Player ratings vs Middlesbrough (H) (8 Viewers)
- Thread starter stupot07
- Start date
SheafIsGod
Well-Known Member
Wilson 5 - nothing to do
Doyle 7 - brilliant performance
McFadzean 5
Panzo 4
Dabo 4
Bidwell 6
Sheaf 9 - different gravy
Allen 3 - League Two player
Palmer 8 - much needed improvement on O’Hare
Godden 1 - passenger
Gyokeres 5 - marked up for the goal, although it was a poor finish if we’re being honest
Subs
Waghorn 3 - get rid
Eccles 2 - lol
Doyle 7 - brilliant performance
McFadzean 5
Panzo 4
Dabo 4
Bidwell 6
Sheaf 9 - different gravy
Allen 3 - League Two player
Palmer 8 - much needed improvement on O’Hare
Godden 1 - passenger
Gyokeres 5 - marked up for the goal, although it was a poor finish if we’re being honest
Subs
Waghorn 3 - get rid
Eccles 2 - lol
SeaSeeEffCee
Well-Known Member
Wilson 6
Dabo 6
Doyle 7
McFadzean 6
Panzo 6
Bidwell 7
Sheaf 5
Allen 6
Palmer 7
Godden 5
Gyokeres 8
Eccles 6
Dabo 6
Doyle 7
McFadzean 6
Panzo 6
Bidwell 7
Sheaf 5
Allen 6
Palmer 7
Godden 5
Gyokeres 8
Eccles 6
robbiethemole
Well-Known Member
Steve Martin - Ref 2. Comedian by name, this bloke was fucking atrocious, along side his shit Lino on Tesco side, neither of them called the numerous fouls and the one where there defender tripped himself up then gave them the decision was a fucking joke.
What are the rules on a drop ball now? Cos I think he was totally wrong giving their keeper the ball after the free kick that felled Crooks, surely we should have had it in our half.
What are the rules on a drop ball now? Cos I think he was totally wrong giving their keeper the ball after the free kick that felled Crooks, surely we should have had it in our half.
Saddlebrains
Well-Known Member
Wilson 7
Dabo 7
Doyle 8
McFadzean 8
Panzo 8
Bidwell 8
Sheaf 8
Allen 8
Palmer 9
Godden 5
Gyokeres 8
Eccles 6
Waghorn 6
Huge 3 points.
Palmer is a player just got to keep him fit. Love to see him and Callum off Gyok
Allen is much better deeper
Doyle and Panzo are very good defenders, Gyok was the gyok of last year
Bidwell again, brill
Happy
Dabo 7
Doyle 8
McFadzean 8
Panzo 8
Bidwell 8
Sheaf 8
Allen 8
Palmer 9
Godden 5
Gyokeres 8
Eccles 6
Waghorn 6
Huge 3 points.
Palmer is a player just got to keep him fit. Love to see him and Callum off Gyok
Allen is much better deeper
Doyle and Panzo are very good defenders, Gyok was the gyok of last year
Bidwell again, brill
Happy
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Wilson - 6: as soon as I was about to turn to my dad and say how solidness was looking he did something dodgy (I forget exactly what). Solid enough, but still has a bit of mental in him that worries me. Some good game management today though.
Doyle - 7: Like him a lot. Looks more confident and not as out of place as I’d think on the right. Can see he’s got a future ahead of him.
Fadz - 7: Good Fadz. Cleaned up, marshalled the defence well, threw himself at everything. Absolutely vital with the two inexperienced players alongside him.
Panzo - 7: The odd mistake like the others but excellent on the ball and showed some really nice foresight and controlled clearances. Is improving his awareness which was a worry early on.
Dabo - 7: Was better, got an assist, but still some horrific final balls. Will play a lot worse.
Allen - 7: One of his better games. Far less effective when Eccles came on but looked much better at CM than AM. Quality ball out to Dabo that TBH I doubted he had in him.
Sheaf - 5: Poor. Gave the ball away a couple of times, not as effective in the tackle, looked more like Sheaf of early last season. Hope it’s just a blip as he’s had a good season.
Bidwell - 8 (MOTM): Solid defensively, puts a good ball in, takes the piss with where we take throw ins from. A good solid experienced Championship player. Looks completely different from last season.
Palmer - 7: Closed down really well, holds and uses the ball well, really should have had two goals today though. Everyone knows you aim right from that distance, hasn’t he been watching Kick For Cash?
Godden - 6: Anonymous mostly, too slow to make an impact and only really useful when you’re dominating the ball like first half. Would’ve put Tavares on as Middlesbrough started playing very high second half.
Gyokeres - 8: Well taken goal, got absolutely nothing from the ref despite seemingly having been entered in a wrestling match rather than football. Can be selfish at times, but so are all good strikers.
