Ratings v Derby (2 Viewers)
- Thread starter The Philosopher
- Start date
The Philosopher
Well-Known Member
They’re not utterly clueless, they have a different opinion to you is all.
He’s a great finisher. Usually, link up
play is so so
Razzle Dazzle Dean Gordon
Well-Known Member
Moore - 7 - Generally solid but some decidedly dodgy kicking at times
Hyam - 7 - Generally solid, don't recall too many errors really
Bidwell - 6
Sheaf - 7 - Thought he had a decent game out of position again
Maatsen - 6 - Based primarily on his forays forward as he really didn't cope defensively today
Dabo - 6 - Probably lucky not to be sent off but generally did ok today
Allen - 6 - Generally a solid performance, nothing great nor terrible
Hamer - 6
Shipley - 5 - Pretty much anonymous
O'Hare - 6
Godden - 7 - Thought he had a better game today, should have had an assist and took his goal brilliantly
Gyokores - 5 - Looked a threat but 2 pretty poor finishes that cost us a win when combined with the BS penalty
Not convinced we 'deserved' to win today on the balance of play but it feels very galling having missed two sitters and conceded a dodgy pen
Hyam - 7 - Generally solid, don't recall too many errors really
Bidwell - 6
Sheaf - 7 - Thought he had a decent game out of position again
Maatsen - 6 - Based primarily on his forays forward as he really didn't cope defensively today
Dabo - 6 - Probably lucky not to be sent off but generally did ok today
Allen - 6 - Generally a solid performance, nothing great nor terrible
Hamer - 6
Shipley - 5 - Pretty much anonymous
O'Hare - 6
Godden - 7 - Thought he had a better game today, should have had an assist and took his goal brilliantly
Gyokores - 5 - Looked a threat but 2 pretty poor finishes that cost us a win when combined with the BS penalty
Not convinced we 'deserved' to win today on the balance of play but it feels very galling having missed two sitters and conceded a dodgy pen
The Philosopher
Well-Known Member
I thought Maatsen did well when he came on. He’s a lot more pacy than Bidwell and more creative going forward.
IMO Maatsen is a better LWB than Bidwell in our set up.
Maatsen would not be able to cover LCB as well as Bidwell did.
I don’t rate Bidwell as a LWB. Too slow and hasn’t got into our style to play. Dabo and Maatsen are almost like backtracking wingers. Bidwell isn’t that.
He did well today (Bidwell) and I was pleasantly surprised that he could slot in as LCB.
stupot07
Well-Known Member
He really didn't, he had a shocker defensively, Ebiowei went past him at will, all of Derbys attacked came down our left. Maatsen was either too easy to get past or was out of the position, he gave the ball away a lot, often choosing the wrong option. He had one or two moments going forward but not many.
He was nowhere near an 8 or being our second best player today. If Bidwell had put that performance in you'd have been giving him a 4 or a 5.
Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
larry_david
Well-Known Member
Unfortunately Ian Maatsen was dreadful today
TwistAndShoutCCFC1987
Well-Known Member
I thought the southport cannavaro (aka jake bidwell) played well in an unfamiliar position