Cardiff Ratings (11 Viewers)

Forums New posts
The Philosopher

The Philosopher

Well-Known Member
Wilson 8

Clean sheet and better than recent performances. Ran out well. Gathered well.

Doyle 7

Ok

Rose 7

Ok

Panzo 7

Ok

Dabo 7

Thought he did quite well and got forward well. Hit the defenders more than space though.

Bidwell 6

Gets into good positions but doesn’t hit the space or run in as much as he should. Sometimes he leaves balls that he possibly could reach if he put his foot to the floor. Either he’s slow or lazy.

Sheaf 8

The difference between him now and 12 months ago is staggering. One thing he does is play the ball forward more than he did. Before many passes were sideways or backwards. Great interceptions and totally baffling why he went off.

Hamer 8

Good performance but no rewards. Sitting deeper and running towards the box plays to his strengths. Good efforts on goal. Unlucky.

Allen 6

One or two good bits of play but out of his depth. Sorry.

Palmer 7

Just not his day. Good touch, movement, pressing.

Gyok 7

Kicked all over and had his short pulled more than a Xmas cracker. In the Prem he’d have the protection of VAR and would be a different prospect.

Subs

Kane 6

Good runs and went with the law of average tactic: kick it over 10 times and 2 kicks will be decent.

Waghorn 3

Totally inept. Offside pointlessly on shirt pass interplays. Dummies to the opposition and wayward passes.

No threat, no creativity, no point.

£15k / week? (According to SBB) Disgraceful decision. I said at the time it was a strange decision and got pelters. I was wrong. Awful signing.
 
Last edited:
WestEndAgro

WestEndAgro

Well-Known Member
Wilson 7
Dabo 6.5
Rose 8 motm
Doyle 7
Panzo 7
Bidwell 7
Sheaf 8
Hamer 7
Allen 6
Palmer 7
Gyokeres 6

Kane 7
Waghorn 4

Rose was excellent as was Sheaf, good cameo from Toddy, thought we were good defensively, and the better team overall.
 
Last edited:
pusbccfc

pusbccfc

Well-Known Member
Wilson - Not worth rating. An under 8 keeper could have done his job tonight.

Dabo - 5: Clear he was unfit. Generally ok considering.

Rose 7
Doyle 7
Panzo 7.5

Bidwell 5:. A better attacking full back has a field day tonight. So many good balls to him and very little done. Agonisingly slow at times. Would love to see him as a left back in a 4.

Hamer 7.5
Sheaf 7.5
Allen 6 - Works hard but the prime example of a player that's just not good enough if we want to aim for a higher position. Would he start in any other side in the top 12?

Palmer 6: Frustrating player. Some lovely bits of play but lost of wasteful attempts. Beyond on, he's no O'Hare and doesn't drag defenders away from Vik.

Vik 5: Completely pocketed. Trying to much because there is absolutely no options to support him. If only we had a decent player up there with him. Referee gave him absolutely nothing.

Subs

Kane 7 - Clearly trying to put himself in the shop window. Looked good.

Waghorn - Taking into account the wages, one of the worst signings Robins has ever made. Movement was awful. Touch was poor. Painfully slow. Stuck with him until the end of his contact.

Robins - What does Taveres have to do to have a chance over Waghorn. Surely he can't do much worse?
 
Skybluecol

Skybluecol

Well-Known Member
Defence did what they could and played well as a unit. Hamer below par again. Sheaf his normal self. Allen off tonight. Palmer growing into the team and Gyokeres wanted to get into a battle that he was never going to win.
Robins...love the bloke but tactics was poor tonight. If we take the same approach against Bristol City then we will not win that game.
Really feels like 2 points lost this evening.
Cardiff came here for a point and got it.
Anyway, can't wait for Sunday! PUSB!
 
  • Like
Reactions: SAJ
Blind-Faith

Blind-Faith

Well-Known Member
Wilson 8
Dabo 6
Rose 8
Doyle 8
Panzo 9 motm
Bidwell 7
Sheaf 8
Hamer 7
Allen 7
Palmer 7
Gyokeres 6

Kane 7
Waghorn 1- managed to put his kit on properly
 
shmmeee

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
Wilson - 6
Rose - 7
Doyle - 5
Panzo - 6
Dabo - 4
Hamer - 8
Sheaf - 8
Bidwell - 5
Palmer - 6
Allen - 5
Vik - 5

Kane - 7
Waghorn - 5
 
shmmeee

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
Skybluefaz said:
Wilson picking up some of the easiest 8's of his life here. Really didn't have anything to do. Thought Panzo, Hamer and Sheaf were probably the pick. Didn't think Dabo was as bad as some people saw him on here tbh. We missed O'Hare.
Click to expand...