Eccles - 6: Barely noticed he was playing TBH.
Waghorn - 6: Ran about well enough.
Doyle - 7: Like him a lot. Looks more confident and not as out of place as I’d think on the right. Can see he’s got a future ahead of him.
Fadz - 7: Good Fadz. Cleaned up, marshalled the defence well, threw himself at everything. Absolutely vital with the two inexperienced players alongside him.
Panzo - 7: The odd mistake like the others but excellent on the ball and showed some really nice foresight and controlled clearances. Is improving his awareness which was a worry early on.
Dabo - 7: Was better, got an assist, but still some horrific final balls. Will play a lot worse.
Allen - 7: One of his better games. Far less effective when Eccles came on but looked much better at CM than AM. Quality ball out to Dabo that TBH I doubted he had in him.
Sheaf - 5: Poor. Gave the ball away a couple of times, not as effective in the tackle, looked more like Sheaf of early last season. Hope it’s just a blip as he’s had a good season.
Bidwell - 8 (MOTM): Solid defensively, puts a good ball in, takes the piss with where we take throw ins from. A good solid experienced Championship player. Looks completely different from last season.
Palmer - 7: Closed down really well, holds and uses the ball well, really should have had two goals today though. Everyone knows you aim right from that distance, hasn’t he been watching Kick For Cash?
Godden - 6: Anonymous mostly, too slow to make an impact and only really useful when you’re dominating the ball like first half. Would’ve put Tavares on as Middlesbrough started playing very high second half.
Gyokeres - 8: Well taken goal, got absolutely nothing from the ref despite seemingly having been entered in a wrestling match rather than football. Can be selfish at times, but so are all good strikers.
Eccles - 6: Barely noticed he was playing TBH.
Waghorn - 6: Ran about well enough.
SheafIsGod
Well-Known Member
Why have you given an “anonymous” player a 6? You think Godden’s was an above average performance today? What does someone need to do to get a 1, 2 or 3 rating?
Greggs
Well-Known Member
to be fair he worked very hard and won most of his aerial duels against a much taller defender.
SheafIsGod
Well-Known Member
Did he bollocks
Frostie
Well-Known Member
Agree on his performance as a whole, the Palmer foul that led to his booking was ridiculous.
As absurd as it seems, the drop ball might have actually been correct though. Technically, if the last touch was in the area when play was stopped then it's given to the keeper. That said I thought Panzo had touched it before play was stopped but not certain.
Last edited:
Blind-Faith
Well-Known Member
Wilson 7
Dabo 7
Doyle 7
McFadzean 7
Panzo 6
Bidwell 7
Sheaf 7
Allen 7
Palmer 7
Godden 6
Gyokeres 8
Just a good all round solid team performance, no one bar VIK had an absolute blinder but no one had an absolute stinker. A fantastic 3 points
Dabo 7
Doyle 7
McFadzean 7
Panzo 6
Bidwell 7
Sheaf 7
Allen 7
Palmer 7
Godden 6
Gyokeres 8
Just a good all round solid team performance, no one bar VIK had an absolute blinder but no one had an absolute stinker. A fantastic 3 points
D
Deleted member 9744
Guest
Agree with those marks except i would give Allen a 7. Possibly even a 7 for Eccles who i thought played really intelligently for the short time he was on and covered for Dabo well. Sensible substitution at the time.
What has happened to Sheaf? Hardly involved today and seemed weak in the tackle.
rob9872
Well-Known Member
Lots of good performances today. I said at the time Rose got injured it could be a blessing, despite his pace, he does make mistakes. 2 and a half games later with zero conceded, Panzo looking a massive upgrade and Doyle getting more comfortable in Rose's position even being left footed.
I rarely give 10s in ratings but I thought Viks all round play today was immense. Better officiating and he'd have had more 1 on 1s. Absolutely bullied their back line. So lucky to have him still, make the most until January I guess.
Forget the table, unbeaten in 3, consecutive clean sheets, onwards and upwards!
I rarely give 10s in ratings but I thought Viks all round play today was immense. Better officiating and he'd have had more 1 on 1s. Absolutely bullied their back line. So lucky to have him still, make the most until January I guess.
Forget the table, unbeaten in 3, consecutive clean sheets, onwards and upwards!
rob9872
Well-Known Member
It was sensible and I'm not a huge Kelly fan, but looking forward to his return too as I'd have loved him on for the last 10 mins to steady the ship
AOM
Well-Known Member
Was it when he tried to kick it out and the ball nearly spinned over himself and he then headed it out for a throw in haha?
Saw McFadzean cracking up at that too
Thought he was pretty steady aside from that today
D
Deleted member 2477
Guest
Wilson 7 Solid, no mistakes couple of saves when it counted
Dabo 6 decent going forward but lost his man a few times especially when Gilles came on
Doyle 7 good never looked fazed
McFadzean 7 lead the back line like a caprtain
Panzo 6 a few stray balls and looked vulnerable to balls over the top but did ok
Bidwell 8 starting to prove the doubters wrong and another solid defensive display
Sheaf 6 quiet game for him by his standards
Allen 7 as usual very busy and breaks up play but lacking in the final third
Palmer 8 good display and really got stuck in With some good balls. Missed a sitter though
Godden 7 didnt score but created space for Vic and never stopped both attack and defensively
Gyokeres 9 was a handful all game and took his goal well. Little greedy at times
Dabo 6 decent going forward but lost his man a few times especially when Gilles came on
Doyle 7 good never looked fazed
McFadzean 7 lead the back line like a caprtain
Panzo 6 a few stray balls and looked vulnerable to balls over the top but did ok
Bidwell 8 starting to prove the doubters wrong and another solid defensive display
Sheaf 6 quiet game for him by his standards
Allen 7 as usual very busy and breaks up play but lacking in the final third
Palmer 8 good display and really got stuck in With some good balls. Missed a sitter though
Godden 7 didnt score but created space for Vic and never stopped both attack and defensively
Gyokeres 9 was a handful all game and took his goal well. Little greedy at times
AOM
Well-Known Member
Yeah haha, he went mental at the final whistle too.
Fair play to him, he's keeping Moore out on merit at the moment
bawtryneal
Well-Known Member
Bidwell man of match
Gyokores and Doyle second best
Gyokores and Doyle second best
clint van damme
Well-Known Member
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Wilson 6
Dabo 7
Doyle 8
McF 8
Panzo 7
Bidwell 7
Allen 7
Sheaf 7
Palmer 7
Gyo 9 MOTM Keep him till the summer, we stay in the league
Subs
Eccles 6
Waghorn 6
Dabo 7
Doyle 8
McF 8
Panzo 7
Bidwell 7
Allen 7
Sheaf 7
Palmer 7
Gyo 9 MOTM Keep him till the summer, we stay in the league
Subs
Eccles 6
Waghorn 6
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
Spot on Ratings and Synopsis.
Depends if someone touched the ball after Crooks was hit. If no one touched it then Martin was right. If someone else touched it after the ball hit Crooks then the drop ball should have been to us where the ball was last touched.
Martin though I’m sure Is anti Coventry at least. Look at his past performances when he’s reffed us.
WBA 2022 last season gives West Brom a dubious penalty in 90th minute.
2021 Luton gives penalty against JCS clearly 2 yards outside box. 5-0
2021 Luton gives penalty against McFadzean and sends him off when the ball hits his shoulder.2-0
2021 Fails to give penalty against Brentford when 10 yards from the incident but gives penalty because the linesman further away than him flags for it.
2020 QPR gives penalty against McFadzean which looks dubious with player running out of box.
So what are the odds of this? The only 5 matches he referees in a 2 year period involving City a penalty is involved in every match. The 1 for Coventry was given by the linesman not the referee. He has only given 10 penalties in that 2 year period in 44 championship matches but interestingly 5 of them have been in Coventry matches and it just so happens he only referred 5 matches.
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Agree mostly I'd probably bump bidwell to a 7
pusbccfc
Well-Known Member
Agreed but would have Godden lower and an 8 for Wilson who was solid.
Godden offers nothing when he's not scoring.
Offhegoes
Well-Known Member
How Palmer gets anything less than an 8 is beyond me. His clever passing and flicks were brilliant. Very excited to see him and O’Hare link up soon.
Bit worried about this Vik & Godden partnership. Not working, and Godden hasn’t scored for 4 games. Surely he will go back to the box when O’Hare is fit, and he slots alongside Palme with Vik upfront.
Bit worried about this Vik & Godden partnership. Not working, and Godden hasn’t scored for 4 games. Surely he will go back to the box when O’Hare is fit, and he slots alongside Palme with Vik upfront.
GaryMabbuttsLeftKnee
Well-Known Member
I thought Palmer was very good today. Gyokeres clearly too good for us, our best player almost every game. Doyle had a very good game as did Panzo.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
We will play the box midfield at Bristol city. That worked so well last year there. Hamer with 2 brilliant assists one for Maatsen who was playing AM in the Box. Palmer has really impressed me. He showed lots of energy and wanted to get stuck into tackles too.
rob9872
Well-Known Member
Who else in the box then?
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
I'm not sure Kelly or Ohare are ready to start as they wernt even on the bench today. Unless its Eccles/Sheaf/Allen/Palmer.
Cant wait to get Hamer and Ohare back. Then that's one hell of a midfield in this division imo.
