Duffys Tetralogy
Active Member
Came across this on twitter. Not a pretty sight.
Rose with no back up at RCB could be season defining.
Rose & Mcfadz (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Duffys Tetralogy
- Start date
Came across this on twitter. Not a pretty sight.
Rose with no back up at RCB could be season defining.
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Judging individual players by team win percentage is possibly one of the dumbest things fans do.
If you want to know the end goal of that thinking, look at Philosoraptors graphs which basically do that and have ridiculous stuff like Dacosta as our best player or whatever.
If you want to know the end goal of that thinking, look at Philosoraptors graphs which basically do that and have ridiculous stuff like Dacosta as our best player or whatever.
fatso
Well-Known Member
I used to have a pair of purple pants (I had many other colours, but only one pair of purple ones)
I remember that I never ever saw city win a single game while I wore those purple pants, so I can only deduce that those pants cost us loads of points over the years, and that must be far more relevant than which bloody defensive duo we stick with!
He does for the majority of the time... it's just the one or two total brainfarts per game that are the issue.
Moore and Wilson seem to suffer the same issue!
Liquid Gold
Well-Known Member
I think Rose just seems to take an age to get into the swing of things and then inevitably gets an injury or something by the time he gets going.
If the plan is for him to take over from Hyam then I think we're just going to have to accept a few mistakes from him and persevere until he gets into the swing.
If the plan is for him to take over from Hyam then I think we're just going to have to accept a few mistakes from him and persevere until he gets into the swing.
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
He’s played a lot less Championship footy than Hyam since we came up, Hyam just under 8k minutes, Rose 3.6k.
He’s basically where Hyam was at the end of our first season. Which wasn’t all that great.
SkyBlueSam01
Well-Known Member
I actually think Rose has more potential than Hyam despite clearly being less solid at present. I liked Hyam but Rose is certainly better on the ball (minus mistakes), more mobile and more of a threat in the oppo box.
As others have said with more game time at this level he could easily step up. Would also give more balance in a back 3 than Hyam as he has more similar attributes to Panzo and Doyle on the left IMO.
As others have said with more game time at this level he could easily step up. Would also give more balance in a back 3 than Hyam as he has more similar attributes to Panzo and Doyle on the left IMO.
Last edited:
Liquid Gold
Well-Known Member
Couple years ago I’d have agreed with you but he just hasn’t had the game time.
Big big season for him to prove it.
SkyblueDad
Well-Known Member
Rose is a decent player blighted last season with succession of niggly injuries. Think he’ll be okay this season.
stevefloyd
Well-Known Member
Never rated Rose way way too many cock ups in him, his pass straight to the opposition which led to their second goal was shocking but there again everyone was at it giving the ball away even Rodris done it a couple of times for Man City
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
The main issue in the second goal was less him giving it away but more his failure to recognise the runner.
Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk