Player ratings (3 Viewers)
- Thread starter Corrado
- Start date
Blind-Faith
Well-Known Member
Can’t decide between Leo and McCallum for MOTM , but everyone gets top marks tonight. What a result!!!
SeaSeeEffCee
Well-Known Member
The front three the only ones to get below a 7 for me today. McCallum, Ostigard and McFadzean all excellent. Impressed by DaCosta’s application today as well, felt like he’d really learnt from the QPR game.
cov donkey kick
Well-Known Member
Everyone an nine apart from godden a four and walker a five .
D
Deleted member 9744
Guest
Agree. He looked really good. Didn’t look very tall though?
Skybluefaz
Well-Known Member
O'Hare struggled, great team performance though
D
Deleted member 9744
Guest
Looks right to me
D
Deleted member 5849
Guest
Wilson 6 - he was there!
DaCosta 5 - Some half decent attacking once King Giles was on the pitch, kept the glorious boy Giles quiet, but before that was all over the place positionally
Hyam 8 -solid
McFadzean 8 - solid
Ostegard 9 - Solid + goal
McCallum 9 MotM - solid and actually offered an outlet
James 7 - OK. Neither here nor there.
Kelly 6 - started well, faded.
O'Hare 5 - not one of his better games, nothing really worked
Godden 5 - not match fit, terrible miss
Walker 7 - made good runs, offered an outlet, two misses
Gyokeres and Biamou 5 - didn't really do anything, either of them.
Hamer 6 - a bit Kellyesque. Involved, but wayward passing.
DaCosta 5 - Some half decent attacking once King Giles was on the pitch, kept the glorious boy Giles quiet, but before that was all over the place positionally
Hyam 8 -solid
McFadzean 8 - solid
Ostegard 9 - Solid + goal
McCallum 9 MotM - solid and actually offered an outlet
James 7 - OK. Neither here nor there.
Kelly 6 - started well, faded.
O'Hare 5 - not one of his better games, nothing really worked
Godden 5 - not match fit, terrible miss
Walker 7 - made good runs, offered an outlet, two misses
Gyokeres and Biamou 5 - didn't really do anything, either of them.
Hamer 6 - a bit Kellyesque. Involved, but wayward passing.
Ian1779
Well-Known Member
Thought he put in a lot of hard graft, was pretty relentless chasing down their defenders.
Liquid Gold
Well-Known Member
7s and 8s all round
6s for O’Hare, Godden and Walker for missing those chances.
6s for O’Hare, Godden and Walker for missing those chances.
D
Deleted member 5849
Guest
"He's Swedish and I don't know his route into Rotherham." The pundit's scouting report on him.
Ian1779
Well-Known Member
When it’s sometimes better to say nothing....
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
Wilson 6
Mcfadz 8
Hyam 8
Osrigaard 9
Mcallum 10
Da costa 7
James 9
Kelly 8
O hare 6
Godden 6
Walker 6
Got 7
Biamaoi 6
Hamer 6
Mcfadz 8
Hyam 8
Osrigaard 9
Mcallum 10
Da costa 7
James 9
Kelly 8
O hare 6
Godden 6
Walker 6
Got 7
Biamaoi 6
Hamer 6
Skybluefaz
Well-Known Member
That's a given with him. Probably the style of game went against him.
Wilson 5 Didn’t have much to do. He can’t kick. Haircut is bad considering barbers reopened on Monday
McCallum 8 His best game of the season. I’d have him back next year on that showing
Hyam 6 The season can’t end soon enough for him but he was fine tonight
McFadzean 7 Mercifully error-free tonight, and when that’s the case, you’ve got a good CB
Ostigard 8 Getting better with every game. Looked shaky early this season but now looks almost too good for us
Dacosta 6 Technically and positionally he’s all over the place, but he can make stuff happen, especially against a papier-mâché defense like Rotherham’s
Kelly 5 Seemed to just punt the ball skyward whenever he got it. Off night for him
James 8 MOTM Made up for a few dubious set-pieces with a peach for Ostigard. One of few players who looks comfortable at this level, and kept things ticking over
O’Hare 6 Shocking miss, didn’t really impose himself on the game. Wouldn’t blame him for being tired at this point of the season
Godden 5 Worst miss of the game, in a game full of bad misses. Bit of a lost year for him
Walker 6 Didn’t offer much in front of goal, but his movement continues to be excellent
Gyokeres 6 Let’s be honest, this guy is entirely forgettable, and if he signed somewhere else tomorrow, not a single one of us would care
Biamou 5 Max gonna Max
Hamer 6 Offered as much as O’Hare did in a fraction of the time
Looking at those ratings it feels like I’m being harsh on a team that won comfortably. But having heard for weeks that Rotherham were a football juggernaut, sitting pretty and just waiting to cash in all those games in hand after pulling off Operation COVID False Flag, you’ll have to forgive me for being underwhelmed with what they actually looked like tonight. Because they were shit.
McCallum 8 His best game of the season. I’d have him back next year on that showing
Hyam 6 The season can’t end soon enough for him but he was fine tonight
McFadzean 7 Mercifully error-free tonight, and when that’s the case, you’ve got a good CB
Ostigard 8 Getting better with every game. Looked shaky early this season but now looks almost too good for us
Dacosta 6 Technically and positionally he’s all over the place, but he can make stuff happen, especially against a papier-mâché defense like Rotherham’s
Kelly 5 Seemed to just punt the ball skyward whenever he got it. Off night for him
James 8 MOTM Made up for a few dubious set-pieces with a peach for Ostigard. One of few players who looks comfortable at this level, and kept things ticking over
O’Hare 6 Shocking miss, didn’t really impose himself on the game. Wouldn’t blame him for being tired at this point of the season
Godden 5 Worst miss of the game, in a game full of bad misses. Bit of a lost year for him
Walker 6 Didn’t offer much in front of goal, but his movement continues to be excellent
Gyokeres 6 Let’s be honest, this guy is entirely forgettable, and if he signed somewhere else tomorrow, not a single one of us would care
Biamou 5 Max gonna Max
Hamer 6 Offered as much as O’Hare did in a fraction of the time
Looking at those ratings it feels like I’m being harsh on a team that won comfortably. But having heard for weeks that Rotherham were a football juggernaut, sitting pretty and just waiting to cash in all those games in hand after pulling off Operation COVID False Flag, you’ll have to forgive me for being underwhelmed with what they actually looked like tonight. Because they were shit.
Last edited:
Agree with a majority of these. Maybe a bit toppy with some of the defence marks but defence/midfield (Kelly and James) won this tonight didn’t give Rotherham a sniff...not a great game for any of the forwards but a wins a win !! Get in !!!
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
Not seen you post much lately mate?
Have been about. Had to steer clear of some threads (match day meltdown...didn’t even need a City match day on Tuesday
)
D
Deleted member 11652
Guest
Superb to a man in my opinion. Mccallum man of the match.
Don’t agree with some of the harsh ratings.
Don’t agree with some of the harsh ratings.
Blind-Faith
Well-Known Member
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
I don't rate Dacosta but 5 
Dickie
Well-Known Member
Agree. Ladapo and Wing too.
SeaSeeEffCee
Well-Known Member
DaCosta wasn’t great with the ball but I felt like he’d really taken onboard feedback from the QPR game and stuck to his position well and was defensively solid.