Its easy to say we missed O’Hare but the fact is too many others didn’t step up. We missed a ST two wingbacks and a second AM today. And a someone to tell one of the CBs to move up
 
stupot07

stupot07

Well-Known Member
Wilson 6
Rose 7.5
Doyle 7
Panzo 7
Dabo 4
Bidwell 6
Hamer 7
Sheaf 8
Allen 6
Palmer 6
Gyokeres 5

Subs
Kane 7
Waghorn 5

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
Skybluefaz

Skybluefaz

Well-Known Member
shmmeee said:
Its easy to say we missed O’Hare but the fact is too many others didn’t step up. We missed a ST two wingbacks and a second AM today. And a someone to tell one of the CBs to move up
Click to expand...
Fair enough, we missed someone who could get on the ball in that position between midfield and attack. I'll give them credit for dealing with Vik. He got frustrated and played worse for it. We're just lacking those extra few players too give us a chance at the playoffs 😔
 
shmmeee

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
Skybluefaz said:
Fair enough, we missed someone who could get on the ball in that position between midfield and attack. I'll give them credit for dealing with Vik. He got frustrated and played worse for it. We're just lacking those extra few players too give us a chance at the playoffs 😔
Click to expand...

I think we’re misusing Palmer. He wants to come deep and have options ahead of him. Vik isn’t a get on a through ball type striker, he wants to wander wide. Can’t believe I’m saying this but maybe Tavares is the best option with Palmer in the 10 role.

Overall we just don’t have enough forward players cos O’Hare can be at both ends of the pitch like Robins likes. Bidwell isn’t forward thinking enough and none of our RWBs really work either so we just don’t have enough players forward.

Dragging Hamer back was fucking criminal though. If Sheaf didn’t have an injury it was a really dumb move.
 
fernandopartridge

fernandopartridge

Well-Known Member
shmmeee said:
I think we’re misusing Palmer. He wants to come deep and have options ahead of him. Vik isn’t a get on a through ball type striker, he wants to wander wide. Can’t believe I’m saying this but maybe Tavares is the best option with Palmer in the 10 role.

Overall we just don’t have enough forward players cos O’Hare can be at both ends of the pitch like Robins likes. Bidwell isn’t forward thinking enough and none of our RWBs really work either so we just don’t have enough players forward.

Dragging Hamer back was fucking criminal though. If Sheaf didn’t have an injury it was a really dumb move.
Click to expand...
You're wrong about Vik, he drags wide when the service isn't there through the middle
 
shmmeee

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
fernandopartridge said:
You're wrong about Vik, he drags wide when the service isn't there through the middle
Click to expand...

Maybe. He does love to run into the area from wide though. Ultimately we just don’t commit enough forwards. Fair enough for some games but today, at home, against a team that clearly wasn’t trying to win its criminal.
 
fernandopartridge

fernandopartridge

Well-Known Member
shmmeee said:
Maybe. He does love to run into the area from wide though. Ultimately we just don’t commit enough forwards. Fair enough for some games but today, at home, against a team that clearly wasn’t trying to win its criminal.
Click to expand...
Agreed, said so in the match thread. For all the good crossing positions we've got 1-2 players in the box.
 
P

PVA

Well-Known Member
Wilson 6
Dabo 5
Rose 6
Doyle 7
Panzo 6
Bidwell 5
Hamer 7
Sheaf 7
Allen 5
Palmer 6
Gyokeres 6

Kane 7
Waghorn 4
 
S

SAJ

Well-Known Member
shmmeee said:
I think we’re misusing Palmer. He wants to come deep and have options ahead of him. Vik isn’t a get on a through ball type striker, he wants to wander wide. Can’t believe I’m saying this but maybe Tavares is the best option with Palmer in the 10 role.

Overall we just don’t have enough forward players cos O’Hare can be at both ends of the pitch like Robins likes. Bidwell isn’t forward thinking enough and none of our RWBs really work either so we just don’t have enough players forward.

Dragging Hamer back was fucking criminal though. If Sheaf didn’t have an injury it was a really dumb move.
Click to expand...
Sheaf was taken off because he had just been booked for dissent.
 
Terry_dactyl

Terry_dactyl

Well-Known Member
Was Waghorn really on the pitch long enough to warrant such low marks/criticism? He didn’t do anything but wasn’t really the reason we didn’t get the win.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AOM
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 11 (members: 0, guests: 11)
Top