Max Biamou (12 Viewers)

[stupot07]

Freddie sears at Colchester was miles better than Biamou. He had decent championship seasons at Ipswich too.

O’donovan has done well in league one.

Kevin Kyle is a tough one. He even had good goal scoring spells in Scotland and Sunderland

Freddie Sears did well after leaving us, at the time he played for us he was young, lightweight and ineffective.

O'Donovan had 1 good loan spell in league one

Kyle cost us £1m and scored 5 league goals.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

 

---

[Deleted member 11652]

Freddie Sears did well after leaving us.

O'Donovan had 1 good loan spell in league one

Kyle cost us £1m and scored 5 league goals.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

So sears definitely a better player. O’donovan I’m fishing with a bit but I was so shocked when I saw his record at Hartlepool!

Kyle probably on Max’s level. Says it all really

 

[Sick Boy]

Kyle played and scored in the PL...

 

[stupot07]

So sears definitely a better player. O’donovan I’m fishing with a bit but I was so shocked when I saw his record at Hartlepool!

Kyle probably on Max’s level. Says it all really

He became a better player. At the point of signing he wasn't, therefore Biamou was a better player for us in the championship.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

 

[stupot07]

Kyle played and scored in the PL...

Which goes to show you have to judge solely on what they did with us.

Kyle is pretty much rated as our worst signing ever.

Anyway I'm bored now. He's third choice for a reason.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

 

[Deleted member 11652]

He became a better player. At the point of signing he wasn't, therefore Biamou was a better player for us in the championship.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

I’ve already explained what I’m asking. Players to have had worse careers than Max. Nimely and Hines are the only clear 2 that I’ve seen

 

[ccfc92]

Maybe we have turned a corner & we can go on a winning run ......i don't see why not

IIRC, we haven't won 2 in a row all season.

I think 7 points from next 3 games will see us safe.

 

[Ccfcisparks]

I’ve already explained what I’m asking. Players to have had worse careers than Max. Nimely and Hines are the only clear 2 that I’ve seen

Hines scored in the prem surely that makes him better than Max too?

 

[Deleted member 11652]

Hines scored in the prem surely that makes him better than Max too?

As a whole career, I don’t think so. But if that’s what you think fair enough.

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

Not another Max thread.

It clearly rocks a lot of people's boats, but is now a big yawn. It is really just trench warfare between two sides who know their own minds. Anyway, I know I'm right. He is at best 2nd reserve striker, and if anybody offered us something for him, we should bite their hand off. But other opinions are available...

The story and thread wasn’t about Max it was about him saying we will stay up

 

[Grendel]

He’s on his way

 

[ccfc1234]

He’s on his way

Grendel, did not think it were possible but either Peter Duckett is on the wind up or you have found someone with an even more disproportionate view of Max's abilities than yourself.

 

[better days]

Relax mate, for what it's worth I think Biamou will develop into a better player than Bergkamp anyway.

And he's not scared of flying

 

[procdoc]

Just read the thread. If you think Roy O’Donovan was a better player than Biamou then football clearly isn’t your sport. I don’t think Max is particularly good either but fuck me some of the views on here are completely dumb

 

[Nick]

Biamou has done more in the Championship than Bright and Nazon.....

 

[Grendel]

Grendel, did not think it were possible but either Peter Duckett is on the wind up or you have found someone with an even more disproportionate view of Max's abilities than yourself.

Was he being sarcastic about Hamer as well?

 

[Ccfcisparks]

Just read the thread. If you think Roy O’Donovan was a better player than Biamou then football clearly isn’t your sport. I don’t think Max is particularly good either but fuck me some of the views on here are completely dumb

 

[mark82]

This thread is comedy gold.

 

[Grendel]

This thread is comedy gold.

true



The point being for younger members Mick Ferguson scored more headed goals than virtually anyone for the club and in the top flight once scored three hat tricks in a season

 

[Deleted member 11652]

true



The point being for younger members Mick Ferguson scored more headed goals than virtually anyone for the club and in the top flight once scored three hat tricks in a season

The cult are everywhere.

 

[mark82]

true



The point being for younger members Mick Ferguson scored more headed goals than virtually anyone for the club and in the top flight once scored three hat tricks in a season

Christ, that's ridiculous. Has to be some sort of satire, surely.

