Tyler Walker (8 Viewers)

Forums New posts
D

Deleted member 5849

Guest
GaryMabbuttsLeftKnee said:
You make some good points but there is no way that someone at 30 is all of a sudden going to develop a good touch. He's been playing professionally for years and it is still horrific. He could play until he's 48 and that isn't going to improve
Click to expand...
I'd suggest less bad, than good!
 
cc84cov

cc84cov

Well-Known Member
If we get walker & Godden fit soon we have a chance if we don’t we will be in trouble same as pre season Godden is key to survival this season he’s not the messiah but he’s the best natural striker at the club,walker will play a lot better next to Godden,max is like a defender playing up front
 
Earlsdon_Skyblue1

Earlsdon_Skyblue1

Well-Known Member
Sick Boy said:
The criticism of him is all part of diverting it away from a certain other forward.
Click to expand...

To be honest, I think it goes the other way too.

I have no horse in this race, and want to see both do well. I also don't think anyone is doubting that Walker isn't the better of the two players, it is just more about what he is giving at the moment. Our backs are up against the wall, and whilst Max makes the wrong decisions over and over again, you can at least see that he is giving his all. Unfortunately, when you lack quality, everyone needs to dig in. It works the same right down to Sunday league level.

Walker is a good finisher, you can tell that. That is all he has though, and it isn't enough. You could see the reaction yesterday when we scored. Some people were really desperate to try and not give the goal to Max, where in the game before, Walker won a header and those same people were acting as if it was Ballon d'Or worthy.

We cannot carry anyone when we are in a dog fight and at the moment Walker needs to contribute more. It's all well and good saying that he needs better service (to which I agree to an extent), but he also has to make the most out of what he is getting, and he isn't. One time yesterday that stood out especially was when he was yomping around in an offside position and the ball game flying through to him. He has to do better, which hopefully is more to do with lack of sharpness.

Whilst I agree that there is an element of people blowing up Biamou's arse, there is also a contingent excusing Walker for underperforming due to being unable to say anything positive about Biamou. In reality, they both haven't been good enough. One due to ability I think, the other due to performance.
 
hill83

hill83

Well-Known Member
Earlsdon_Skyblue1 said:
To be honest, I think it goes the other way too.

I have no horse in this race, and want to see both do well. I also don't think anyone is doubting that Walker isn't the better of the two players, it is just more about what he is giving at the moment. Our backs are up against the wall, and whilst Max makes the wrong decisions over and over again, you can at least see that he is giving his all. Unfortunately, when you lack quality, everyone needs to dig in. It works the same right down to Sunday league level.

Walker is a good finisher, you can tell that. That is all he has though, and it isn't enough. You could see the reaction yesterday when we scored. Some people were really desperate to try and not give the goal to Max, where in the game before, Walker won a header and those same people were acting as if it was Ballon d'Or worthy.

We cannot carry anyone when we are in a dog fight and at the moment Walker needs to contribute more. It's all well and good saying that he needs better service (to which I agree to an extent), but he also has to make the most out of what he is getting, and he isn't. One time yesterday that stood out especially was when he was yomping around in an offside position and the ball game flying through to him. He has to do better, which hopefully is more to do with lack of sharpness.

Whilst I agree that there is an element of people blowing up Biamou's arse, there is also a contingent excusing Walker for underperforming due to being unable to say anything positive about Biamou. In reality, they both haven't been good enough. One due to ability I think, the other due to performance.
Click to expand...

Agree with this. I fall for it myself, when I’m constantly seeing players slated by the same people either way I feel the need to purposely find positives to counter them. Others work the opposite way when smoke is being blown up a players arse 24/7.

The reality is we are feeding on scraps. I don’t even rate Matty ‘Isolated sick note’ Godden to be honest.

I do want them all to do well though of course, I’m not that invested in my opinion of players. No names mentioned.
 
shmmeee

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
Earlsdon_Skyblue1 said:
To be honest, I think it goes the other way too.

I have no horse in this race, and want to see both do well. I also don't think anyone is doubting that Walker isn't the better of the two players, it is just more about what he is giving at the moment. Our backs are up against the wall, and whilst Max makes the wrong decisions over and over again, you can at least see that he is giving his all. Unfortunately, when you lack quality, everyone needs to dig in. It works the same right down to Sunday league level.

Walker is a good finisher, you can tell that. That is all he has though, and it isn't enough. You could see the reaction yesterday when we scored. Some people were really desperate to try and not give the goal to Max, where in the game before, Walker won a header and those same people were acting as if it was Ballon d'Or worthy.

