would there have been on here. Lucky to get it and we still deserved the win.PUSB!!

Lucky to get the penalty?! It was nailed on, so much so none of the Brentford players even the defender that conceded it argued it with the ref.

Sent from my SM-N960F using Tapatalk

 

[Johhny Blue]

Lucky to get the penalty?! It was nailed on, so much so none of the Brentford players even the defender that conceded it argued it with the ref.

Sent from my SM-N960F using Tapatalk

They were scared of him

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

He was excellent for me

 

[Colin Steins Smile]

He and his assistants had a good game. They clamped down on players stealing yards on throw ins. The game seemed straightforward to officiate as both teams didn’t focus on the dark arts.
I think the half time break allowed Hamer to escape a yellow card for repetitive fouling. As he’d clocked a few in succession in the 1st half.
The penalty was right and no complaints about our yellow cards.