 

[TomRad85]

This is a good one.

Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk

 

[Grendel]

I know one thing. If Max suddenly starts wearing shades and dons a white suit and is sponsored by Kool Aid prepare for a 10,000 reduction in attendances

 

[Ccfcisparks]

This is a good one.

Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk

I disagree with that. I think it would be 25.

 

[mark82]

The cult are everywhere.

The worst thing is it causes overreactions the other way from the likes of yourself and others. He's clearly a very limited player, he'd be nowhere near starting at this level if it weren't for the injuries we've had this year, but given his limitations he's done an ok job. Not great, not awful. If we want to progress we need someone of a similar ilk who is better and just generally more consistent.

 

[Deleted member 11652]

The worst thing is it causes overreactions the other way from the likes of yourself and others. He's clearly a very limited player, he'd be nowhere near starting at this level if it weren't for the injuries we've had this year, but given his limitations he's done an ok job. Not great, not awful. If we want to progress we need someone of a similar ilk who is better and just generally more consistent.

Okay I over reacted. He’s the 4th worst striker we’ve had at this level not the 3rd

 

[mark82]

Okay I over reacted. He’s the 4th worst striker we’ve had at this level not the 3rd

We've had many worse at this level (in terms of performance for us - I don't give a shit what they did for other clubs). Particularly when you consider most of those were signed as starters at this level, whereas Max was surplus to requirements at the start of the season. Probably fairer to look back and compare him to 3rd/4th choice strikers rather than starters anyway. All this doesn't mean I think he's the Messiah.

 

[Grendel]

The worst thing is it causes overreactions the other way from the likes of yourself and others. He's clearly a very limited player, he'd be nowhere near starting at this level if it weren't for the injuries we've had this year, but given his limitations he's done an ok job. Not great, not awful. If we want to progress we need someone of a similar ilk who is better and just generally more consistent.

Believe it or not I don’t actually post as much personal abuse against him as others do and certainly others do against other players

Biamou is a cult figure - others I could possibly compare him to are Houchen (definitely and if he was in the social media age he’d be worshipped on Twitter) and potentially Sean Flynn

 

[procdoc]

We've had many worse at this level (in terms of performance for us - I don't give a shit what they did for other clubs). Particularly when you consider most of those were signed as starters at this level, whereas Max was surplus to requirements at the start of the season. Probably fairer to look back and compare him to 3rd/4th choice strikers rather than starters anyway.

It’s a pointless exercise talking to this idiot. He think O’Donovan is better. I’ve had pub players better than O’Donovan

 

[mark82]

Believe it or not I don’t actually post as much personal abuse against him as others do and certainly others do against other players

Biamou is a cult figure - others I could possibly compare him to are Houchen (definitely and if he was in the social media age he’d be worshipped on Twitter) and potentially Sean Flynn

There's much better reason to worship Houchen to be fair.

 

[procdoc]

Believe it or not I don’t actually post as much personal abuse against him as others do and certainly others do against other players

Biamou is a cult figure - others I could possibly compare him to are Houchen (definitely and if he was in the social media age he’d be worshipped on Twitter) and potentially Sean Flynn

Sean Flynn was pretty much shite. I thought Telfer was shite too but was quite popular because he ran a lot

 

[Ccfcisparks]

We've had many worse at this level (in terms of performance for us - I don't give a shit what they did for other clubs). Particularly when you consider most of those were signed as starters at this level, whereas Max was surplus to requirements at the start of the season. Probably fairer to look back and compare him to 3rd/4th choice strikers rather than starters anyway. All this doesn't mean I think he's the Messiah.

Better than Robbie Simpson?

 

[Deleted member 11652]

It’s a pointless exercise talking to this idiot. He think O’Donovan is better. I’ve had pub players better than O’Donovan

I’ve played with better players than Biamou. Tbf one lad I’ve played with probably has more goals at the Ricoh

 

[procdoc]

I’ve played with better players than Biamou. Tbf one lad I’ve played with probably has more goals at the Ricoh

If you’ve played the game I thought you’d have a better understanding of it to be honest

 

[mark82]

Better than Robbie Simpson?

Simpson 'can be a City star'

ROBBIE SIMPSON could be the dark horse of the Championship, claims Coventry City boss Iain Dowie.

www.coventrytelegraph.net