We cannot carry anyone when we are in a dog fight and at the moment Walker needs to contribute more. It's all well and good saying that he needs better service (to which I agree to an extent), but he also has to make the most out of what he is getting, and he isn't. One time yesterday that stood out especially was when he was yomping around in an offside position and the ball game flying through to him. He has to do better, which hopefully is more to do with lack of sharpness.

Whilst I agree that there is an element of people blowing up Biamou's arse, there is also a contingent excusing Walker for underperforming due to being unable to say anything positive about Biamou. In reality, they both haven't been good enough. One due to ability I think, the other due to performance.
Click to expand...

“Desperate not to give the goal to Max”

He didn’t touch the fucking ball!
 
K

KenilworthSkyBlue

Well-Known Member
cc84cov said:
He takes balls into feet well laying it off all his stuff on you tube is working off service the game where DaCosta put in about 15 crosses was suited to walker that’s his game
Click to expand...

I don't need to look on YouTube as I watch every game. He has spells where he executes his role admirably, but I fail to see how you could qualify either his touch or ability to bring others into play as 'good' when he's just not consistent enough at either
 
Nick

Nick

Administrator
hill83 said:
Agree with this. I fall for it myself, when I’m constantly seeing players slated by the same people either way I feel the need to purposely find positives to counter them. Others work the opposite way when smoke is being blown up a players arse 24/7.

The reality is we are feeding on scraps. I don’t even rate Matty ‘Isolated sick note’ Godden to be honest.

I do want them all to do well though of course, I’m not that invested in my opinion of players. No names mentioned.
Click to expand...

Yeah I do the same, it's probably just to try and bring a bit of balance to it when people are trying too hard to go over the top.

Same with Bakayoko and Sheaf sometimes. Somebody like Rolls Royce Hyam could overhit a pass in the same half as Sheaf and it's his fault.

Bakayoko got abuse before he had kicked a ball and people just stuck with it, yeah he isn't the best footballer in the world but some of the shit he gets is shocking.
 
D

Deleted member 5849

Guest
KenilworthSkyBlue said:
I don't need to look on YouTube as I watch every game. He has spells where he executes his role admirably, but I fail to see how you could qualify either his touch or ability to bring others into play as 'good' when he's just not consistent enough at either
Click to expand...
I think he's talking Walker rather than Biamou
 
Liquid Gold

Liquid Gold

Well-Known Member
Max’s first touch is so poor it often goes right away from him and turns into a pass. I love the guy for what he’s done in his city career but it’s become so clear that he’s nowhere near the level required to be a starter and play 90 minutes in the championship. I could take him coming on for 10-15 because he will bust a gut against tired defenders but he just doesn’t have the quality from the start.

Even in Walker’s poor second half when he dropped deep he controlled the ball easily, spread it to a midfielder and peeled off to make the forward run. Proper CF play. When Max does it his first touch balloons it anywhere, the defender gets in and then they have to fight for the ball. To some fans this fighting for the ball means he’s putting the effort it when in reality a decent striker wouldn’t have put himself in that position to start with.
 
cc84cov

cc84cov

Well-Known Member
Liquid Gold said:
Max’s first touch is so poor it often goes right away from him and turns into a pass. I love the guy for what he’s done in his city career but it’s become so clear that he’s nowhere near the level required to be a starter and play 90 minutes in the championship. I could take him coming on for 10-15 because he will bust a gut against tired defenders but he just doesn’t have the quality from the start.

Even in Walker’s poor second half when he dropped deep he controlled the ball easily, spread it to a midfielder and peeled off to make the forward run. Proper CF play. When Max does it his first touch balloons it anywhere, the defender gets in and then they have to fight for the ball. To some fans this fighting for the ball means he’s putting the effort it when in reality a decent striker wouldn’t have put himself in that position to start with.
Click to expand...
Fully agree with this
 
Earlsdon_Skyblue1

Earlsdon_Skyblue1

Well-Known Member
shmmeee said:
“Desperate not to give the goal to Max”

He didn’t touch the fucking ball!
Click to expand...

Sure, but my point was that if it had been Walker we would be hearing how he 'forced the goal' or some such other phrase.

The reality is that we are lacking in quality, but my frustration is that if we get relegated I still think it will have been preventable. Maybe I am just utterly deluded, but so many games now I have looked at our points return and thought we could do better. A match finishes and we draw or lose, and I think we could have actually won it. We aren't being outclassed particularly. We are giving away stupid goals, failing to take our chances, and adopting poor tactics.

It reminds me of the season we got relegated from the Championship last time. Our team was shit, but we were competing. It worries me that we are not grinding out results really. It wouldn't take much to stay up, but we are slipping further and further away.
 
stupot07

stupot07

Well-Known Member
A really good point Earlsdon.

Walker "great work to force the defender into playing the ball into his own net, if he wasn't there we wouldn't of scored"

Biamou "he only scored the own goal because Biamou isn't good enough to get into front of it"



Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
 
Earlsdon_Skyblue1

Earlsdon_Skyblue1

Well-Known Member
stupot07 said:
A really good point Earlsdon.

Walker "great work to force the defender into playing the ball into his own net, if he wasn't there we wouldn't of scored"

Biamou "he only scored the own goal because Biamou isn't good enough to get into front of it"



Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

I've probably got a bit too involved getting defensive to be honest, but it just frustrates me every fucking game. I feel like we could be coming away with points and we aren't.

I'm really concerned and I think we only have ourselves to blame.
 
Sick Boy

Sick Boy

Super Moderator
Earlsdon_Skyblue1 said:
To be honest, I think it goes the other way too.

I have no horse in this race, and want to see both do well. I also don't think anyone is doubting that Walker isn't the better of the two players, it is just more about what he is giving at the moment. Our backs are up against the wall, and whilst Max makes the wrong decisions over and over again, you can at least see that he is giving his all. Unfortunately, when you lack quality, everyone needs to dig in. It works the same right down to Sunday league level.

Walker is a good finisher, you can tell that. That is all he has though, and it isn't enough. You could see the reaction yesterday when we scored. Some people were really desperate to try and not give the goal to Max, where in the game before, Walker won a header and those same people were acting as if it was Ballon d'Or worthy.

We cannot carry anyone when we are in a dog fight and at the moment Walker needs to contribute more. It's all well and good saying that he needs better service (to which I agree to an extent), but he also has to make the most out of what he is getting, and he isn't. One time yesterday that stood out especially was when he was yomping around in an offside position and the ball game flying through to him. He has to do better, which hopefully is more to do with lack of sharpness.

Whilst I agree that there is an element of people blowing up Biamou's arse, there is also a contingent excusing Walker for underperforming due to being unable to say anything positive about Biamou. In reality, they both haven't been good enough. One due to ability I think, the other due to performance.
Click to expand...
I’ve repeatedly said that neither Godden or Walker should be first choice in this league, i said pre-season Godden was a decent back-up striker at this level.

Biamou and Baka should be nowhere near the squad and need to be released. The push back against Biamou is due to the pathetic nonsense that gets pushed out by the usual suspects, like the headed goals not counting, he won more free kicks etc etc.
 
D

Deleted member 5849

Guest
Sick Boy said:
I’ve repeatedly said that neither Godden or Walker should be first choice in this league, i said pre-season Godden was a decent back-up striker at this level.
Biamou and Godden should be nowhere near the squad and need to be released. The push back against Biamou is due to the pathetic nonsense that gets pushed out by the usual suspects, like the headed goals not counting, he won more free kicks etc etc.
Click to expand...
See, I think with Walker, give him a full season injury / illness free, and play to his strengths, and he's more than good enough to get us 15+ goals. I'm more than happy with him as first choice.

Harsh, releasing Godden, mind! At the worst get a fee for him!
 
Sick Boy

Sick Boy

Super Moderator
Deleted member 5849 said:
See, I think with Walker, give him a full season injury / illness free, and play to his strengths, and he's more than good enough to get us 15+ goals. I'm more than happy with him as first choice.

Harsh, releasing Godden, mind! At the worst get a fee for him!
Click to expand...
I meant Bakayoko!
 
shmmeee

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
stupot07 said:
A really good point Earlsdon.

Walker "great work to force the defender into playing the ball into his own net, if he wasn't there we wouldn't of scored"

Biamou "he only scored the own goal because Biamou isn't good enough to get into front of it"



Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

I too like getting angry at scenarios I’ve imagined.
 
Liquid Gold

Liquid Gold

Well-Known Member
For me Walker isn’t at full speed yet, he’s been out injured for ages, had COVID, not seen regular football since December 2019. Even then he’s scored and assisted for us.

Let him play himself into form without losing your shit every 5 minutes because he’s definitely better than our 4 other options.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 9 (members: 0, guests: 9)
Top